logo
Let Students Finish the Whole Book. It Could Change Their Lives.

Let Students Finish the Whole Book. It Could Change Their Lives.

New York Times16-02-2025

In her memoir, Dorothy Allison writes, 'Two or three things I know for sure and one of them is that telling the story all the way through is an act of love.'
Throughout my teaching career at independent schools, which began during the Clinton administration, I've also been telling students that reading a story all the way through is an act of love. It takes stillness and receptivity to realize this, it takes a willingness to enter the life of someone you'll never meet, and it requires great practice.
It's easy to join the hand-wringing chorus, blaming TikTok's corn drill challenge, Jake Paul and their ilk for the diminuendo of Dickens. But we cannot let reading become another bygone practice. In their more than eight hours of screen time a day, on average, students navigate a galaxy of mediated experiences; schools need to be a bastion of the analog experience of the physical book.
The study of English involves more than reading. It includes written expression and the cultivation of an authentic voice. But the comprehension of literature, on which the study of English is based, is rooted in the pleasure of reading. Sometimes there will be a beam of light that falls on a room of students collectively leaning into a story, with only the scuffing sounds of pages, and it's as though all our heartbeats have slowed. But we have introduced so many antagonists to scrape against this stillness that reading seems to be impractical.
The test scores released at the end of last month by the National Assessment of Educational Progress reveal disturbing trend lines for the future of literacy in our country. Thirty-three percent of eighth graders scored 'below basic' on reading skills, meaning they were unable to determine the main idea of a text or identify differing sides of an argument. This was the worst result in the exam's 32-year history. To make matters worse, or perhaps to explain how we got here, the assessment reported that in 2023 only 14 percent of students said they read for fun almost every day, a drop of 13 percentage points since 2012.
In its attempt to make English more relevant, the National Council of Teachers of English — devoted to the improvement of language arts instruction — announced in 2022 that it would widen its doors to the digital and mediated world. The aim was to retreat from the primacy of the written word and invite more ideas to be represented by images and multimedia. 'It behooves our profession, as stewards of the communication arts, to confront and challenge the tacit and implicit ways in which print media is valorized above the full range of literacy competencies students should master,' the council said.
Around the time this decision was made, only 37 percent of American 12th graders were rated as proficient or better at reading. So the council's determination that 'the time has come to decenter book reading and essay writing as the pinnacles of English language arts education' seems highly questionable.
But literacy involves more than the scraps and fragments of mediated experiences. And reading, in particular, is an important exercise in inferiority, an insistence on listening to something without imposing your own design on it. It's a grounding and an ascension. While we still have the institutions of school and class time as well as the books that line our walls, we need to challenge students with language and characters that may not come to them immediately but might with healthy discipline.
The notion that students can master a range of literary competencies is further diluting the already deluded approach to English class. To put the National Council of Teachers of English guidelines in action, teachers are substituting intertextuality and experiential learning for engaging with the actual text. What might have been a full read of 'The Great Gatsby' is replaced by students reading the first three chapters, then listening to a TED Talk on the American dream, reading a Claude McKay poem, dressing up like flappers and then writing and delivering a PowerPoint presentation on the Prohibition. They'll experience Chapters 4 through 8 only through plot summaries and return to their texts for the final chapter.
Going mostly by summary and assumption, students get thumbnail versions of things. They see the Cartesian grid, the lines on a map that chart the ocean, but they 'don't see the waves,' as the media theorist Douglas Rushkoff recently said about the reality in which many seem to be living in now. They see 'the metrics that can be measured rather than the reality that those metrics are simply trying to approximate.' He is not an alarmist, but he is alarmed about losing the 'in-between, this connective reality.'
Of all the things I could do in this world, I'm fortunate to peddle stories from faraway lands to young minds and see whether I can rouse their synapses. Sometimes, I'll admit, I'd rather be watching sports or 'Saturday Night Live' clips or sleeping, even. And it's not easy for students to crack open a book, to decipher language written in a way they don't speak and to codify multisyllabic names. (It's also not easy for them to wake up at 5:30 for hockey practice, but they're really good at this.)
The juniors and seniors I taught last fall had little knowledge of environmental activism or animal welfare when I handed them Richard Powers's 'Bewilderment,' about a precocious 9-year-old who is consumed with saving endangered species as his grieving father struggles to protect him. But the vicarious safety of fiction gave students an invitation to discuss planetary ethics and the power and limits of parental love. This pathos they raised will be a part of their forming identities. Had they merely read the summary, they would have seen many of the same words, but they'd have lacked the feeling part.
When a semester begins, I often give my students a wicked little essay by Virginia Woolf, 'How Should One Read a Book?' She advises, 'Begin not by sitting on the bench among the judges, but by standing in the dock with the criminal. Be his fellow worker, become his accomplice.' Like this, a classroom allows students to travel along with dockworkers and tycoons, tyrants and liberators. And when they have turned the last page, Woolf invites the reader to 'leave the dock and mount the bench. He must cease to be the friend; he must become the judge.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Bob Costas Condemns ABC, Shari Redstone for Not Standing Up to Trump Attacks on Free Press
Bob Costas Condemns ABC, Shari Redstone for Not Standing Up to Trump Attacks on Free Press

Yahoo

time18 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Bob Costas Condemns ABC, Shari Redstone for Not Standing Up to Trump Attacks on Free Press

Bob Costas blasted President Trump's lawsuits against media companies — and the executives who are buckling under them rather than fighting back. 'The free press is under attack. Democracy as we know it is under attack,' Costas said Monday night. Costas, who retired from play-by-play game coverage in 2024 after a 44-year career as a journalist and sportscaster, made the remarks while accepting the lifetime achievement Mirror Award from Syracuse University's Newhouse School at the Edison Ballroom in New York. The Emmy winner didn't mince words when it came to ABC's decision to pay a $15 million settlement to Trump rather than contest the president's claims in court. 'All they should have said was George misspoke. They didn't have to pay a $15 million ransom.' Costas also had harsh words for Paramount chief Shari Redstone, who has already offered Trump $15 million to settle his $200 billion lawsuit over his allegation that CBS edited a '60 Minutes' interview with Kamala Harris, a settlement that the president declined last month. 'Did Shari Redstone — because she wants to effect a merger that Trump's FCC could stand in the way of — did she have to besmirch and undercut the gold standard in our lifetime of broadcast journalism, '60 Minutes?'' he said, referring to the pending merger between Paramount and Skydance. 'Paying $20 million in ransom to Trump is just the cost of doing business when there's billions of dollars at stake,' Costas said. 'What's happening now are not matters of small degree,' he continued, saying that these lawsuits, and Trump's banning news outlets he dislikes from the Oval Office, as well as efforts to shut down PBS, NPR and the Voice of America, are 'different in kind to anything certainly in my lifetime and maybe in the history of the American presidency.' 'These are ongoing assaults on the basic idea of a free press,' he said. You can watch Costas' speech in the embedded video above. The post Bob Costas Condemns ABC, Shari Redstone for Not Standing Up to Trump Attacks on Free Press | Video appeared first on TheWrap.

TikTok star detained by ICE, leaves US amid Trump immigration crackdown
TikTok star detained by ICE, leaves US amid Trump immigration crackdown

Yahoo

time18 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

TikTok star detained by ICE, leaves US amid Trump immigration crackdown

As President Donald Trump ramps up his immigration crackdown, not even TikTok's most-followed star is immune from removal from the U.S. Khaby Lame, a 25-year-old who skyrocketed to TikTok fame during the global fixation on the app during the Covid-19 pandemic, was detained by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement at Harry Reid International Airport in Las Vegas on June 6 for 'immigration violations,' according to a statement provided by ICE. Lame, who holds the title of the most-followed account on TikTok with over 162 million followers, entered the country on April 30 and overstayed the terms of his visa, the ICE statement said. According to the agency, Lame, an Italian citizen, was 'granted voluntary departure June 6 and has since departed the U.S.' Lame did not immediately respond to a request for comment sent to his team. Another TikTok personality, self-described pro-Trump influencer Bo Loudon, was quick to take credit for Lame's departure. 'I discovered he was an illegal who overstayed an invalid VISA, evaded taxes, and I personally took action to have him deported,' the 18-year-old Loudon posted on X on June 6. Loudon, who is close friends with Barron Trump and vocally boosted the president during the 2024 election cycle, also accused Lame of being a 'far-left illegal alien,' despite the TikToker not posting overtly political content on his page. Loudon did not immediately respond to a request for comment on how he discovered that Lame had overstayed his visa, or how he conveyed the message to the authorities. Lame's detainment and departure comes amid the Trump administration's escalation of its mass deportation efforts. A wave of ICE detentions in Los Angeles last week sparked massive protests across the city, prompting a harsh crackdown from the Trump administration that has included the deployment of as many as 4,000 National Guard troops and several hundred Marines to quell the unrest, which local Democratic officials have decried as unnecessary and incendiary.

Trump says he will ‘liberate' Los Angeles in speech to mark the 250th anniversary of the Army
Trump says he will ‘liberate' Los Angeles in speech to mark the 250th anniversary of the Army

Hamilton Spectator

time21 minutes ago

  • Hamilton Spectator

Trump says he will ‘liberate' Los Angeles in speech to mark the 250th anniversary of the Army

FORT BRAGG, N.C. (AP) — President Donald Trump called protesters in Los Angeles 'animals' and 'a foreign enemy' in a speech at Fort Bragg on Tuesday as he defended deploying the military on demonstrators opposed to his immigration enforcement raids. Trump, in his most aggressive language yet regarding the protests in Los Angeles, used a speech ostensibly supposed to be used to recognize the 250th anniversary of the U.S. Army to denounce the demonstrators while repeating his false statements about the 2020 election being rigged and attacking the previous commander-in-chief, former President Joe Biden. The Republican president, who sees the military as a critical tool for domestic goals, has used the recent protests in Los Angeles as an opportunity to deploy the National Guard and U.S. Marines over the objections of California's Democratic governor to quell disturbances that began as protests over immigration raids. While protesters blocked a major freeway and set cars on fire over the weekend in Los Angeles, the demonstrations in the city of 4 million people have largely been centered in several blocks of downtown. 'We will not allow an American city to be invaded and conquered by a foreign enemy. That's what they are,' Trump said Tuesday. Trump's heated rhetoric came has he's left open the possibility of invoking the Insurrection Act, one of the most extreme emergency powers available to the president. It authorizes him to deploy military forces inside the U.S. to suppress rebellion or domestic violence or to enforce the law in certain situations. The president also called Los Angeles 'a trash heap' with 'entire neighborhoods under control' of criminals and said the federal government would 'use every asset at our disposal to quell the violence and restore law and order.' 'We will liberate Los Angeles and make it free, clean, and safe again,' Trump added. Trump also announced his administration was restoring the names of seven military bases that were given the monikers of Confederate leaders until being changed by the Biden administration. Fort Pickett, Fort Hood, Fort Gordon, Fort Rucker, Fort Polk, Fort A.P. Hill and Fort Robert E. Lee will have their names changed back, Trump said. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth already brought back the names of Fort Bragg and Fort Benning in Georgia. 'Can you believe they changed that name in the last administration for a little bit?' Trump said. 'We'll forget all about that.' Before he spoke, Trump watched the U.S. Army demonstrate a missile strike, a helicopter assault and a building raid, a preview of the kind of show of American military might he's expected to display in the nation's capital for a massive military parade this weekend . Fort Bragg, which is located near Fayetteville, North Carolina, serves as headquarters for U.S. Army Special Operations Command. Highly trained units like the Green Berets and the 82nd Airborne are based there. The atmosphere resembled a state fair with military flair. Inflatable slides and attractions for children were set up in a field, with artillery, trucks and helicopters parked on another section of the lawn. Right outside the security checkpoint — but still on the base — two stands were selling Trump political hats, T-shirts and other paraphernalia. Hegseth and Army Secretary Dan Driscoll were also at Tuesday's event, along with service members, veterans and their families. Hegseth, who has said he's ridding the military of 'woke,' told the crowd at Fort Bragg that the U.S. is 'restoring the warrior ethos' to its armed forces. 'We're not a college or a university. We're not interested in your woke garbage and political correctness,' Hegseth said, drawing cheers. Driscoll, who spoke to the crowd earlier in the afternoon, called Trump 'the greatest recruiter in our Army's history.' Trump has promoted the Army's anniversary as a reason to hold a military parade in Washington on Saturday, which is also his 79th birthday. Tanks and other vehicles will roll down city streets in a reminder of how the Republican president is reshaping the armed forces after returning to the White House this year. Trump has authorized the deployment of 4,000 National Guard soldiers to the city over the objections of California Gov. Gavin Newsom, a Democrat. About 700 Marines were deployed to the Los Angeles area, but had not yet been sent to respond to the protests. California sued Trump over the deployment, with the state attorney general arguing that the president had 'trampled' the state's sovereignty. California leaders accused Trump of fanning protesters' anger, leading crowds to block off a major freeway and set self-driving cars on fire. ___ Price reported from Washington. Associated Press writer Lolita Baldor in Washington contributed to this report. Follow the AP's coverage of President Donald Trump at . ___ This story has been corrected to reflect that the 82nd Airborne Division, not the U.S. Army Rangers, is based at Fort Bragg. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store