Ex-MP Maria Chin fails in challenge to shariah show-cause order
Published on: Thursday, June 26, 2025
Published on: Thu, Jun 26, 2025
By: Ho Kit Yen, FMT Text Size: Ex-Petaling Jaya MP Maria Chin Abdullah was sentenced by the shariah court to seven days' jail for contempt of court on April 25, 2022. PUTRAJAYA: The Federal Court has unanimously denied former Petaling Jaya MP Maria Chin Abdullah leave to appeal in her bid to challenge a show-cause order issued by the shariah court for alleged contempt. Justice Nordin Hassan said Maria had failed to show the existence of a novel issue warranting a hearing of her appeal. 'The issue of the jurisdiction of the shariah and civil courts was made clear in previous cases, including a recent one on a woman's challenge against her religious status,' he said. Also on the panel hearing the application were Justices Abu Jais Bakar and Vazeer Alam Mydin Meera. The court made no order in respect of costs. In her bid to initiate a judicial review, Maria had asked the High Court to quash a shariah court order handed down on Oct 14, 2019 allowing businessman SM Faisal SM Nasimuddin leave to initiate contempt proceedings against her. She claimed the order was made in bad faith. The order was made in respect of a press statement Maria issued on Sept 5, 2019, in which she claimed that 'Muslim women are still being discriminated (against) under Malaysia's shariah legal system'. She said the shariah court's decision to sentence Faisal's former wife, Emilia Hanafi, to seven days in prison for rescheduling his visitation dates with their children was a 'grave injustice' and a 'total disgrace to the judicial system'. The shariah high court sentenced Maria to seven days' jail for contempt of court on April 25, 2022. In the underlying proceedings, the High Court granted Maria leave to challenge the show-cause order, but the Court of Appeal reversed that decision last year. The appeals court ruled that the civil courts have no jurisdiction to hear matters from the shariah court. Maria was represented by lawyers Bahari Yeow and Rosli Dahlan while senior federal counsel Ahmad Hanir Hambaly appeared for the government. Lawyer Akberdin Abdul Kader, who held a watching brief for Faisal today, later said Maria would have to go back to the shariah appeals court for her appeal against the seven-day sentence. Religious affairs minister Na'im Mokhtar meanwhile urged the public to respect the court's decision, and the shariah court as a legitimate and sovereign judicial institution. 'I must emphasise that any attempt to make room for civil court interference in shariah court decisions not only goes against the spirit of the constitution, but also jeopardises the stability of the dual legal system that is a hallmark of the Malaysian judiciary,' he said in a Facebook post. * Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel and Telegram for breaking news alerts and key updates! * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available.
Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
9 hours ago
- New Straits Times
NST Leader: Of Little Napoleons
Often observed throwing their weight around and lording over those who rely on them, "Little Napoleons" create tension wherever they go — be it a government department, a corporate office or a school. While their disruptive presence is widely acknowledged in Malaysian society, little has been done to curb this persistent irritation. What makes these individuals particularly bothersome is their penchant for imposing unwarranted strictures on straightforward administrative processes — actions they likely deem brilliant, or believe will serve the interests of their superiors. Such examples stretch back decades: recall how women whose attires failed to meet specific conservative values were subjected to the humiliating "hair-dryer" treatment, seemingly an assertion of moral superiority. The "Little Napoleon" concept originates from the "Napoleon Complex", also known as the "Napoleon Syndrome" or "Short-Man Syndrome". While often linked to men of short stature who display overbearing public behaviour — a perceived compensation for physical or social shortcomings — the full extent of a Little Napoleon's conduct is rarely visible. Their actions are, in fact, much worse when unobserved. These individuals shower favouritism on the well-connected or those willing to "pay extra", disregarding established procedures. They deliberately obstruct or delay services, creating unnecessary bureaucratic hurdles, and demand bribes for essential services or approvals. They also harass and threaten those who challenge their actions, using their influence to suppress dissent. A clear example is when Raja of Perlis, Tuanku Syed Sirajuddin Putra Jamalullail, criticised the "Little Napoleon" culture at the Kangar Municipal Council after a rebranding initiative, meant to reflect its statewide role, was deliberately undermined; a critique the state's top officials quickly acknowledged. The "Little Napoleon" phenomenon, far from being a simple nuisance, has bred public distrust, bureaucratic inefficiency and organisational demoralisation. They resist modernisation, preferring traditional systems that afford them control, and oppose diversity and inclusion to maintain a homogenous workforce they can dominate. And yes, they routinely deflect accountability for their errors. Tackling this requires comprehensive governance and oversight, including increased transparency, accountability, public education and advocacy to ensure these civil servants are held responsible. Perhaps establishing an independent ombudsman or internal affairs unit could effectively resolve the problem of Little Napoleons undermining the government's good work. Public service unions are known to defend "Little Napoleons", dismissing concerns about their impact on service until it's too late. Still, the government should not cower from losing public favour or give in to political blackmail when purging unmotivated, unproductive and uncommitted civil servants. For these "Little Napoleons", it's simple: shape up or get shipped out.
Malaysiakini
10 hours ago
- Malaysiakini
Is DAP gunning for non-Muslim armed forces chief, PAS leader asks
In a bizarre turnaround, PAS supreme council member Zuhdi Marsuki accused DAP of stoking racial sentiments over the promotion of a non-Malay to lieutenant-general in the armed forces. Congratulating Johnny Lim on his new post, Zuhdi questioned if DAP is looking to have a non-Muslim lead the armed forces in the future. 'Because DAP made an issue out of the matter, I want to ask...
The Sun
10 hours ago
- The Sun
ASEAN SOMTC focuses on combating 10 cross-border crimes
KUALA LUMPUR: The 25th ASEAN Senior Officials Meeting on Transnational Crime (SOMTC) concluded in Putrajaya after five days of intensive discussions aimed at combating 10 major cross-border crimes affecting the region. The meeting, hosted by Malaysia as the ASEAN Chair, focused on terrorism, cybercrime, human trafficking, drug smuggling, wildlife and timber trafficking, and money laundering. Mohamad Azlan Razali, secretary of the Ministry of Home Affairs (KDN) International Division, highlighted Malaysia's key role in shaping short-term and long-term action plans to strengthen regional crime-fighting efforts. 'The SOMTC platform allows us to move collectively and coordinate actions at regional and domestic levels,' Mohamad Azlan said during an appearance on Bernama TV's 'ASEAN: From Kuala Lumpur to the World' programme. He emphasised the importance of partnerships with dialogue countries like the US and China in knowledge and technology transfer. The meeting, which began on June 23, included senior officials from all ASEAN member states, observer country Timor-Leste, and representatives from 10 dialogue partners, including the US, China, the UK, and Australia. One key challenge discussed was the differing legal frameworks among ASEAN nations, particularly in handling crimes like drug trafficking. To address this, a long-term initiative involves publishing a legal handbook to serve as a common reference for member countries. 'Through this handbook, each member country can review their legislation to better combat cross-border crimes,' Mohamad Azlan explained. The SOMTC also facilitates strategic information sharing among ASEAN nations to dismantle transnational crime syndicates more effectively. For instance, close cooperation between Malaysian police and neighbouring countries has helped rescue citizens trapped in scam call centres abroad.
