The difference between ‘hate speech' and ‘freedom of speech'
Recent trade negotiations between the US and the UK require the government to make a tough decision. At a time when the British economy is in crisis – and its citizens in dire need of a boost – will Sir Keir Starmer choose to put economic value over and above the protection of British values such as truth, tolerance and diversity?
As reported by The Independent, sources close to vice president JD Vance have indicated that the British government will have to repeal its hate speech laws and protections for LGBT+ people in order to get a trade deal over the line – in the name of the Trump administration's quest for 'freedom of speech'.
To my mind, this begs the bigger question of whether we are now in a position of accepting 'hate speech' as 'freedom of speech' – and whether this is really the only path to economic sustainability.
I hold big tech's greed and exploitation of people accountable. We are not really living under the laws of our countries, but the directly imposed laws and control of big tech – who control the daily lives of more than 2bn people. They – deliberately or not – have conveniently disguised the perpetuation of the former in the name of the latter.
Why? Because they know that when people are angry, they stay on their platforms longer – and this enables them to serve more ads in people's feeds. They can make more money, no matter the cost to our relationships and mental health. It's that simple. 'We the people' have become the largest unpaid workforce in human history – and we've sacrificed some of our humanity and freedom in the process.
Freedom of speech and hate speech are not the same things. One is the right to express opinions and ideas freely, without censorship or fear, as long as it doesn't violate the law. The other is abusive or threatening language that expresses prejudice directed at another person. Tech platforms may have brainwashed us by telling us all that hate speech is free speech, but it doesn't have to be this way. Sadly, the online safety act is a toothless tiger in the face of big social media control – and I believe the answer is not pointlessly lobbying social platforms to change, but giving people an alternative that supports them.
Eradicating hate speech on social media can be done at scale. I know, because at WeAre8 we have built the social platform and the AI engine that does just this. We have spent the last four years building and training AI models to detect and block directed hate while amplifying freedom of speech. And one of our most fascinating discoveries was that blocking directed hate actually amplifies freedom of expression, fuels conversation between people – and creates a safe environment for people to express themselves, ask questions and have challenging conversations without the fear of being abused or 'cancelled.'
People are tired of being judged, of not being heard – and above all, of fighting. We've forgotten how we should be treating each other – and have mistakenly replaced curiosity and learning with fear and judgment. Somewhere along the way, we surrendered our freedom and values to those who have the ability to control, amplify or silence our voices online – and now we see governments following their lead and calling for the removal of citizen protections in trade agreements.
We are weak when we are divided and disconnected. The big question for us now is: Do we choose a better way for ourselves, our families and our communities – or surrender to the laws and economic control of big tech?
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
North Wales Chronicle
14 minutes ago
- North Wales Chronicle
UK ‘utterly condemns' escalation after Iran attacks US military base
Iran announced on state television that it had attacked forces stationed at Qatar's Al Udeid Air Base, in retaliation to America's strikes on its nuclear programme. Armed forces minister Luke Pollard said the UK was monitoring the 'fast-changing situation' closely and that 'the UK Government utterly condemns any escalation'. 'Force protection now is at its highest state across all deployed units in the Middle East,' he told the Commons. 'The additional RAF Typhoon jets announced by the Prime Minister have now arrived in the region to reinforce our posture, deter threats and reassure our partners, and I want to be clear, we will not rule out sending further capabilities if they are required,' he said. The Foreign Office had advised British nationals in Qatar to 'shelter in place' after a US security alert. Qatar, which had earlier shut its air space temporarily, said it successfully intercepted the missiles and no casualties were reported. A base in Iraq housing US troops was also targeted, but Iran did not claim credit for that attack. Foreign Secretary David Lammy had urged Iran to 'take the off ramp' and return to the negotiating table with the US. His plea came after an air raid by American B-2 stealth bombers and a salvo of submarine-launched missiles hit Iran's nuclear facilities on Saturday night. Meanwhile, the UK has started evacuating Britons from Israel, with the first group of 63 flown back via Cyprus and due to return to the UK on Monday. The Foreign Secretary said an RAF A400 had taken the group of British nationals and that more flights will follow. He also confirmed that one British national in Israel had been injured during Iranian missile attacks and had been offered consular support. Downing Street said 'around 1,000' people had requested a seat on an evacuation flight – a quarter of the 4,000 who had registered their presence in Israel or Palestine with the Foreign Office. The Government has withdrawn staff from its embassy in Iran and is operating 'remotely', Mr Lammy told MPs. Mr Lammy previously spoke of a two-week window for a diplomatic solution after President Donald Trump's apparent decision last week to delay US military action. On Monday, he said the window had 'narrowed' but told MPs the need for a diplomatic solution remained. 'My message for Tehran was clear, take the off ramp, dial this thing down, and negotiate with the United States seriously and immediately. 'The alternative is an even more destructive and far-reaching conflict, which could have unpredictable consequences,' he said. He also faced questions on the legality of the US strikes, but said it 'must rightly be a matter for the US government in relation to their action' and added: 'This was not our action. We have been clear that we were not involved.' Earlier, Downing Street had said that preventing Tehran from obtaining a nuclear bomb was a 'good thing' for the UK, but declined to comment on whether the US strikes complied with international law. Meanwhile, Israeli jets hit targets in Tehran on Monday including the security headquarters of the Revolutionary Guard Corps and Evin Prison, the regime's main site for detaining political prisoners and human rights activists. In turn, Iran carried out its own strikes against cities in Israel, and sparked fears of a wider regional conflict as it accused the US of crossing 'a very big red line'. Meanwhile, oil prices reached their highest level for nearly six months over fears a regional conflict could restrict supply, especially if Iran decided to blockade the Strait of Hormuz. The jump in prices prompted Mr Trump to post on his Truth Social platform: 'EVERYONE, KEEP OIL PRICES DOWN. I'M WATCHING! YOU'RE PLAYING RIGHT INTO THE HANDS OF THE ENEMY. DON'T DO IT!' Mr Lammy told MPs the Government was 'closely monitoring' the energy markets and urged Iran to keep the Strait of Hormuz open, saying a blockade would be 'a monumental act of economic self-harm' and make reaching a diplomatic solution even harder.
South Wales Argus
14 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
UK ‘utterly condemns' escalation after Iran attacks US military base
Iran announced on state television that it had attacked forces stationed at Qatar's Al Udeid Air Base, in retaliation to America's strikes on its nuclear programme. Armed forces minister Luke Pollard said the UK was monitoring the 'fast-changing situation' closely and that 'the UK Government utterly condemns any escalation'. 'Force protection now is at its highest state across all deployed units in the Middle East,' he told the Commons. 'The additional RAF Typhoon jets announced by the Prime Minister have now arrived in the region to reinforce our posture, deter threats and reassure our partners, and I want to be clear, we will not rule out sending further capabilities if they are required,' he said. Armed forces minister Luke Pollard said the UK was monitoring the 'fast-changing situation' (PA) The Foreign Office had advised British nationals in Qatar to 'shelter in place' after a US security alert. Qatar, which had earlier shut its air space temporarily, said it successfully intercepted the missiles and no casualties were reported. A base in Iraq housing US troops was also targeted, but Iran did not claim credit for that attack. Foreign Secretary David Lammy had urged Iran to 'take the off ramp' and return to the negotiating table with the US. His plea came after an air raid by American B-2 stealth bombers and a salvo of submarine-launched missiles hit Iran's nuclear facilities on Saturday night. Meanwhile, the UK has started evacuating Britons from Israel, with the first group of 63 flown back via Cyprus and due to return to the UK on Monday. The Foreign Secretary said an RAF A400 had taken the group of British nationals and that more flights will follow. He also confirmed that one British national in Israel had been injured during Iranian missile attacks and had been offered consular support. Downing Street said 'around 1,000' people had requested a seat on an evacuation flight – a quarter of the 4,000 who had registered their presence in Israel or Palestine with the Foreign Office. The Government has withdrawn staff from its embassy in Iran and is operating 'remotely', Mr Lammy told MPs. Mr Lammy previously spoke of a two-week window for a diplomatic solution after President Donald Trump's apparent decision last week to delay US military action. On Monday, he said the window had 'narrowed' but told MPs the need for a diplomatic solution remained. 'My message for Tehran was clear, take the off ramp, dial this thing down, and negotiate with the United States seriously and immediately. 'The alternative is an even more destructive and far-reaching conflict, which could have unpredictable consequences,' he said. He also faced questions on the legality of the US strikes, but said it 'must rightly be a matter for the US government in relation to their action' and added: 'This was not our action. We have been clear that we were not involved.' David Lammy urged Iran to 'take the off ramp' Earlier, Downing Street had said that preventing Tehran from obtaining a nuclear bomb was a 'good thing' for the UK, but declined to comment on whether the US strikes complied with international law. Meanwhile, Israeli jets hit targets in Tehran on Monday including the security headquarters of the Revolutionary Guard Corps and Evin Prison, the regime's main site for detaining political prisoners and human rights activists. In turn, Iran carried out its own strikes against cities in Israel, and sparked fears of a wider regional conflict as it accused the US of crossing 'a very big red line'. Meanwhile, oil prices reached their highest level for nearly six months over fears a regional conflict could restrict supply, especially if Iran decided to blockade the Strait of Hormuz. The jump in prices prompted Mr Trump to post on his Truth Social platform: 'EVERYONE, KEEP OIL PRICES DOWN. I'M WATCHING! YOU'RE PLAYING RIGHT INTO THE HANDS OF THE ENEMY. DON'T DO IT!' Mr Lammy told MPs the Government was 'closely monitoring' the energy markets and urged Iran to keep the Strait of Hormuz open, saying a blockade would be 'a monumental act of economic self-harm' and make reaching a diplomatic solution even harder.
Glasgow Times
16 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
UK ‘utterly condemns' escalation after Iran attacks US military base
Iran announced on state television that it had attacked forces stationed at Qatar's Al Udeid Air Base, in retaliation to America's strikes on its nuclear programme. Armed forces minister Luke Pollard said the UK was monitoring the 'fast-changing situation' closely and that 'the UK Government utterly condemns any escalation'. 'Force protection now is at its highest state across all deployed units in the Middle East,' he told the Commons. 'The additional RAF Typhoon jets announced by the Prime Minister have now arrived in the region to reinforce our posture, deter threats and reassure our partners, and I want to be clear, we will not rule out sending further capabilities if they are required,' he said. Armed forces minister Luke Pollard said the UK was monitoring the 'fast-changing situation' (PA) The Foreign Office had advised British nationals in Qatar to 'shelter in place' after a US security alert. Qatar, which had earlier shut its air space temporarily, said it successfully intercepted the missiles and no casualties were reported. A base in Iraq housing US troops was also targeted, but Iran did not claim credit for that attack. Foreign Secretary David Lammy had urged Iran to 'take the off ramp' and return to the negotiating table with the US. His plea came after an air raid by American B-2 stealth bombers and a salvo of submarine-launched missiles hit Iran's nuclear facilities on Saturday night. Meanwhile, the UK has started evacuating Britons from Israel, with the first group of 63 flown back via Cyprus and due to return to the UK on Monday. The Foreign Secretary said an RAF A400 had taken the group of British nationals and that more flights will follow. He also confirmed that one British national in Israel had been injured during Iranian missile attacks and had been offered consular support. Downing Street said 'around 1,000' people had requested a seat on an evacuation flight – a quarter of the 4,000 who had registered their presence in Israel or Palestine with the Foreign Office. The Government has withdrawn staff from its embassy in Iran and is operating 'remotely', Mr Lammy told MPs. Mr Lammy previously spoke of a two-week window for a diplomatic solution after President Donald Trump's apparent decision last week to delay US military action. On Monday, he said the window had 'narrowed' but told MPs the need for a diplomatic solution remained. 'My message for Tehran was clear, take the off ramp, dial this thing down, and negotiate with the United States seriously and immediately. 'The alternative is an even more destructive and far-reaching conflict, which could have unpredictable consequences,' he said. He also faced questions on the legality of the US strikes, but said it 'must rightly be a matter for the US government in relation to their action' and added: 'This was not our action. We have been clear that we were not involved.' David Lammy urged Iran to 'take the off ramp' Earlier, Downing Street had said that preventing Tehran from obtaining a nuclear bomb was a 'good thing' for the UK, but declined to comment on whether the US strikes complied with international law. Meanwhile, Israeli jets hit targets in Tehran on Monday including the security headquarters of the Revolutionary Guard Corps and Evin Prison, the regime's main site for detaining political prisoners and human rights activists. In turn, Iran carried out its own strikes against cities in Israel, and sparked fears of a wider regional conflict as it accused the US of crossing 'a very big red line'. Meanwhile, oil prices reached their highest level for nearly six months over fears a regional conflict could restrict supply, especially if Iran decided to blockade the Strait of Hormuz. The jump in prices prompted Mr Trump to post on his Truth Social platform: 'EVERYONE, KEEP OIL PRICES DOWN. I'M WATCHING! YOU'RE PLAYING RIGHT INTO THE HANDS OF THE ENEMY. DON'T DO IT!' Mr Lammy told MPs the Government was 'closely monitoring' the energy markets and urged Iran to keep the Strait of Hormuz open, saying a blockade would be 'a monumental act of economic self-harm' and make reaching a diplomatic solution even harder.
