Indian Panthers suspension: Companies out of pocket, CEO Parveen Batish alleged to owe thousands of dollars
Pure Athletic owner Chris McKinley told the Herald he was approached by the organisation in February with an urgent request for supporter tees.
'They ordered 1500 tees and we gave them a super price to help them out as they were a new team coming into the NBL.'
McKinley said the total invoice was $21,562.50. He said his business would normally get a 50% deposit for this sort of order, but the Panthers needed it 'urgently' and he was told the money was coming.
More than two months later, McKinley told the Herald his business has not received a single payment, despite the tees being handed out to supporters at games.
He claimed Panthers owner Parveen Batish constantly promised payment via text messages, but didn't follow through.
'I believe this guy Parveen honestly does not care about anybody, he has showed no remorse and just treats people like s***.'
Meanwhile, Auckland-based business Makers Merch has referred the embattled organisation to the Disputes Tribunal, also citing a failure to pay for customised merchandise.
Owner Troy Signal told the Herald he supplied the Panthers with a few thousand units of hand clappers, branded with the organisation's logo.
'Usually what we do is we don't take any orders without payment upfront ... out of goodwill we released the goods so that they would get them before their deadline.'
Signal claimed payment is also more than two months overdue and that Batish had stopped answering his phone calls.
'[It's] a couple of thousand dollars. It's nothing huge, but being a small business operating only nine months ... obviously it's still an amount that does sting us when it comes out of the back pocket.
The Panthers – owned by India's INBL Pro league and Batish – have had a turbulent tenure off the court since announcing they would join the NBL late last year, which in turn has led to a winless season from nine games.
Visa delays for Indian players and national team commitments led to the organisation recruiting New Zealanders to fill in. Originally appointed head coach Miles Pearce also resigned after one game.
In their recent outing against the Canterbury Rams in Pukekohe, the game was called off due to the Panthers being unable to field a full squad. It is understood the team was planning a protest over lack of payment and treatment of players.
Advertise with NZME.
Speaking to the Herald on Thursday, before it was announced the Panthers would be suspended indefinitely, Batish confirmed there were outstanding invoices the organisation needed to pay suppliers.
'We know we're at fault. We have been slow at making some payments and financially we haven't been as professional as we should have been,' Batish said.
Asked if he was aware the organisation had been referred to the Disputes Tribunal, Batish said yes, but he had not heard from any tribunal so far.
'It's not like we're running away, we are here. Sometimes you might have to wait ... He's entitled to do exactly what he's doing and that's okay, but my commitment to him and to you is that they will be paid.
'There has been a timing issue, I've apologised to them profusely for that, but not from a commitment to run away.'
Batish claimed all outstanding invoices would be paid by May 15 – in line with a commitment made to the NBL.
'I've always said to any supplier that has come forward that 100% we will pay you, but right now I'm trying to work out exactly when that would be.'
Asked about other outstanding payments, Batish said he could 'hand on heart' say all New Zealand players from the Panthers had been paid completely.
As for Panthers staff, Batish said they have had some interim payments and were not fully up to date, 'but they will be and they know that'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
1News
3 hours ago
- 1News
How rich is your region? Housing, employment and debt compared
Times have been tough for many New Zealanders in recent months. But the effect of the downturn hasn't been felt evenly, and some areas are tracking better than others. Wellington still holds up in terms of income, and is now near the top of housing affordability statistics, too. The top of the South Island has the best credit scores. Unemployment is lowest in the South Island. Here is how the regions stack up. Northland ADVERTISEMENT Early morning sunrise over Tutukaka Coast, Northland, New Zealand. (Source: According to MBIE data, Northland had an average household income last year of $123,900. House prices vary according to where in the region you are. As a whole, Northland house prices are still 12.2% below their peak. In the Far North, it takes about 48% of a median household income to service an 80% mortgage on a median-value house. In Whangarei, it's just over 50%. Rents moved up 1.7% in May compared to April, according to Trade Me data, and Cotality says it takes about a third of median household income to cover the median rent. One of Northland's bigger problems is unemployment. Data shows just under 11% of the population is on JobSeeker support. Northland's GDP per capita is $54,796, according to MBIE. The morning's headlines in 90 seconds, including new corruption report, California protests, and Justin Baldoni's legal loss. (Source: 1News) According to Otago University's deprivation index, which measures deprivation based on factors like access to internet, income, employment, qualifications, living space and living conditions, the Far North District of Northland had 57% of its population in the two most deprived deciles. ADVERTISEMENT ASB recently noted that construction activity was particularly weak in Northland. Simplicity chief economist Shamubeel Eaqub said Northland was isolated, which created problems, but if the road to Auckland was improved, it could lift incomes and opportunities. Auckland (Source: Getty) A little further south, incomes are much stronger. Auckland's average household income according to MBIE is $155,100 a year and GDP per capita was $88,355. Stats NZ weekly data showed that Auckland had the second-highest median household income, at $2615. Auckland's unemployment rate is 5.4%, according to Infometrics. While people are earning more in Auckland, housing is a bigger drain. ADVERTISEMENT Auckland had a median house price of $1 million in April, and first-home buyers were paying a median of just over $900,000 in the latest Cotality data. In Auckland, just under 48% of median household income would go on servicing a mortgage on a median-priced house. Auckland house prices remain 21.6% below their peak. Trade Me data, which measures asking rents, showed they had dropped 1.5% in May compared to April to $670. That was joint second-highest in the country but Cotality's data showed that, compared to incomes, they were more affordable than most main centres, requiring a median 25% of income. About a quarter of Auckland's total population is recorded as having a bachelor's degree or higher qualification. Auckland's unemployment rate on an annual average basis was 5.4% in the year to March, according to Infometrics. Recent Worldline data showed Auckland and Northland had one of the smallest increases in spending in May in core retail merchants, year-on-year, up 1.1%. Waikato ADVERTISEMENT Aerial view of Waikato River (Source: MBIE says Waikato's average household income is $129,100 a year and GDP per capita is $68,598. Waikato also has a relatively higher number of people out of work - 7.3% are on JobSeeker Support. The Otago University deprivation index shows 54% of South Waikato's population is in the two most deprived deciles. Waikato house prices are 12.1% below their peak but Cotality has noted that the smaller price fall has meant affordability hasn't improved in the same way that it has in some other centres. Rents are flat, according to Trade Me, with an average weekly asking price of $580. Cotality says renting requires a median 27.5% of income. Farming incomes are relatively strong which may help areas such as Waikato. Cotality noted this as a driver in a recent property market update. BNZ's chief economist Mike Jones noted farm sales and fertiliser imports are trending up. ADVERTISEMENT In South Waikato, earlier RNZ analysis showed 23% of the population was employed by a relatively small number of manufacturing businesses. Eaqub said variation in prosperity around the country was driven by economic opportunities. "Different places have different reasons for being. Because of geography, the makeup of industries, economic opportunities, different levels of income, different amount of job opportunity, that really underpins a lot of the other stuff. "What is the reason for people living there? Farming, manufacturing, retirement living - how many jobs will there be, what kind of income, what kind of wealth can be generated there versus how much is brought in from other places?" Bay of Plenty Mt Maunganui view from Moturiki Island, New Zealand. (Source: Bay of Plenty had an average income of $134,100 last year and average asking rent of $660. ADVERTISEMENT Trade Me said that rents dropped 2.9% in April compared to March. GDP per capita was $67,650 In Bay of Plenty, 8% of the population is on Jobseeker support. But the picture is mixed within the region: while areas such as Tauranga and Mount Maunganui are better off, Kawerau has 78% of its population in the most deprived deciles. Kawerau has 42% of its people employed by a small number of manufacturing businesses. Bay of Plenty house prices are 13.5% below their peak. Tauranga is a standout in the housing market, the least affordable main centre with a value-to-income ratio of 8.6 according to Cotality. This is down from 12.1 at the peak. Paying a median mortgage takes 51.6% of a median household income in Tauranga and 61.4% in the Western Bay of Plenty. Cotality noted this could be affected by people moving into the area with investment income or other assets. ADVERTISEMENT Eaqub said Tauranga, alongside Queenstown, was a standout region with different reason for being. "They are kind of 'sunshine coast' where people go to retire so they have different drivers of society and economy." Taranaki Taranaki Maunga and Panitahi (Source: ASB recently singled Taranaki out as a poor performer on a regional basis, recording a "tough year" in 2024. Construction activity was weak, employment dropped 2.5% in the year because of lower gas production, the bank said, and consumer confidence fell. Taranaki's spending in core retail was up 3.7% in May, year-on-year. MBIE said the region had an average household income of $132,400, and GDP per capita of $85,362. ADVERTISEMENT Trade Me says the average asking rent is $610 a week, up 1.7% year-on-year. Renting requires a median 31.4% of income, according to Cotality. This is another area with variation in house prices, from a median of $495,000 and $500,000 in South Taranaki and Stratford, respectively, and $685,000 in New Plymouth according to the Real Estate Institute. Gisborne Overlooking the town of Gisborne, New Zealand from Kaiti Hill. (Source: Gisborne's average household income was $133,200 last year, and had GDP per capita of $55,326. But it had the highest weekly asking rent of anywhere in the country in Trade Me's last update, at $680 a week. This could be influenced by a relatively smaller number of properties for rent. Cotality said renting would take 31.5% of a median income. Gisborne and Hawke's Bay house prices are still 16.6% below their peak. Servicing a mortgage requires 34.3% of a median income. Gisborne has the lowest Centrix credit score, on average, in the country. ADVERTISEMENT Infometrics chief forecaster Gareth Kiernan said Gisborne's physical distance from most of New Zealand was a hurdle. Hawke's Bay An aerial view of Napier, Haewke's Bay. (Source: Hawke's Bay has an average household income last year of $149,600 according to MBIE. GDP per capita was $64,935. The average asking rent, according to Trade Me, of $670 is on par with Auckland and up 6.3% between April and May. There are pockets that are more prosperous, and many not so - Wairoa has 75% of its population in the most deprived deciles according to Otago's data. Kiernan said, the prosperity or otherwise of some regions could be traced back to the economic reforms of the 1980s. "When there were massive transitional costs from the removal of protection or subsidies for some industries, which resulted in high and persistent unemployment in some areas, dragging down average socioeconomic outcomes for those areas." ADVERTISEMENT Manawatū-Whanganui Mt Ngauruhoe and Mt Ruapehu view from Lake Taupo (Source: MBIE said this region had average household income of $119,200 and GDP per capita of $59,834. Whanganui had the biggest annual spending change in the country in May, up 6.9%. Palmerston North is relatively affordable for renters, requiring 26.4% of income, according to Cotality, and towards the cheaper end for buying, too, at 34%. Compared to income, housing in Whanganui is more expensive. ADVERTISEMENT Wellington The Beehive (Source: Wellington has been going through tough times with the government cutting back on spending but the data still shows it has the highest incomes in the country. According to Stats NZ, it had the highest median weekly income of $2870 last year. MBIE said the average household income was $162,400. Almost 30% of Wellington's population reported having a degree-level qualification or higher. Infometrics said the annual average unemployment rate to March was 4.8%. Historically, the capital had much lower unemployment than the rest of the country but that is no longer the case. ADVERTISEMENT MBIE said the Wellington region's GDP per capita was $92,776. Wellington house prices are 25.1% below their peak. The big fall in house prices has helped affordability a lot. Cotality said prices were at pre-2017 affordability levels, with a value-to-income ratio of 6.5. It is the cheapest main centre to rent in, with median rents 23.5% of median household income. Spending in May was down 1.3% year-on-year, the only centre to record a fall. Marlborough Picton, Marlborough. (Source: Marlborough has an average household income of $119,100 and GDP per capita of $84,296. It has the second-highest average credit score in the country according to Centrix, behind nearby Tasman region. ADVERTISEMENT Kiernan said the unemployment rate tended to be lower on average in the South Island. He said historically, people who did not have a job there would leave to find one, and that could mean shifting to cities in the North Island. "That tends to keep a cap on joblessness down there." Marlborough's unemployment rate is 3.1%. Tasman Picton, Marlborough. (Source: As well as having the highest credit scores in the country, the Tasman region has some of the least affordable housing, according to Cotality. It was the fourth-least affordable in terms of mortgage repayments compared to household income, at 56.6%. That is behind areas such as Thames-Coromandel, Queenstown, Western Bay of Plenty and Central Otago, which Cotality notes can be particularly affected by outside investors buying properties. ADVERTISEMENT Tasman's unemployment rate is 3.5%. Canterbury New Regent St in Christchurch. (Source: Canterbury has an average household income of $132,300, and GDP per capita of $74,772. ASB recently ranked Canterbury second in terms of regional economic performance. Cantabrians were the second most optimistic in the country after Aucklanders, the bank said. ADVERTISEMENT Construction activity was relatively strong. The area's housing market hasn't had such big swings as other parts of the country. Christchurch has an unemployment rate of 5.4% and Selwyn 3%. Ashburton sits at 3.6%. The Selwyn district has 62% of its population in the least deprived deciles, according to Otago University. West Coast The road up to Denniston Coal Mine on the West Coast (Source: The West Coast has average household income of $117,900 and GDP per capita of $75,057. The region is relatively isolated but has some of the cheapest housing in the country. Infometrics puts the average rent at $393 a week compared to $575 for the country as a whole. ADVERTISEMENT Cotality's data shows an 8% mortgage takes less than 25% of the median household income in Grey, the most affordable in the country. Kiernan said sometimes areas with cheaper housing would attract people who could not afford to live elsewhere. "It may be negative in terms of the overall average skill base, education and income potentially earned." Otago The Square of Dunedin Historical Railway Station (Source: Otago has been a stronger performer recently, boosted by a recovery in tourism. Spending in Otago was up 4.6% year on year in May, after a strong month in April, too. The region's unemployment rate in March was just 2.9%. In Queenstown Lakes, almost 60% of the population is in the least deprived deciles. ADVERTISEMENT Queenstown has some of the most unaffordable housing in the country. An 80% mortgage on a median value house requires almost 84% of the median local household income. Cotality said that reflected investment from outside the region and people bringing equity in to the market. According to Infometrics, Otago has the lowest unemployment rate in the country, at 2.9%. Southland Esk Street in Invercargill. (Source: Southland has an average household income of $110,900 and GDP per capita of $83,620. Recent property data showed that house prices had returned to their previous peaks - but that is only a median $485,000. In Invercargill, it takes just 29.2% of the median household income to service a mortgage on a median property. ADVERTISEMENT The average asking rent according to Trade Me was $480 a week in April. Eaqub said areas that could not maintain their reason for being, and were negatively affected by shifts in technology and urbanisation, could end up worse off while other places could see their fortunes improve.
Scoop
8 hours ago
- Scoop
Premium Clean New Zealand Marks Decade Of Excellence With Environmental Impact Campaign
Press Release – Premium Clean Auckland, Aotearoa New Zealand, 2 June 2025 — Premium Clean New Zealand proudly celebrates its 10th anniversary this month, launching the innovative 'Planting the Future' campaign in partnership with Trees That Count, New Zealand's native tree planting programme. Growing a Greener Future, One Clean at a Time The centrepiece of Premium Clean's anniversary celebration is the 'Planting the Future' initiative. Every customer who books a cleaning service will automatically contribute to New Zealand's reforestation efforts, with Premium Clean planting one native tree for each service booked. 'We've spent ten years cleaning and caring for Kiwi whānau and businesses — from weekly house cleans to those crucial end-of-lease cleaning services that help tenants get their bond back,' said Managing Director Shirley Kohli. 'Now we're extending that manaakitanga to our taiao. It's a pretty choice knowing every clean helps restore our beautiful Aotearoa landscape.' Celebrating Our Loyal Customers To thank customers for a decade of support, Premium Clean is offering 25% off on all services throughout June and July using the discount code ' PCS10YRS. ' This offer is perfect for residential cleans, commercial services catering for all serviced locations. Recognising Team Excellence Premium Clean's success comes down to our outstanding team. This month, we're hosting a special anniversary awards lunch to recognise our dedicated staff with loyalty awards and employee recognition prizes. 'Our team's been absolutely brilliant — their hard yakka has been the cornerstone of our success,' added Thompson. 'From bond cleans to weekly maintenance, they've built our reputation across New Zealand.' Since 2015, Premium Clean has grown from a small local operation to one of Aotearoa's most trusted cleaning providers. It specialises in residential cleaning, commercial services, and comprehensive end-of-lease cleaning that helps Kiwi renters secure their bond returns. New Zealanders can join this milestone celebration by booking services at contributing to spotless spaces and Aotearoa's environmental future. About Premium Clean NZ Founded in 2015, Premium Clean NZ is a leading residential and commercial cleaning service provider. It specialises in weekly cleaning, one-off services, and comprehensive end-of-lease cleaning solutions, floor care services, Upholstery cleaning, and Carpet cleaning that help tenants secure their bond returns.
NZ Herald
8 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Kiwis working for longer as youth employment and older workforce rises
Working lives are getting longer as New Zealanders join the workforce earlier and work longer after retirement, according to Stats NZ. Census data shows almost one in two Kiwis between 65-69 years old were still employed in 2023, while the percentage of people aged 15 to 29 in employment
