Documented cigarette industry: FBR tax collection may fall significantly
ISLAMABAD: The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) tax collection from documented cigarette industry is expected to fall significantly as compared to last year, contrary to recent optimistic projections, highlighting growing challenges in the sector amid rising smuggling and regulatory inefficiencies.
Industry sources dismissed NGOs' version that the government's revenue collection from the cigarette industry for fiscal year 2024-25 would reach PKR 285 billion.
However, industry insiders and financial analysts caution that this figure is not grounded in factual analysis.
Official sources indicate that the government is more likely to collect around PKR 250 billion, especially considering adjustments that will be made in June related to advance tax payments.
A major factor behind the revenue shortfall is the exorbitant imposition of Adjustable Federal Excise Duty (FED) on acetate tow, a key raw material used in cigarette manufacturing.
The industry had recommended an adjustable FED rate of PKR 4,000 per kg, which was intended to increase the cost of doing business for the illicit players and was supposed to be adjusted against the final tax liability improving documentation and reconciliation.
Contrary to this recommendation, the government imposed a FED rate of PKR 44,000 per kilogramme, an eleven fold increase. This sharp rise has inadvertently made smuggling far more lucrative and has led to a dramatic increase in illicit activity. To underscore the severity of the smuggling issue, law enforcement agency officials have already seized 447 metric tons of acetate tow in 2025 alone. This quantity is roughly equivalent to seven billion cigarettes representing a massive loss of revenue and a major threat to the sustainability of legitimate businesses.
Recently, the government issued an ordinance intended to empower provincial law enforcement agencies to conduct enforcement activities against the illicit cigarette sector. However, no official notification has been issued to implement this law, effectively delaying any meaningful action on the ground.
Observers say this slow response risks allowing illegal cigarette smuggling to flourish unchecked, further eroding the government's revenue base. The government seems to be slow peddling the issue, which is unfortunate given the significant fiscal and social implications.
As the fiscal year draws to a close, the government faces mounting pressure to address these regulatory and enforcement gaps to secure vital revenue and provide a level playing field for all players in the industry.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
13 hours ago
- Business Recorder
September Fed rate cut bets undermine dollar, handing Indian rupee a breather
MUMBAI: The Indian rupee is set to open slightly higher on Thursday, aided by a decline in the US dollar after weaker-than-expected private payrolls and services data spurred concerns over the US economic outlook and fuelled hopes of a dovish Federal Reserve stance. The 1-month non-deliverable forward indicated a open in the 85.82-85.84 range, versus 85.90 in the previous session. The Indian currency has logged daily losses in six of the past seven sessions, and on Wednesday it slipped past the 86 level. 'The rupee should find relief from its downtrend,' a currency trader at a Mumbai-based bank said. Whether that opening move has any follow through or holds is doubtful, he said. The 85.70–85.75 zone will now act a support for the dollar/rupee pair, while resistance is in the 86.00–86.10 region, he added. The current bias, he noted, favours a break past 86.00–86.10 rather than a sustained move dip below 85.70–85.75. The dollar dropped against its major peers on Wednesday and the currency was down versus Asian currencies on Thursday after two disappointing sets of data raised the odds of the Fed cutting rates at the September meeting. The probability of Fed rate reduction this month remains low. Indian rupee falters as bullish exits, dollar strength collide The private survey showed the increase in US private payrolls was well short of estimates. The Institute for Supply Management (ISM) report on the US services sector unexpectedly showed a contraction. The ISM's measure of prices paid for services inputs rose to 68.7, the highest level since November 2022, from 65.1 in April. Concerns around the US economic outlook mounted after the data, pushing US yields and the dollar lower, Morgan Stanley said in its daily commentary. Private payroll has been slowing since the fourth quarter of 2024, signalling softening in the labour market and the ISM services data signals stagflation concerns, it added.
Business Recorder
13 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Pakistan debt stock reaches all-time high of Rs75trn
KARACHI: The federal government's total debt stock surged by over Rs 6 trillion during the first ten months of this fiscal year (FY25) due to massive borrowing to finance the budget deficit. According to a statistic released by the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) on Wednesday, the central government's total debt, comprising domestic and external liabilities, rose by 9 percent during July-April of FY25. Overall, the stock reached an all-time high level of Rs 74.936 trillion by the end of April 2025 compared to Rs 68.914 trillion as of June 2024, depicting an increase of Rs 6.022 trillion. The major growth in debt stocks was attributed to domestic borrowings, which rose by 11.37 percent or Rs 5.363 trillion to reach Rs 52.523 trillion in April 2025 up from Rs 47.16 trillion in June 2024. The domestic debt comprised long-term loans worth Rs 44.132 trillion and short-term borrowings amounting to Rs 8.328 trillion. Pakistan govt's debt stock soars to Rs73.6trn by March-end External debt, in rupee terms, saw an increase of Rs 659 billion during the first ten months of FY25, reaching Rs 22.413 trillion by the end of April 2025 compared to Rs 21.754 trillion in June 2024. The SBP reported that the Weighted Average Customer Exchange Rate of the US dollar was Rs 278.3668 in June 2024 and Rs 280.9739 in April 2025. The federal government's debt showed a notable increase of Rs 1.248 trillion in April 2025 due to massive borrowing to finance the budget deficit. On a month-on-month (MoM) basis, the federal government's debt stock rose by 2 percent from Rs 73.688 trillion in March 2025 to Rs 74.936 trillion in April 2025. Analysts noted that the tax collection by the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) is 26 percent higher during the first eleven (July-May) months of this fiscal year compared to previous year; however, cumulatively FBR has failed to achieve the target. The shortfall in revenue collection has compelled the federal government to borrow from domestic and external resources. FBR had missed its revenue collection target by some one trillion rupees in the first eleven months of this fiscal year due to lower imports and slowing economic growth. The FBR has collected some Rs10.233 trillion between July-May of FY25 as against the budgetary target of Rs11.241 trillion for the same period. The SBP has already emphasised the need for a sharp acceleration in tax revenue growth to meet the annual targets. Achieving the primary balance target remains a significant challenge for the government. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
17 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Agri sector witnesses dramatic slowdown: PKIC
ISLAMABAD: The country's agriculture sector has witnessed a dramatic slowdown, with growth dropping to 0.56 percent from 6.25 percent since July 2024, Pakistan Kissan Ittehad Council (PKIC) President Khalid Mehmood Khokhar said on Wednesday. Addressing at a press conference, he said that the decline in major crop yields has severely impacted both the economy and the livelihoods of farmers. He said that cotton production has dropped to 5.55 million bales — 50 percent below the government's target and 34 percent less than last year. Cotton import bill is projected to surge to $1.9 billion, up from $448 million the previous year, he said. Khokar said that the country's wheat production has also suffered, declining by 8.91 percent to 28.98 million tons from last year's 31.81 million tons. Maize production fell by 15.4 percent to 8.24 million tons, compared to 9.74 million tons in the previous year, he said. Khokhar stated that since May 2024, farmers have collectively suffered losses of around Rs2,200 billion in wheat alone — equivalent to 23.15 percent of the crop sector's contribution to GDP for the fiscal year 2023–24. The resulting financial strain has weakened farmers' purchasing power and affected the productivity of other crops as well, he said. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
