‘Reeks of desperation': Former Eagles' shot at Fyfe, Dockers
Former West Coast defender Alex Withderden has taken a bizarre swipe at his former arch-rivals Fremantle, saying the Dockers' selection of Nat Fyfe 'reeks of desperation'.
The Dockers parachuted the dual Brownlow medallist into their team to take on Gold Coast at People First Stadium on Saturday despite not playing at all this season.
Fyfe has not suited up since he injured his hamstring while playing for Peel Thunder in round two and the former skipper's last AFL game was all the way back in round 24 of last year.
The 33-year-old joins ruckman Sean Darcy and defender Josh Draper in coming into the team for injured captain Alex Pearce, hard-running defender Cooper Simpson (shoulder) and small forward Isaiah Dudley — who will miss for personal reasons.
Darcy returns despite Luke Jackson starring in the No.1 ruck role with the decision to bring him back also causing plenty of consternation among AFL fans.
Witherden — who was delisted by the Eagles last year after 62 games in four seasons having crossed from Brisbane — said he was shocked at the selection of Fyfe and Darcy.
'I nearly fell off my chair when I saw it last night,' Witherden told SEN.
'I was really surprised. I feel like the last fortnight they've played some of their better footy in recent years, they've really started to get going, they've got a bit more speed on the ball which has given their forwards really good looks.
'I'm just not sure why you would mess with the mix that you've got at the moment, there was just no need to, but we do know that Darcy and Fyfe at their best can be really big assets for the Fremantle footy club going forward.
'The other key thing about this which shocks me is Perth to Gold Coast is the longest travel in AFL footy … for guys with injury history it just doesn't seem to make sense either.'
Witherden then stunned when he took a bit swipe at the Dockers' decision for picking Fyfe ahead of a crucial clash against the Suns which they're not expected to win. Former West Coast defender Alex Witherden has taken a strange swipe at the Dockers. Credit: Will Russell/AFL Photos / AFL Photos via Getty Images
'It reeks of desperation or a Hail Mary or whatever it might be,' he said.
'It doesn't quite pass the sniff test for me, I would've liked to see them both come back through the WAFL.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
22 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Kane Cornes steps away mid-season amid controversies
Divisive footy commentator Kane Cornes has taken a step back from his overloaded schedule in the wake of several controversies. Cornes was nowhere to be seen on Sunday night for his usual commitments with Channel 7 and the AFL. FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer. He was also replaced by Sam Edmund who took over the hosting duties for Cornes' SEN radio slot on Monday morning. CODE Sports first reported the news of Cornes' mid-season break which comes after the 42-year-old found himself in the spotlight for all the wrong reasons. In April, the Channel 7 protagonist was black-listed by North Melbourne in an extraordinary move. The move came after North Melbourne accused Cornes of 'bullying behaviour' and 'vindictive attacks' on the club and its players. Two weeks ago he was back in the spotlight after he was involved in a fiery confrontation with Western Bulldogs coach Luke Beveridge. Despite not appearing on his regular programming, Channel 7 have said the time away is nothing out of the ordinary for their talent and he'll be back behind the microphone for Round 13. 'All of our talent take time off throughout the AFL season. Just like the players have a bye round, we make sure our team gets a break too,' O'Keeffe said 'This is Kane's scheduled leave, and he'll be back on deck for Thursday Night Footy this week. 'Dale Thomas will step into the Agenda Setters chair tonight, alongside Caroline Wilson, Craig Hutchison and Nick Riewoldt. Tomorrow night, Hawthorn coach Sam Mitchell joins the panel alongside Luke Hodge, Craig Hutchison and Caroline Wilson.' Cornes made the blockbuster switch to join Channel 7 after years behind the microphone at Channel 9. 'It was an opportunity that I was thrilled to have a listen to. It was too good to pass up,' Cornes said on SEN after the move was announced in August last year. 'It's been weighing on me a little bit with Channel 9 because they've been so amazing and it's such a great place to work. 'I get along with everyone so well there and I think the shows we do there are excellent. 'To tell everyone as I did (on Monday) was a weight off the chest and I'll move on to a place that I'm really excited to join.'
West Australian
23 minutes ago
- West Australian
GEORGIE PARKER: AFLW should mimic NRLW State of Origin with a Australia-Ireland game in season build-up
In the new frontier of women's professional sports, the AFL still has a lot to learn from the NRL — and its AFLW fixture for the upcoming season isn't getting it any closer to being the head of the class The NRL and AFL are like Melbourne and Sydney — two cities always bickering to everyone and anyone who will listen about who is better, even though both are major players in their own right. The AFL can truly claim to be a national sport and boasts much better crowd numbers, but the NRL holds its own with broadcast figures, especially in its women's competition. The NRLW State of Origin series has drawn a lot of eyeballs, with nearly two million people watching NSW claim the series over Queensland two weeks ago. Then, last week, two million people watched the dead rubber match — something the AFLW could only dream of. The AFLW's biggest match of the year last season, the grand final, attracted 354,000 viewers. The NRLW Grand Final, played as a curtain-raiser to the men's decider, drew nearly 700,000 viewers. The NRLW has a few advantages over the AFLW. The game itself, while tough, is simpler at its core, so the contrast between the men's and women's playing styles isn't as stark. The season is shorter, with the NRL holding back on rapid expansion, which has created more depth across the 12 teams. And the biggest point of difference? State of Origin — a marquee event that highlights star players and gives fans a reason to tune in during the regular season. The AFL, however, has not nailed it with the most recent AFLW fixture update when it comes to combating the sleeping giant that is the NRLW. While it's an improvement on last season's debacle, there are still plenty of holes. Firstly, why aren't there any double-header matches during the crossover with the AFL finals? This is a prime opportunity to attract a different audience during a period when there's less men's footy being played. The NRL has already shown how well this strategy works. Secondly, why are there no matches at Marvel Stadium? Given the nature of women's footy, matches are more affected by rain — and even more so by wind — than the men's game. Using a venue like Marvel, which is shielded from the elements, seems like a no-brainer to improve the standard of play and attract fans who are still on the fence. We all know Marvel is owned and managed by the AFL, so scheduling AFLW double-headers there to create a better TV product (which is where the money is) should be in their best interest. And finally, can we replicate something like the NRLW State of Origin during the men's season to generate interest in the AFLW? Perhaps an Australia-Ireland series, similar to the old International Rules format, given the sheer number of elite Irish players in the league. Whatever the solution, something needs to change. For the amount of money being invested in the AFLW, the return on investment isn't stacking up. And I think the frustration around that investment will only grow if more innovation isn't shown.
The Advertiser
an hour ago
- The Advertiser
Port star considers more heart surgery at season's end
Port Adelaide's Brownlow medallist Ollie Wines is considering more heart surgery at the end of the AFL season. Wines suffers from a heart irregularity which sometimes causes palpitations, leading him to be substituted out of three games in the past four seasons. The 30-year-old admits frustration at the condition arising most recently - and forcing his substitution - from Port's away win against Sydney on April 20. That episode followed heart surgery last December in a bid to correct the issue. "I had a procedure back in December and there was one per cent likeliness that it wouldn't work," Wines told reporters on Monday. "And unfortunately, I'm in the one per cent that it hasn't worked. "So we've gone back to a bit of an intervention plan that we had the previous two years to manage it up to that operation and that is working well so far. "We will reassess at the end of the season to see if we do it again and try a surgical operation." But Wines remained pragmatic about his heart issue. "It was frustrating (to be subbed out against Sydney)," he said. "But, look, at the end of the day, luckily for me it's not life threatening. "And it's something that cost me a game of footy, enough to get subbed out of a game of footy. "So I'm in a really fortunate position. I've got the best cardiologists and doctors around me at the footy club and they've talked me through everything. "So at the moment, it's just this plan that has previously worked. "I've never had an episode when we're using this intervention and once the season ends, we'll assess if I need a procedure again." Wines and his teammates have returned to training after a mid-season bye which came with the Power languishing in 15th spot with four wins and seven losses ahead of meeting GWS in Canberra on Saturday night. Some pundits have blamed Port's fall on the coaching succession plan - head coach Ken Hinkley will step down at season's end and be replaced by long-time assistant Josh Carr. But Wines said from the February announcement of the handover "nothing has changed". "Ken's our coach, he will be for the rest of the year," he said. "And I know he's got a lot of energy and enthusiasm for the job and we'll be there for him.. "Despite not winning a premiership, I think we've always been up there and we've played a lot of finals. "Ken's done a lot for me personally as a footballer and off the field so I'm always going to play for him." Port Adelaide's Brownlow medallist Ollie Wines is considering more heart surgery at the end of the AFL season. Wines suffers from a heart irregularity which sometimes causes palpitations, leading him to be substituted out of three games in the past four seasons. The 30-year-old admits frustration at the condition arising most recently - and forcing his substitution - from Port's away win against Sydney on April 20. That episode followed heart surgery last December in a bid to correct the issue. "I had a procedure back in December and there was one per cent likeliness that it wouldn't work," Wines told reporters on Monday. "And unfortunately, I'm in the one per cent that it hasn't worked. "So we've gone back to a bit of an intervention plan that we had the previous two years to manage it up to that operation and that is working well so far. "We will reassess at the end of the season to see if we do it again and try a surgical operation." But Wines remained pragmatic about his heart issue. "It was frustrating (to be subbed out against Sydney)," he said. "But, look, at the end of the day, luckily for me it's not life threatening. "And it's something that cost me a game of footy, enough to get subbed out of a game of footy. "So I'm in a really fortunate position. I've got the best cardiologists and doctors around me at the footy club and they've talked me through everything. "So at the moment, it's just this plan that has previously worked. "I've never had an episode when we're using this intervention and once the season ends, we'll assess if I need a procedure again." Wines and his teammates have returned to training after a mid-season bye which came with the Power languishing in 15th spot with four wins and seven losses ahead of meeting GWS in Canberra on Saturday night. Some pundits have blamed Port's fall on the coaching succession plan - head coach Ken Hinkley will step down at season's end and be replaced by long-time assistant Josh Carr. But Wines said from the February announcement of the handover "nothing has changed". "Ken's our coach, he will be for the rest of the year," he said. "And I know he's got a lot of energy and enthusiasm for the job and we'll be there for him.. "Despite not winning a premiership, I think we've always been up there and we've played a lot of finals. "Ken's done a lot for me personally as a footballer and off the field so I'm always going to play for him." Port Adelaide's Brownlow medallist Ollie Wines is considering more heart surgery at the end of the AFL season. Wines suffers from a heart irregularity which sometimes causes palpitations, leading him to be substituted out of three games in the past four seasons. The 30-year-old admits frustration at the condition arising most recently - and forcing his substitution - from Port's away win against Sydney on April 20. That episode followed heart surgery last December in a bid to correct the issue. "I had a procedure back in December and there was one per cent likeliness that it wouldn't work," Wines told reporters on Monday. "And unfortunately, I'm in the one per cent that it hasn't worked. "So we've gone back to a bit of an intervention plan that we had the previous two years to manage it up to that operation and that is working well so far. "We will reassess at the end of the season to see if we do it again and try a surgical operation." But Wines remained pragmatic about his heart issue. "It was frustrating (to be subbed out against Sydney)," he said. "But, look, at the end of the day, luckily for me it's not life threatening. "And it's something that cost me a game of footy, enough to get subbed out of a game of footy. "So I'm in a really fortunate position. I've got the best cardiologists and doctors around me at the footy club and they've talked me through everything. "So at the moment, it's just this plan that has previously worked. "I've never had an episode when we're using this intervention and once the season ends, we'll assess if I need a procedure again." Wines and his teammates have returned to training after a mid-season bye which came with the Power languishing in 15th spot with four wins and seven losses ahead of meeting GWS in Canberra on Saturday night. Some pundits have blamed Port's fall on the coaching succession plan - head coach Ken Hinkley will step down at season's end and be replaced by long-time assistant Josh Carr. But Wines said from the February announcement of the handover "nothing has changed". "Ken's our coach, he will be for the rest of the year," he said. "And I know he's got a lot of energy and enthusiasm for the job and we'll be there for him.. "Despite not winning a premiership, I think we've always been up there and we've played a lot of finals. "Ken's done a lot for me personally as a footballer and off the field so I'm always going to play for him."
