Protests in Goa over NIO hydrologists' report claiming Mahadayi river diversion will have limited impact on the coastal State
A protest has emerged in Goa following the publication of a scientific paper, 'The water budget of the Mahadayi river and its implications for the inter-State dispute', by scientists and researchers from the CSIR- National Institute of Oceanography (NIO), Goa and the Indian National Centre for Ocean Information Services, Ministry of Earth Sciences, Hyderabad.
Also Read | Farmers in Karnataka condemn Centre's decision to extend term of Mahadayi tribunal
The legal dispute between Karnataka and Goa over the water sharing agreement from the Mahadayi river has lasted over two decades. Despite the Mahadayi Water Disputes Tribunal's (MWDT) order five years ago, the matter remains an emotional subject in both the States.
The paper, published in the Journal of Earth System Sciences by scientists and researchers: K. Anilkumar, D. Shankar and K. Suprit — has assessed the water budget of the Mahadayi river, an inter-State basin on India's west coast, by using rainfall mapping and rainfall run-off model to allow them to simulate the discharge at any point along the Mahadayi.
The river, called Mahadayi in Karnataka and Mhadei in Goa, arises in the Western Ghats and flows into the eastern Arabian Sea. This river basin is spread over three States — Goa, Karnataka, and Maharashtra.
The paper says Karnataka's plans for diversion of the river as approved by the MWDT would not have much impact on Goa. The diversion from the Kalasa tributary could have 'significant impact' but its impact is restricted to the northern part of the Mhadei Wildlife Sanctuary in Goa.
Scientists recommend that by creating check dams and storage facilities inside the wildlife sanctuary, the ecological impact of the river diversion could be minimised.
The length of the Mahadayi in Karnataka is 36 km and its length in Goa is 74 km. The Mahadayi basin covers an area of 2,032 sq km of which 380 sq km (18%) is in Karnataka, 72 sq km (4%) in Maharashtra, and 1,580 sq km (78%) in Goa. The tribunal has permitted the Karnataka government to utilise 1.72 tmcft of water from Kalasa nala and 2.18 tmcft from Bhandura Nala (two of the main tributaries of Mahadayi).
Tillari dam example
The researchers suggest a solution in the paper that Goa and Karnataka can reach an agreement on similar lines to the one Goa has with Maharashtra for the Tillari dam, in which the dam is built upstream on the Maharashtra side, since Goa does not have the space nor the geography to host a large dam without a huge environmental and people cost — and both States have a share of the water.
For the Kalasa nala, there is a significant impact of the permitted diversion — 1.72 tmcft (48.7 Mcum) by the Mhadei Water Dispute Tribunal in the northern part of the Mhadei Wildlife Sanctuary, but the impact on the Mahadayi discharge on the Mandovi estuary is less than the natural variability. Similarly, the diversion of 2.18 tmcft (61.73 Mcum) from the Bhandura nala as permitted by the tribunal will only have a minor impact on the (river's) discharge at the Goa–Karnataka border, the paper said.
The MWDT was set up in 2010 following the failure of the States to reach an agreement.
The tribunal passed the order in August 2018 and in its award granted Karnataka a total of 13.42 tmcft (380 Mcum) of water of which 8.02 tmcft (227 Mcum) was for the proposed Mhadei Hydroelectric project, 1.5 tmcft (42 Mcum) for in basin use and irrigation and allowed the diversion of 1.72 tmcft (48 Mcum) of water from the Kalasa stream and 2.18 tmcft (61 Mcum) at the proposed Bandura dam. In all, the tribunal permitted Karnataka to divert 110 Mcum of water from the Mhadei basin to the east flowing into Malaprabha basin.
Both the States have challenged the tribunal's verdict before the Supreme Court.
'Though the tribunal upheld Goa's contention that the projects would jeopardise navigation in the Mandovi estuary, available information is sufficient to show that these projects have no impact on navigation in the Mandovi estuary or the Cumbarjua Canal. Indeed, navigation in the Mandovi, which is made possible by the tides, is possible even during the lean season, when the natural flow of the Mhadei is negligible,' the paper said.
Demand explanation
Following this report, members of the Mhadei Movement, dressed in blue T-shirt, staged a protest outside the NIO complex near Goa's Dona Paula, with placards displaying a red cross mark on the photographs of the scientists, shaming them, with words such as 'BJP sold Mahadayi', 'Mhadei deal by NIO', 'Anti-Goa NIO'... demanding an explanation from the hydrologists and the institutes for the reason behind publishing the report.
Revolutionary Goans Party (RGP) president Manoj Parab said, 'Why are the non-Goan scientists running research on this subject that does not concern them? We are questioning the timing of this report. We spoke to environmentalist Rajendra Kerkar who has done extensive research on Mhadei and he told us that the NIO scientists wrote the report sitting inside their air-conditioned office without having any ground understanding. The three scientists have manufactured this report to favour Karnataka which has gone ahead with the construction of dams on the river, despite the case being heard by the Supreme Court. This is a conspiracy by the BJP.'
The party further demanded Goa Chief Minister Pramod Sawant and Congress leaders from the State to come out and speak on the matter and make their stand clear or are they too in favour of the report, Mr. Parab questioned.
Viresh Mukesh Borkar, RGP's MLA, said, 'The report was published on September 11, 2024, quietly, and no one knew. It is surprising as the Chief Minister also did not say a word on this for so many months. This looks like a hidden agenda of the BJP government. When the case is already before the Supreme Court, publishing this report means the scientists want to favour the case of the Karnataka government. It is a known fact that Goa's groundwater is depleting, and this river serves the people and flora and fauna of north Goa, if they block its flow from the Western Ghats, Goa will face a man-made disaster.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
a day ago
- The Hindu
Proposed extension centre of CSIR-National Institute for Interdisciplinary Science and Technology to focus on core areas of research and product development
A satellite centre planned by the CSIR-National Institute for Interdisciplinary Science and Technology (CSIR-NIIST) at the Bio 360 Life Sciences Park here at Thonnakkal will focus on core areas of research and product development, including solar-driven hydrogen production from wastewater. A State Cabinet meeting on Thursday (June 5) gave the nod for establishing the 'Extension Centre for Innovation, Technology and Entrepreneurship.' The Cabinet approval also included allocation of 10 acres of land on a 90-year lease at the Bio 360 Life Sciences Park. Collaborative hub 'The proposed CSIR-NIIST innovation centre will serve as a collaborative hub fostering interdisciplinary research, product development, and entrepreneurship,' NIIST officials said. Major initiatives planned under it include a pilot plant for the solar-driven production of hydrogen from wastewater, an AYUSH manufacturing and standardisation hub, a production line for biopolymer and bio-based products, a bio-enabler bio manufacturing unit and a regional resource development centre. It will also be the first satellite centre of NIIST, a laboratory under the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR). NIIST described the decision to establish the centre as a strategic move aligned with its mission to drive sustainable, inclusive innovation and reinforce Kerala's position as a hub for science-driven entrepreneurship. The Bio 360 Life Sciences Park is a flagship initiative of the State government's Kerala State Industrial Development Corporation (KSIDC).
Time of India
2 days ago
- Time of India
Neeri studying health effects of microplastics, experts discuss sustainable tech, waste management
Nagpur: CSIR-Neeri director Dr S Venkata Mohan on Thursday expressed concern over plastic waste entering the oceans during his address at the institute's auditorium on the occasion of World Environment Day. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now "Plastic waste is a major issue globally. Only 10% of plastic is being recycled. Plastic management is a multi-pronged issue. Neeri is monitoring microplastic, toxicology and health issues from it," he said. Dr Mohan described Neeri's role in plastics management, including the monitoring of microplastics in air, water, and soil. He also mentioned that Neeri is actively involved in health studies related to microplastic exposure. He briefed the audience on technologies such as waste-to-graphene conversion and thermocatalytic combustion for plastic waste management. K Rajeevan, vice president and chief technology officer, Larsen and Toubro Limited, Chennai, was the chief guest. Besides Dr Mohan, Dr P Ganesh Kumar, R&D Head, L&T Water Technology Centre, Chennai, was also present. A meeting was also held between Rajeevan and Neeri scientists to explore new avenues for joint research, technology transfer, and deployment Rajeevan said that science and technology can play a pivotal role in converting plastics into biodegradable materials. He highlighted the importance of interdisciplinary collaboration to tackle complex environmental challenges. He stressed the need to shift from a linear to a circular economy and called for a change in mindset — from exploitation of nature to co-existence with it. He also underlined the value of sustainable innovations in industrial processes and urged scientists and engineers to develop scalable and affordable green technologies. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Rajeevan briefed about water supply, irrigation, and municipal wastewater projects accomplished by Larsen and Toubro Limited. He discussed smart monitoring systems, automation, and advanced technologies such as membrane filtration and MBBR, highlighting their role in delivering efficient, sustainable, and scalable water and irrigation solutions for both urban and industrial applications. He informed that the Prime Minister recently inaugurated the L&T-built Surya Regional Bulk Water Supply Scheme to ensure a water-secure future for Vasai-Virar and Mira Bhayandar regions. He also highlighted the futuristic innovations of L&T's Water Resource Centre.. Dr Debishree Khan, senior scientist, Neeri, conducted the proceedings. Prakash Kumbhare, senior principal scientist, Neeri, proposed a vote of thanks.
The Hindu
2 days ago
- The Hindu
On a wing and a prayer
On April 4, the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research – National Aerospace Laboratories (CSIR-NAL) announced that it had entered into a 'historic agreement' with a private company, Pioneer Clean AMPS Pvt Ltd, to manufacture the upgraded version of the Hansa-3, called the Hansa-3 NG (Next Generation). This two-seater trainer aircraft gives trainee pilots the opportunity to practise within India while undergoing their basic flying training. Touted as 'India's only government R&D organisation in civil aircraft development', CSIR-NAL is in Bengaluru and was established in 1959. 'While we have had a successful track record, we have now managed to seal a partnership with a private company, which will manufacture these planes,' N. Kalaiselvi, Director-General, CSIR, had said at the launch event held in Delhi. It was also presided over by Union Minister for Science and Technology Jitendra Singh and Minister for Civil Aviation Ram Mohan Naidu. Pioneer Clean AMPS Pvt Ltd is three years old and expected to set up manufacturing facilities as well as handle marketing, servicing, and after-sales. NAL will be closely involved in the initial years to help the company with various aspects of manufacturing and operations, says Abhay Pashilkar, Director, CSIR-NAL. Kishore Patel, founder and managing director of the Mumbai-based company, says his experience in business lay in the chemicals and automotive sector, but he decided to venture into aircraft manufacturing because of the opportunities and untapped potential. In the past year, he has organised a team of experts from the aviation sector, including engineers and scientists from organisations such as Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd — India's workhorse producer of defence aircraft — to be able to manufacture the Hansa-3 (NG). 'The aviation sector is rapidly growing and with that, the demand for trained pilots. We expect locally manufactured aircraft trainers to be cheaper and offer quick turnaround time for maintenance than foreign planes,' he said on the sidelines of a press event to announce the technology transfer. The making of a plane The NAL, a cluster of buildings spread out on a verdant campus of centenarian banyan and peepal trees, was intended to be away from the city. Few public labs in India can boast of having their own runways. Among these, the CSIR-NAL runway — a bluish grey rectangle of tarred road improbably laid out in a vast grassy field — is unique. It isn't your everyday airstrip intended for the private planes of the privileged. It is meant for planes imagined, designed, crafted, welded, and assembled on the campus. Even a small plane going awry mid-flight can be an aerial coffin for the pilot, and at worst, a crashing inferno of a public hazard. Therefore, every plane, when it flies for the first time, is a nerve-wracking experience for the engineers, designers, and technicians behind it because of the many things that could go wrong. It's inevitable that a runway and a surrounding vista, far from a bustling city, be built into a facility made to make planes. In one of these buildings is a cavernous workshop. There is a smattering of plane-parts: fuselage, wings, cockpit, propeller in various degrees of assembly, with none having reached their denouement. Like the baking moulds used to create cookies or cakes in assorted shapes, the fuselage — or the main spindle-shaped body of the plane where passengers and pilot are seated — is made by layering multiple layers of 'composites' like glass fibre, carbon fibre, and aluminium over spindle-shaped moulds. Depending on whether the plane will be a two-seater or a five-seater, the placing of the plane's engines, the positions where the wings will be, different fuselage is employed. There are large 'layup' machines housed in various locations of the workshop. Like the handlooms that spin out fabric, these machines can spin out the 'composites' used to make wings or any other parts. 'You can have up to 70 layers of composite depending on which part of the plane is involved and how they must be attached to the fuselage,' explains Abbani Rinku, Chief Scientist and the person in charge of CSIR-NAL's flagship Hansa (Swan) category of planes. First flight On May 11, 1998, three nuclear tests were conducted deep in Rajasthan's Pokhran desert, the first time such bombs had gone off since 1974, in a move by India to 'announce' its status as a nuclear power. It's the reason that India annually commemorates this day as Technology Day. Nearly 2,000 km away in Bengaluru, another tech event took place: the inaugural test flight of the Light Trainer Aircraft Hansa-3 Prototype II. Speaking in Parliament on June 8, 1998, then Education and Science Minister Murli Manohar Joshi said, 'This aircraft is a prototype designed, developed, and manufactured by National Aerospace Laboratories, Bangalore.' The production of the aircraft was to be taken up towards the end of 1998 by a private sector company in Bengaluru. The expected cost of production was ₹30 lakh per aircraft. NAL had entered into an agreement with Taneja Aerospace and Aviation (TAA), which had a manufacturing base in Hosur, Karnataka, to make the plane. Out of the 14 Hansa planes that were manufactured, one was made by TAA, says Rinku. However, he doesn't explain why more planes weren't manufactured by the company. They have all been given to flying clubs used by the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) and were being used as trainer-aircraft for pilots in training. The upgraded version of the Hansa-3 that will be made by Pioneer is a far more evolved variant of the one from Joshi's time. The aircraft offers a digital display (glass cockpit) system and is powered by an advanced fuel-efficient Rotax 912 iSc3 Sports engine and bubble canopy with a cabin width of 43 inches. It is equipped with electrically operated flaps to meet the user's requirements. It can fly up to 620 nautical miles and has 7-hour endurance and maximum cruise speed of 98 knots calibrated airspeed (KCAS). All of this also translates to the Hansa costing around ₹3 crore, a 10-fold spike. Pashilkar says it is still half the cost of an equivalent imported plane, and with the manufacturing and repairs expected to be handled locally, have a lower 'down-time' than comparable ones. Moreover, he added, the real draw of the plane is that many more pilots can be trained within India (today, several must go abroad for their licences). It will meet what Naidu projected as an 'explosive' demand for planes and pilots in India. The country will need 30,000 pilots in the next 15-20 years, with 1,700 planes to be added to the fleet, he had said. Manufacturing blues The CSIR-NAL is a research agency. Its mandate is in designing new planes. This means experimenting with every component of the aircraft — wings, fuselage, tail, propeller — and figuring out new ways of making planes lighter and more durable. They are also expected to design planes for a range of purposes, for instance as air-ambulances, or transporting cargo, or chartered planes, or fuselage of varying lengths to run smaller planes that can be used in towns and cities, sans full-sized airports. These new designs can then be taken up by private manufacturing companies that can make these planes in bulk, service them, find new markets, export, and most importantly establish the complex chain of intermediary manufacturers and suppliers of the complex hardware that must all be integrated into the manufacture of an aircraft. Despite successfully designing two-seater planes such as the Hansa and a 14-seater plane, Saras, the NAL hasn't yet been able to successfully rope in an Indian company that will manufacture its planes. In 2018, the CSIR-NAL made significant upgrades to the Hansa-3, including integrating a glass-cockpit as well as significantly improved avionics and instrumentation. It announced a partnership with Mesco Aerospace Pvt Ltd to design and manufacture the Hansa-3 NG. The 'targeted' cost of manufacturing the plane would be ₹80 lakh-₹100 lakh, an accompanying press release had said then. Rinku says while Mesco showed interest in producing the NG plane, the firm couldn't continue beyond one year. 'There were reportedly some internal issues (with the company) but nothing to do with the aircraft or its design. While we had signed an agreement to be involved right from the stage of designing the aircraft, we didn't progress to the stage of production,' he adds. This forced NAL to look for a new partner to design the Hansa-3 NG, and after four years of search found a partner in Pioneer. It isn't because the manufacturing of plane parts, assembling them, or establishing workshops is technically daunting that only research institutions like the CSIR-NAL or the Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (which makes defence aeronautical systems) are capable of. In America, Pashilkar says, the Hansa category of planes would come under the 'home-built' category. The Hansa has its origins in a category of planes called the Light Canard Research Aircraft (LCRA), a Long-EZ aircraft developed by pioneering American aerospace engineer and designer Burt Rutan and put together in 1985 at NAL by a team led by Rustom Damania. Over the 300 hours that the plane was flown in its lifetime, engineers and scientists discovered practical challenges, including the use of composites. 'We simply imported it as a knock-down kit, assembled it ourselves, then flew it. Even today, these are categorised as home-built planes and so in theory can be built by anyone. Despite all the know-how and potential, it is challenging to get a private manufacturer,' says Pashilkar. Among the concerns that potential manufacturers raised were the availability of trained and skilled manpower. 'There's huge attrition in this industry. Yes, setting up the facilities to manufacture plane parts aren't that challenging, but it requires extremely skilful people.' For a plane like Hansa, it is essential that every component be made to the exact weight specifications. 'We can now make it to within a kg of the required weight. Few organisations in India can do that. Take welding. While it sounds simple, only a few organisations — like HAL — have been approved by aviation regulators to be able to weld components. Aviation is a highly regulated sector, and you can't go to a corner shop,' explains Pashilkar. 'A car, if it malfunctions on the road, can be taken to the roadside for fixing. You can't do that for an aircraft. Hence, the making and manufacture — given the risks — of even the smallest part is tightly regulated. This deters private sector participation.' Then there's the challenge of importing the raw material to make the composites. 'With so few manufacturers, nobody produces these materials in India. And because nobody makes enough of this, there are few manufacturers, necessitating imports. You add up all the demand for civilian planes — an existing fleet of about 800 with 1,200 in the next five years — and it still doesn't make commercial sense for a private manufacturer to set up a foundry (to make raw materials) in India,' Pashilkar reckons. Another challenge is finding pilots. The NAL does not have pilots of its own, and given that these are test planes, it depends on pilots from the Indian Air Force. 'Whether it is Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd, or us, there is always a shortage of pilots. Because there are different certification requirements for civil and military aircraft, we face delays in flying our test aircraft,' rues Pashilkar. By the rules under which NAL works, any private manufacturer has to first replicate NAL's manufacturing facilities. 'Following this, they can come to our facilities and get help with making the first prototype; then we can go to theirs for the next one,' explains Pashilkar. 'This time, we've reduced technology transfer fees and given them two-year access to our facilities. Aircraft manufacturing is full of challenges in India, but we persevere.' Edited by Sunalini Mathew
