Proposed Idaho state law could make some lies a felony crime with prison time
An Idaho lawmaker is pushing a bill that, if passed, would make knowingly lying about another person a felony crime in the state.
House Speaker Mike Moyle introduced the bill on Friday, which would prohibit a person "with actual malice" from publishing a false statement about another person.
According to the Idaho Press, the bill defines "actual malice" as knowing the statement is false or with reckless disregard as to whether or not the statement is false.
The bill also defines "publish" as "communicate to a person or persons."
Msnbc Set For High-stakes Defamation Trial In 'Uterus Collector' Lawsuit
Moyle shared an example with the outlet, explaining that it would be illegal to yell "fire" in a crowded room if there wasn't a fire.
Read On The Fox News App
"I'm a firm believer in our First Amendment right, but I also believe that our founding fathers did not include in the First Amendment as being able to lie about somebody," Moyle said.
If the bill passes, the penalty would be up to a $100,000 fine, up to five years in prison, or both prison and a fine.
Jury Finds Cnn Committed Defamation Against Navy Veteran, Settlement Reached On Punitive Damages
The outlet reported that the bill would also allow the attorney general or county prosecuting attorney to pursue prosecution if the statement is made about a state elected official or state employee in regard to their official conduct.
Under the new bill, someone convicted of "criminal libel" would also be responsible for providing restitution to the victim for specific costs incurred or lost as a result of the false statement.
George Stephanopoulos And Abc Apologize To Trump, Are Forced To Pay $15 Million To Settle Defamation Suit
The House State Affairs Committee unanimously introduced the bill. However, Rep. Bruce Skaug, R-Nampa, said he would like a legal analysis of the potential First Amendment issues the bill could raise.
"My concern is that if you make every liar a felon, then we're going to be in a lot of trouble, not enough room in our jails," Skaug said.
Libel in Idaho code is currently defined as "malicious defamation," which is expressed in order to "blacken the memory of one who is dead, or to impeach the honesty, integrity, virtue or reputation, or publish the natural or alleged defects, of one who is alive, and thereby to expose him to public hatred, contempt or ridicule."
The punishment for the current Idaho code is a fine of up to $5,000 or confinement in county jail for up to six months.Original article source: Proposed Idaho state law could make some lies a felony crime with prison time
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
32 minutes ago
- Yahoo
'Milk' screenwriter Dustin Lance Black: Respond to ship renaming order by building coalitions
Dustin Lance Black, the Oscar-winning screenwriter of the 2008 Harvey Milk biopic Milk, says the best way for LGBTQ+ people to react to the Trump administration's order to take Milk's name off a Navy ship is to build coalitions with other marginalized people. Keep up with the latest in + news and politics. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has ordered the renaming of the USNS Harvey Milk and directed the Navy to consider renaming the other ships planned for its class, all named for civil rights icons, such as Thurgood Marshall, a crusading lawyer and the first Black U.S. Supreme Court justice; another justice, women's and LGBTQ+ rights champion Ruth Bader Ginsburg; labor leaders Cesar Chavez and Dolores Huerta; and abolitionists Sojourner Truth and Harriet Tubman. 'This is one of the oldest plays in the playbook … if they divide, they'll conquer,' Black said Sunday on MSNBC's The Weekend. 'If gay people want to react to this the way Harvey Milk would say to react to this is to understand Harvey's gonna be an icon no matter what Pete does. Now it's time to do what Harvey said to do. He said this is not about ego. … This is about the 'us-es' coming together.' 'He didn't mean just LGBTQ folks,' Black said of Milk, the first out gay person elected to public office in California — a member of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors, serving just a year before his assassination in 1978. 'He was talking about the people who he worked for, who he fought so hard for, like seniors in San Francisco who couldn't afford to live in the home that they had grown up in. About union workers who supported Harvey because Harvey had boycotted Coors beer so union workers could have a living wage to raise their kids. For the folks in Chinatown, he said, let's get those ballots in Mandarin so your vote counts.' - YouTube 'Those of us who feel and know we are treated differently under the law for who we are, we have to come together, we cannot become myopic, we cannot simply focus on our own needs, we have to lock arms and build those coalitions, and sadly right now we find ourselves in a similar position to where we were back in Harvey's time, when those coalitions were fractured,' he added. It's our work not to fall for this nonsense. It's our work right now to lock arms. So if you're a gay person who's pissed off by this, in Pride Month here in Los Angeles, get out on the streets and stand up for our brothers and sisters who are suffering in the Latino community up here right now. Do that. Show up for our brothers and sisters, not just thinking about ourselves. That's what Harvey would do.' Republican U.S. Sen. Ted Budd of North Carolina, who blocked Democratic colleague Adam Schiff's resolution to urge the reversing of the renaming order, claimed the way the ships were named broke with Navy tradition. Budd was 'ill informed, I think at best,' or was 'peddling misinformation,' Black said. Related: Before becoming a politician and activist in San Francisco, Milk served in the Navy and was forced to resign for being gay. He also worked on Wall Street and as a Broadway production associate. Milk excelled in the Navy, as he did at everything he set his mind to, Black noted. He was also among 'countless LGBTQ people who served proudly,' the writer said. Black's mother and stepfather were both in the military, so he grew up around people who had to serve in the closet, he pointed out. 'What it's time for is to recognize that,' he concluded. Last week, Black and Sean Penn, who played Milk in the movie and won the Best Actor Oscar, had blasted Hegseth's order in interviews with The Hollywood Reporter. 'This is yet another move to distract and to fuel the culture wars that create division,' Black told the publication. 'It's meant to get us to react in ways that are self-centered so that we are further distanced from our brothers and sisters in equally important civil rights fights in this country. It's divide and conquer.' Penn emailed the Reporter, saying, 'I've never before seen a Secretary of Defense so aggressively demote himself to the rank of Chief PETTY Officer.' Black added, 'Pete Hegseth does not seem like a smart man, a wise man, a knowledgeable man. He seems small and petty. I would love to introduce him to some LGBTQ folks who are warriors who have had to be warriors our entire life just to live our lives openly as who we are.'
Newsweek
32 minutes ago
- Newsweek
75 Democrats Express 'Gratitude' to ICE in Antisemitism Vote Amid LA Unrest
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Seventy-five Democrats broke ranks on Monday, joining Republicans in voting for a House resolution condemning antisemitism and expressing "gratitude" for Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and other law enforcement personnel. Why It Matters Monday's vote comes as Los Angeles is reeling from days of political unrest after ICE raided several downtown city neighborhoods and arrested more than 50 people. The arrests are part of the Trump administration's broader crackdown on undocumented migrants, which has also swept up people who are legally permitted to be in the United States. President Donald Trump has deployed 4,000 National Guard troops to L.A. since the protests started unfolding and has also mobilized 700 Marines to respond if the strife escalates. What To Know Monday's resolution condemned this month's antisemitic attack in Boulder, Colorado, in which the suspect, Mohamed Sabry Soliman, faces 118 criminal charges, accused of targeting a march calling for the return of Israeli hostages in Gaza. The resolution also "affirms that free and open communication between State and local law enforcement and their Federal counterparts remains the bedrock of public safety and is necessary in preventing terrorist attacks; and expresses gratitude to law enforcement officers, including U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement personnel, for protecting the homeland." Of the 212 Democrats in the House, 113 voted against the resolution, which was introduced by Republican Representative Gabe Evans. Seventy-five Democrats voted in favor of the measure, including Representative Joe Neguse, who represents the district where the Boulder attack occurred. Six lawmakers—five Democrats and one Republican—voted "present." This is a breaking news story. Updates to follow.
Yahoo
43 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Red cards, hotlines and legal tips: How to respond to ICE raids in Los Angeles
As immigration enforcement efforts spark protests and concerns across Southern California, advocacy organizations are sharing critical resources to help residents understand and protect their rights and report illegal activity. Here's what you need to know: Individuals participating in protests may distribute flyers, chant, picket, and hand out literature in public spaces such as sidewalks, parks, and plazas. These activities are generally protected under the First Amendment, provided they do not block access to buildings or disrupt counter-demonstrations, according to ACLU Southern California. LIVE: Continuing coverage of Los Angeles protests However, protesters may not block sidewalks or entrances, interfere with opposing protests, or engage in obscene or knowingly false speech that incites violence. Marching in the streets often requires a permit, and demonstrators must follow local traffic laws. Speech activity is broadly protected in public areas and many government-owned facilities that are open to the public. However, these protections do not apply in federal buildings, courthouses, or on private property without consent. Some privately owned spaces open to the public, such as shopping malls, may allow limited free speech activity under specific rules. You are not required to answer questions about your immigration status or where you were born. Noncitizens are required to carry immigration documents, but they are not required to present them unless asked to do so by an agent. Never provide false information or documents. If contacted by the FBI, you do not have to answer questions. Politely request to speak with a lawyer. You may decline interviews or agree to speak only with legal counsel present. Mexico's president condemns violence amid protests against ICE raids Individuals have the right to remain silent, refuse searches, and ask for an attorney if arrested. Regardless of immigration status, everyone is protected by the Constitution. If stopped by the police, remain calm and do not attempt to flee, advocates say. Ask if you are free to leave. If not under arrest, you may walk away. You have the right to refuse to answer questions and to decline searches unless an officer has reasonable suspicion of a weapon. In a vehicle stop, drivers must show their license, registration, and also have the right to remain silent and may request to leave if they are free to do so. Officers may search a vehicle without consent only if they believe it contains evidence of a crime. Do not resist arrest. Ask to remain silent and request a lawyer immediately. Do not sign or say anything without legal representation. You have the right to make a local phone call, and police may not listen if you are calling an attorney. Noncitizens should speak only to their lawyer about immigration matters. An arrest may impact an individual's immigration status, and any documents signed without the presence of counsel could have lasting consequences. For more information or legal assistance, click here. Earlier this year, the Los Angeles Unified School District began distributing 'red cards' — small, wallet-sized guides that outline constitutional protections for immigrant families. The cards offer instructions on what to do if approached by immigration agents and are part of a broader campaign to reassure students and families that schools remain safe spaces. Available to citizens and non-citizens alike, the documents were created by the Immigrant Legal Resource Center and are available in 16 languages, from Spanish to Haitian Creole to Tigrinya. Click here to access them. Residents can also call their county's Rapid Response Network to report ICE activity and enforcement actions Here is the contact information Central Valley: 559-206-0151 Kern County: 661-432-2230 Los Angeles: 888-624-4752 Boyle Heights (L.A.): 323-805-1049 Orange County: 714-881-1558 San Bernardino/Riverside: 909-361-4588 CHIRLA: 213-353-1333 ORALE (Long Beach): 562-276-0267 Immigrant Defenders: 213-833-8283 Immigrant Rapid Response Hotline: 805-870-8855 (Santa Barbara, Ventura & San Luis Obispo) In the event of an emergency or if you witness a crime in progress, call 911 immediately. For non-emergencies, tips can be submitted anonymously through L.A. Crime Stoppers or through the city's Bureau of Street Services. The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department also allows residents to file police reports online for certain non-violent crimes. To report graffiti in unincorporated areas of the county, residents can use the Public Works reporting system. Additional concerns, including other public nuisances or infrastructure issues, can be reported through the county's general services portal. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
