Pro-Conquest film fuels debate in Mexico over colonial legacy
A Spanish documentary extolling the virtues of the country's conquest of the Americas now showing in Mexico has added fuel to a politically charged debate over the legacy of colonialism.
"Hispanic America: A Song of Life and Hope" by Spanish director Jose Luis Lopez-Linares claims to offer "a new vision" of the colonial period.
Shot in Mexico, Peru, Ecuador and Bolivia, it depicts the Spanish as having had a civilizing impact on the Americas, bequeathing a proud heritage of Catholicism and art, including lofty Baroque-inspired Spanish colonial architecture.
It makes no mention of the abuses committed in the name of evangelizing the Indigenous peoples of the New World.
The film's release in Mexico comes hot on the heels of a fallout between Mexico's new president Claudia Sheinbaum and the Spanish government.
Sheinbaum outraged Madrid by barring Spanish King Felipe VI from her inauguration ceremony earlier this month for failing to apologize for atrocities committed during the 1519-1521 Conquest of Mexico and the ensuing three centuries of colonial rule.
"It's a rubbish, manipulative and racist piece of propaganda that attempts to rewrite history," Mexican journalist Jose Juan de Avila, who attended a VIP screening of the film this week in Mexico City, complained to AFP.
- Competing narratives -
The film's release also coincided with the anniversary of Italian-born explorer Christopher Columbus's arrival in the New World on October 12, 1492, which paved the way for the colonization of the Americas.
The date is a national holiday in Spain, where it is widely known as Hispanic Day.
But in Mexico and other Latin American countries it is known as Dia de la Raza (Day of the Race), a commemoration of native resistance against the Conquest and of cultural diversity.
"The Conquest was a violent act," Sheinbaum reiterated on Wednesday, adding that she wanted to "reconstruct the past" to strengthen relations between Spain and Mexico.
For Spanish author Carlos Martinez Shaw, the film draws on the ideology promoted by late Spanish dictator Francisco Franco, who pushed the "unbridled glorification" of colonialism.
Some Mexicans, however, subscribe to the view advanced in Lopez-Linares's documentary that the Conquest was a source of enlightenment.
When Avila, the journalist, challenged the director at the screening for his "shameful" depiction of the colonial period, he was shouted down by audience members, mostly Mexicans of European descent.
Juan Miguel Zuzunegui, a philosopher and staunch defender of Mexico's Hispanic heritage who is interviewed in the film, called it a message of "love in the face of hate speech."
- 'Heroes and saints' -
Mesoamerica, a region that comprised parts of Mexico and Central America, had an estimated population of 15 million to 30 million people when conquistador Hernan Cortes arrived with an army of several hundred men, bringing horses, swords, guns -- and smallpox -- in 1519.
After a century of battles, massacres and plagues, only an estimated one million to two million Indigenous inhabitants remained.
The debate over the Conquest "remains very heated" in Mexico, Federico Navarrete, a historian at the National Autonomous University of Mexico, told AFP.
It raises uncomfortable questions about the "privilege" enjoyed by Mexicans of European origin and on "the inequalities that still exist in Mexico" between people with light and dark skin, he added.
In Spain, where King Felipe attended the film's premiere in April, the legacy of colonialism was also publicly debated in the run-up to Hispanic Day.
Activists from a militant Catholic association put up posters defending the 16th-century "conquistadors" in public spaces in Madrid, Valencia, Toledo and other cities.
"Neither genocidal nor slave traders, but heros and saints. Happy Hispanic Day!" the posters read.
Mexican historian Alfredo Avila said that the debate was being stoked on either side of the Atlantic for domestic political gain.
"There are nationalist interests at stake in both cases," he said.
Around the world, former colonial powers are coming under pressure to face up to the less glorious chapters of their past.
Emmanuel Macron deeply upset conservatives in France when he declared during his 2017 presidential campaign that his country's colonization of Algeria was a "crime against humanity."
en-st/cb/bbk
Hashtags
- Entertainment#Spanish,Conquest,Mexicans,HispanicAmerica:ASongofLifeandHope,Catholicism,Baroque-inspired,Indigenous,ConquestofMexico,Mexican,Italian-born,HispanicDay,LatinAmerican,DiadelaRaza,DayoftheRace,European,Hispanic,Sheinbaum,JoseLuisLopez-Linares,ClaudiaSheinbaum,FelipeVI,JoseJuandeAvila,ChristopherColumbus,CarlosMartinezShaw,FranciscoFranco,Lopez-Linares,Avila,JuanMiguelZuzunegui,HernanCortes,AFP
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
‘The girls are fighting' AOC mocks Trump-Musk break-up
She had her popcorn ready. A smug Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez had a snarky six-word comment for broken-up bros President Trump and former 'First Buddy' Elon Musk. 'Oh man . . . the girls are fighting, aren't they?' the socialist lawmaker gloated in a story she shared to her 9.2 million Instagram followers Friday. Advertisement 3 AOC gloated as she commented on the bromance beak-up. instagram/aoc The gleeful remark, which came outside the US Capitol, was in response to a journalist asking the New York congresswoman for her two cents on the highly public spat. 3 Big, beautiful break up: President Trump and former 'First Buddy' Elon Musk are no longer an item. AFP via Getty Images Advertisement AOC, who previously blasted the once-burgeoning bromance and called Musk 'one of the most unintelligent billionaires I have ever met,' went on to say, 'I told you so.' 'This was something that was a long time coming. . . . These two huge egos were not long for being together in this world as friends,' she mocked. 'We'll see what the impacts of it are legislatively.' 3 The two men engaged in a public spat this week, trading insults on their respective platforms. Getty Images Advertisement AOC previously slammed Trump's big beautiful bill — which is at the center of the feud between the former BFFs. The social media tiff escalated quite quickly this week, after Musk called Trump's budget bill a 'pork-filled . . . abomination,' and the president accused the Tesla CEO of having 'lost his mind.'
San Francisco Chronicle
2 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
One of Napa Valley's oldest winemaking families debuts a major tasting room transformation
It's a story made for Hallmark Channel: Tired of the hustle in Hollywood, a screenwriter returns to his sleepy hometown, realizes the story of his career was right in front of him all along and decides to tell it through the revitalization of his family's historic wine business. It sounds scripted, but that's exactly what Greg Pestoni has spent the past decade doing. Now, the transformation of St. Helena's charming Pestoni Family Estate Winery is ready for its premiere. Pestoni credits famed director and winery owner Francis Ford Coppola for inspiring his move from his native Napa Valley to Hollywood after high school in the 1980s. Since the third grade, he was friends with Coppola's son, Roman, and recalls watching rough cuts of 'Apocalypse Now' on a Betamax before it was released. Napa was a quiet agricultural valley, and he was anxious to get out. 'You didn't idolize (your friends) who worked in the vineyard,' said Pestoni.'It was as sexy as picking walnuts.' But after 27 years in the film industry and two discouraging Guild strikes, the screenwriter, who worked on 'The Godfather' movies, returned to a very different Napa Valley, one that felt a lot more like Hollywood than when he left it. There, he found a story he desperately wanted to tell: His family's 130-year-old wine journey. 'This was an unsung period of winemaking,' Pestoni said. 'When you think of the 1890s and the bunch that was making wine, who is still here doing it? Just a few.' In the 1880s, the Swiss-Italian Pestonis arrived in Napa Valley. In 1892, Greg Pestoni's great-grandfather, Albino Pestoni, planted vineyards and built a winery in the Eastern hills on Howell Mountain. The winery shut down due to Prohibition and was sold in the early 1920s; a few years later, Greg Pestoni's grandfather, Henry Pestoni, purchased a property on Whitehall Lane in the Rutherford wine region, now the home of Pestoni's Sauvignon Blanc vineyard. Like many wine families, the Pestonis picked up other agricultural pursuits during Prohibition. Over the years, the family raised chickens, hogs and dairy cows, but it also grew grapes and made bootleg brandy. Henry Pestoni allegedly sold his brandy to staff at the Napa County courthouse and, in return, they'd tip him off about upcoming federal raids. Greg Pestoni's uncles also owned a Napa Valley winery and bootlegged alcohol; the original stone building is now the home of Ehlers Estate. In the early 1960s, Greg Pestoni's father, composting pioneer Bob Pestoni, founded the Upper Valley Disposal Service, revolutionizing winery waste recycling. He went on to own a second operation, the Clover Flat Landfill just south of Calistoga. (The family sold both companies in 2023; last month, federal prosecutors closed an investigation into environmental crimes and obstruction of justice related to both properties, now owned by a company called Waste Connections.) The family went decades without commercially producing wine, but they continued to grow and sell grapes. Then, in 1994, the winery next door came up for sale. Bob Pestoni bought it, and Greg Pestoni's brother, Andy Pestoni, became the winemaker. They named the winery Rutherford Grove after a eucalyptus grove on the property, but it created confusion with two other local businesses, the Rutherford Grill restaurant and Rutherford Hill Winery. 'Someone would ask if we served the duck burger,' joked Greg Pestoni, adding that he felt the name 'sounded like a big operation,' when the winery only makes a few thousand cases of wine a year. Shortly after Greg Pestoni returned home in 2014, he convinced his father to change the name to Pestoni Family Estate Winery. He called relatives to compile old family photos and wrote up the family's history for the website. 'It helped make it a much more personal experience,' Greg Pestoni said. 'I think what's really missing in Napa these days is the people behind something and the story behind something.' The winery has been one of the last remaining embodiments of a down-home era in Napa Valley, before luxury resorts, Michelin-starred restaurants and multi-million-dollar tasting rooms, like its flashy new neighbor, Bella Union. 'You get the feeling of going to somebody's house or being in somebody's yard,' said Greg Pestoni. 'People would say, 'You're like a Sonoma winery in Napa.' They don't want the secret to get out of this place, they don't want to tell anybody.' But remaining a secret isn't good for business, especially during a global downturn in wine sales. Despite Pestoni's prime positioning off Napa Valley's busy Highway 29, the winery has remained under the radar, and like many of the region's older wineries, the family decided to renovate. 'We're in Napa,' Greg Pestoni said. 'We needed to step up.' They started with the large, grassy picnic area surrounded by eucalyptus and redwood trees, which became a COVID-19 pandemic hot spot. 'Saturdays and Sundays were bananas. We were serving on picnic tables and our staff were crossing the lawn in 100-degree heat,' recalled Aimee Pestoni, Greg Pestoni's wife. 'People wanted to be outside, and they still do.' Pestoni kept its picnic lawn — one of the few kid-friendly spots in Napa Valley — but built a new pavilion for more formal tastings. The striking cedar pavilion, featuring a bar, tables and heaters, was designed by the same architect behind San Francisco's Rolex boutiques. Yet a much more significant transformation took place inside the 1995 tasting room. 'There were no seats, you'd slam (the wine) down and go on your way,' said Aimee Pestoni. While the lawn maintains Pestoni's classic, old Napa feel, the new tasting room interior catapults visitors to the present: It's moody, sophisticated and edgy, designed like a cozy study found within a luxurious mountain escape. The space features dark wood, a stone fireplace, velvet bar stools and leather armchairs with fur throws. Geometric fur rugs look like tile from a distance, while custom wallpaper features layers of burlap, hand-painted and then fringed, by an Alaskan artist. The change is a jarring departure from the family's humble roots, but upon closer observation, visitors will find ties to the Pestoni story in every nook and cranny. There's a wall of black and white family photos, including a 1919 capture of Henry Pestoni at his coming home party from World War I, taken at the William Tell Hotel in St. Helena. Historic documents sit underneath the glass top of a coffee table, including the assessment taxes for the original 1892 winery ($2 for four gallons of wine) and a corn sales ledger. A bookshelf displays an antique winemaking tool and remnants of a wooden backpack, which Albino Pestoni made and used while herding in the Swiss Alps in the 1870s. Noted Napa Valley designer Erin Martin also incorporated eclectic homages to the family's history, like an ornate, hand-carved cuckoo clock that nods to their Swiss-Italian heritage. The centerpiece is a massive chandelier constructed from a round, wooden form, which was used to make wine casks in the 19th century. A black crow sculpture sits on the chandelier, a quirky tribute to Joe, Greg Pestoni's pet crow that the family rescued and fed when he was growing up. Andy Pestoni recently retired, so his brother hired renowned consulting winemaker Aaron Pott to help craft the wines, which include classic Napa grapes like Petite Sirah, Sangiovese and Barbera. Fancier tasting experiences ($50-$125) launched with the renovation, but the winery can still accommodate walk-ins and kids. Those looking for something casual can opt for a self-guided tasting at a picnic table ($45) and bring their own provisions, which most Napa Valley wineries don't allow. 'We want to keep that vibe,' said Aimee Pestoni.
Boston Globe
3 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Filipino Americans celebrate culture and community at Iskwelahang Pilipino graduation
Advertisement Camille Halloran, 9, from Boston, performed a traditional Filipino dance during a graduation ceremony and cultural dance showcase for Iskwelehang Pilipino. Matthew J. Lee/Globe Staff Founded in 1976, Iskwelahang Pilipino claims the title of the oldest continually operating cultural school for Filipino Americans in the country. During the school year, students from toddlers to teens gather for classes in Filipino music, dance, language, history and identity. The annual graduation doubles as a cultural showcase, with performances by Iskwelahang Pilipino's rondalla string ensemble, regional folk dances and original student projects. This year's celebration, the 49th anniversary of the school's founding, carried extra weight, as it was the first graduation since Iskwelahang Pilipino relocated from Bedford, its longtime home, to a new space in Watertown. After a year of moving between temporary locations and uncertainty about the school's future. It also came at a time when both Advertisement Iskwelahang Pilipino's executive director, Myra Liwanag, has been part of the school since 1986, was a member of the first graduating class and now leads the organization her niece is graduating from. Watching this year's seniors perform, she said, was both joyful and bittersweet. Graduating seniors Brandon Lindsey, and Victoria Liwanag performed the traditional Filipino dance called, 'Manton' during the graduation ceremony. Matthew J. Lee/Globe Staff 'We want them to grow and be successful, but we don't want to lose them,' said Liwanag. 'Some of them are going far away, but we've been fortunate that a lot of those who stay get back involved.' Several alumni did just that, returning to take part in this year's performances — some stepping in just days before the show to join the rondalla ensemble or reprise dances they had learned years earlier. 'Rondalla — which is 'circle in the round' — is about developing a community. That's why people never graduate from it, because you don't graduate from a community,' said Elsa Janairo, who now directs the string ensemble she first joined as a child, also in 1986 . 'So moments like these are milestones, but they're not endings, and it's wonderful when we have the opportunity to bring back alumni and have them support the younger students and just keep the cycle going.' The graduation's dance segment featured pieces from the Maria Clara Suite, a repertoire of dances introduced during Spain's 333-year colonization of the Philippines. Drawing from Spanish styles like flamencoand jota, the performances reflected how Filipinos adapted colonial influences into uniquely local forms. Advertisement 'It's part of our ingenuity,' said Patricia Yusah, who has taught Filipino dance at Iskwelahang Pilipino for more than four decades. 'We took what was brought to us and Filipinized it.' Yusah said the program rotates regional styles each year to reflect the cultural range of the archipelago — from indigenous mountain dances to dances from the lowland regions of Luzon and the Visayas shaped by Spanish and Catholic traditions, to Muslim traditions from Mindanao. 'There's always something new to show,' she said. Just as its dances reflect the country's diversity, Iskwelahang Pilipino's lessons dig into the history behind them. The curriculum includes history units on colonialism, Filipino resistance and lesser-known Filipino American figures. Lilly Bolandrina, a 2020 graduate who now volunteers with the school's communications team, said the experience shaped her political worldview. Vela Harmon-Li wore a malong (a traditional Filipino-Bangsamoro rectangular or tube-like wrap.) Matthew J. Lee/Globe Staff 'Growing up, we mostly learned history from one perspective,' said Bolandrina — a perspective that neglected the Philippines, also a US colony for almost 50 years, as well as Filipinos and Filipino Americans' contributions to U.S. and world history. 'But at IP, we saw the fuller picture. It gave me pride, and it gave me tools to stand up for myself.' As one of the few students of color in her elementary school, Bolandrina remembers being singled out and made to feel like she didn't belong. 'Being in a place that celebrates your differences, and treats you as important and valuable and special and interesting because of those differences, was just so empowering,' she said. Iskwelahang Pilipino also helped her understand that being Filipino American doesn't mean existing halfway between two cultures — it means belonging fully to both. Advertisement 'No matter who you are, no matter how much Filipino you think you are — when you're here with us, we see you as a full Filipino, and we see you as one of us,' she said. That sense of empowerment has taken on new necessity in recent years, amid rising anti-Asian discrimination and political threats to immigrant communities. Bolandrina said the school has grown more protective of its members by limiting public promotion of its location and choosing not to ask about immigration status. 'We want to stay open and celebratory,' she said. 'But we also want to stay safe.' Children dance a traditional Filipino dance during the graduation ceremony. Matthew J. Lee/Globe Staff In spite of those challenges, Iskwelahang Pilipino's leadership remains resolute in preserving the school for the next generation of Filipino Americans. As the organization approaches its 50th year, Myra Liwanag said her focus is on building a foundation that can sustain Iskwelahang Pilipino for another 50. 'Everything costs more. Families are stretched thinner,' she said. 'But this kind of cultural education is so important, especially for kids who are only a generation or two removed from immigration. We want them to know that who they are is enough.' Nathan Metcalf can be reached at
