India Says No To UN Aviation Investigator In Air India Crash Probe: Report
India would not allow a UN investigator to join a probe of a crashed Air India jet that some safety experts had criticized for delays in analysis of crucial black box data, two senior sources familiar with the matter told Reuters.
Earlier this week, the United Nations aviation agency took the unusual step of offering India one of its investigators to provide assistance following the Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner crash killing at least 260 people in Ahmedabad on June 12.
Previously, the International Civil Aviation Organization has deployed investigators to help with certain probes, such as the downing of a Malaysian plane in 2014 and a Ukrainian jetliner in 2020, but those times the agency had been asked for assistance.
ICAO had asked for the investigator who was in India to be given observer status, but Indian authorities refused the offer, the sources said. The news was first reported on Thursday by the Indian news channel Times Now.
India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB), which is leading the probe into the world's deadliest aviation accident in a decade, did not return a request for comment. ICAO was not immediately available for comment.
India's civil aviation ministry said on Thursday that investigators downloaded flight recorder data around two weeks after the crash.
Previously, safety experts had questioned a lack of information about the probe, including the status of the combined black box unit recovered on June 13, along with a second set that was found on June 16.
Questions were also raised on whether the recorders would be read in India or in the US since the National Transportation Safety Board is participating in the investigation. The Indian government held only one press conference on the incident, and no questions were taken.
Under international rules known throughout the industry by their legal name "Annex 13," the decision of where to read flight recorders should be made immediately in case the evidence obtained could avert future tragedies.
Earlier this week, an Indian aviation ministry official who declined to be named said the department has been "following all the ICAO protocols." The official added that media representatives have made updates on important events.
Most air crashes are caused by multiple factors, with a preliminary report expected about 30 days after the accident.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
36 minutes ago
- Time of India
India's lost engineers built America's technology empire: Will US visa hurdles spark a tech ascent back home?
Picture a nation where dreams are narrowly defined, where engineering and medicine are not just career paths but cultural commandments. A country where students endure gruelling exams of staggering difficulty, claw their way into elite institutions, only to chart their futures not within its borders, but thousands of miles away. This is India, home to millions of dreamers who weigh success by effort, excellence, and global opportunity. For decades, its most brilliant minds have earned degrees and their dreams, boarded flights westward, and seeded innovations in the boardrooms of Silicon Valley. India's deep-seated and celebrated focus on engineering and medicine has produced a workforce that the world relies on, especially the United States, whose technological sector has established and flourished with the contributions of Indian talent. But now, as the land of opportunities is shrinking the welcome mat under the weight of visa restrictions and policy uncertainty, a historic crossroads has emerged: Can India transform its long-standing brain drain into a transformative brain gain? The answer may well define the next chapter of its technological destiny. When brilliance took flight The making of this diaspora dates back to a time when Indian households recited career mantras with a singular rhythm: Engineer or doctor, or you are left behind. The 1990s, with their liberalisation boom, brought an alluring promise: Engineering not just entailed prestige, it presented a silver platter of opportunities. It was a ticket to mobility, prosperity, and often, America. What started as an individual ambition propelled into a national aspiration. Coaching centres mushroomed in small towns. Families drained their savings. Aspirants competed not just for limited college seats, but for a future that seemed to be secure and lucrative. The IITs and other engineering institutions became launching pads, alas, not for Indian industry, but for outbound talent. Fueling the American tech juggernaut Meanwhile, on the other side of the globe, the US was undergoing its own transformation. A tech revolution was underway, but domestic talent pipelines were woefully short. Here, entered the H1B visa programme, a legislative bridge that connected American corporate needs with Indian intellectual capital. Indian engineers flocked to America's tech firms, first as quiet contributors, then as leaders. Companies like Infosys, TCS, and Wipro deployed thousands of workers to the US on client-facing projects. Simultaneously, American tech titans like Microsoft, Google, and Amazon opened their gates to Indian talent. It was not long before the corner offices too carried Indian names—Pichai, Nadella, Narayen. This shift wasn't accidental. It was systemic. Today, Indian nationals receive more than 70% of all H-1B visas issued annually, according to USCIS. In some years, the number has crossed 75%. The pipeline from Indian campuses to US cubicles was not a leak, it was a designed outlet. The obsession that fed two economies, but starved one India's unprecedented push for engineering education created a surplus, hundreds of thousands of engineers each year, many with no robust domestic job market to absorb them. The local ecosystem, for all its startup buzz, lagged far behind in opportunities, infrastructure, and innovation capital. The result was almost predictable: a global migration where talent sowed growth abroad and left India grappling with underutilisation and oversaturation Here claps the irony, while India exported minds, it imported software, platforms, and services, often built by its own citizens working on foreign shores. A crack in the pipeline Now, the well-oiled machinery that kept this talent drain going is grinding against new realities. The H-1B visa system, already stretched by demand, is under intense scrutiny. In FY 2024, over 780,000 applications were filed for just 85,000 slots. Multiple applications by single beneficiaries have raised red flags. Proposed reforms suggest a shift to a beneficiary-based lottery model, potentially ending the era of mass filings and gaming the odds. Add to that surging wage thresholds, stricter compliance measures, and growing political resistance to foreign labour, especially in election years, and suddenly, the American dream feels overweighted. From drain to dynamo: A new possibility for India What was once perceived as brain drain can take a U-turn to brain gain and benefit the home country, India. As global immigration hurdles rise, Indian professionals are reviewing their long-term plans. The country stands at the threshold of a potential talent renaissance. This is not merely limited to reversing the flow, but creating a conducive ground to make it a preferred destination for its own brightest minds. India today is better positioned than ever to convert returning or deterred engineers into national assets. With its expanding startup ecosystem, growing digital infrastructure, AI and semiconductor missions, and government-led initiatives like "Make in India" and " Startup India ," the soil is fertile. What it needs now is deep reform in research funding, public-private partnerships in innovation, better university-industry integration, and a cultural shift that values invention as much as instruction. Rather than being a training ground for foreign economies, India must become a destination for its own talent. That shift will require bold policymaking, targeted investment, and a conscious dismantling of the prestige economy that equates foreign relocation with success The road ahead India's engineering graduates did not just build apps; they built an empire abroad. But empire-building should no longer be an outsourced exercise. The same minds that helped power global tech can now rewire India's future—if given reason to stay, and room to rise. The question, then, is no longer just about visa quotas. It's about national vision. If the US closes its gates, India must open its own doors wider, not just for returnees, but for innovation itself. Is your child ready for the careers of tomorrow? Enroll now and take advantage of our early bird offer! Spaces are limited.
Time of India
36 minutes ago
- Time of India
'Led To End Of Op Sindoor': Cong Jabs Centre As Trump Teases Trade Deal, Takes Shot At Jaishankar
As US President Donald Trump declared an imminent 'very big deal' with India, Congress leader Jairam Ramesh criticised the Centre, linking it to the "abrupt" conclusion of Operation Sindoor. The US president has consistently stated that he utilised trade discussions with India and Pakistan to halt confrontations following the Pahalgam terror attack, although India has consistently rejected these assertions. Jairam Ramesh demanded transparency from the government and urged Jaishankar to focus on addressing what he called a collapse in Indian diplomacy, instead of speaking about the Emergency imposed 50 years ago. #donaldtrump #indiadeal #jairamramesh #operationsindoor #pahalgamattack #sjaishankar #indiandiplomacy #transparency #tradetalks #usindia #congress #modigovt #foreignpolicy #bilateralrelations #nationalsecurity #politicalcriticism #internationalaffairs #pakistan #emergency #indiapakistan #toi #toibharat Read More
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
ICAO request to join Air India crash investigation under consideration, probe on as per global standards, say sources
The International Civil Aviation Organization's (ICAO) unusual request of joining the investigation into the June 12 crash of Air India's Boeing 787-8 aircraft in Ahmedabad is being considered by the government, according to senior government officials. Any decision on the matter will be taken keeping in view the procedures and protocols followed for air accident investigations and the needs of this specific probe, they said. The United Nations' aviation body has requested the government to give 'observer status' to an ICAO investigator in the probe that is being led by India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB). There has been speculation that the government has rejected ICAO's offer. Sources, however, indicated that the proposal is under consideration. ICAO usually joins aircraft accident investigations in very specific circumstances, mostly when the accident occurs in a conflict zone or the plane is brought down by military action. Officials said that ICAO's request to join the Ahmedabad crash probe is highly unusual. 'The request is under consideration and has not been rejected. All international protocols and processes, as required for such probes, will be assessed before deciding on ICAO's request. The decision will also be based on the needs of the investigation, which is currently going smoothly and in line with the laid-down procedures in India that are in line with ICAO guidelines,' said a senior government official, who did not wish to be identified. In its request to the government, ICAO is learnt to have suggested that its presence in the probe will help ensure that international standards, procedures, and best practices are followed in the investigation. All but one of the 242 people on board the aircraft perished in the accident, which also led to casualties on the ground. Apart from Indian nationals, 53 British nationals, seven Portuguese nationals, and one Canadian national. Another government official said that the AAIB-led probe is already being assisted by representatives from the US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), plane maker Boeing, and engine manufacturer GE, and there was no question of international standards and protocols not being followed. The official added that the government has no problem in onboarding any other overseas organization or expert, but provided that such a need is actually there. Instances of ICAO joining air crash probes includes the downing of Malaysia Airlines flight MH17 in 2014 and Ukrainian International Airlines flight PS-572 in 2020, both of which were accidental shoot-downs around conflict zones. Notably, in both these instances, the investigating agencies had sought ICAO's assistance in the probes, and not the other way around. Extraction and analysis of data from the black boxes of the ill-fated is being done at the AAIB's new state-of-the-art laboratory in Delhi, according to the Ministry of Civil Aviation (MoCA). The black boxes are critical in aircraft accident investigations as they provide data on scores on parameters and aircraft systems, helping the investigators identify the most likely causes of an accident. On Thursday, MoCA said that the AAIB 'promptly initiated' an investigation and constituted a multi-disciplinary team following the tragic crash of Air India flight AI171 in Ahmedabad. This team, constituted as per international protocol, is led by AAIB Director General GVG Yugandhar, and includes an aviation medicine specialist, an air traffic control officer, and representatives from the NTSB. The NTSB is assisting the AAIB in the probe as the aircraft was designed and manufactured in the US by an American company—Boeing. Sukalp Sharma is a Senior Assistant Editor with The Indian Express and writes on a host of subjects and sectors, notably energy and aviation. He has over 13 years of experience in journalism with a body of work spanning areas like politics, development, equity markets, corporates, trade, and economic policy. He considers himself an above-average photographer, which goes well with his love for travel. ... Read More
