Pay equity-affected support worker challenges van Velden to do her job for one week
Workplace Relations Minister Brooke van Velden has defended the pay equity law changes.
Photo:
RNZ / Samuel Rillstone
A disability support worker affected by the [https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/560368/national-briefed-its-mps-two-days-prior-to-pay-equity-overhaul-announcement
pay equity law change] is challenging ACT Minister Brooke van Velden to do her job for a week.
The Workplace Relations Minister's bill passed under urgency on Wednesday night and means 33 claims, representing thousands of workers, must be started again.
Workplace Relations Minister Brooke van Velden has defended the changes, saying she cares about and values the work of women, and this will make the process for claims clearer.
Jo-Chanelle Pouwhare is among the affected claimants and told
Checkpoint
she believes the Minister would change her mind about whether they are fairly paid if she undertook their roles.
"It's just really misogynistic, what they've decided to do. It's not just a huge slap in the face for women, but the impacts [on] families," she said.
"They're worrying more [about] the economy. Look after the workforce, the woman in your workforce."
She said being a care and support worker for the disability sector means she encompasses different roles.
"People might be out there saying 'well get another job don't be social worker'. Well, why when this can be paid, we can get valued, in society we're needed," Pouwhare said.
"Look at the pandemic crisis that we face. It's ironic that all these pay equity claims, the 33 of them, majority of them were the essential workers."
In the organisation she works for, two of the pay scales are below the living wage.
"We've got level one, level two, level three, level four. Two of those levels [are] below the living wage. It could even be three."
Workers must train to get to the next pay scale, she said Level 1 sits just above minimum wage.
"That's an atrocity in itself. You wonder why people may not want to go to work," Pouwhare said.
At the top of the pay scale, the pay sits at $29.10 an hour, she said.
"I've been with this organisation for five years. However, I was able to cross credit my Bachelors," Pouwhare said.
"Somebody that's fresh into the industry has to start on a maybe $0.20 or $0.40 more than the minimum wage, then they have to train and go study, it's not funded."
While she was studying, Pouwhare had to take out a student loan.
"I was still paying it off when I started working here and I think the third year I was working here, I managed to pay it off and it was a huge chunk of my wage," Pouwhare said.
She challenges van Velden to work in her role for at least one to two weeks.
"I guarantee she'll go back, and they might re-think because I can guarantee she probably wouldn't last two days," Pouwhare said.
"For a woman to do that to other women, who's come from a privileged background, wouldn't even probably know what a struggle looks like.
"I challenge you to give it a go sister. If you can handle it and you still believe that these women in the care and support sectors, do in any of these claims, give it a go. You tell us how you can come up with a resolution to say that this is still just."
The majority of the people being impacted by the pay equity law change are Māori and Pasifika, she said.
She feels the government is flushing women's and their families lives down the toilets.
"To take those 33 claims and the trees they wasted on [with] the paper that was printed out for those 33 claims, she just uses it for toilet paper," Pouwhare said.
Van Velden said
she still supported pay equity
but the current thresholds were "a bit too loose".
"I'm a woman and I support women who work," van Velden told
Midday Report.
"I also support removing gender based discriminations from our workforces but what I don't support are muddied laws and unclear laws.
"So these changes are better for all women who are working where we can genuinely say hand on heart that what they are finding with their claims is genuine gender based discrimination."
ACT leader David Seymour has congratulated van Velden, saying that she has saved the Budget for the government by billions of dollars through changing the law.
Pouwhare said Seymour's comments are another slap in the face.
"They've gone and given these landlords tax cuts, why can't they take the money from them?" Pouwhare said.
"This coalition government, they need to be renamed demolition, that's what they're doing to these women and their rights to a fair and just wage."
In this year's Budget, she said she wants the pay equity claims to be approved.
"It shouldn't have even gotten to this point where we have to fight. They should be recognising the significance of all these different female dominated employments [sic] out there."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Former Justice Minister Judith Collins refuses to apologise to Lake Alice survivor
Lake Alice survivor Karilyn Wildbore and family. Photo: RNZ/Jimmy Ellingham A senior government minister has refused to apologise to a Lake Alice abuse survivor for telling the United Nations more than 10 years ago that there was no state torture in New Zealand. Then-Justice Minister Judith Collins made the comments in 2014, a decade before the government first used the word 'torture' in relation to the Lake Alice child and adolescent unit in the 1970s. She said she was acting on UN reports from the time. The government now says that children and young people who suffered electric shocks or painful paralysing injections at the Rangitīkei institution are eligible for redress, because they were tortured. Included in that is the offer of $150,000 rapid redress payments , which Levin woman Karilyn Wildbore has decided to take up. In March, she also asked for her compensation to include an apology from Collins, now Attorney-General and Minister of Defence, for her 2014 comments. When questioned about New Zealand's obligations under UN conventions, particularly from the Iranian delegate, Collins said: "In response to Iran, I can advise that there is no state torture in New Zealand." In a letter to Wildbore this week, Collins said she would not apologise for the comments. "My response to Iran's remarks reflected the findings of the United Nations subcommittee on the prevention of torture, which had visited New Zealand in April 2013. "In its report, provided to New Zealand in November 2013, the subcommittee found 'no evidence of torture or physical ill-treatment' in places of detention in New Zealand." Collins said she acknowledged the experiences of Wildbore and others at the Lake Alice unit. "However, I don't believe that what I told the UPR [universal periodic review] in 2014, in response to a remark from Iran, was wrong. "As such, I am unable to provide the apology Ms Wildbore has requested." Wildbore said she was not surprised. "Denial's the name of the game at the moment," she said. "No matter what you do, people don't want to be responsible." Wildbore said Collins should have known about what had happened at Lake Alice, especially since the first compensation payments were made more than a decade before 2014. Only last year, the government began using the word 'torture' to describe the unit's treatment of children and young people, under lead psychiatrist Dr Selwyn Leeks. The $150,000 rapid payments are part of a $22.68 million package for Lake Alice Survivors announced late last year. Survivors who received electric shocks or paralysing injections could either opt for these payments or head to arbitration. Collins' office was contacted for comment. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Pasifika recipients say King's Birthday honours not theirs alone
Mele Ikiua with four of her five children. L-R: Eunique Ikiua, Kaira-Jo Talagi-Ikiua, Topui Jnr Talagi-Ikiua, Ms Ikiua, Hannah Edwards-Ikiua Photo: Supplied A New Zealand-born Niuean educator says being recognised in the King's Birthday honours list reflects the importance of connecting young tagata Niue in Aotearoa to their roots. Mele Ikiua, who hails from the village of Hakupu Atua in Niue, has been named a member of the New Zealand Order of Merit for services to vagahau Niue language and education. She told RNZ Pacific the most significant achievement in her career to date had been the promotion of vagahau Niue in the NCEA system. The change in 2023 enabled vagahau Niue learners to earn literacy credits in the subject, and receive recognition beyond "achieved" in the NCEA system. That, Ikiua said, was about continuing to increase learning opportunities for young Niue people in Aotearoa. "Because if you look at it, the work that we do - and I say 'we' because there's a lot of people other than myself - we're here to try and maintain, and try and hold onto, our language because they say our language is very, very endangered." "The bigger picture for young Niue learners who haven't connected, or haven't been able to learn about their vagahau or where they come from [is that] it's a safe place for them to come and learn… There's no judgement, and they learn the basic foundations before they can delve deeper." Her work and advocacy for Niuean culture and vagahau Niue has also extended beyond the formal education system. Niuean community in Auckland: Mele Ikiua with Derrick Manuela Jackson (left) and her brother Ron Viviani (right). Photo: Supplied Since 2014, Ikiua had been the co-ordinator of the Niue stage at Polyfest, a role she took up after being involved in the festival as a tutor. She also established Three Star Nation, a network which provides leadership, educational and cultural programmes for young people. Last year, Ikiua also set up the Tokiofa Arts Academy, the world's first Niue Performing Arts Academy. And in February this year, Three Star Nation held Hologa Niue - the first ever Niuean arts and culture festival in Auckland. She said being recognised in the King's Birthday honours list was a shared achievement. "This award is not only mine. It belongs to the family. It belongs to the village. And my colleagues have been amazing too. It's for us all." She is one of several Pasifika honoured in this weekend's list. Read more: Others include long-serving Auckland councillor and former National MP Anae Arthur Anae ; Air Rarotonga chief executive officer and owner Ewan Francis Smith ; Okesene Galo; Ngatepaeru Marsters and Viliami Teumohenga. Cook Islander, Berry Rangi has been awarded a King's Service Medal for services to the community, particularly Pacific peoples. Berry Rangi has been awarded a King's Service Medal for services to the community, particularly Pacific peoples. Photo: Berry Rangi She has been instrumental in lifting the coverage rates of breast and cervical screening for Pacific women in Hawke's Bay. "When you grow up in the islands, you're not for yourself - you're for everybody," she said. "You're for the village, for your island." She said when she moved to Napier there were very few Pasifika in the city - there were more in Hastings, the nearby city to the south. "I did things because I knew there was a need for our people, and I'd just go out and do it without having to be asked." Berry Rangi also co-founded Tiare Ahuriri, the Napier branch of the national Pacific women's organisation, PACIFICA. She has been a Meals on Wheels volunteer with the Red Cross in Napier since 1990 and has been recognised for her 34 years of service in this role. She also contributes to maintaining the heritage craft of tivaevae (quilting) by delivering workshops to people of all ages and communities across Hawke's Bay. Another honours recipient is Uili Galo, who has been made a Member of the New Zealand Order of Merit for services to the Tokelau community. Galo, of the Tokelau Aotearoa Leaders Council, said it is very gratifying to see his community's efforts acknolwedged at the highest level. "I've got a lot of people behind me, my elders that I need to acknowledge and thank... my kainga," he said. "While the award has been given against my name, it's them that have been doing all the hard work." He said his community came to Aotearoa in the 1970s. "Right through they've been trying to capture their culture and who they are as a people. But obviously as new generations are born here, they assimilate into the pa'alangi world, and somehow lose a sense of who they are. "A lot of our youth are not quite sure who they are. They know obviously the pa'alangi world they live in, but the challenge of them is to know their identity, that's really important." Two sporting recipients named as Members of the New Zealand Order of Merit in the King's Birthday Honours say the honour is for all those who have worked with them. Pauline-Jean Henrietta Luyten, with Eroni Clarke of the Pasifika Rugby Advisory group. Photo: Supplied Pauline-Jean Henrietta Luyten, who is of Tongan heritage, has been involved with rugby at different levels over the years, and is currently a co-chair of New Zealand Rugby's Pacific Advisory Group. Annie Burma TeinaTangata Esita Scoon, of Cook Islands heritage, has been involved with softball since she played the sport in school years ago. While they have been 'committed' to their sports loves, their contribution to the different Pasifika communities they serve is being recognised. Luyten told RNZ Pacific she was humbled and shocked that people took the time to actually put a nomination through. "You know, all the work we do, it's in service of all of our communities and our families, and you don't really look for recognition," she said. "The family, the community, everyone who have worked with me and encouraged me they all deserve this recognition." Luyten, who has links in Ha'apai, Tonga, said she has loved being involved in rugby, starting off as a junior player and went through the school competition. After moving down to Timaru, she was involved with community and provincial rugby, before she got pulled into New Zealand Rugby Pacific Advisory Group. Luyten made New Zealand rugby history as the first woman of Pacific Island descent to be appointed to a provincial union board in 2019. She was a board member of the South Canterbury Rugby Football Union and played fullback at Timaru Girls' High School back in 1997, when rugby competition was first introduced . Her mother Ailine was one of the first Tongan women to take up residence in Timaru. That was back in the early 1970s. As well as a law degree at Otago University Luyten completed a Bachelor of Science in 2005 and then went on to complete post-graduate studies in sports medicine in 2009. Pauline-Jean Henrietta Luyten with Sina Latu of the Tonga Society in South Canterbury. Photo: Supplied She is also a founding member of the Tongan Society South Canterbury which was established in 2016. On her rugby involvement, she said the game provides opportunities for Pasifika families and she is happy to be contributing as an administrator. "Where I know I can contribute has been in that non-playing space and sort of understanding the rugby system, because it's so big, so complex and kind of challenging." Fighting the stereotypes that "Pasifika can't be directors" has been a major one. "Some people think there's not enough of us out there. But for me, I'm like, nah we've got people," she stated. "We've got heaps of people all over the show that can actually step into these roles. "They may be experienced in different sectors, like the health sector, social sector, financial, but maybe haven't quite crossed hard enough into the rugby space. So I feel it's my duty to to do everything I can to create those spaces for our kids, for the future." Earlier this month the group registered the New Zealand Pasifika Rugby Council, which moved a motion, with the support of some local unions, that Pasifika be given two votes within New Zealand Rugby. "So this was an opportunity too for us to actually be fully embedded into the New Zealand Rugby system. "But unfortunately, the magic number was 61.3 [percent] and we literally got 61, so it was 0.3 percent less voting, and that was disappointing." Luyten said she and the Pacific advisory team will keep working and fighting to get what they have set their mind on. For Scoon, the acknowledgement was recognition of everyone else who are behind the scenes, doing the work. Annie Scoon, of Cook Islands heritage, has been involved with softball since she played the sport in school years ago. Photo: Supplied She said the award was for the Pasifika people in her community in the Palmerston North area. "To me what stands out is that our Pasifika people will be recognized that they've had a voice out there," she said. "So, it's for them really; it's not me, it's them. They get the recognition that's due to them. I love my Pacific people down here." Scoon is a name well known among the Palmerston North Pasifika and softball communities. The 78-year-old has played, officiated, coached and now administers the game of softball. She was born in the Cook Islands and moved with her family to New Zealand in 1948. Her first involvement with softball was in school, as a nine-year-old in Auckland. Then she helped her children as a coach. "And then that sort of lead on to learning how to score the game, then coaching the game, yes, and then to just being an administrator of the game," she said. "I've gone through softball - I've been the chief scorer at national tournaments, I've selected at tournaments, and it's been good because I'd like to think that what I taught my children is a passion for the game, because a lot of them are still involved." A car accident years ago has left her wheelchair-bound. She has also competed as at the Paraplegic Games where she said she proved that "although disabled, there were things that we could do if you just manipulate your body a wee bit and try and think it may not pan out as much as possible, but it does work". "All you need to do is just try get out there, but also encourage other people to come out." She has kept passing on her softball knowledge to school children. In her community work, Scoon said she just keeps encouraging people to keep working on what they want to achieve and not to shy away from speaking their mind. "I told everybody that they set a goal and work on achieving that goal," she said. "And also encouraged alot of them to not be shy and don't back off if you want something." She said one of the challenging experiences, in working with the Pasifika community, is the belief by some that they may not be good enough. Her advice to many is to learn what they can and try to improve, so that they can get better in life. "I wasn't born like this," she said, referring to her disability. "You pick out what suits you but because our island people - we're very shy people and we're proud. We're very proud people. Rather than make a fuss, we'd rather step back. "They shouldn't and they need to stand up and they want to be recognized."
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Justice, food and a CatWalk: King's Birthday Honours in Wairarapa and Wellington
Dame Catriona Williams. Photo: Supplied A new dame and knight in Wairarapa have met their titles with surprise and humour, while over the hill in Wellington, a renowned food critic is chuffed to be honoured for doing what he loves. Dame Catriona Williams has been honoured for her services to spinal cord injury and equestrian sport. A former Olympic equestrian rider, Dame Catriona founded the CatWalk Spinal Cord Injury Trust in 2005 - a few years after a catastrophic fall during competition left her with a broken neck. Since then, CatWalk - which marks its 20th anniversary this year - has raised more than $10 million towards research for a spinal cord injury cure through various fundraising events and challenges, such as climbing to Everest Base Camp on a hand cycle and completing the New York City Marathon. Most recently, she cycled 1100km over 11 days from Scotland to London to raise funds for the cause - an intense, but fun feat which followed a second spinal cord injury in 2021. Speaking to RNZ, Dame Catriona said she felt honoured to have been considered for a damehood, but was quick to point out that CatWalk's work to promote a cure for spinal cord injuries was a team effort. "What we do at CatWalk has taken legs - if you can take the pun out of that - we're really excited about where things are heading at the moment and I'm excited about what my body is doing - and that is 20 years post-injury. "I feel we're at a critical stage in the research - getting legs and bodies moving - if this [damehood] can help expediate the process, I'm all for it." However, she said the ultimate goal was to make CatWalk obsolete and believed a cure for spinal injuries wouldn't come from a single pill or operation, but a combination of factors. Until that time, Dame Catriona said she would continue to encourage those in a wheelchair to keep going - as the late American actor who played Superman Christopher Reeve once did for her. Reeve suffered a spinal cord injury after being thrown from a horse in a competition in 1995. "He sent me a letter wishing me all the best and said, 'You'll find new ways to do the same old things,' and he's right. "But I guess what gets me out of bed every morning these days is the young ones. Seeing what they go through daily and knowing what's ahead of them ... "Don't give up on that dream of walking or dancing or doing what you did on your feet before - because I absolutely believe we're going to see some massive changes over the next five to 10 years." Regarding her new title, she said it would take some getting used to. "I can't wait to tell my husband - he's going to laugh at that one for sure." Meanwhile, former judge Sir Mark Cooper (Ngāti Mahanga, Waikato-Tainui) has received a knighthood for his services to the judiciary. While pleased and concious of the honour, he said he would not be printing new stationery. "It's a nice thing to happen at the end of a long career." Sir Mark Cooper. Photo: Supplied After graduating in the 1970s and spending some time as a lawyer, Sir Mark rose through the ranks of the judiciary, becoming a Kings Counsel in 2000, before being appointed to the High Court bench in 2004. Ten years later he was elevated to the Court of Appeal. He said one of the most memorable years during that time was leading the the Royal Commission of Inquiry into Building Failure caused by the Canterbury earthquakes. From 2011-2012 he chaired 33 public hearings and led the commission to deliver four reports under intense time pressure and public scrutiny - a task he admitted was daunting at times, but ultimately a privilege. The inquiry was conducted at a time when Canterbury was still being rocked by aftershocks, he said, and the devastation was in your face, not just in the ruined buildings, but in the community's shared grief and anxiety. "I felt the need to try and reach people who had suffered through the earthquake, who'd lost loved ones and also people who had been maimed ... sometimes I think we perhaps didn't do enough [for them]." He said it was a moving experience listening to people's stories and was determined to be as empathetic as possible. "In a situation like that, that affected so many... I don't think you can afford to be aloof and hold people at arms length." Reflecting on his career, Sir Mark said his cases had run the gamut, with some easier to talk about than others, such as 153-day hearing concerning a malfunctioning boiler that ended up settling. "The other end of the scale are the cases involving horrific murders, which stick in the mind. "In the criminal jurisdiction there's a constant parade of things like that - terrible things that people have done to their fellow citizens." He said classical music and his dogs were a lifeline throughout - "You never return from a walk with a dog without feeling better than when you set out." Of his time on the bench, Sir Mark said he'd tried to be "user-friendly," respectful, and in contrast to his own experience with judges as a young lawyer - unintimidating. "You know most people in court would rather be somewhere else, and you've got to bear that in mind. "You're usually dealing with something which has had a serious impact on the people who are there." He admitted he probably didn't always succeed, but noted that a well-timed joke could make the experience more enjoyable. "I have on occasions tried to be funny, a bit of light-hearted humour on the bench ... can help to lighten the atmosphere and you can be self-deprecating as well. "That's all part of making it all a bit more human." Renowned Wellington food critic David Burton was happy to admit that getting "bling" from King Charles now ranked as one of his proudest moments. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone The critic and author of several books on food history has been appointed an Officer of the New Zealand Order of Merit for his services to food writing. "As a writer I'm delighted to be honoured simply for doing what I enjoy best. I realise the etiquette requires me to say I feel humbled but, if I'm being honest this is the proudest moment of my life - apart from my wedding day, of course." Burton has been contributing to the field since 1982, first as a food columnist and restaurant critic for The Evening Post newspaper (later The Dominion Post ) and continues to write reviews for Cuisine magazine - a relationship that has lasted more than 30 years. Although perhaps best known for his critiques, he said he primarily saw himself as a food writer, with the coffee-table edition of French Colonial Cookery a favourite. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone While some of his reviews still featured on local restaurant walls, he said ultimately the power of the critic's pen had waned over the 40-odd-years he'd been reviewing. He cited a changing media landscape where "everybody is a critic, everybody has an opinion" as the root cause, but wasn't fazed by it. On balance, there were overwhelmingly more good meals than bad over the years, he said - a few brilliant, some terrible, and the rest just middling, which proved to be the hardest reviews to write. He knew the skewerings were typically the most memorable, but defended them as the right of a critic to express an honest opinion, as long as it was done without malice. "[The restaurants] think that we're writing for them, but no, we're writing for the reader, we're writing for the customer - a very important distinction." Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone On his Order of Merit, Burton said he had many people to thank, not least those in hospitality who had entertained and "suffered" him over the decades. And despite the recent tough years for the industry, he was still excited by what chefs were doing - highlighting Rosella's on Wellington's Majorbanks St as delivering some of the most surprising dishes of late, and the recently opened Supra on Eva St as one to watch. Burton said he'd be enjoying the capital's culinary scene in celebration of his honour on Monday night, but was determined to leave his critic's hat at the door.
