Three Obstacles Facing Israel-US Aid Distribution Plan in Gaza
DayofPal– A controversial U.S.-backed aid distribution plan faces mounting refusal and logistical challenges just one day before its scheduled implementation at a time the humanitarian crisis deepens for more than 2.4 million residents of the Gaza Strip.
The plan, spearheaded by the American nonprofit 'Gaza Relief Foundation' and led by a former U.S. Marine, proposes a distribution system tightly controlled by Israel and secured by private American security firms. However, the plan is encountering serious opposition, particularly from the United Nations and major humanitarian organizations.
According to reports from Zman Israel, three major obstacles threaten the viability of this aid model:
No Humanitarian Experience
The plan relies on two private firms, Safe Reach Solutions and U.G. Solutions, both run by former U.S. military and CIA officers, and lacking any significant background in humanitarian work or knowledge of the Palestinian context.
The involvement of executives formerly associated with Blackwater has raised concerns among relief agencies, many of which have declined to participate. Notably, Safe Reach Solutions has reportedly advertised positions on LinkedIn for 'humanitarian liaison officers' to bridge operations with the aid sector.
Unclear Funding
The Gaza Relief Foundation has yet to clarify how it will fund its operations, including the procurement of food and the payment of contractors.
Israeli media revealed attempts to broker deals with Israeli companies to supply the aid material, prompting fears that the plan is blending humanitarian assistance with commercial gains for the Israeli occupation.
Observers warn that this could compromise the neutrality of the aid effort.
Israeli Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich has stated that only minimal aid will be allowed into Gaza, a move experts warn could lead to inflated prices and widespread theft.
A 20-kilogram food box meant to support a family for a week could become a highly coveted commodity.
One senior Israeli diplomat acknowledged that Gaza residents carrying aid over long distances could be at risk of robbery.
The plan to draw tens of thousands of people into queues each day was described as 'insane and unfeasible.'
Widespread Criticism from UN
UN humanitarian official Tom Fletcher criticized the aid model as a 'cruel sideshow' during a recent Security Council session.
He warned that placing distribution centers only in southern and central Gaza could be seen as advancing Israel's objective of depopulating the north.
Fletcher emphasized that the proposed model would not only exclude vital areas from receiving aid but also make humanitarian assistance conditional on political and military goals, effectively using hunger as a bargaining tool.
The Washington Post reported that this plan could severely limit the operational capacity of established UN agencies and international relief groups in Gaza.
Many organizations adhere strictly to principles of impartiality and independence, avoiding involvement with armed entities. Representatives from 10 major humanitarian organizations told the newspaper that limiting distribution to select southern locations would be discriminatory and could provoke further displacement.
UN Secretary-General António Guterres reaffirmed that the organization would not support a plan that disregards core humanitarian principles.
The Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs stated that both the Secretary-General and the Emergency Relief Coordinator have pledged not to participate in any initiative that lacks neutrality or independence.
The UN urged global leaders to push for an end to the blockade and enable unrestricted aid entry.
'Our teams remain on the ground in Gaza, ready to scale up deliveries as soon as the blockade is lifted,' the office stated. 'We have significant stocks of vital supplies waiting for entry.'
Shortlink for this post: https://daysofpalestine.ps/?p=63212
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Days of Palestine
9 hours ago
- Days of Palestine
American Aid: Death Traps for Gazans and Engineered Starvation
DaysofPal – Thousands of starving civilians in Gaza had no idea that heading to receive aid in western Rafah, in the southern Gaza Strip—hoping to feed their hungry children—would turn them into targets of mass death and slaughter. In a horrifying scene that underscores the brutality of the Israeli occupation, the so-called 'American aid distribution centers' have become death traps, where Palestinians are being killed twice—once by starvation, and again by bullets and bombs. At dawn on Sunday, civilians in Rafah witnessed one of the deadliest massacres yet, carried out by Israeli occupation forces under the newly introduced aid distribution mechanism. The assault left at least 31 civilians dead and over 200 injured. According to the Euro-Mediterranean Human Rights Monitor, Israeli forces—along with a U.S.-founded organization—directed Palestinians to collect aid from the Rafah area, instructing them to wait until 6 a.m. to pass through checkpoints. Instead of receiving food, they were met with direct fire from Israeli quadcopter drones, tank shells, and gas canisters allegedly deployed by staff from the American organization. Harrowing Scenes The massacre and the graphic images of the victims lying in blood near the American-Israeli aid center in Rafah sparked outrage on social media. Thousands of Palestinian and Arab users expressed shock and grief, calling the attack a heinous crime against starving civilians. Activists have pointed to U.S. Middle East envoy Steve Wietkoff as a key figure behind the tragedy. They argue that his rapid dismissal of Hamas's response to a ceasefire proposal gave Israel a green light to escalate military operations. 'The American aid was soaked in blood… dozens of martyrs piled on top of each other, gunned down while waiting for food,' one user wrote. Death, Chaos, and Humiliation Salah Abdel Ati, head of the International Commission to Support the Palestinian People's Rights (ICSPR), condemned the attacks, saying Israel had turned aid distribution points into zones of 'death, chaos, and humiliation.' Speaking to Safa News Agency, Abdel Ati emphasized that targeting civilians under the guise of humanitarian aid amounts to a war crime and a deliberate act of genocide. Since the start of this aid mechanism on May 27, at least 49 civilians have been killed and over 305 injured in Rafah and the Wadi Gaza Bridge area, with many still missing. He described the mechanism as a tool of mass killing, meant to weaponize hunger, dismantle international humanitarian frameworks, and sideline agencies like UNRWA. He called on the UN, the international community, and the signatories of the Geneva Conventions to take immediate steps to stop this engineered famine and protect civilians. A Policy of Engineered Genocide According to political analyst Wissam Afifa, the massacre was not an isolated incident but part of a broader policy of 'engineered genocide' dressed in humanitarian language—planned in Washington and executed by Israel. Afifa noted that Steve Wietkoff's visit was not aimed at brokering a ceasefire, but at forcing through a deal aligned with Israeli security interests. His silence on the Rafah massacre, analysts argue, further confirms the U.S. is no longer a neutral broker but an active participant. 'Humanitarian Aid' as a Cover for Execution Political commentator Eyad Al-Qarra said that the events in Rafah expose the true face of the U.S. administration, which continues to market Wietkoff's initiative as a 'humanitarian solution' while simultaneously complicit in bloodshed. He referred to the so-called Wietkoff proposal as a diplomatic façade meant to impose Israeli terms, while aid centers have functioned as execution grounds. 'Today, the starving were murdered in cold blood—with a clear American fingerprint,' Al-Qarra said. 'Were the aid shipments meant to feed the hungry—or to gather and execute them?' Al-Qarra concluded that this was not a tragic accident, but a premeditated massacre, reportedly involving armed personnel from the American organization overseeing aid. 'Those who fund the occupation, offer it political cover, and manage its aid distribution cannot pretend to be humanitarian.' Shortlink for this post:
Days of Palestine
9 hours ago
- Days of Palestine
Palestinian Center for Prisoners' Defense Issues Urgent Call to Uncover Fate of Gaza Detainees
DaysofPal — The Palestinian Center for the Defense of Prisoners has issued an urgent appeal regarding the continued enforced disappearance of hundreds of Palestinian detainees, particularly those from the Gaza Strip, who are being held in Israeli prisons and detention centers under harsh, opaque conditions that violate international humanitarian law. The Center disclosed that Israeli authorities have acknowledged the detention of 2,790 Palestinians from Gaza but are deliberately withholding information about the fate of 144 individuals. This occurs amid a complete absence of legal safeguards or international monitoring over the conditions in which these detainees are being held. Mohammed Shaaban, head of the Palestinian Center for the Defense of Prisoners, reported that the Center has received testimonies and documented reports detailing horrific abuses suffered by detainees—especially those from Gaza—including physical and psychological torture, and the systematic denial of medical treatment. Shaaban stressed that the Center has initiated legal and human rights efforts, in coordination with international organizations, to draw global attention to the plight of Gaza's detainees. He emphasized that the current situation in Israeli prisons represents a profound moral failing and a stain on the conscience of humanity. Shortlink for this post:
Days of Palestine
19 hours ago
- Days of Palestine
70-year-old Gaza detainee dies in Israeli prison, adding to rising prisoner death toll
DaysofPal – A 70-year-old Palestinian man from Gaza, Muhammad Ibrahim Abu Habel, died in Israeli custody on January 10, according to a joint statement released by the Detainees and Ex-Detainees' Affairs Commission and the Palestinian Prisoner Society (PPS). Abu Habel, a father of 11, had been detained by Israeli occupation forces (IOF) on November 12, 2024, at the 'Civil Administration' checkpoint. His death brings the number of Palestinians who have died in Israeli detention since the beginning of Israel's ongoing assault on Gaza to at least 71, including 45 from the besieged territory. Rights groups warn that this reflects a worsening pattern of systemic abuse and 'organized crimes' against Palestinian prisoners. 'This marks the deadliest period in the history of the Palestinian prisoners' movement since 1967,' the statement said, noting that a total of 308 Palestinian detainees have died in Israeli custody over the decades. The Commission and PPS highlighted an alarming trend of torture, medical neglect, starvation, and sexual violence in Israeli detention facilities, particularly targeting detainees from Gaza. 'Torture remains the primary cause of death among detainees,' the statement asserted, adding that many are also subjected to inhumane treatment and denial of medical care. Testimonies from released detainees describe harrowing conditions and daily mistreatment. The rights groups emphasized that many deaths occur under opaque circumstances, with Israeli authorities often issuing 'limited and contradictory' official explanations. In some cases, families and legal representatives had to fight simply to confirm whether a detainee was alive. The two groups also expressed concern about the worsening circumstances facing over 10,400 Palestinians who are incarcerated in Israeli facilities. These include 2,214 Palestinians from Gaza who have been classified as 'illegal combatants,' 49 women, more than 440 children, and 3,562 administrative detainees who have been detained without charge or trial. These figures exclude an unknown number of detainees held in secretive Israeli military camps. Calling for accountability, the commission and PPS held Israel 'fully responsible' for Abu Habel's death. They renewed their demand for an independent international investigation into the treatment of Palestinian detainees and urged global human rights bodies to take action. 'It is time to break the exceptional immunity granted to Israel,' the groups stated, calling for serious international steps, including sanctions and isolation, to hold Israel accountable for violations of international law and human rights. Shortlink for this post:
