NYC students have regained ground lost during the pandemic, but reading scores remain stubbornly low
New York City children who just started grade school during the pandemic are rebounding in math — but schools are still struggling to teach students how to read, according to highly anticipated data released Wednesday as part of the 'Nation's Report Card.'
The National Assessment of Educational Progress, or 'NAEP,' showed an 8-point increase in the average test score of a local fourth grader in 2024, according to district snapshot reports. With the latest improvements, students are performing at about the same level as fourth graders before the COVID years.
In 2022, the last year the test was given, fourth-grade math scores plummeted by 9 points — a record drop since the National Center for Education Statistics, which administers the gold-standard exam, started collecting data.
'The latest NAEP results underscore the resilience of New York City's students and educators,' Chyann Tull, a spokeswoman for the city's public schools, said in a statement.
'Our test scores have returned to pre-pandemic levels, and this stability reflects the extraordinary efforts of our schools to support learning recovery and maintain high standards for all students.'
But signs of headway end there.
The latest NAEP results show how a representative sample of fourth and eighth graders performed in math and reading.
Apart from fourth-grade math, New York City schools failed to improve on any of the other tests — though averaged roughly the same scores as before the pandemic and in other large cities.
In 2024, fourth-grade readers considered 'economically disadvantaged' had an average score than was 37 points lower than their peers — a significant widening over two decades, when that gap was 18 points.
'We hoped to see post-pandemic improvement — but the reality is that it hasn't happened,' said Marielys Divanne, executive director of the New York chapter of Educators for Excellence. 'We cannot afford to be passive in the face of these disparities.'
On top of the disruptions to classroom time, the pandemic contributed to mental health challenges for young people. Chronic absenteeism has remained stubbornly high, with more than one-third of local students missing 10% or more of last school year.
Average reading scores dipped by 2 points among the city's fourth graders and 1 point in eighth grade. Neither decline is considered significantly different by NCES but continue a worrisome trend: Fewer than 3 in 10 local-test takers scored proficient — or better — in reading. (The NAEP standard for proficiency exceeds that of most state tests.)
'This is not just a pandemic story,' NCES Commissioner Peggy Carr told reporters during a briefing. 'Our nation is facing complex challenges in reading.'
The city's top education officials are trying to overhaul how the system teaches literacy, requiring community school districts to choose between one of three research-backed curricular options. While teachers are still being trained in the new methods, experts have advised the local school system to stay the course as the city's school chancellor, Melissa Aviles-Ramos, has made some tweaks to the requirement.
A similar push to standardize curriculum is also underway in math.
'While there is still so much to be done, we remain committed to building on this foundation and fostering continued growth citywide,' said Tull, the city schools spokeswoman.
Other states that have adopted the so-called 'science of reading' before New York saw improvements in their NAEP scores. Carr cited Louisiana as doing 'what most states were unable to do' by surpassing its pre-pandemic reading scores for fourth graders.
'They did focus heavily on the science of reading,' Carr told reporters, 'but they didn't start yesterday. They've been working on it several years. So I would not say that hope is lost. And I would not say that we cannot turn this around — it's been demonstrated that we can.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
a day ago
- Newsweek
Gen Z Parents Not Reading to Children Alarms Experts
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Literacy rates are declining, screen time is increasing, and experts are sounding the alarm on the death of parents reading to their children. Though it is critical for their cognitive development, there has been a significant drop in parents, particularly those from younger generations such as Gen Z, reading to their children, and fewer are doing so for pleasure. As the alarm sounds on what could be a burgeoning literacy crisis, Newsweek spoke to the experts to find out more. Reading Time Down, Screen Time Up Recent research and data have shown there is a clear pattern among young children and the media that they are consuming: reading is on the decline, and screen time is on the up. Photo-illustration by Newsweek/Getty/Canva On average, children aged 8 to 12 spend between four and six hours watching and using screens each day, and teenagers can spend up to nine hours on screens, according to the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. Screen Time and Children In 1984, the first year that data is available for, 35 percent of 13-year-olds reported that they were reading for fun "almost everyday." By 2023, this figure had dropped to 14 percent, as per the NAEP. NAEP Long-Term Trends: Student Experiences A recent survey from HarperCollins UK found that there is a pronounced disinterest in reading aloud for younger parents. Less than half of parents of children up to 13 years old describe reading aloud to kids as being "fun," for them; and 29 percent of children aged 5 to 13 think that reading is more "a subject to learn," than "a fun thing to do." Only 32 percent of 5- to 10-year-olds will frequently choose to read from enjoyment, which is down from 55 percent back in 2012. Literacy rates in the U.S. appear to be decreasing, dropping nearly 10 points since 2017. In December, data released by the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) showed that 28 percent of adults in the U.S. ranked at the lowest levels of literacy, compared to 19 percent in 2017 Why Is It Important To Read to Children? "There are so many advantages to reading together with your child," Hugh Rabagliati, a psychology professor at the University of Edinburgh in Scotland, told Newsweek. "Books help kids to learn new concepts and ideas; they encourage kids to engage in discussion; and they prepare kids for reading, through attending to wordplay and vocabulary." Carmel Houston-Price, professor of language and cognitive development at the University of Reading in England, told Newsweek over email: "For young children, it's 'book-sharing' rather than 'reading' that best supports their development, as 'sharing' implies that the child and parent are not just reading the printed pages but are actively engaging with the book and each other; turning the pages, repeating the lines, talking about the pictures, relating the story to the child's own experiences. "Babies and toddlers often show interest in looking at books before their first birthday, particularly books with textures, flaps or rhymes that catch their attention, precisely because these types of books allow the type of exploration and interaction with the adult that is beneficial to children's learning," Houston-Price said. She added: "Book-sharing also supports children's early language development, both in terms of the vocabulary used in the book and children's skill in answering questions and telling stories." Stock photo: A person reads at the Rice University Library on April 26, 2022 in Houston, Texas. Stock photo: A person reads at the Rice University Library on April 26, 2022 in Houston, Maryanne Wolf, the director of the Center for Dyslexia, Diverse Learners, and Social Justice and professor-in-residence at the University of California, told Newsweek over email: "Few realize the multiple linguistic, cognitive, social-emotional, and neurological contributions made by the simple act of reading daily to one's young child---beginning from the first moments they can sit upon a lap. "Not only does the baby begin to associate reading with the emotions of love and protection, the language and cognitive circuits of the young brain are learning the sounds (phonemes) of their language, the meanings of first words, the slow appreciation of what books convey," Wolf added. What Is the Impact of Not Reading to Children? Not reading to children, then, will see a loss of these benefits. Houston-Price said that, without the opportunity to share books with parents, all these benefits are "likely to be lost." Wolf, meanwhile, said: "The loss of this opportunity by parents will ineluctably affect the acquisition of reading by their children in ways and the delight we want every child to experience when learning to read." Stock photo: A student in the library reads a book on February 2, 2022 in New York City. Stock photo: A student in the library reads a book on February 2, 2022 in New York B. Neuman, professor of Childhood Education and Literacy Development at the Steinhardt School of Culture, Education and Human Development, told Newsweek that, in settings where families aren't reading aloud, and books aren't present, "more often than not, children do not experience lots of things." "The scholarly culture that surrounds them early on, helping them establish a reading habit, less ability to attend to a storybook reading in school contexts, a limited understanding of the purpose of reading—joy, information, imagination," Neuman said. "Given what we know about early learning impacting on children's later development," Houston-Price said, "we should be giving young children the very best start in life, which includes opportunities to share books." How Can Reading Be Reintegrated Into Daily Routines? So, what should parents be doing to help reintegrate reading? Neuman said, "Parents should limit children's use of digital media," and should "consider a routine of reading to children regularly." Other tips for parents include carrying "books with them wherever they go," as well as "spending time reading themselves," which, in turn, provides a "good model of reading enjoyment to children." And technology isn't necessarily the enemy here. Rabagliati told Newsweek: "There are also some great technological solutions, like screen-free Yoto Players. These provide some of the same benefits of reading aloud, but don't require the parents to become a human audiobook." Houston-Price said that parents should make sure there are "age-appropriate books around the house that children can access." She added: "Regular visits to a local library might help to ensure there is variety on offer, but remember that young children enjoy repetition much more than adults do, so be prepared to read the same book over and over again. "Look at a book for just a few minutes at a time with very young children, or for as long as they are keen to," Houston-Price said, adding: "There's no need to read a book cover to cover or to read every line." She also noted: "Many children enjoy the routine of a story at bedtime, so perhaps let your child choose a book and take a few minutes to have a cuddle and a read before bed."
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Five years later, some COVID-era graduation traditions live on
COLUMBUS, Ohio (WCMH) — High school graduations were among the hundreds of practices adjusted in the wake of COVID-19, and five years later, some still don't look the same. In 2020, many districts turned to virtual ceremonies or heavily restricted in-person events. Five years out, high school seniors are able to enjoy a more classic ceremony. However, some central Ohio school districts continued select COVID-era practices, turning adaptations into new traditions. See previous coverage of 2020 adaptive graduations in the video player above. Grandview Heights Superintendent Andy Culp said in 2020, the district hung banners of the graduating class along a fence on Grandview Avenue. Hayley Head, Grandview Heights' executive assistant to the superintendent, said the tradition has continued since. Initially parent-driven, Head said the banners are hung the weeks around graduation to celebrate seniors. Big Lots reopening fourth wave of revived Ohio stores 'Five years later, this has become one of the many traditions that celebrate our graduating seniors and it is also a much anticipated community tradition as well,' Head said. Bexley City Schools also continues to hang senior banners along Main Street post-COVID, as does Whitehall on Yearling Road. Whitehall Schools Director of Communications Amanda Isenberg said the district prints individual banners for each senior. 'It has become a visible way to celebrate our graduates and their hard work,' Isenberg said. Larger districts were less likely to maintain COVID-era traditions. New Albany-Plain Local Schools spokesperson Patrick Gallaway said district bus drivers delivered yard signs for each graduate in 2020, but with 441 graduates this year alone, it was not cost-effective to continue it. 'The one thing we still do is a slide show that we run on the jumbotron at Huntington Park before the ceremony,' Gallaway said. 'It is definitely a labor of love.' Gallaway said parents have also continued making an Instagram account each year since 2020 to celebrate the graduating class. The account is not associated with the school, but posts photos of graduates and their after-high school plans. Where to find specials Friday for National Donut Day New Albany-Plain is one of many larger districts that did not maintain new traditions, but have leaned into the technological or logistical adjustments from COVID. Hilliard and South-Western City Schools representatives both said commencement is almost entirely back to pre-COVID operations, but both schools now offer video formats for people who cannot attend in person. South-Western makes graduation videos available online after, and Hilliard livestreams the event. Pickerington spokesperson Jacqueline Bryant said the district first implemented a ticketing system for graduation in 2020. The district continues to use ticketing, although students now receive eight tickets each instead of the two they had in 2020. Olentangy spokesperson Amanda Beeman said the district adapted in 2020 and 2021, but has since gone back to its many pre-COVID traditions. She said with multiple high schools, anything else would be tricky. Gahanna-Jefferson, Reynoldsburg, Upper Arlington, Canal Winchester and Westerville also told NBC4 they have fully reverted back to pre-pandemic celebrations. 'We had a parade instead of a graduation ceremony in 2020. We tried doing both a ceremony and a parade in 2021, but it turned out to be too much for families to juggle,' Upper Arlington spokesperson Karen Truett said. 'We've been back to 'normal' for the past several years.' Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Campaign to revive ‘neglected' Grove Park allotments which played role in WWII
A campaign to revive allotments in Grove Park, with community history dating back over 100 years, has been launched with the goal to raise £12,500. Baring Road Allotments in Grove Park were first established in 1913 as a Co-Operative Land Club and managed by the Lee and District Land Club. Spanning over 11 decades, these historic allotments played a key role during WWII as part of the 'Dig for Victory' campaign, providing food to local residents. But over the years these allotments – described as an 'amazing community asset' – have become uncultivated and neglected, with the Covid-19 pandemic playing a major role in their decline. These historic allotments played a key role during WWII as part of the 'Dig for Victory' campaign. (Image: Donna Ford) A campaign, established by the allotment's new committee Wild Rangers, could see the allotments transformed to their former glory. The non-profit organisation, which is dedicated to enhancing underused green spaces, is set to launch its Aviva Crowdfunding Campaign with a £12,500 goal fundraiser, with an Open Day and Plant Sale set to take place this Saturday (June 7) between 12pm and 2pm. Kay, founder of Wild Rangers, said: 'It's disappointing to see the neglect of such an amazing community asset. Growing together has so many benefits for mental wellbeing; helps combat social isolation; improves physical health; and helps to strengthen local communities.' A campaign could see the allotments transformed to their former glory. (Image: Donna Ford) The revitalisation of the allotments are part of a wider community-led imitative to establish The Railway Children Urban National Park to safeguard Grove Park's greenspace, which is believed to have been the inspiration for E. Nesbit's The Railway Children. Work has already commenced to clear the allotments, with work led by staff and volunteers, however the fundraiser is hoped to raise needed funds to help the organisation tackle larger capacity jobs to get the allotments up and running again. The reduction of local allotments has been impacting communities across the UK over the last decade, as research conducted by Sheffield University revealed that allotment land has decreased by over half (65 per cent) by 2016. The revitalisation of the allotments are part of a wider community-led imitative to establish The Railway Children Urban National Park. (Image: Donna Ford) However, these spaces can be vital for local communities in a bid to help tackle food poverty, with Lewisham Council passing the 'Right to Food Borough' motion committing to helping communities in Lewisham have more access to healthy and sustainable food. Kay explained: 'Allotments up and down the country are often under-appreciated. This despite a growing demand and long waiting lists. 'With new fresh community-led energy now getting behind bringing this vital space back to life, we can enable many more people enjoy the benefits as the revived plots can be taken up by new tenants. 'We also hope we can raise enough funds to also deliver a community garden within the allotment.'
