‘We don't try people in the media': Attorneys voice concerns with online civilian groups
SPRINGFIELD, Mo. — A group of citizens are taking justice into their own hands to catch predators.
A Lebanon man is now charged with attempting to entice a minor online after a citizen group tipped off police.
However, the group 'Operation Soap' found itself in a controversy after Lebanon Police put out a statement about what it calls 'vigilante groups.'
This statement sparked controversy online and Ozarks First is continuing to follow the story now that charges have been filed.
Ozarks First asked a prosecutor and a defense attorney how they feel about these online groups.
'Law enforcement agencies can't partner with them,' said Greene County Prosecutor Dan Patterson. 'They can't turn them into agents of the state. That can create problems for a case. And under their task force standards, they can't partner with citizen-led groups for a number of reasons.'
PREVIOUS COVERAGE: Arrest made after citizen group brings attention to police
'My advice to these kind of vigilante groups is leave that sort of thing up to the police and let them do their investigation, then it would be much more likely to be upheld in court,' said criminal defense attorney Adam Woody.
Both the Springfield Police Department and Greene County Sheriff's Office are members of the Cyber Crimes task force in Southwest Missouri.
'They cannot, under the standards of those organizations, work with a citizen group conducting its own investigation outside of law enforcement,' Patterson said. 'It's prohibited by their standards.'
Patterson says the best approach to these cases is to support local law enforcement.
'So that we both protect convictions, due process, and the integrity of the criminal justice system,' Patterson said.
Under Missouri law, there's a statute that says the 'bait' must be an actual minor or a police officer.
'When the statute was originally written, it had some language about it not being an offense that a police officer was posing as an underage person,' Patterson said. 'As the law evolved, the Supreme Court basically said this is a poorly written statute and they kind of unwrote that part of the statute.'
Ozark County Jail enters into contract with ICE
'If the state were to try to pursue actual enticement of a child charges with a vigilante group as the victim, that's not something that would that would pass muster,' Woody said. 'That would be dismissed relatively quickly because it's contrary to the statute.'
While that's still part of the statute, it has changed to include an attempt at the crime.
'If the person believes they're communicating with an underage person and they take a substantial step to committing whatever crime it is, then it could be prosecuted,' Patterson said. 'Again, the key is the integrity of the investigation.'
Woody explained the circumstances further.
'Even if the other person is not an actual minor or a police officer masquerading as a minor, prosecutors can still proceed under an attempt provision for the person making an attempt to commit the offense,' Woody said.
It was through this statute that 29-year-old Michael Rupe of Lebanon was arrested and now charged.
Court records show a local civilian group was able to provide evidence to Lebanon Police of Rupe messaging who he believed to be a 14-year-old girl.
'I'd encourage any citizen, if you believe there's a child who's being enticed or aware of an offender who's using the internet in that manner to make a tip to the Springfield Police Department, the sheriff's office or the task force on Internet Crimes Against Children,' Patterson said.
Patterson says none of these civilian-led cases have come across his desk.
'I know that some reports have been made to the Springfield Police Department,' Patterson said. 'We've not received any of those for investigation.'
Citizens can file a report with the MoICAC task force online.
'We have to provide due process to the defendant and convict them in a courtroom, not in a Facebook video,' Patterson said.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
17 hours ago
- Yahoo
Cal Fire employee arrested at Patterson station in child porn case
A Cal Fire firefighter was arrested Thursday while on duty at a fire station in Patterson following a cybertip that led investigators to suspect he was in possession of child pornography, authorities said. Joseph Trevor Forney, 41, is facing multiple felony charges after an investigation by the Manteca Police Department's Hi-Tech Crimes and Internet Crimes Against Children (ICAC) unit uncovered sexually explicit material involving minors — including children under 10 years old. Detective Matthew Phillips of the Manteca Police Department received a tip from the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children on May 8, according to a news release. Using online forensic tools, Phillips identified Forney as a suspect and obtained both a search warrant and an arrest warrant. Police said Forney had uploaded, possessed and distributed child sexual abuse material. He was taken into custody June 5 while working at the Cal Fire Del Puerto station in Patterson, where he was assigned as a full-time employee. According to authorities, Forney has worked for Cal Fire since 2023 and has been stationed in the Patterson, Santa Clara and Santa Cruz areas. He also has a prior criminal history in Idaho and completed parole in 2024. Police emphasized that his past convictions were not related to child sexual exploitation. Forney was booked into the San Joaquin County Jail and faces the following charges: Possession/distribution of obscene material depicting a minor Possession of obscene matter involving a sex act with a minor under 12 Sexual depiction of a minor engaged in sexual conduct Annoying or molesting a victim under 18. 'Cal Fire demands its employees uphold standards of professional conduct both on and off duty. We are aware of this criminal case and are monitoring it closely. Cal Fire will determine next steps as these investigations progresses,' the agency said in a statement. 'The department urges anyone with information related to this case — or who may know of children who have disclosed being victimized by Joseph Forney — to contact Phillips at mphillips@ or 209-456-8101,' police said. The case reference number is 25-02083.
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
LPD arrests 15 after drug investigation
Lebanon Police have announced the arrest of 15 individuals after indictments on 85 counts of drug and weapon related offenses. The arrestss came as the department closed an investigation recently. The LPD's Special Operations Division conducted a targeted operation to arrest the individuals at the end of May. This follows an investigation by the Narcotics Unit into drug sales within the city. While serving the arrest warrants, LPD also arrested four other individuals on outstanding warrants. 'We're proud of the dedicated efforts of our detectives, investigators and officers who made this operation a success,' LPD said in a press release. 'We're also grateful to the Wilson County Sheriff's Office for their assistance.' The District Attorney General's office in Lebanon released the names of the individuals. Bradley Carey, Christopher Cason, Demetris Cason, Tabitha Cook, Brittany Fox, Damon Grimmett, Frederick Henderson, Monti Hill, David Jackson, Quantae Jackson, D'auvionne Jennings, Charles Miller, Laretta Patterson, Bettie Steward and Richard Worley were arrested on a total of 85 counts of drug and weapons charges. The names of the other four arrested on outstanding warrants have not been released.
Miami Herald
3 days ago
- Miami Herald
Patterson questioned about intentions, feelings for poisoned victims
June 6 (UPI) -- The prosecution in the Erin Patterson mushroom murder meal trial went another round with Patterson Friday to prove she purposely invited her estranged husband Simon's family over to her house for a meal in order to kill them. Patterson has maintained that she asked Simon's parents Don and Gail Patterson, and his aunt and uncle Heather and Ian Wilkinson, over for that meal, a lunch of beef Wellington, to her home in Australia in August of 2023 to tell them about a cancer diagnosis. She has since admitted she misled them about having cancer but instead had really invited them to her home to discuss her plans to have weight-loss surgery. Don and Gail died later that week, as did Heather, from the ingestion of poisonous death cap mushrooms, which prosecutors allege Erin purposely put in their lunch. Ian was sickened and hospitalized but survived. Prosecutor Nanette Rogers alleged in her opening statement Friday that Patterson did not consume death cap mushrooms at the lunch, but pretended to have been sickened as a cover-up and that was "why we say she was reluctant to receive medical treatment for death cap mushroom poisoning." Rogers put forth to Patterson that she not only had allegedly invited the victims over to kill them with a death cap-laced meal, but had furthermore prepared an extra poisoned meal in case Simon, who had declined his invitation to dine that day, changed his mind and came to eat. Patterson testified Tuesday that she had only eaten a small portion of the beef Wellington lunch because she was deep in conversation and later had vomited up the food because she also ate cake and has a history of binging and purging. Patterson also testified that she went to the hospital after the meal but discharged herself against medical advice, which prosecutors used to suggest that she was not sickened by the food. The prosecution then alleged Patterson purposely didn't feed the poisoned meal to her kids, which was why she didn't have them medically assessed. Rogers also mentioned messages Patterson allegedly sent to her Facebook friends, and to Don, Gail and Simon. "You had two faces, a public face of appearing to have a good relationship with Don and Gail," she said to Patterson. "I suggest your private face was the one you showed in your Facebook message group." Rogers went back through messages Patterson ostensibly wrote about Don and Gail, which were laced with expletives and allegedly mentioned she wanted "nothing to do" with them. She also suggested that Patterson had not shown any concern for Simon's parents, never asking how they felt after learning they were initially sickened. "Incorrect," Patterson said. Rogers then asked, "And you never asked how Heather was going, and I assume you disagree?" "Correct," Patterson replied. Patterson has pleaded not guilty to three counts of murder and one of attempted murder in the case. She will take the stand again Tuesday. Copyright 2025 UPI News Corporation. All Rights Reserved.
