
Robots spare India's elephants
It flaps its ears and squirts water from a waving trunk, but this elephant is a life-size mechanical replica rolled out to replace the endangered animals in India's Hindu temples.
Made of fibreglass and rubber, and trundling on a wheeled metal frame strong enough to hold a rider, the model is one of dozens that animal rights campaigners are trumpeting as an alternative to keeping elephants in captivity in India.
Elephants are used during many Hindu temple ceremonies, paraded through packed crowds with flashing lights, thumping drums and ear-splitting music. Deadly attacks by panicked pachyderms are common.
"It is a wild animal, it likes to live in jungles," said C G Prakash, 68, a former official at the popular Chakkamparambu Bhagavathy temple in India's southern Kerala state. "We are capturing it and torturing it. It's totally unethical".
Prakash was instrumental in bringing the robot elephant to the temple. It was donated by the Voice for Asian Elephants Society, which said it would aid "cruelty-free temple traditions".
'Remain with families'
Campaigners from the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) India say the more than 2,700 captive elephants in the country often face "severe physical and psychological stress". Despite being herd animals, they are often kept alone and chained up for much of the day. PETA has funded more than a dozen models since 2023, donated on the condition that temples move their elephants to approved sanctuaries.
"Mechanical elephants help retain age-old traditions in a modern way," said PETA's Khushboo Gupta. "They help ensure real elephants can remain with their families in their natural jungle habitats".
Like the real thing, models are draped with a golden headdress and bedecked with flower garlands. Model makers say a luxury version – complete with electric motors powering a nodding head, rolling eyes and a lifelike swishing tail – can cost more than $5,500.
Professional model maker Prasanth Prakasan, 42, said he and three friends began making elephant models as an art project, but are pleased they are now helping protect real animals.
"What we are doing is saving elephants, and we are happy about it," he said.
The team has made nearly 50 such elephants – with a production line at the workshop building several more. For those keen on an elephant at their wedding, models can be rented without the cumbersome permits required for a costly real one, he pointed out.
'Exploited'
Accidents involving spooked elephants trampling crowds are common and some temples switching to models cite the safety of their worshippers. In February alone, PETA recorded incidents in Kerala involving nine captive elephants losing control, with five people killed. In one, an elephant at a festival was spooked by fireworks, jabbed its companion with a tusk and triggered a stampede that killed three people and injured dozens.
"Those who take care of them, many don't follow the rules", said V K Venkitachalam, 60, from the Heritage Animal Task Force rights group.
Animal welfare is also gaining growing attention. In November, Kerala's High Court issued guidelines for the better treatment of captive elephants.
"Their use is often sought to be justified on the touchstone of tradition and religious practice," the court wrote.
But "animals are being commercially exploited without any care or concern for their well-being", it said.
The guidelines were later stayed by the Supreme Court saying guidelines were impractical.
'Non-violence'
There are fewer than 50,000 Asian elephants in the wild, according to the World Wildlife Fund, the majority in India, with others in Sri Lanka and Southeast Asia. The species is endangered, according to the International Union for Conservation of Nature.
As elephant habitats shrink, conflict between humans and wild elephants has grown – 629 people were killed by elephants across India in 2023-2024, according to parliamentary figures.
Over the same period, 121 elephants were killed – the vast majority by powerful electric fences, as well as by poaching, poisoning, and being hit by trains.
For animal rights activists, the model elephants are a safe solution that fits with religious principles.
"This initiative honours ahimsa, or non-violence, a tenet of Hinduism", PETA's Gupta told AFP.
Among some worshippers, the placid models are a relief.
"When it is a live elephant, there's a fear amongst us. What if it runs amok?" 58-year-old teacher Jayasree Sivaraman Narayaneeya said. "Since it's a robotic elephant, we feel much safer." afp
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Business Recorder
5 days ago
- Business Recorder
Bangladesh says India pushes back 1,200 people
DHAKA: Bangladesh said Wednesday that neighbouring India has pushed more than 1,270 people across its border in the past month, mainly Bangladeshis, but also Indian citizens and Rohingya refugees. Bangladesh, largely encircled by land by India, has seen relations with New Delhi turn icy since a mass uprising toppled Dhaka's previous government last year. 'Between May 7 and June 3, Indian authorities pushed in 1,272 individuals, including a few Indian citizens and Rohingya, through 19 bordering districts', Border Guard Bangladesh (BGB) officials said. 'Only yesterday, they pushed 50 individuals.' India's Hindu nationalist government has often described undocumented immigrants as 'Muslim infiltrators', accusing them of posing a security threat. Refugee camp schools at risk in Bangladesh in aid crisis India has not commented on the recent returns across their shared border. Bangladeshi Jahidul Molla, 21, said he was among those sent back, saying he had been living in India's western state of Gujarat since he was 14. 'They picked us up from home and put us on a plane,' Molla told AFP, adding that after two weeks in a camp, he was then taken onboard a ship, along with more than 50 others, almost all men. 'For the next three days, they kept beating us, and we were starving', reporting that they were then dropped overboard in the mangrove swamps of the Sundarbans, which straddle the border between the nations. 'They dropped us… the coast guard rescued us and handed us over to the police'. AFP could not independently verify his account. India shares a long and porous border with neighbouring Muslim-majority Bangladesh. The mostly Muslim Rohingya have been persecuted in Myanmar for decades, with many fleeing a 2017 military crackdown. More than a million escaped to Bangladesh, but others fled to India. The BGB official said 'some of the Rohingya' were registered with the UN refugee agency in India. Md Touhid Hossain, who heads the foreign ministry in the caretaker government, said Dhaka was 'putting all our efforts' into resolving the issue through dialogue. Indian media report that, since a four-day conflict with Pakistan last month, authorities have pushed back more than 2,000 alleged illegal Bangladeshi immigrants. In February, Amit Shah, India's interior minister said 'the issue of illegal intruders is also related to national security, and it should be dealt with strictly', adding that 'they should be identified and deported'.


Express Tribune
16-03-2025
- Express Tribune
The timeless treasures of Thar
To a Karachiite, Tharparkar likely conjures images of suffering farmers or malnourished children. While these hardships are real and often underreported, in many ways, it is urban centres like Karachi that are impoverished – not in monetary wealth, but in culture, tradition and gratitude. Thar, in contrast, seems blessed with infinite riches. Over the past decade, mainstream news has largely focused on the extreme drought that gripped Thar around 2014 and lasted nearly six years. Yet, beyond its struggles, there is much to learn from the region, its people, and their way of life in order to better what is truly at stake. Rather than being viewed solely as a charity case, Tharparkar deserves a central place in discussions on climate change and cultural preservation in the region. A desert brimming with life A desert region, locals term describe Thar as an 'abad registan' (inhabited desert) in Urdu, rather than a truly barren one. It is dotted with trees and bushes as far as the eye can see, and peacocks roaming in their natural habitat. Once a fertile land, it is believed that the now extinct Saraswati or Ghaggar-Hakra River flowed nearby. A model of interfaith harmony In Tharparkar, it feels a humble shepherd pays little mind to who the prime minister of Pakistan is. Here, politics and religion take a backseat to culture, which shapes public life. At its best, Thar and its people offer a model of interfaith harmony. 'There is no such thing as caste or creed here,' says Mukhi Lachmandas, a caretaker at the Sant Nenuram Ashram, home to the Shree Hinglaj Mata Mandir in Islamkot. He is seen chopping vegetables for a communal meal being prepared. The temple feeds countless people everyday regardless of their religion and caste, using support it receives from the entire community. Its atmosphere is calm, with devotional music playing constantly in the background, punctuated by the occasional ringing of bells by devotees. Bhagro Mal Nachez, a Hindu born in Tharparkar who has spent much of his life in Islamkot, is a frequent presence at the temple. Having come here to escape poverty, he now sings the verses of the giants of poetry in the Indian subcontinent's Sufi tradition — the likes of Kabir, Bulleh Shah, Bhitai, Ustad Bukhari, and Bhagat Pallaj, to name a few. 'They preach the message of humanism,' he says of these poets. Hindu-Muslim Sufism was once the dominant spiritual tradition of the Indian subcontinent, but over time, it has faded into the margins. In places like Tharparkar, however, remnants of this past still endure. Could this decline, in part, have caused the rise in intolerance and, consequently, cultural erasure? It could be the other way around – cultural erasure leads to further intolerance, and more intolerance in turn accelerates cultural erasure, creating a vicious cycle. Sounds and colours Maryam Naz is a folk singer and dholak player from Thar. The bright colours of her ghagra-kanjra — the traditional attire of Thari women, influenced by Gujarati, Punjabi, and Sindhi styles — are a large part what makes Tharparkar colourful and lively. Though she is one of many talented folk musicians in the region, she remains largely unrecognised outside of it, receiving little attention or support. With the right investment, Thari music could find a significant regional audience. Yet, like many artists here, Maryam's voice remains unheard despite its beauty, and her art goes undervalued. Lack of investment isn't the only challenge Thar's art and music face. 'Our youth does not pay attention to continuing our culture,' laments Bhagro, his words indicate the fleeting sense of responsibility among younger generations when it comes to preserving heritage. 'But still, our old culture persists.' The Jain legacy of Thar Tharparkar is home to many ancient Jain temples. One of the oldest known religions in the Indian subcontinent, it is now extinct in Pakistan, but continues to thrive in neighbouring India, particularly in Rajasthan and Gujarat. At the core of Jain philosophy is the principle of 'ahimsa' or non-violence, which serves as the moral foundation for devout followers of the faith. Strict Jains abstain from eating even certain vegetables like onions or garlic, which are harvested by uprooting the plant. Since they believe this act causes harm to living beings — something they strive to avoid at all costs — they deem such foods impermissible. Some of this may sound extreme, but even so, how much harm, as opposed to the good, could such a belief possibly do? Could it be that extinguishing such beliefs in our society has contributed to the exploitative subjugation of nature? Biodiversity at risk Hinglaj Mata is believed to be a version of the goddess Sati. The name 'Sati' means truthful and etymologists traces the Urdu word for truth 'sach' back to the Sanskrit 'sat'. Devotees of Sati revere her as the goddess of fertility and longevity. As it stands, both qualities are exactly what Tharparkar and Sindh need now more than ever. Haji Muhammad Kumbher, a wildlife photographer and resident of Mithi, sees the climate crisis, cultural loss and wildlife decline as deeply interconnected. 'In August, Thar is green,' he says – the season offers a glimpse into the region's once fertile ancient past. 'The bird that Shah Latif sang about, the Taro, is believed by locals to signal imminent rain with its chirp.' Having spent years photographing Thar's wildlife, Kumbher is acutely aware of species vanishing from the landscape. 'Near Rann of Kutch, there are still many plants. Khipp (Leptadenia pyrotechnica) is one example — you won't find it here anymore, but if you go towards the Rann of Kutch (at the border with Gujarat), you'll still see it there.' 'The tractor doesn't spare anything,' Haji Muhammad complains, referring to the disappearance of khipp. Once abundant in Thar, the plant is known among locals for its role in stabilising the soil. The herb is a natural carbon sequester as well. 'A person using a camel [for agriculture] is mindful of which plants should not be harmed,' he says. But the tractor, in its so-called efficiency, spares nothing — not even the herbs that have evolved as vital parts of the ecosystem. This raises a deeper question: how do we, as a society, define true efficiency? 'People used khipp a lot back when the when Sindhu composed the Vedas,' Haji Muhammad shares, delving into ancient history. Speaking of recent times, he adds, 'The milk used to bathe idols during the Shiv Mela is sometimes infused with khipp.' The Shiv Mela is an annual festival held in Mithi, drawing people from across the region, regardless of faith or creed. Investing in resilience Tharparkar can grow everything its people need to survive. The only challenge, as local food industry businessman Pyaro Shivani explains, is that the region can go years without rain. 'Food is mostly grown during the rainy season,' he tells us at his home in Mithi. The regional diet, he shares, revolves around locally grown mung daal, sesame, and bajra (pearl millet), along with honey and butter, among other staples. 'We eat them from July to November, and after that, we preserve them and store them in our homes,' he says. Pyaro emphasises that despite the recurring droughts in Tharparkar, investing in and promoting locally grown food could help mitigate the worst effects. 'Agriculture in Tharparkar is largely organic. If efforts were made to develop it, it wouldn't matter if it didn't rain for 10 years,' he claims. According to him, the income generated from this commerce could sustain locals through prolonged droughts. Standing at the crossroads Thar is a place few from Karachi will ever visit. Yet, standing at a crossroads in time and space, it symbolises not just the gradual extinction of species, but also of culture and compels us to question the connection between ecological and cultural loss. It is easy to overlook the most ordinary yet heartwarming aspect of local customs — the emphasis on hospitality. The welcoming nature of the residents serves as a reminder of the importance of gratitude. Moreover, one gets the sense that those deeply connected to their history and traditions, whether through poetry and song or inherited wisdom, understand the importance of intergenerational knowledge in helping them endure through thick and thin. In big cities like Karachi, one encounters countless people who have been given everything, yet often fall prey to greed and cynicism. In contrast, in places like Thar, where resources are scarce, people seem to possess an endless reserve of generosity, gratitude, and openness. This shared cultural wealth belongs to all who live on these lands and beyond. For some, it lies buried deep, waiting to be unearthed; for others, it remains close to the surface. The only question is: are we curious enough to seek it? Zain Haq is a freelance contributor All facts and information are the sole responsibility of the author


Express Tribune
15-03-2025
- Express Tribune
Sindh comes alive with festival of colours
It's the festival of good over evil. It's the festival of welcoming spring. It's the festival of triumph. It's a festival for everyone. It's the festival of colours. It's Holi - Happy Holi! One of the major Hindu festivals, Holi, has been celebrated across Sindh with religious and cultural zeal. "For me, it's more of a cultural festival than a religious one," commented Mukesh Meghwar, an activist and educationist from Badin. "We [Hindus] celebrate it with our own community and friends [Muslims]. We share the colours - the colours of life." He said that most of his friends in Umerkot have been celebrating the festival for the last three days. "They have tried to break the silence. They have tried to bring back peace in the area. They have tried to discourage fear," he added. "On this special occasion, we celebrate colours because they are universal, and they have their own meanings, which we should all understand," Meghwar said. Some of the biggest Holi events took place in Mithi and Umerkot - the two major cities where Hindus are in majority. Muslims also joined the celebrations in these cities, as well as in Hyderabad, Sukkur, and Karachi. Prof KS Nagpal, a senior educationist and writer, told The Express Tribune that he celebrated Holi in Kandhkot. "Colours are everywhere. This is a festival of happiness and tells the story of triumph over tyranny." Most people on this occasion wear their old clothes, and according to Prof Nagpal, this is a festival for the poor. "Special dishes are prepared for this festival. We throw colours on each other to spread joy and mark the beginning of a new journey in life." "Holi gives you the message of harmony. It also gives you hope. It's a festival of happiness that everyone wants to enjoy," Prof Nagpal explained. He added that for the people of Sindh, Holi will be truly celebrated when water is restored to the Indus River. In Karachi, Holi was celebrated in different parts of the city, especially in the old city areas, including Narainpura, Saddar, Clifton, and other localities. The caretaker of the Ganish Mandir in Mauripur, said that his community celebrated the day on Thursday. "The celebrations started in the morning and continued until late in the evening," he said. "Special prayers were offered for peace and prosperity in our country," he concluded. Mukhi Sahil, a resident of Umerkot, said that it was the first time the festival truly felt alive. "Umerkot was different this year. The markets remained closed. Everyone participated - Hindus and Muslims." He added that the dhandhya made the festival even more colorful. "Dhandya dance was organised at various spots." He said that thousands of people from the city and nearby areas attended the late evening programmes of Holi. Owing to Ramazan, most of the programmes were arranged after Iftar.