Philippine VP Duterte slams impeachment as ‘a scrap of paper', urges Senate to throw it out
MANILA, June 24 — Philippine Vice President Sara Duterte has described the impeachment complaint against her as 'nothing more than a scrap of paper' in her formal response to the Senate, saying the case was baseless and should be dismissed for being unconstitutional.
The impeachment, widely seen as a test of political alliances, comes amid an acrimonious falling out between Duterte and President Ferdinand Marcos Jr that has sparked a broader power struggle ahead of the 2028 presidential election.
Marcos, who has distanced himself from the case, is limited to a single term but is expected to groom a successor to run. Duterte, the daughter of former President Rodrigo Duterte, is viewed as a strong rival contender if she avoids impeachment.
'The Vice President enters a plea of not guilty, without waiving any of her jurisdictional and other objections over the charges,' Duterte said in a submission dated June 23.
She dismissed the accusations against her as baseless, calling them 'exaggerations and speculations that are not supported by evidence' in the 34-page response to the Senate.
In February, the House of Representatives voted to impeach Duterte for betrayal of public trust and high crimes, sending the case to the Senate. On June 11, the Senate returned the case to the House shortly after convening as an impeachment court.
The Senate also ordered Duterte to respond to the allegations in the case, including that she had plotted to assassinate Marcos and others based on a statement she made in November about hiring an assassin.
She is also accused of misusing public funds both as vice president and during her stint as education secretary.
As well as saying there was nothing substantive for her to answer in the case, Duterte argued the impeachment complaint was the fourth filed against her, with the three earlier ones not acted on by the lower house.
This, she said, violated a constitutional safeguard against more than one impeachment proceeding against the same official within a year, reiterating the arguments she used in asking the Supreme Court to dismiss the complaint. That case is ongoing.
'There are no statements of ultimate facts in the Fourth Impeachment complaint. Stripped of its 'factual' and legal conclusions, it is nothing more than a scrap of paper,' Duterte's reply said.
She faces a lifetime political ban if convicted.
Congresswoman Gerville Luistro, a member of the impeachment prosecution panel, confirmed the lower house had received Duterte's reply to the Senate on Monday.
'The entire prosecution team is currently studying each and every allegation contained in the answer. Certainly, we will be filing a reply within 5 days from receipt as provided in the rules,' Luistro said in a phone message. — Reuters
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
41 minutes ago
- Malay Mail
Gobind announces MyGOV Malaysia app to launch in July, streamlining access to govt services
KUALA LUMPUR, June 24 — Digital Minister Gobind Singh Deo today announced that the MyGOV Malaysia mobile application will be launched in July 2025. Gobind said the MyGOV Malaysia app is part of the nation's Government Technology (GovTech) initiative, aimed at providing Malaysians with easy access to various government agencies through a single gateway. 'This is part of the government's plan to transform Malaysia into a digital nation,' he said in a statement. 'It is only right to ensure we have a single platform where Malaysians can deal with various government agencies seamlessly.' The MyGOV Malaysia mobile application will initially focus on seven main services: travel (passport-related matters), registration (birth and citizenship), driving (road tax and driving licenses), healthcare (appointments and medical records), summons, housing (land tax/assessment rates), and the Rahmah Cash Aid (Sumbangan Tunai Rahmah). More features are expected to be added in the future. Gobind said MyGOV Malaysia will be integrated with MyDigital ID to streamline access to government services via a single, secure platform. 'Users will be able to verify their identity and access multiple services directly through the mobile application using their MyDigital ID credentials. 'This unified approach not only simplifies user interaction with government platforms but also underpins the broader commitment to digital inclusivity, trust, and service excellence by the Ministry of Digital,' he said. The app will allow Malaysians to access multiple services directly on their mobile devices. 'This is part of our journey in transforming Malaysia into a digital nation, a journey that will benefit Malaysians and ensure no one is left behind in a trusted digital environment,' he added. As of June 23, Gobind said 2,604,160 MyDigital ID registrations had been recorded. He added that the single sign-on integration will initially cover 34 main government system applications, with more services to be included soon. Gobind also highlighted that the development of MyGOV Malaysia involves collaborations with the private sector, including telecommunications companies and banking institutions. The end goal, he said, is to provide users with easier, safer access to services while benefiting the government by optimising operational costs at Urban Transformation Centres (UTCs) nationwide and improving productivity through better data-driven decision-making.
Free Malaysia Today
an hour ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Probe, prosecution of businessman not in vain, MACC officer tells court
Businessman G Gnanaraja was fined RM230,000 after pleading guilty to an alternative charge of using company funds to enrich himself under Section 218(1) of the Companies Act in 2020. KUALA LUMPUR : An investigating officer from the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) told the sessions court in Lim Guan Eng's corruption trial here that their efforts to probe and charge businessman G Gnanaraja had not 'gone to waste'. Eng Heng Jun acknowledged that Gnanaraja was initially charged with cheating key witness Zarul Ahmad Zulkifli in Lim's undersea tunnel project case, but that those charges were later withdrawn. Gnanaraja was fined RM230,000 after pleading guilty to an alternative charge of using company funds to enrich himself under Section 218(1) of the Companies Act in 2020. Eng told the court that the RM230,000 was paid to the government's coffers. 'I disagree with counsel's suggestion that Section 218(1) was a 'minor' charge (as opposed to the cheating charges which carried a custodial sentence),' he said during cross-examination by defence lawyer Haijan Omar. Haijan had questioned the prosecution's move to offer Gnanaraja an alternative charge. Eng said the Section 218(1) charge was offered to Gnanaraja after Zarul in 2019 amended his witness statement, telling authorities that he had made 'mistakes' regarding the source of funds allegedly used to pay Gnanaraja. He added that the amendments to the witness statement meant 'it was insufficient to proceed with the cheating charges'. Tiara Katrina Fuad, who also represented Lim, then questioned the investigating officer on whether he doubted Zarul's credibility as a witness. 'So, do you think he was not a credible witness because he changed his stand?' she asked. Eng disagreed with the lawyer, saying the instructions to offer the Section 218(1)(a) charge came from the deputy public prosecutor. The hearing continues before judge Azura Alwi on June 25. Lim is charged with using his position as then Penang chief minister to ask Zarul for a 10% cut of the profits from the undersea tunnel project and accepting RM3.3 million in kickbacks from the businessman. He is also accused of two counts of dishonestly misappropriating RM208.7 million worth of state land.
Free Malaysia Today
an hour ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Suspend and review UM's open channel intake, says MCA
Introduced in 2018, Universiti Malaya's open channel was initially positioned as a supplementary admissions route aimed at increasing intake capacity and institutional financial sustainability. PETALING JAYA : MCA has called for a suspension of Universiti Malaya's open channel (Satu) intake for the 2025/2026 session until the higher education ministry reviews its admissions mechanism, following claims of structural inequality. Party president Wee Ka Siong today launched a position paper by MCA on the matter, in which the party said the apparent selectiveness in UM's student admissions raised questions about meritocracy in the process. In the paper, MCA said the availability of two parallel channels – Satu and the more competitive Unit Pusat Universiti (UPU) system – reinforced inequality, as lower-income students could only apply via UPU, while those with more funds could afford Satu's higher fees. Introduced in 2018, Satu was initially positioned as a supplementary admissions route aimed at increasing intake capacity and institutional financial sustainability. According to UM's 2021 annual report, Satu is a means to increase the university's revenue and financial sustainability, offering its students 'priority access' with the goal of 'expanding the inclusivity of the UM student population by attracting potential undergraduates from diverse socio-economic backgrounds'. Tuition fees under Satu range from RM52,800 for a bachelor of Malay studies to RM500,000 for the bachelor of medicine and bachelor of surgery (MBBS) programme, according to the fee schedule for 2025/2026. MCA said the system had effectively become a dual-track one, where one track is subsidised and opaque, and the other is 'pay-to-enter and financially exclusive'. The party also highlighted the lack of transparency in the selection criteria and intake quota between the UPU and Satu admission pathways. 'While both claim to uphold academic standards, the absence of detailed, publicly disclosed intake data by qualification type (STPM, matriculation, foundation and diploma) fuels suspicion of systemic bias,' it said in the paper. MCA said this matter was further compounded by UPU's 90:10 merit formula, which assigns 10% of admission weight to co-curricular achievements. 'While matriculation students benefit from structured, centrally assessed programmes; STPM students, particularly from smaller schools, often lack access to formalised participation and proper documentation of their co-curricular achievements. 'This makes it harder for even high-performing STPM candidates to accumulate sufficient merit points and secure entry into competitive courses such as MBBS,' it said. MCA said the exorbitant increase by 67%, from RM299,200 to RM500,000 for MBBS under the Satu system had placed Malaysia's top public medical programme beyond the financial reach of most B40 and M40 families. 'This effectively closes off a vital path to professional education for thousands of academically qualified students,' read the paper. MCA called for this fee increase to be put on hold, and for an independent audit of the Satu structure to be conducted to justify the costs in comparison with other equivalent universities.
