Defence lawyer tries to poke holes in Crown's case, asks jury to find Adam Drake not guilty
Adam Drake's defence lawyer Michael Lacy (centre) made closing arguments on Monday, asking the jury to find his client not guilty of second-degree murder. (CTV Atlantic / Callum Smith)
Adam Drake's defence lawyer tried to poke holes in the Crown's case against him on Monday.
The defence made their closing arguments to the jury, asking them to find Drake not guilty of second-degree murder in the death of battle rapper Pat Stay.
Defence lawyer Michael Lacy said the Crown is asking jurors to use 'confirmation bias' to deliver a guilty verdict – something they took an oath to reject, vowing to judge fairly.
He called out several flaws in the quality of surveillance video, which is a key piece of evidence for the Crown. If it was that clear, the Crown would've played the video and sat down, he said.
The defence described the footage as grainy, saying people can't accurately identify movement, and that the camera's distance from the stabbing creates another challenge.
Lacy raised several questions, saying jurors might wonder why another man chased down Stay and sucker punched him after, asking if that man was 'finishing off what he started?' The jury heard that man was arrested after the stabbing along with another.
Lacy argued there's no evidence whatsoever that Adam Drake made physical contact with Pat Stay.
He suggested the Crown has simply not proven beyond a reasonable doubt that Drake – to the exclusion of other potential suspects – stabbed Pat Stay.
The only 'just' decision, according to Lacy, would be to return a not-guilty verdict.
He also highlighted testimony that Drake's demeanour didn't change after the stabbing, that he went to a hotel room with a friend's family and left the next day wearing the same clothing.
He also pointed out that no blood or DNA was detected on Drake's satchel which he wore that night.
He acknowledged Stay was beloved, that he deserves justice, his family deserves answers, and the community wants closure. However, he added 'real justice' doesn't come from convicting someone 'to find peace.'
'You can't convict Adam Drake on suspicion, uncertainty, or desire to resolve a tragic case,' he said. 'You require clear, reliable proof.'
Lacy said finding proof beyond a reasonable doubt is a 'heavy burden' to reach because it's to avoid the risk of convicting an innocent person.
'The defence does not have to prove anything. The burden is on the Crown to overcome the presumption of innocence,' Lacy said.
While wrapping up his closing arguments, Lacy reminded the jury that the Crown gave 19 reasons to convict Drake. But he said jurors only 'need one to acquit: reasonable doubt.'
He told the jury they could not rule out at least three other people that he suggested could've been responsible and asked them to return a not guilty verdict.
The jury will begin deliberating on Tuesday, after Justice Scott Norton gives final instructions.
For more Nova Scotia news, visit our dedicated provincial page
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
16 minutes ago
- CBC
Cape Breton regional police adding cameras for officers, cars and downtown streets
Police officers, patrol cars and even some streets in the former towns of the Cape Breton Regional Municipality are expected to be outfitted with video recording equipment sometime this fall. Bodycams, dashcams and surveillance equipment will make citizens and officers safer and provide better evidence in court cases, Chief Robert Walsh said Tuesday after a meeting of the municipality's board of police commissioners. The street cameras will likely deter some crimes and help police solve others that may have happened or are in progress, he said. "If there was a critical incident such as an armed robbery or an active shooter, our communications centre could access that video livestream in real time, get the information, the images, and provide that detail to our officers in real time, so we have a better situational awareness and a better response for police," Walsh said. The public may have some concerns about privacy, but police will have policies that should alleviate those worries, he said. "The cameras in downtown cores and at key intersections would only be used for an investigative purpose and we want to reassure the public that they are not monitored continuously," the chief said. Bodycams and dashcams will make police operations more transparent, Walsh said. However, he said policies are still being developed on when those cameras can be activated or deactivated by officers. He said guidance on that may be coming from the province. The force is getting quotes for all the cameras this summer. Depending on cost, it plans to buy up to nine dashcams for patrol cars, more than 120 bodycams for officers and up to 50 street surveillance systems. Street cameras will not only go in downtown Sydney, they'll also go up in the former towns of North Sydney, Sydney Mines, Glace Bay, New Waterford, Dominion and Louisbourg. The police budget this year includes about $700,000 for equipment, much of which will be for cameras and software. Walsh has said in a previous interview that the cost of the software includes unlimited cloud-based data storage that will be able to handle video files. CBRM Coun. Glenn Paruch, who chairs the police commission, said the cameras are a good idea. "It's change, but I think change is needed here in the city," he said. Privacy concerns There will always be some people with concerns about their privacy on public streets, but some downtown businesses already have their own cameras trained on their stores. That doesn't seem to deter shoppers, Paruch said. The difference is that police surveillance cameras will only be viewed when a crime has been committed or is in progress, he said. "If there was no incident, they can't just go use that without having proper cause." Walsh said Cape Breton police will use Charlottetown as a model for its camera system. Police there have labelled all street cameras with the city's E-Watch brand to notify the public about the presence of video surveillance.
CTV News
20 minutes ago
- CTV News
Suspect reportedly seen with gun in Kensington Market crashes into police cruiser
A suspect reportedly seen with a gun in Kensington Market crashed a vehicle into a police cruiser, Toronto police say. (Mike Nguyen/ CP24) A suspect who was reportedly seen with a gun in Kensington Market crashed into a police cruiser in the area early Thursday morning. Police said they were called to the area of Augusta Avenue and Denison Square at around 4:20 a.m. for reports of a person with a gun. Police said the suspect fled in a vehicle but later collided with a police cruiser in the area. No injuries were reported. The investigation is ongoing, police said, and some road closures are in place in the area.
CTV News
21 minutes ago
- CTV News
Still searching: Jennifer Catcheway's story
Winnipeg Watch Bernice and Wilfred Catcheway share their 17-year journey searching for their daughter, missing since her 18th birthday.
