Irish Examiner view: Disturbing revelations by RTÉ Investigates about nursing homes
The revelations in the RTÉ Investigates programme about the standard of care in some private nursing homes were deeply disturbing.
Readers may be aware of some of the cases of neglect cited in those investigations, of vulnerable elderly people being abandoned or ignored, left at risk of dangerous falls, or in some cases left in unchanged incontinence pads.
Little wonder that David Robinson, a consultant geriatrician at St James's Hospital in Dublin, described the situation as such : 'It's abuse — there's no other word for it.'
He is absolutely correct.
It would be grimly fascinating to hear someone make a counter-argument that the treatment shown somehow does not constitute abuse.
It is no slight on the journalists involved, however, to say that while these specific instances are shocking, they are hardly surprising.
On a regular basis, we are reminded that whether it is young children in creches, teens reported as missing from Tusla care, and now the abuse of the elderly, our citizens are regularly betrayed by the systems and structures set up to care for them.
In the specific area of elder care, older readers may remember other shocking revelations 20 years ago in the case of the Leas Cross nursing home, revelations which led to calls for legislation and enforcement to ensure that never happened again.
Judging by this week's revelations, nothing has changed,
That is not the only question facing the State.
The bland apologies of the corporate owners of the homes are as meaningless as they are predictable, but it has emerged that Hiqa inspected the homes concerned repeatedly in recent years — with the most recent inspection of one home finding that the institution was 'short-staffed', with some residents who were at a high risk of malnutrition.
It seems surprising that swifter action was not taken in this particular instance.
Then again, the impending excavation of the Tuam babies' burial ground this week reminds us that the State can fail its citizens no matter what age they are.
Shameful obstruction of Leona Macken
Earlier this week, the HSE apologised to Leona Macken in court over 'failings' which occurred in caring for her.
Ms Macken and her husband Alan had taken an action against the HSE, and the court heard evidence which indicated that her 2016 and 2020 smear tests by Quest Diagnostics should not have been reported as negative.
The court concluded that the delay in identifying pre-cancerous abnormalities led to her cancer diagnosis.
A mother of two young daughters, she now has incurable metastatic cancer.
This is clearly a nightmare for the Macken family, and huge credit is due to Leona Macken for her bravery — not only in pursuing this action, but in advocating strongly that other women go for smear tests. She has pointed out in interviews that while those tests did not work for her, they can work for other people.
Minister for health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill also apologised to Ms Macken this week, and added: 'She should not have had to fight for her records.
'They need a resolution to their case, and they do not need additional stress through going through the court process,' she said.
This was a reference to Ms Macken having to fight for an audit of her records, something which — as pointed out by the minister — was bound to cause additional stress at a severely testing time for the family.
This unwillingness to co-operate with individuals seeking answers has uncomfortable echoes in a case which was in the headlines last week. The O'Farrell family, of Monaghan, spent almost 15 years seeking information from several State agencies about the man who killed their son and brother Shane in a hit-and-run incident, only to be stonewalled by many of those agencies.
This form of reflexive obstruction is shameful and seems driven by an overwhelming urge to protect institutions at all costs, irrespective of the stress that that puts on individuals.
Ms Macken's grace and dignity this week, and her attitude, should embarrass those who placed that stress on her.
What's your view on this issue?
You can tell us here
True community pub in Kerry
The story coming out of deepest south Kerry has something of the Ealing comedies about it. A community is downhearted by the prospect of losing its pub, only to rally to the cause and buy it.
Things looked grim when Humphrey Ó Conchuir and Noreen Uí Chonchuir, towners of the Inny Tavern (Tábhairne na hÚine) in Dromaid, south Kerry, decided to retire. A lack of prospective buyers seemed to doom the establishment to dereliction but Forbairt na Dromoda Teo — the local community social enterprise organisation — stepped in.
It raised enough funds for a deposit, as well as securing a bank loan for the property. When there was a shortfall, they launched a GoFundMe campaign, which has generated almost €107,500 to date.
Some of that support has come from ex-pats, but some has also come from people who have seen similar facilities disappear in their own part of Ireland and who don't want the same to happen elsewhere.
Not every community has that kind of support — or an organisation with the drive of Forbairt na Dromoda Teo — but it is good to see a rural area make a stand against decline and depopulation.
Read More
Irish Examiner view: Scene of shame at Tuam may give closure
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Extra.ie
4 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Nursing home that was subject of 'distressing' RTE documentary breached HIQA restrictions
A nursing home that was the subject of a shocking RTÉ Investigates documentary admitted new patients after it was banned from doing so by the regulator for the sector. The Residence in Portlaoise, Co. Laois, has a capacity of over 100 residents and was found to be non-compliant after an inspection by the Health Information and Quality Authority (HIQA) in February. The nursing home was banned from admitting new clients in late April until improvements were made, but admitted new ones after the cut-off date and during the same period RTÉ was filming the hidden-camera documentary at the facility. A nursing home that was the subject of a shocking RTÉ Investigates documentary admitted new patients after it was banned from doing so by the regulator for the sector. Pic: Getty Images (file photo) HIQA confirmed yesterday it would carry out a review of The Residence and the 26 other facilities run by the Emeis Ireland Group, the country's largest nursing home operator. Wednesday night's programme exposed what the Minister for Older People called 'extremely distressing' treatment of people who live at The Residence and another Emeis nursing home in Glasnevin, Dublin. The documentary showed elderly people being left unsupervised for long periods, shortages in vital items such as incontinence pads, and requests to use the toilet going unanswered for lengthy periods of time. The Residence in Portlaoise, Co. Laois, has a capacity of over 100 residents and was found to be non-compliant after an inspection by the Health Information and Quality Authority (HIQA) in February. Pic: Shutterstock (file photo) One elderly man was recorded pleading to go to the bathroom for 25 minutes before he was helped to the toilet, while another resident was left on the toilet for an extended period with a broken call bell after a staff member went on their break. Minister of State for Older People Kieran O'Donnell said he had met with HIQA about the failings shown in the film. 'What we saw from the programme was neglect and abuse of older people, and clearly a key element to that was lack of staffing,' Mr O'Donnell said yesterday. When asked if HIQA had failed residents of the nursing homes, the minister said: 'Certainly from what we saw on that programme last night, one could not stand over. I want to ensure this never happens again.' The nursing home was banned from admitting new clients in late April until improvements were made, but admitted new ones after the cut-off date and during the same period RTÉ was filming the hidden-camera documentary at the facility. Pic: Getty Images (file photo) One carer working in a home run by Emeis Ireland, who flagged issues with HIQA, waited more than four months before an inspection was carried out. HIQA stated it was aware the documentary 'makes very distressing viewing for all nursing home residents, and their families and friends'. 'The nursing homes featured in this programme were subject to a number of additional inspections in an effort to bring them into compliance,' HIQA said. Eoghan Kenny, Labour Cork North-Central TD and Oireachtas Public Accounts Committee member, said he plans to urge his PAC colleagues to invite HIQA in to answer questions. 'The fact HIQA took over four months to investigate issues identified by RTÉ is beyond belief,' he said. 'What we witnessed last night was utterly appalling. HIQA are failing in their statutory remit to investigate and resolve issues when they arise locally. It's vital we have the highest standards of care for older people.' The February HIQA inspection at the Portlaoise home found residents 'sometimes experienced extended waiting times' for help because there weren't enough staff. However, this failing still hadn't been addressed by the time the documentary was being made months later. Footage showed 23 residents left in a day room with just one healthcare assistant taking care of them for hours. Professor Amanda Phelan of DCU's School of Nursing, who featured in the documentary, said the residents were dehumanised for the convenience of staff and treated like they were in 'a holding area'. The Irish Daily Mail has contacted Emeis Ireland for comment.
RTÉ News
4 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Health Safety Authority to inspect nursing homes featured in RTÉ programme
The Health and Safety Authority is to carry out inspections at two centres which featured in a RTÉ Investigates documentary examining standards of care at Ireland's largest private provider of nursing homes. The inspections will review general health and safety measures at both The Residence Portlaoise and Beneavin Manor in north Dublin to ensure risk assessments, patient handling and health and safety training are in place. The inspections come on foot of detailed complaints made to HIQA by two undercover RTÉ carers who witnessed repeated examples in both homes of frail older residents being handled inappropriately or lifted without the use of proper handling equipment. The concerns were subsequently passed to the HSA as they do not fall under the remit of Health and Information Quality Authority. HIQA has also confirmed that it is carrying out a review of all nursing homes operated by the Emeis Ireland group. It also said that following an inspection of The Residence Portlaoise in February, it initiated proceedings to stop admissions to the nursing home. The provider was advised of this measure in February, a formal notification was issued in March and the restriction came into effect on 22 April. However, the nursing home was in breach of the sanction after 22 April. It is understood a flurry of admissions took place to the home in late April, including post 22 April and during which time RTÉ Investigates had an undercover healthcare assistant working at the home.
Irish Examiner
9 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Cork mother undergoing bowel cancer treatment to bring Nathan Carter to City Hall for charity gig
Natasha O'Byrne, a Cork mum of two, was diagnosed with bowel cancer last November. The 25-year-old is still undergoing chemotherapy. She began to feel unwell on July 19, 2024. 'I know the date exactly because the All-Ireland final was a couple of days later, and I couldn't go. I had gotten pains in my chest; I thought I was having a heart attack. 'My GP put it down to gallstones and referred me for a colonoscopy. I was waiting and waiting for the appointment to come, and by October, the pains had gotten so bad I ended up having to call an ambulance.' Once O'Byrne was admitted to hospital, a doctor diagnosed her with pancreatitis. Over the next few days, she underwent a number of tests: An ultrasound, an MRCP, an MRI of the pancreas, and a CT scan. During the tests, her doctor noticed some enlarged lymph nodes in her abdomen and requested a biopsy to check for lymphoma. He also saw some polyps in her bowel. 'He said just to be on the safe side, he wanted to do the two biopsies. On the 11th of the 11th, which I would consider a lucky number, I wasn't so fortunate,' she says. 'The results of the biopsies showed it was not lymphoma. It was actually bowel cancer.' It is unusual for younger people to be diagnosed with bowel cancer, explains Amy Nolan, director of clinical affairs at the Irish Cancer Society (ICS). The HSE currently runs a bowel cancer screening programme for people aged between 59 and 70. Natasha O'Byrne with her four year old son Max. The mother of two is currently undergoing treatment for bowel cancer and has launched a fundraiser in aid of the Irish Cancer Society. Picture: Chani Anderson. It's a simple test that Nolan says could be the key to identifying bowel cancer at an early stage, which significantly improves a person's outcome. 'People get the test in the post, they just have to take a little bit of their poo and add it to the vial, send it back, and that's the test,' says Nolan. 'If anything is worrying in that sample, they will be contacted.' According to the ICS, bowel cancer is the second most common cancer among men and the third most common among women, with around 2,500 new cases in Ireland each year. Even though it's less common for younger people to be diagnosed with bowel cancer — about one in 10 diagnoses are in people under 50 — it's occurring more frequently now, says Nolan. To that end, the charity has recently launched a collaboration with Trinity St James's Cancer Institute to provide a young-onset programme for people with gastrointestinal cancers. The pilot programme — a first in Europe — offers wraparound supports, including sexual health and fertility; how to live beyond your cancer diagnosis; and a dedicated medical social worker who helps people deal with the practicalities of a cancer diagnosis, such as managing at home with young families. O'Byrne is the third generation in her family to be diagnosed with cancer: Her grandmother had breast cancer, and her mother had lung cancer. The realisation that she too had the disease was a traumatic experience: 'That was the first day I met my oncologist, and he's been amazing ever since. He didn't go into too much detail that first day, because it was just so traumatic getting that information. He did say I needed to begin chemotherapy as soon as possible so that they could attack the cancer as quickly as they could.' Natasha O'Byrne: "It's OK to sit and deal with the negative, too, but in small doses. I learned in counselling to make sure I'm not diverting my attention away from the negative completely, but equally, you're dealing with it in a healthy manner." Picture: Chani Anderson. With time of the essence, she did not opt to freeze her eggs, 'which would typically be offered to people of my age'. Luckily for O'Byrne, she already had two children: Emilija, aged six, and Max, aged five: 'I had to wait a month for chemo, but it would have been two months if I were to freeze my eggs. "I wanted to get the chemo started, because in two months, you don't know how much it would progress. So my thought was I already have a family, and looking at my kids, they're all I ever wanted.' She started chemotherapy on December 6, 2024. Since then, she's been having chemotherapy every second Friday: 'Thankfully, my tumour has now shrunk significantly according to my latest scan, but I'm on continuous chemo for now and we'll see what the next couple of scans bring.' She says she has a lot more energy than she had in the months before her diagnosis, when she says she was 'a shell of myself'. The diagnosis has understandably been difficult to come to terms with, but O'Byrne is determined to remain open-hearted: 'For myself, my own mental health, my kids, I focus more on the positives. It doesn't mean blocking out the negative, though. "It's OK to sit and deal with the negative, too, but in small doses. I learned in counselling to make sure I'm not diverting my attention away from the negative completely, but equally, you're dealing with it in a healthy manner.' She is currently working on a fundraiser for the ICS. She approached country singer Nathan Carter to see if he'd be available to perform a headline show at Cork City Hall on July 30. 'He was actually going to be in Munster at that time, and was delighted to be part of it. "Between my grandmother and my mom, the ICS have been a part of our family since the early 2000s, so we're just trying to raise as much money for them as possible. "It will go toward clinical trials, night nurses for palliative care, and volunteers who transport chemotherapy patients to and from treatment. We want as many people to survive cancer as possible.'
