Senedd rules stop politicians defending themselves MS says
The rules that dictate how Senedd members should behave prevent politicians from defending themselves against unfounded allegations, according to a senior Plaid Cymru Senedd member.Siân Gwenllian was found to have broken the code of conduct after she passed on parts of a confidential letter which showed that a complaint against her had been dismissed.The MS for Arfon told the Senedd that Welsh Parliament politicians have "no right" to defend their reputations against complaints about their behaviour by sharing "relevant information".The chair of the standards committee, Hannah Blythyn, said the committee was committed to helping to strengthening processes in place.
At the centre of the row was a rejected complaint of a cover-up over allegations against Rhys ab Owen, which Gwenllian had been involved in handling internally when she was Plaid Cymru chief whip.Ab Owen was banned from the Senedd for six weeks, and expelled by Plaid, for inappropriately touching and swearing at two women while drunk on a night out.How Plaid Cymru dealt with the original allegation was criticised by the standards commissioner Douglas Bain last year.He said there was a lack of clear procedure and criticised the fact that the complainant's phone number was given to the now independent MS, who used it to apologise.But in a letter to the individual claiming a cover-up by Gwenllian, Bain declared the complaint inadmissible, saying he had found "no evidence" of such a thing.Gwenllian was found last week to have broken the Senedd's members' code of conduct, after she shared extracts from the confidential letter, which she had been given a copy of.News website Nation.Cymru reported the claims last August. When asked to comment by its journalist, Gwenllian co-ordinated a response with the Plaid Cymru press team, requesting that an extract of the letter be provided.It was hoped that providing the extract would stop publication. Nation.Cymru included the passages when it published its article.
An acting commissioner, Dr Melissa McCullough, was brought in to adjudicate a further complaint about the release of the confidential details.She found that Gwenllian had broke the code of conduct by releasing the paragraphs, but was "reasonably defending herself".She said members can "find themselves obligated" by the Senedd's code of conduct "to remain silent in response to complainant-led public allegations, some of which may have already been assessed and deemed inadmissible by the commissioner".In the Senedd on Wednesday, Gwenllian called for the code of conduct to change, describing the situation as "morally unacceptable".She said: "As the code currently stands, Senedd members have no right to defend their reputations by sharing relevant information when that reputation is maligned."When the standards commissioner dismisses completely unfounded allegations, the code prevents members from defending themselves - even if those same allegations are at risk of resurfacing."
The standards committee of the Senedd has agreed to look at the rules again.In the Senedd Blythyn reminded MSs "of the specific need to respect confidential markings on documents, as well as the importance of maintaining confidentiality when it comes to the complaints process more generally".But she added: "The committee agreed with the acting commissioner that there is a need for balance between confidentiality and the ability of a member to defend themselves against allegations, particularly once a complaint process is complete."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wales Online
20 minutes ago
- Wales Online
Welsh council leader 'concerned' about impact immigration plan could have on care
Welsh council leader 'concerned' about impact immigration plan could have on care Cllr Huw Thomas said the UK Government's plans to restrict oversees recruitment of care workers is "certainly a matter of concern" Cllr Huw Thomas said he is concerned about the UK Government's immigration plans (Image: Cardiff Council ) The Labour leader of Cardiff Council said he is concerned about UK Government immigration plans that could affect social care in the city. Cllr Huw Thomas spoke about plans to restrict oversees recruitment of care workers at a building topping out ceremony in Grangetown on Friday, June 6. The UK Government said its plan, which is part of the recently published immigration white paper, is aimed at stopping carers from oversees being subject to "shameful levels of abuse and exploitation". However, unions, care agencies and councils have come out in criticism of the move which they say will exacerbate the pressure the care sector is already under. Never miss a Cardiff story and sign up to our newsletter here. When asked how concerned he was about the plans, Cllr Thomas said: "I think it is certainly a matter of concern. "There are migrant workers in the care sector in Cardiff doing incredibly important work in very difficult circumstances. "We want to support them and as a council we are working with trade unions to support that work force. Article continues below "What that's meant over the last couple of years is that the marketplace for domiciliary care... is actually quite resilient in Cardiff. "I think if there would be changes... that are proposed to be introduced, that would weaken the resilience of the delivery of domiciliary care. The leader of Cardiff Council, Cllr Huw Thomas, was speaking at an event in Grangetown (Image: Ted Peskett ) "It is a concern. We are feeding that concern into Government for their consideration." A Cardiff Council official told councillors at a scrutiny committee meeting in February 2023 that the local authority was having issues with recruiting social care staff. An advert posted on the council's Facebook page in May 2025 said it currently has "vacancies in a number of care roles". In a statement published on May 11, the UK Government said some carers seeking work in the UK arrived to find themselves "saddled with debt", being treated unfairly and discovering the jobs they were promised didn't exist. The Welsh Local Government Association (WLGA) has also come out in criticism of the plans. WLGA spokesperson for Health and Social Care, Cllr Charlie McCoubrey, said: "Councils have long struggled to recruit social care workers, especially in rural and coastal areas. "The Welsh Government's Real Living Wage has helped, but international recruitment has been an important part of keeping services going. "These proposals risk shutting off a vital source of social care workers at the very moment local services are under extreme pressure. "Councils are working hard to support people to live with dignity and independence – but this depends on having a workforce in place. "Removing this option without a fully funded plan to grow the domestic workforce is a significant risk. "It will take time and investment to build a resilient, sustainable care workforce. "In the meantime, we fear the consequences will be felt by the people who rely most on support – older people, people with disabilities, and unpaid carers. Article continues below "Workforce planning must reflect the reality on the ground. "Local authorities are uniquely placed to understand the needs of their communities, and their insights must shape national decisions."
ITV News
4 hours ago
- ITV News
Restart coal mining and bring back traditional steelmaking to Wales, says Nigel Farage
Nigel Farage has called for the blast furnaces at Port Talbot's steelworks to reopen as Reform UK sets its sights on the Welsh Senedd elections in 2026. On a visit to the town, the party leader said the resumption of traditional steelmaking should be the ambition. Farage has also suggested some coal mines could re-open in Wales to power the production of steel in Port Talbot. Speaking at a press conference, the Reform UK leader said he believes his party has a chance of ending Labour's long-standing dominance in Wales during the Senedd elections next May amid opinion poll momentum and gains made at the local polls last month. The Labour UK government has backed plans for a new £1.25 billion electric arc furnace at the Tata steelworks, with the switch-on due in 2027 as part of the push towards greener production. The plant's last blast furnace was shut down in September 2024, and nearly 2,000 people in Port Talbot have lost their jobs. Criticising the government's current plans, Farage said: "The electric arc is fine for recycling steel, it doesn't produce the virgin steel needed for military hardware, but the problem is that it uses vast amounts of electric in the the most expensive industrial electric prices in the world. "I very much doubt that furnace will ever be switched on . Our ambition is to reindustrialise Wales. Our belief is that we should make our own steel. Our belief is - for what uses coal still has - we should use our own coal. "I'm not saying let's open up all the pits, what I am saying is there are specific types of coal for certain uses that we still need in this country and we need for the blast furnaces here that we should produce ourselves." Tata Steel had been working to fully decommission and strip most of the iron and steelmaking assets across the Port Talbot site by the end of 2024, leaving little possibility of restarting the blast furnaces in their current company said many of the existing 'heavy end' assets - such as blast furnaces and coke ovens - had reached the "end of their operational life."Tata Steel CEO Rajesh Nair has previously said that there was "no way" the blast furnaces could be kept going, for both technical and financial Cameron Pleydell-Pearce, a steel expert and professor at Swansea University, told ITV Wales it would not be as straightforward as simply reopening the furnace in isolation, saying that there would be a need to import iron ore due to its low availability in the Pleydell-Pearce said: "One of the things that's important to remember is the furnace in Port Talbot was not shut down with the mind to restart it.""If you want to open any steel plant, you're going to have to invest hundreds of millions, if not billions, depending on the configuration that you want.... Because we're in a position where this furnace is going to be hard to restart, just from a technical perspective, it has to factor into it as well. So it's not just the investment that you're making, but the technical complexity of restarting."He continued: "It's not impossible, but the question is whether or not that fits into the strategy that's right for the UK. We have an abundance of scrap in the UK, so a scrap-recycling strategy makes sense. In other locations, there are plentiful supplies of iron ore and lower energy costs, so it might make sense for those locations to go with more ore-based steelmaking." Speaking about Farage's proposals, Chris Bryant, MP for the Rhondda and Ogmore, said: "This is really cruel politics from Nigel Farage, trying to pretend he's got a plan and he hasn't got a plan at all. "He couldn't afford what he's saying and the truth is the mines aren't going to re-open, they shouldn't re-open, these would be dangerous jobs and would be economically unviable. He should go home and be ashamed of himself."It makes me really cross that somebody waves this kind of flag, populism at its absolute worst. He knows he can't achieve it, he knows it wouldn't be right for climate change, for the economy, he knows he's on a hiding to nothing." A spokesperson for Community Union, one of the largest unions representing steelworkers at Tata's Port Talbot site, said: 'We will always support credible policies that create more well-paid jobs in the steel sector, but our steel communities deserve better than to be used as a political football. If Reform have serious plans for the future of our steel sector in Wales, they should set them out in full.' A Welsh Labour spokesperson has accused the Reform UK leader of bringing "fantasy politics" and a "magic money tree" to the town. They said: 'The people of Wales will see through the false hope and false promises of a public-school boy from England who does not understand them and does not understand Wales. In a wide-ranging press conference, Farage also announced a number of policies of immigration in Wales if Reform UK topped the polls next May: A pledge to put local people at the front of the social housing queue and to stop the use of any building for asylum seeker accommodation To scrap nation of sanctuary status for Wales To stop funding for "woke" policies including: £10.5 million for Equality, Inclusion and Human Rights budget, £440,000 on developing insects for food, including insect-based food for children and to end funding to the Wales Refugee Council. Farage's speech comes as Reform seeks to draw a line under internal clashes after chairman Zia Yusuf quit the party on Thursday only to return 48 hours later, saying the resignation had been 'born out of exhaustion'. He referenced this disagreement in his speech saying: "We hit a speed bump- it could've been that we were driving more than 20mph", jibing at the Welsh Government's default speed limit policy - something he has pledged to scrap if Reform UK were in power in the Senedd. It followed a row in which Yusuf described a question to the Prime Minister concerning a ban on burkas from his party's newest MP, Sarah Pochin, as 'dumb'. During his speech Farage also welcomed two independent Merthyr Tydfil Councillors who have defected to Reform UK - Andrew Barry and David Hughes. When pressed on whether there would be more high-profile defections in the Senedd or in Parliament, and if he'll name any candidate to stand as First Minister in Wales, he insisted "we very much want to look at Reform Wales being autonomous. There are names in Wales that I am talking to."
Cambrian News
5 hours ago
- Cambrian News
No changes to 20mph speed limits in Ceredigion
During the 'listening phase' from May to September 2024, Ceredigion County Council received 62 individual comments, of these 23 expressed support for the new 20mph limits, 20 expressed desires for a change to the national policy, 16 objected to existing 20mph limits on county roads, eight referred directly to Welsh Government-managed Trunk Road locations, over which the council has no jurisdiction, and three were deemed out of scope.
