Lawsuit alleging racism in Louisiana's 'Cancer Alley' revived on appeal
April 10 (Reuters) - A federal appeals court has revived a civil rights lawsuit which alleges a south Louisiana parish engaged in discriminatory land-use practices that placed polluting industries in majority-Black communities on a stretch of land nicknamed "Cancer Alley."
A three-judge panel of the New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Wednesday held, opens new tab that a trial court judge was wrong to toss the case by three faith-based community groups in St. James Parish on grounds that it had not been brought in time.
"Now we can finally get back to the urgent work of addressing the public health emergency caused by the parish's constant and easy approval of every request by any petrochemical company seeking to operate in these majority-Black communities," Pam Spees, a lawyer for the plaintiffs at the Center for Constitutional Rights, said in a statement.
A lawyer for the parish did not respond to a request for comment.
The groups – Inclusive Louisiana, Mt. Triumph Baptist Church and RISE St. James – sued in 2023, alleging that the disproportionate placement of petrochemical plants in majority Black areas violates the U.S. Constitution's 13th Amendment as a vestige of slavery and their equal protection rights under the 14th Amendment.
The lawsuit said no major polluting facilities have been approved by the council in white communities in the parish in 46 years, while dozens of 'dangerous and extractive facilities' have been located in Black communities.
U.S. District Judge Carl Barbier had tossed those and other claims on grounds that the plaintiffs had sued too late over a land use plan the parish adopted in 2014 which categorized two heavily populated districts as "industrial," allowing plants to be built there.
However, U.S. Circuit Judge Carl Stewart, writing for Wednesday's panel, said that the lawsuit was not challenging a discreet government action a decade ago but rather a longstanding pattern and practice of racially discriminatory land use decisions.
Stewart, an appointee of Democratic President Bill Clinton, pointed to allegations that fell within the statute of limitations period which were not time-barred concerning actions the parish took in August 2022.
At that time, the organizations alleged in their 2023 lawsuit, the parish declined to issue a moratorium on "polluting industry" in majority-Black communities while granting white residents' request for a moratorium on the solar industry.
"While it is unclear at this pleading stage whether these alleged incidents of discrimination can ultimately prove a violation of the Organizations' constitutional or statutory rights, as alleged they plainly fall within the applicable one-year limitations period," Stewart wrote.
He said the trial judge had also wrongly concluded that the groups lacked standing to pursue claims their religious rights were violated, saying they had raised sufficient allegations that the parish's land use practices restricted their access to the cemeteries of their enslaved ancestors.
His opinion was joined by U.S. Circuit Judges Catharina Haynes, an appointee of Republican President George H.W. Bush, and Patrick Higginbotham, an appointee of Republican President Ronald Reagan.
The case is Inclusive Louisiana v. St. James Parrish, 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 23-30908.
For the plaintiffs: Pam Spees of Center for Constitutional Rights
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
25 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Islamophobia fears ‘help Iranian propaganda spread in Britain'
Iran has 'leveraged' fears of offending Islamic communities to establish an extensive propaganda network in Britain, a report has warned. Research by the US-based National Union for Democracy in Iran (Nufdi) found that the UK has become a 'flashpoint' for influence operations in Europe by the Iranian regime and its Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps (IRGC). It listed more than a dozen organisations which it claims are directly linked to Tehran and advance its agenda by lobbying organisations and MPs. The report comes after Dan Jarvis, the security minister, warned that Iran is becoming 'increasingly emboldened' and 'aggressive' in its actions in the UK. Nufdi campaigns for a democratic and secular Iran and holds an annual Iran conference in Washington DC. In the report, it warned that Tehran is exerting increasing influence in an 'attempt to influence the British populace to adopt an appeasement policy'. It said this included efforts to 'radicalise the pre-existing diaspora' and UK nationals and 'whitewash the actions' via organisations like cultural centres. 'These cultural centres enjoy the benefits of being protected by their religious/quasi-religious status and have become deeply rooted in several of the diaspora communities within the UK,' the group warned. 'The regime's influence within the cultural realm is particularly difficult to combat due to its leveraging minority Islamic communities and a perception of innocence, appearing as an institution fostering cooperation and community.' The report cited several examples of cultural centres in Britain hosting lectures by IRGC commanders. As well as cultural centres, Tehran's influence extended to the lobbying of politicians and 'a robust and deep-rooted educational network', it added. 'Whether it is... an inability of the Home Office to designate the IRGC as a terrorist organisation, or operating a vast network of propaganda centres masquerading as cultural centres, the IRI's [Islamic Republic of Iran] influence within the United Kingdom is vast… and highly effective,' the report concluded. Earlier this year, Mr Jarvis warned Parliament of an increasing threat from Iranian activities in the UK. He cited figures from MI5, which revealed that since the start of 2022, security services have had to respond to 20 Iran-backed plots against British citizens and residents. 'The regime has become increasingly emboldened, asserting itself more aggressively to advance their objectives and undermine ours,' he told MPs. 'This is evidenced by the fact that direct action against UK targets has substantially increased over recent years.' The Government has not proscribed the IRGC as a terrorist organisation, despite calls for it to do so, for fear of cutting off diplomatic ties with Iran. It has however, put the group on the enhanced tier of a new foreign agents registration scheme, meaning Iranian activities in the UK face greater scrutiny.
Reuters
27 minutes ago
- Reuters
Tens of thousands march in Romania demanding LGBTQ equality
BUCHAREST, June 7 (Reuters) - Tens of thousands of Romanians joined an LGBTQ Pride march in Bucharest on Saturday, demanding civil union partnership legislation and equal rights after a highly-contested presidential election last month buoyed the far right. The European Union state has so far ignored a 2023 ruling by the European Court of Human Rights, which found Romania had failed to enforce the rights of same-sex couples by refusing to recognise their relationships. Socially conservative Romania decriminalised homosexuality in 2001, decades later than other parts of the EU, but still bars marriage and civil partnerships for same-sex couples. "We want legal protection for same-sex couples, an easy legal procedure for transitioning, protection against hate speech and prejudice-based crimes," said Teodora Roseti, president of Romanian LGBTQ rights organisation ACCEPT and Pride's organiser. In Bucharest, marchers danced and carried the rainbow flag 20 years after the first Pride parade was held, carrying banners such as "Love is the worst feeling you could hate", "Equality in love, equality in inheritance. Civil partnership for all". Roughly 30,000 people attended the parade, ACCEPT estimated. The march comes at a fraught moment in Central and Eastern Europe, where far right parties have gained ground. Poles held a similar parade on Saturday. Hours before the Romanian march, a smaller anti-Pride protest took place, with participants demanding an Orthodox Christian nation and waving flags carrying the Celtic cross, a known far-right symbol. In Romania, centrist Bucharest mayor Nicusor Dan ultimately won the presidential election against hard-right opposition leader George Simion, a strong opponent of LGBTQ rights. ACCEPT and LGBTQ rights group Mozaiq warned of a rise in hate speech against the community during the election campaign, and their headquarters were defaced. In neighbouring Hungary, parliament passed legislation earlier this year that de facto bans holding Pride marches.
Reuters
28 minutes ago
- Reuters
Former Reform UK chair Yusuf returns to party two days after quitting
June 7 (Reuters) - Zia Yusuf said on Saturday he would return to Britain's right-wing Reform UK party, two days after quitting as its chair, blaming his abrupt resignation on exhaustion from the job. Yusuf, a businessman who is not a lawmaker himself, resigned on Thursday hours after a row with a Reform lawmaker over her call for a ban on the burqa, the full-length garment worn by some Muslim women. Yusuf became Reform chair last year, tasked by party leader Nigel Farage with professionalising the party. While it has since overtaken Prime Minister Keir Starmer's Labour in the polls, the exit of several senior figures has raised questions over whether Farage can hold together a team ahead of the next election, expected in 2029. "After 11 months of working as a volunteer to build a political party from scratch, with barely a single day off, my tweet was a decision born of exhaustion," Yusuf said on X, referring to the earlier post announcing his resignation. Yusuf said he would focus on a new role overseeing an Elon Musk-inspired "UK DOGE team" within Reform that the party hopes will reduce wasteful spending at the councils it controls after its victory in a series of local elections last month. The party has seen departures from its upper ranks before. One of its lawmakers, Rupert Lowe, was suspended by the party in March over allegations including threats of physical violence against Yusuf. No charges were brought against Lowe, who denies the allegations. And in November its deputy leader Ben Habib quit, citing "fundamental differences" with Farage. Farage said Yusuf would assist Reform with policy, fundraising and media appearances in addition to his work on local councils. "Zia will continue to be an important part of the team we are building to fight and win the next general election," Farage wrote on X.
