Europeans seek 'digital sovereignty' as US tech firms embrace Trump
BERLIN, June 21 (Reuters) - At a market stall in Berlin run by charity Topio, volunteers help people who want to purge their phones of the influence of U.S. tech firms. Since Donald Trump's inauguration, the queue for their services has grown.
Interest in European-based digital services has jumped in recent months, data from digital market intelligence company Similarweb shows. More people are looking for e-mail, messaging and even search providers outside the United States.
The first months of Trump's second presidency have shaken some Europeans' confidence in their long-time ally, after he signalled his country would step back from its role in Europe's security and then launched a trade war.
"It's about the concentration of power in U.S. firms," said Topio's founder Michael Wirths, as his colleague installed on a customer's phone a version of the Android operating system without hooks into the Google ecosystem.
Wirths said the type of people coming to the stall had changed: "Before, it was people who knew a lot about data privacy. Now it's people who are politically aware and feel exposed."
Tesla (TSLA.O), opens new tab chief Elon Musk, who also owns social media company X, was a leading adviser to the U.S. president before the two fell out, while the bosses of Amazon (AMZN.O), opens new tab, Meta (META.O), opens new tab and Google-owner Alphabet (GOOGL.O), opens new tab took prominent spots at Trump's inauguration in January.
Days before Trump took office, outgoing president Joe Biden had warned of an oligarchic "tech industrial complex" threatening democracy.
Berlin-based search engine Ecosia says it has benefited from some customers' desire to avoid U.S. counterparts like Microsoft's (MSFT.O), opens new tab Bing or Google, which dominates web searches and is also the world's biggest email provider.
"The worse it gets, the better it is for us," founder Christian Kroll said of Ecosia, whose sales pitch is that it spends its profits on environmental projects.
Similarweb data shows the number of queries directed to Ecosia, opens new tab from the European Union has risen 27% year-on-year and the company says it has 1% of the German search engine market.
But its 122 million visits from the 27 EU countries in February were dwarfed by 10.3 billion visits to Google, whose parent Alphabet made revenues of about $100 billion from Europe, the Middle East and Africa in 2024 - nearly a third of its $350 billion global turnover.
Non-profit Ecosia earned 3.2 million euros ($3.65 million) in April, of which 770,000 euros was spent on planting 1.1 million trees.
Google declined to comment for this story.
Reuters could not determine whether major U.S. tech companies have lost any market share to local rivals in Europe.
The search for alternative providers accompanies a debate in Europe about "digital sovereignty" - the idea that reliance on companies from an increasingly isolationist United States is a threat to Europe's economy and security.
"Ordinary people, the kind of people who would never have thought it was important they were using an American service are saying, 'hang on!'," said UK-based internet regulation expert Maria Farrell. "My hairdresser was asking me what she should switch to."
Use in Europe of Swiss-based ProtonMail rose 11.7% year-on-year to March compared to a year ago, according to Similarweb, while use of Alphabet's Gmail, which has some 70% of the global email market, slipped 1.9%.
ProtonMail, which offers both free and paid-for services, said it had seen an increase in users from Europe since Trump's re-election, though it declined to give a number.
"My household is definitely disengaging," said British software engineer Ken Tindell, citing weak U.S. data privacy protections as one factor.
Trump's vice president JD Vance shocked European leaders in February by accusing them - at a conference usually known for displays of transatlantic unity - of censoring free speech and failing to control immigration.
In May, Secretary of State Marco Rubio threatened visa bans for people who "censor" speech by Americans, including on social media, and suggested the policy could target foreign officials regulating U.S. tech companies.
U.S. social media companies like Facebook and Instagram parent Meta have said the European Union's Digital Services Act amounts to censorship of their platforms.
EU officials say the Act will make the online environment safer by compelling tech giants to tackle illegal content, including hate speech and child sexual abuse material.
Greg Nojeim, director of the Security and Surveillance Project at the Center for Democracy & Technology, said Europeans' concerns about the U.S. government accessing their data, whether stored on devices or in the cloud, were justified.
Not only does U.S. law permit the government to search devices of anyone entering the country, it can compel disclosure of data that Europeans outside the U.S. store or transmit through U.S. communications service providers, Nojeim said.
Germany's new government is itself making efforts to reduce exposure to U.S. tech, committing in its coalition agreement to make more use of open-source data formats and locally-based cloud infrastructure.
Regional governments have gone further - in conservative-run Schleswig-Holstein, on the Danish border, all IT used by the public administration must run on open-source software.
Berlin has also paid for Ukraine to access a satellite-internet network operated by France's Eutelsat (ETL.PA), opens new tab instead of Musk's Starlink.
But with modern life driven by technology, "completely divorcing U.S. tech in a very fundamental way is, I would say, possibly not possible," said Bill Budington of U.S. digital rights nonprofit the Electronic Frontier Foundation.
Everything from push notifications to the content delivery networks powering many websites and how internet traffic is routed relies largely on U.S. companies and infrastructure, Budington noted.
Both Ecosia and French-based search engine Qwant depend in part on search results provided by Google and Microsoft's Bing, while Ecosia runs on cloud platforms, some hosted by the very same tech giants it promises an escape from.
Nevertheless, a group on messaging board Reddit called BuyFromEU has 211,000 members.
"Just cancelled my Dropbox and will switch to Proton Drive," read one post.
Mastodon, a decentralised social media service developed by German programmer Eugen Rochko, enjoyed a rush of new users two years ago when Musk bought Twitter, later renamed X. But it remains a niche service.
Signal, a messaging app run by a U.S. nonprofit foundation, has also seen a surge in installations from Europe. Similarweb's data showed a 7% month-on-month increase in Signal usage in March, while use of Meta's WhatsApp was static.
Meta declined to comment for this story. Signal did not respond to an e-mailed request for comment.
But this kind of conscious self-organising is unlikely on its own to make a dent in Silicon Valley's European dominance, digital rights activist Robin Berjon told Reuters.
"The market is too captured," he said. "Regulation is needed as well."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
31 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Immigration is the biggest burden on NHS, say Labour voters
Labour voters now believe immigration is the biggest burden on the NHS. Britons who backed Sir Keir Starmer's party at the general election last year think high levels of immigration are having more of an effect on the health service than the ageing population. A poll of 2,000 Labour supporters by Merlin Strategy also found that one in five Labour voters would now consider casting their ballots for Reform UK. It comes as Nigel Farage's party continues to enjoy a comfortable opinion poll lead after promising to effectively freeze non-essential migration and put an end to illegal Channel crossings. Research carried out on May 24 asked people who voted Labour in 2024 which of five factors they believed was 'the biggest burden' on the NHS. Some 24 per cent said high levels of immigration, with 22 per cent saying the mental health crisis. Thirteen per cent said a lack of social care provisions, while 12 per cent blamed junk food and obesity. A further 10 per cent said the biggest burden was people vaping. The remaining 19 per cent did not pick an option or said they did not know. Sir Keir said in a major speech last month that record levels of net migration to Britain in recent years had placed a heavy strain on the country's public services. Maxwell Marlow, the director of public affairs at the Adam Smith Institute, which commissioned the poll, said: 'It is clear that the British people have felt the impact of mass immigration on healthcare. 'Unless the government moves quickly, urging immigrants to purchase private health care as a requirement for any visa other than tourism, then they will continue to hold the Government accountable for the very rapid deterioration in their access to healthcare.' Sir Keir has been criticised for a lack of vision during his first year in office, with only 51 per cent of Labour voters saying the Government was prioritising issues that mattered to them. More than one in four (28 per cent) now regretted voting Labour and more than one in five (22 per cent) were now considering whether to vote for Reform at the next election. Two in five respondents (40 per cent) said they approved of Mr Farage, while 41 per cent disapproved. Scarlett Maguire, the director of Merlin Strategy, said: 'Labour voters are clear that they want to see action on cost of living, healthcare, and immigration. 'The Government needs to show that it is in tune with these priorities and that it understands what matters to their core voters.' Merlin Strategy also conducted a focus group in Runcorn and Helsby, one of the safest Labour seats at the 2024 election, before the party lost the seat to Reform by six votes at last month's by-election. Respondents said Sir Keir's Government was 'afraid of upsetting people', while another member of the group said: 'I don't think they give a toss about us.' The group were also unconvinced by the timing of Sir Keir's plans to clamp down on tobacco and vapes, which have banned disposable vapes and will raise the smoking age by one year, every year. 'How is that really relatable to the working person?' one member asked, adding that it was 'just something shiny to put in the media'.
Telegraph
31 minutes ago
- Telegraph
European puppy-smuggling gangs targeted by Government
European puppy-smuggling gangs are being targeted by new legislation capping the number and age of dogs that can cross the border into Britain. The Government-backed private members' bill will close loopholes that were exploited by the gangsters before Brexit, when the UK was a member of the EU pet passport system. The UK is expected to rejoin the EU passport for dogs, cats and ferrets scheme as part of Sir Keir Starmer's reset deal with Brussels. 'We would urge the Government to ensure that the UK-EU agreement does not have a negative impact on the measures included within the Bill,' warned Claire Calder of Dogs Trust. The passport was abused by criminals, many from Eastern Europe. They used forgeries or corrupt vets signing the travel documents without the proper checks to bring hundreds of thousands of poorly treated puppies into Britain. The Government insists the Bill, which has its third reading on July 3, will prevent a surge in puppy smuggling after the UK rejoins the scheme. Dr Danny Chambers, a Liberal Democrat MP and vet, said: 'So long as my Animal Welfare Bill continues to enjoy broad cross-party support and we get it passed into law, then when combined with pet passports, I'm fully confident the government will have the necessary powers to properly crack down on puppy smuggling.' The Animal Welfare (Import of Dogs, Cats and Ferrets) Bill raises the minimum age for commercially imported puppies and kittens from 15 weeks to six months. It gives the Government powers to ban the import of heavily pregnant and mutilated dogs and cats. It cuts the number of dogs, cats and ferrets that can be brought into Britain to five per vehicle or three per foot or air passenger. Currently there is a five animal limit per person, rather than per vehicle. A Government spokesman said rejoining the pet passport scheme would make taking pets on holiday easier and cheaper and that the Bill 'will end puppy smuggling'. Senior Tories in Boris Johnson's government hailed Brexit as an opportunity to end puppy smuggling, but a bill to curb the illegal imports was shelved in 2023. The trade has continued even though Brexit meant far more stringent and costly health checks and paperwork requirements to move animals between the EU and UK. The number of pets involved in 'non-commercial' moves to the UK rose from 100,000 in 2011 to more than 320,000 in 2023, raising concerns that puppy smuggling was rife. The EU is working on new legislation to improve minimum common standards for breeding and keeping cats and dogs and to improve cross-border traceability. But there were warnings this week that it won't stop European 'puppy mills' because it does not cover breeders with three litters or fewer. Animal rights campaigners say that it is about 80 per cent of all breeders and that just one unregulated breeder can produce 100 puppies over one animal's lifetime. The RSPCA said it hoped the UK would be back in the EU pet passport scheme by the summer, but added that proper border enforcement was vital. 'Whilst the Government supported Bill raising the minimum age for puppy imports to six months will help enormously tackle the illegal puppy trade, it must be backed up with well-funded enforcement controls,' said David Bowles, of the RSPCA. Northern Irish politicians this week warned that the region could become a back door into the UK for puppy smugglers because of its Brexit deal, which keeps the border with EU member Ireland invisible. Ulster Unionist Party MLA Robbie Butler said of the Bill: ' What we risk doing here is creating an alternative route where animals are brought legally into the Republic, then re-registered, and quietly moved across the border into Northern Ireland and on to Great Britain without triggering enforcement.'
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
How expats can avoid a financial headache when returning to the UK
Have you moved back to the UK from abroad and faced difficulties sorting your finances? Get in touch money@ In 2024, as many as 77,000 Britons left the UK, according to government figures. But whether it was in search of adventure, love or work, it won't be a permanent move for many, with estimates suggesting that around 30pc of expats will return home within three years. It doesn't matter how good the weather or lifestyle is, the pull of home can be strong. If you've got children, you might want them to be schooled here, while older expats may want to return to family, friends and free healthcare. However, those expats who make the move back to the UK can find that their return is fraught with financial challenges – especially if they didn't keep a UK bank account or maintain a property at home. 'Returning British expats can face hurdles when re-establishing their financial footprint in the UK,' says John Webb, the consumer expert at Experian. 'One of the main challenges is the lack of recent UK credit history, which can affect applications for things like phone contracts, credit cards and mortgages. 'If lenders don't have much information to assess your creditworthiness, it can make getting credit at good rates more challenging. This can often be the case for returning expats who have something called a 'thin file'.' You'll also need to think about tax, your pension and any investments too. Here Telegraph Money explains the obstacles you might encounter, and shares some ideas for how to ease the move. Finding a home and getting a mortgage Be realistic about your finances Register to vote Open a UK bank account Get a SIM-only phone contract Take out a credit card Transferring pensions Managing tax and investments Finding a home and getting a mortgage Laura Doulton, of Clifton Private Finance, says returning expats are often treated as 'mortgage pariahs' by mainstream lenders. 'Even if they've been earning good salaries and paying rent or mortgage payments abroad without issue, UK banks view them as high-risk because they lack a recent UK credit history. Many discover their excellent credit record from living in Dubai or Singapore means nothing to a UK lender.' However impressive your overseas career might look on LinkedIn, it might not be enough to wow lenders. 'Lenders want to see stable UK employment, but returning expats may be starting new jobs or working for international companies with complex pay structures. This creates a Catch-22 situation where they need a UK address to get a mortgage, but need a mortgage to secure that address.' The key is to give yourself time and consult a mortgage broker who specialises in dealing with expats. 'We guide clients to provide comprehensive documentation of their overseas financial history and work with lenders who will consider foreign income and employment contracts,' says Doulton. Louis Levine, a senior mortgage broker at UK Expat Mortgage, a part of Orton Financial, agrees. 'The other hiccup can be that you're starting a new job that hasn't commenced yet, so we often need to prioritise lenders that are more flexible on credit history and can accept only one month's payslips as income evidence for example. Private banks are much more lenient on this for the right clients.' Doulton says she recommends clients kick the process off around four to six months before they come home. Alternatively, you can consider renting first but, as Levine points out, 'with most rental contracts lasting a minimum of 12 months (or six months at best) it's a logistical complication'. Be realistic about your finances Before you start looking for homes, it's important to think about affordability – both in terms of how much property costs in the UK and the level of disposable income you will have, after HMRC has taken its slice. Doulton says it's not unusual for clients to suffer affordability shocks, particularly those who are returning from tax-free jurisdictions such as the UAE or countries with significantly lower tax rates. 'Someone earning £100,000 in Dubai takes home considerably more than someone earning the same in London. When they return, their net income can drop by 30-40pc immediately due to UK tax obligations.' She adds: 'It's important to note that if a client returns to the UK but continues to earn in say dollars or dirhams, lenders will apply a haircut to their income to allow for currency fluctuation, so this can affect their borrowing power further.' Register to vote In addition to giving you the opportunity to vote in local and national elections, joining the electoral roll can boost your credit score – helping you get everything from a phone contract to a credit card or mortgage. To register to vote, you will need an address, which could be problematic if you don't yet have a permanent residence. If you were registered to vote as an overseas voter, you will still need to re-register once you have a permanent address back in the UK. Open a UK bank account Many expats keep a UK bank account, but if you haven't, you'll need to prioritise opening one as soon as you can. 'Once on the electoral roll, use this to apply for a UK bank account,' suggests Levine. 'Ensure it's an account that reports to UK credit rating agencies like Experian.' Depending on the bank, you may be able to open a UK current account before you arrive. HSBC, for example, lets you have accounts in different countries and lets you easily transfer money between them. Get a SIM-only phone contract A new phone contract will be crucial in helping you find your feet when you first get back, but you might encounter a problem with some deals. 'Phone contracts often require a credit check, and without a recent UK credit history, providers may be hesitant to offer a contract. Starting with a SIM-only deal can be easier, and help build your credit profile,' says Webb. Take out a credit card Spending money on a credit card and making timely repayments, can be a helpful way of padding out a thin credit history and give your score a boost. 'It's a good idea to look for a credit builder card, which is designed for people with limited credit history,' says Webb. 'Using it responsibly – keeping balances low and making payments on time – can help demonstrate reliability to lenders.' Most comparison sites will also be able to tell you which cards you'll be eligible for, without damaging your credit score. Transferring pensions If retirement is still a long way off, what you need to do with your pension might not feel immediately pressing – especially when you're dealing with challenges such as finding somewhere to live. Nonetheless, it's something that needs attention sooner rather than later. David Denton, of financial planners Quilter Cheviot points out that lots of returning expats believe that their pensions will seamlessly follow them, wherever they go. The reality, he says, is much more complex. 'If you've built up an overseas pension, you'll need to understand the local rules around transfers and whether your scheme qualifies for a transfer to a UK-recognised provider. Not all overseas pensions are eligible, and tax charges can apply if you get it wrong. 'A financial adviser who specialises in cross-border planning can help you obtain the scheme documentation, explain your options, and model the impact of transferring versus leaving it where it is.' The UK state pension Your entitlement to the UK state pension, meanwhile, will depend on how many years of National Insurance contributions you'll have under your belt when you eventually reach state pension age. To get the full amount, you'll need 35 years. If you have between 10 and 35 years, you'll get a pro rata payment. You'll only end up with no state pension in the UK if you rack up less than 10 years of contributions (either by way of payments from earnings or credits if you were claiming certain benefits). That means it's important to get a state pension forecast to find out where you stand. Denton adds: 'You may be able to make voluntary contributions to fill in any gaps and boost your entitlement.' However, while your entitlement to the UK state pension may have been impacted during your absence, you may have been building up entitlement to an overseas scheme. Denton explains: 'If you've spent time working abroad, you may also be entitled to a state pension from that country. It's important to check whether the UK has a social security agreement with the country you've worked in, as this can affect whether your overseas contributions count towards your UK entitlement or whether you can claim two separate pensions. 'Understanding the interaction between systems is key to avoiding disappointment when you reach retirement age.' He adds: 'For your overseas state pension, it's best to contact that country's pension authority. You'll usually need to provide records of your work history and tax ID. Some countries will coordinate with the UK to streamline claims, while others require completely separate applications, so timing and paperwork can get complicated without help.' Managing tax and investments What could give you an even bigger headache and a shock is tax. Denton warns: 'If you've been in a lower-tax jurisdiction, the UK's income tax, plus things like dividend tax and capital gains tax, can come as a surprise. 'If you've retained overseas assets or income streams, those can also create complications, as the UK taxes you on your worldwide income once you're a resident again. It's crucial to get ahead of the UK tax rules before you return, not after.' Finn Houlihan, the managing director at wealth adviser, AAF Financial, recommends getting specialist tax advice. He suggests starting the process 12 to 18 months before you come home. 'It would be reasonable to assume that the date you will become a UK tax resident would be the date you physically arrive in the UK. However, this would be far too simple for the UK tax authorities. The date you become a UK resident is dependent on your particular circumstances and is assessed under legislation known as the Statutory Residence Test (SRT).' The basic rule for the SRT is that an individual will be resident in the UK for a whole tax year. However, he adds that there are certain circumstances where 'split-year treatment' can be claimed. 'For example, when an individual comes from abroad and starts to work, split-year treatment enables part of a tax year to be taxed as a non-UK resident and the other part to be taxed as a UK resident.' When it comes to investments, Houlihan says that the rule of thumb is to crystallise your gains while you're still non-resident. 'Problems arise if this step is missed and the individual could bring all the gains back into scope of UK tax which could have easily been avoided. The same applies for bank accounts, any interest due should be paid out whilst non-resident.' Before returning home, Houlihan says it's important to work with an adviser to agree the following: Identify the date you will become UK resident for tax purposes. Review all assets and income streams to understand how you will be taxed once you become UK resident. Consider the appropriate restructuring of assets such as pensions, properties, investments and life assurance. Identify and undertake any pre-residence planning opportunities available. He adds: 'Generally most problems can easily be avoided with good planning and advice.'
