New protocol to be introduced following Stonehaven disaster

The Herald Scotland

08-05-2025

It draws on lessons learned from disasters such as the Stonehaven rail crash, in which three people were killed and three sustained serious injuries, and the capsizing of the Nancy Glen which saw the deaths of Duncan MacDougall and Przemek Krawczyk.
Read More:
The protocol will focus on investigating agencies conducting their inquiries in parallel, with different agencies either leading or jointly investigating the various lines of enquiry with mechanisms to manage journey times for the investigation and the sharing of information.
Dorothy Bain KC said: 'The effective investigation of work-related deaths requires the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service to work closely with many partner agencies in a complex investigatory and regulatory landscape.
'I am confident that the introduction of this new protocol will transform the way we work together.'
Debbie Carroll, who leads on health and safety investigations for the COPFS, said: 'Everyone should return home safely after their shift and workplace fatalities are some of the most devastating deaths that family, friends and colleagues have to deal with.
'I am grateful for the involvement of the signatories in the creation and implementation of this protocol.
'It draws upon the experiences of partners to ensure that all necessary and appropriate investigations are undertaken by the relevant agency and that each line of investigation progresses as quickly as it can while the overall journey time of health and safety deaths investigations is reduced.
'The protocol should provide confidence that agencies are doing all they can within their legislative framework to co-ordinate our efforts and to co-operate with each other in the best interests of public safety and of those affected by work-related deaths or activities.'
Richard Hines, ORR's HM Chief Inspector of Railways said: 'As a signatory to Scotland's updated Work-related Deaths Protocol, the Office of Rail and Road recognises the importance of an agreed approach to the joint investigation of deaths within the workplace.
'We are committed to effective communication and sharing best practice with investigative authorities to ensure the high standards set out by the protocol are met.'
Assistant Chief Officer Jon Henderson, Director of Prevention, Protection and Preparedness at the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service said: "During any investigation, it is important that all parties co-ordinate efforts to identify the facts in a timely manner. We are pleased to sign the protocol, which will assist all those involved to deliver a high standard of professionalism in what can be challenging circumstances."
Richard Stoddart, an ONR Principal Nuclear Site Health and Safety Specialist Inspector, said: "It is vitally important that all agencies investigating a work-related death follow a tried and tested approach so that accountability and effective decision-making is at the heart of all enquiries.
"We fully support this new liaison protocol which will ensure that a collaborative and coordinated approach is followed in the best interests of public safety and those affected by work-related deaths."
Neil Cunningham, Head of the Regulatory Compliance and Investigations team at the MCA, said: "Our involvement in this protocol demonstrates our commitment to working in cooperation with other agencies to enhance safety measures and protect the lives of those who work at sea and along the coast."