AFRIBIZ takes on Nthabeleng Likotsi's YWBN over collapsed R9 million share deal
Sifiso Mahlangu | Published 30 minutes ago
What was set to be the first black and female-owned bank is now facing a bleak future. AFRIBIZ Financial Services is taking legal action against YWBN Co-Operative Financial Institution and its founder, Nthabeleng Likotsi, after a failed R9 million share deal in the controversial YWBN Mutual Bank. AFRIBIZ says it is determined to see Likotsi do the right thing.
The dispute began when AFRIBIZ paid R9 million to buy a 26% stake in YWBN Mutual Bank. However, the deal collapsed after YWBN allegedly failed to submit important compliance documents required by the Prudential Authority, South Africa's financial regulator.
Without these documents, the regulator could not approve the issuing of shares, putting the entire deal on hold.AFRIBIZ has accused YWBN of poor management and legal irregularities. The company says it spent significant time and money preparing for the investment and still wants to own the 26% stake it was promised.
In a letter to AFRIBIZ, YWBN admitted it could not meet the compliance requirements and offered to return the R9 million, even though the payment was originally marked as 'non-refundable.'
Still, this offer did not settle the matter. Instead, YWBN suggested offering just 2% of shares in full and final settlement, which AFRIBIZ rejected outright.'Our client remains committed to acquiring the full 26% shareholding,' AFRIBIZ's lawyers said in a statement following a meeting in April 2024.
This clash comes as YWBN faces growing criticism about its operations, governance, and leadership. Likotsi, once praised as South Africa's first woman to start a mutual bank, is now under scrutiny for a lack of transparency and mismanagement. Back in 2021, the Companies and Intellectual Property Commission (CIPC) Tribunal ordered YWBN to return money to investors.
It ruled that the bank had not followed legal rules under the Co-operatives Act, had poor financial recordkeeping, and had collected questionable 'non-refundable' membership fees from investors.
More recently, investors have raised concerns about YWBN relying on celebrity endorsements instead of proving its financial credibility. Legal experts say this case highlights risks in investing in new or unregulated financial institutions.
Advocate Mandla Tshabalala, a corporate law specialist, said, 'For any bank or financial institution, compliance and transparency are not optional — they're essential. Regulators must stay alert.'
As the legal battle heats up, AFRIBIZ is demanding that YWBN follow through on the original share agreement.
Despite YWBN's offer to return the R9 million, AFRIBIZ says it will continue legal action until the full deal is honoured.
This high-profile case has put the spotlight on South Africa's growing but fragile alternative banking sector. With trust in YWBN fading, many are now wondering if the dream of a women-led mutual bank can survive the fallout.
Asked about the previous issues with the CIPC Tribunal and now the legal dispute with AFRIBIZ, Likotsi said the YWBN received its clearance certificate from the CIPC, which indicates that we are compliant with all governance requirements.
'AfriBIZ Financial Services had a business interest in YWBN, when they couldn't meet the minimum basic compliance requirements, we explored different ways they could participate, however, we could not reach an agreement. YWBN remains open and committed to engaging AfriBIZ in future business endeavours'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
13 hours ago
- IOL News
Driving licence printing machine fixed but huge backlogs remain
The Department of Transport has repaired the driving licence card printing machine after months of downtime, but a significant backlog of unprinted cards remains. Image: File Millions have been spent on repairing and maintaining the driving licence card printing machine. The Department of Transport announced earlier last month that the driving licence printing machine was fixed and operations have resumed. The machine had been inoperative since February 5, resulting in a backlog of 747,748 unprinted cards. To reduce the backlog, the Department of Transport's Driving Licence Card Agency extended the working hours of its staff members. In light of this, in a parliamentary question and reply, Rise Mzansi leader Songezo Zibi asked Transport Minister Barbara Creecy about the number of times the machine broke down and how much it cost to repair it. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Zibi then asked how many employees it takes to operate the machine and how much overtime pay has been paid to employees due to lost printing time because of machine breakdowns. Zibi also asked Creecy if there was progress in acquiring a new card machine. Creecy said the backlog of driving licences as of May 15 was estimated at 733,000 cards. Creecy revealed the machine's major breakdowns in the past financial year are as follows: 2022/23 - 26 working days 2023/24 - 48 working days 2024/25 - 17 working days 2025/26 - 38 working days Over the same period, repairs and maintenance costs: 2022/23 - R9,267,862,33 2023/24 - R1,651,772,57 2024/25 - R544,747,64 2025/26 - R624,988,10 (to date) Overtime payment, over the last few financial years, has been: 2022/23 - R1,435,376,79 2023/24 - R1,608,102,52 2024/25 - R1,351,473,78 2025/26 - R0,00 Creecy said it takes four people to operate the machine. About progress made with the process to acquire a new driving licence card printing machine, Creecy said: 'The Minister has directed that a declaratory order be sought from a competent court on the tender to acquire a new machine, in order to ensure that no further irregular expenditure occurs.'
The Citizen
17 hours ago
- The Citizen
Two law firms get lion's share of RAF's R103m legal services spend
A disproportionately high 84%. Scopa wants to know why. Scopa chair Songezo Zibi was unimpressed that Scopa had to ask three times before the RAF supplied information about the top 10 law firms it uses. Picture: Michel Bega/ The Citizen The Road Accident Fund (RAF) paid 84% of the total R103.1 million it spent on corporate legal services in its 2024 financial year to Malatji & Co Attorneys Inc and Maponya Ledwaba Attorneys – just two of the 43 legal firms on its panel. Malatji & Co was paid R55.87 million by the RAF in 2024 and Maponya Ledwaba R30.75 million. The RAF revealed this in a presentation to Parliament's Standing Committee on Public Accounts (Scopa) last week. These two law firms were also paid the bulk of the amount the fund spent on legal services in the RAF's 2023 financial year, with Malatji & Co paid R15.25 million and Mopanya Ledwaba R14.86 million of the RAF's total corporate legal services bill of R34.26 million that year. Zibi said Malatji & Co in particular received 'an incredibly disproportionate portion of the work allocated by the RAF'. Source: RAF presentation to Scopa, 28 May 2025 This information was initially not made available to Scopa and was only provided after committee chair Songezo Zibi complained that it had twice requested information about the top 10 law firms that received briefs from the RAF and accused the fund of deliberately withholding this information from the committee for improper reasons. ALSO READ: RAF CEO placed on special leave with full pay, as MPs grill fund Law firm selection Acting RAF CEO Phathutshedzo Lukhwareni said a panel of 43 law firms was appointed by the RAF in December 2023 but only 19 were briefed and paid during the 2023 and 2024 financial years 'at the time of preparing the report [presentation]'. Lukhwareni said the RAF has a panel of law firms and the selection takes place depending on the complexity of the matter. Scopa member David Skosana of the ANC asked what criteria is used to allocate briefs among the 43 law firms, why only 19 firms had been briefed and paid, and what measures are in place to ensure cost effectiveness and equitable distribution of work among the firms on the panel. Scopa member Mark Burke of the DA said Maponya Ledwaba Attorneys was extracting R30 million a year from the RAF but 'has got one director, three senior associates and an associate as a secretary and an admin clerk'. 'Does that seem right? Does it seem reasonable that a firm with that staff cohort could be extracting that value and delivering value?' asked Burke. Lukhwareni said some of those disbursements were for counsel fees and the cost is determined by the complexity of the matters they have handled and, if the matter is prolonged for a number of years and goes all the way to the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) for instance, the cost will obviously be significant. He said repeat briefings are determined by the successes the law firm have registered in the previous cases but declined to comment on the size of Maponya Ledwaba Attorneys because he is not privy to this information. 'To the extent that they [the two law firms] are in the panel and are competent to be in the panel, I don't see any unreasonability in that,' he said. ALSO READ: RAF needs a Settlement Hub for crash victims – expert The 'complex' cases Mampe Kumalo, who was referred to by Lukhwareni as the RAF's head of legal but is the fund's chief governance officer, said the complex cases these firms had or were handling include the Discovery Health, South African Revenue Service (Sars) and Auditor-General matters. The Discovery Health matters relate to various applications it launched against the RAF linked to the failure of the fund to pay the past medical expenses of claimants. The Sars matter involved an application to stop and prevent the tax collection authority from deducting R5.1 billion – or any part of this amount from the RAF levies it collects – to pay Eskom in terms of a settlement agreement between Sars and the power utility. ALSO READ: R25.5 billion deficit over five years — Can RAF afford to pay out claims? Repeat business despite repeated failure Zibi requested Kumalo to provide Scopa with a detailed breakdown by the close of business on Thursday of the fees paid to the two firms, including attorney fees, party-party costs, the cost of counsel and punitive costs orders against the RAF. 'The reason I want this is that you have persistently been clobbered on the AG matter by a law firm you continue to pay and see absolutely no reason to seek another law firm,' he said. Deputy Minister of Transport Mkhuleko Hlengwa said they must not be ignorant to the fundamental risk which prevails at the RAF because of the lawyers. 'The abuse of the system and the leakages of the money not reaching claimants in part is a result of the construct of the RAF. 'Why are we spending so much money on legal fees?,' he asked. 'We should be spending it on claimants because the whole system is fundamentally structured in a way which is problematic, hence the bill that we will be bringing … to parliament.' ALSO READ: RAF national crisis demands urgent action – expert Malatji responds Approached for comment about how the firm was able to receive such high fees from the RAF and if it has had any engagements with the Special Investigating Unit (SIU), Tebogo Malatji – MD of Malatji & Co Attorneys – told Moneyweb the firm has no way of knowing how the RAF decides to appoint attorneys on matters and what criteria it uses to do so. 'We are thus unable to tender the explanation you seek and suggest that you direct the question to the RAF. As the two directors primarily responsible for the servicing [of] the RAF, I have 31 years practice experience and Ms Sunelle Eloff, 24 years,' he said. 'We have personal injury law experience from the time that we started practice, have acted for the RAF for the most part of our practice lifespan and are therefore experts in the field. 'We are also one of the leading public law specialist firms in the country. 'We can only but speculate that the reasons the RAF instructed us in each instance that they did must have something to do with our years of experience, expertise and suitability for the matter at hand,' said Malatji. 'We have acted for the RAF in several of their most complex matters assisted by senior and junior counsel from the Bar and that accounts for the high value of payments to our firm displayed. 'Moreover, the figures displayed at Scopa as being payments to our firm consist primarily of counsel/advocates and other disbursements and to a lesser extent fees to our firm,' he added 'Until we are confronted with the actual number of instructions issued by RAF to its panel attorneys, we do not accept your assumption that it is our firm that allegedly received a disproportionate number of instructions.' Malatji added that the SIU has not engaged the firm on this issue. Maponya Ledwaba Attorneys has not responded to a Moneyweb request for comment on these same issues. This article was republished from Moneyweb. Read the original here.
The Citizen
3 days ago
- The Citizen
Three GNT execs suspended
On Tuesday, the financially bleeding company was forced to pay R9 million of the missing money. Widows of former Great North Transport employees join affected former and current employees to picket outside of the Office of the Limpopo Premier in demand of the implementation of recommendations made in an investigation regarding the whereabouts of lost pension funds. Picture: Supplied Limpopo Great North Transport (GNT) has placed its chief executive officer (CEO), Dr Matata Mokoele, chief operations officer (COO), Ms Mahlako Mogoshoane, and chief finance officer (CFO), Nazeem Essa, on precautionary suspension. The organisation is a subsidiary of the Limpopo Department of Economic Development, Environment and Tourism (LEDET). The trio were suspended on Tuesday following allegations of financial misconduct amounting to R9 million. It is alleged that medical aid and pension funds belonging to more than 280 employees have not been paid for a considerable number of years. On Tuesday, the financially bleeding company was forced to pay R9 million of the missing money. The agency confirmed on Friday that the trio had been suspended with pay, pending the outcome of internal investigations. 'This resolution was taken in response to serious concerns related to financial governance, operational delivery, and executive accountability. 'The suspensions are effective immediately and will remain in place for a period not exceeding three (3) months,' said the company. During this period, the Board said it will be engaging the shareholder, the Limpopo Economic Development Agency (LEDA), to provide strategic and operational support, including the secondment of interim leadership resources to ensure the continued delivery of essential public transport services. 'We appeal for cooperation and support from all stakeholders during this transitional period and will provide further updates as necessary,' said the board. ANC Youth League welcome decision The ANC Youth League in Limpopo commended the company for its action. Provincial secretary Phineas Sebola said the lack of pension payments has had a profound impact on retired and current employees, particularly those reliant on pensions for income. ALSO READ: Unpaid provident fund sparks protest by Great North Transport employees Some employees, he said, had unfortunately passed away before receiving their money they were owed. Sebola added that the company has a responsibility to rectify logistical issues in Limpopo and provide affordable transportation services. 'This viable transport mode for our people has been disconnected from the communities due to financial mismanagement. 'As the ANCYL, we view this as an opportunity for our parents, brothers, and sisters who worked for the company for years to receive justice and ultimately obtain what is due to them. 'In addition, the ANCYL advocates for the review of the board and urges the departments responsible to consider dissolving the board and bringing a new structure dominated by young people to bring life in GNT. 'It is in our view that the board has not been doing its work efficiently. Instead, it is now shifting the problem to senior executives. 'We believe that older members may be experiencing diminishing returns in terms of their capacity, leading to ineffective governance of our institutions or companies. 'The inclusion of young people will bring fresh perspectives and energetic engagement to the table, offsetting potential fatigue among older members and facilitating the efficient operation of the company,' Sebola explained. DA lay charges On Monday the DA, the third biggest political party in Limpopo after the EFF and the ANC, laid criminal charged at the Polokwane police station against LEDET and LEDA. This followed years of complaints over unpaid pension fund and medical aid payments to GNT employees. 'The board and executive management of LEDA, as the sole shareholder of GNT, bear statutory and fiduciary oversight responsibilities for GNT's operations and financial conduct. They, too, must be held accountable and face consequences. 'Unpaid contributions for pension fund schemes now total R6.78 million, affecting 945 employees. In some cases, employee membership has already been suspended. 'If a partial payment of R1 million is not made by the end of May, all employee memberships will be suspended. 'If the default continues, employees risk permanently losing their pension benefits. 'Medical unpaid contributions totalled R3.21 million, affecting 247 employees. All medical aid coverage for GNT employees has been suspended, meaning employees cannot access healthcare services unless they pay out of pocket,' said Jacques Smalle, Member of the Provincial Legislature in Lebowakgomo. On Friday, LEDA told The Citizen that it has settled the bill and paid an amount of R9 million towards the employees' pension fund and medical aid contributions. NOW READ: R15m in road unworthiness fines for Great North Transport
