Birkenstock sandals are not art, top German court rules
The German sandal maker had sought a ruling that its footwear, known for its cork and latex soles, could be classified as art and thus afforded strong copyright protections.
The company, whose sandals have over the years transformed from unglamourous footwear to coveted fashion items, wanted to stop three of its competitors from selling similar products.
It had wanted the products of the trio - German retailers Tchibo and shoe.com, as well as the Danish retailer Bestseller - to be pulled from the shelves and destroyed.
But the Federal Court of Justice in Karlsruhe sided with the judgement of a lower court, ruling that Birkenstock's sandals could not be considered "copyrighted works of applied art".
"For copyright protection to apply, there must be such a degree of design that the product displays some individuality," the court said.
"Pure craftsmanship using formal design elements" was not enough, said the court, bringing a close to a legal saga that began in May 2023.
Despite the ruling, Birkenstock defended bringing the case.
"We want to ensure that copycats can no longer make money at the expense of our brand," said company spokesman Jochen Gutzy.
Founded in 1774 in a small community in southwest Germany as a firm focused on making orthopaedic footwear, Birkenstock has grown into a global footwear titan.
Its sandals are popular among VIPs, with singers Katy Perry and Britney Spears donning the footwear in recent years.
They also appeared in the hit 2023 movie "Barbie" when actress Margot Robbie swapped high heels for a pink pair.
In 2021 the Birkenstock family sold its majority stake in the group to LVMH-linked equity firm L Catterton and French billionaire Bernard Arnault's family holding fund Financiere Agache.
It launched an international public offering on the New York Stock Exchange in 2023.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Local Germany
3 hours ago
- Local Germany
Five hard truths about starting out as a freelancer in Germany
You've given away any clothes that aren't in shades of black, practiced pounding schnitzels paper-thin and are religiously avoiding anything spicier than black pepper. In short, you're ready for your new life as a freelancer in Germany. Working as a freelancer in Germany isn't all rosy. Complications lurk around every corner, from tricky visas to an endlessly complex tax system. Here are five things you need to know about being a freelancer in Germany. Obtaining a freelance visa can be tough EU citizens do not need a visa to live and work in Germany. Non-EU citizens wishing to freelance in Germany can apply for the Aufenthaltserlaubnis zur freiberuflichen Tätigkeit , or freelance visa. Citizens of a few countries can enter Germany visa-free and apply for the visa within the country. The rest will need to apply at a German consulate in their home country. But getting a freelance visa can be tricky. To be approved, you'll need to prove that you meet certain requirements, including that: Your work will benefit the local economy – in practice, that you have German clients or employees. You earn enough to support yourself – in Berlin, that means your rent + health insurance + €563 Your qualifications are recognised if you work in a regulated profession like law or healthcare You have a pension plan if you are over 45 The relatively stringent requirements are a barrier to many seeking to freelance in Germany. You must also ensure that you continue to meet the requirements when it comes time to renew your visa. READ ALSO: What not to do when you are freelancing in Germany Taxes are no joke Do you know your Freiberufler from your Gewerbe ? Are you ready to calculate your Einkommensteuer-Vorauszahlungen ? Advertisement German bureaucracy is famously fiendish. But it can be especially so for freelancers. Many aspects of the tax system are set up with the assumption that workers are full-time employees. Being a freelancer means negotiating additional layers of bureaucracy, including guessing how much you are likely to earn in the first and second years of work (to determine whether you have to charge your clients VAT or not) and submitting pre-payments every quarter based on how much you think you will earn. READ ALSO: Everything you need to know about paying taxes in Germany You'll also need to determine whether you are a Freiberufler (freelancer) or Gewerbe (self-employed), as the two have different tax implications. Then there's the matter of filing your taxes correctly, including deductions and expenses. The process can be so complicated for freelancers, especially if they work with clients abroad, that many simply hire a tax adviser to do it on their behalf. Be aware that finding a Steuerberater is a mission in itself – many are overbooked and even if you do find one, they do not come cheap. A good rule of thumb is to assume that 50 percent of your net income isn't yours. Set it aside and don't touch it until you've paid off all the taxes you owe. Advertisement Housing can be a nightmare for freelancers The housing market in many German cities is increasingly dysfunctional. In Berlin, Munich and other cities popular with expats, many locals and foreigners find it nigh-on impossible to secure a proper contract at a decent price. Some (your correspondent very much included) bounce between sublets for months or years until they find a permanent home. READ ALSO: 'Always be vigilant' - Expert tips for finding an apartment in Berlin Unfortunately, this problem can be exacerbated by being a freelancer. Many landlords favour applicants with a stable income and look down on people not in full-time employment. Be prepared to spend months living in a WG (shared flat) while you hunt for your own apartment. Heath insurance is pricey Freelancers in Germany pay 100 percent of their health insurance contribution, whereas most employers pay half. In addition, the cost scales differently from taxes. In practice, this means that many freelancers, especially those on low incomes, spend a large proportion of their income on health insurance, regardless of whether they are on private or public health insurance. Options such as low-cost 'expat insurance' are much cheaper but offer only limited coverage. Some creatives can apply to join the Künstlersozialkasse (Artists' Social Insurance Fund) , which pays half of the cost – though applications typically take months to be approved. Advertisement This system can come as quite a shock to people from countries with universal healthcare, where most of the costs are borne out of general taxation. And there's no chance to opt out of the system – being insured is a legal responsibility. Local clients often require German English speakers can get by fairly easily in daily life in Germany, especially in big cities. But it's another story entirely on the job market. Depending on your profession, you may find it tough to find local clients if you don't speak at least professional German. Of course, requirements vary by profession: many tech companies work in English, but more traditional fields like healthcare or engineering will often require a good grasp of the language. Having local clients can come in useful, especially for a visa application. For more on freelancing in Germany visit our dedicated section. But it's not all bad... Don't let the difficulties put you off. Freelancing in Germany comes with meaningful upsides. You'll have easy access to clients across the EU. Germany's big cities are creative business hubs where you can network with potential clients. And while bureaucracy can be painfully cumbersome, Germany offers extensive legal protections in the case of non-payment of contracts and for protection of your intellectual property. Share your own experiences of freelancing in Germany in the comments below. Are there any downsides or upsides I missed?
Local Germany
4 hours ago
- Local Germany
How you can challenge Germany's controversial property tax on your home
Following a major reform to Germany's property tax rules as of the beginning of this year, millions of land- and homeowners are challenging the amount of property tax they owe. Why were the property tax rules changed? Germany's old rules around property tax ( Grundsteuer ) had been ruled unconstitutional in 2018. The Federal Ministry of Finance explains on its website that is was because the old tax code treated similar properties differently (depending on the region) and therefore violated the principle of equal treatment, which is protected by Basic Law. The primary change to the rules that impacts homeowners is that the valuation of properties has been updated. Until the end of 2024 property valuations were based on decades old standard values – these were established in 1964 for properties in former West German states and as far back as 1935 in former East German states. Property valuations have now been reassessed, as of January 1st, 2022. Additionally, a law was added that allows cities to increase the assessment rate on undeveloped plots of land. This was intended to disincentivise speculation on land that might otherwise be developed. In simple terms, the rule reform has seen properties revalued, and for many homeowners in Germany it brought a significant increase in the property tax they owe going forward. REVEALED: Where buyers can find the most property for sale in Germany Widespread objections across Germany But many homeowners do not agree with the property tax increases, and some argue that the new assessments are unfair. Since new valuation assessments were sent out, millions of property owners have appealed. According to a report by Focus Online, 1.4 million objections were received by the tax offices in Baden-Württemberg – meaning that nearly 30 percent of homeowners in the southwestern state feel their assessment was incorrect or unjustified. Advertisement The situation is similar in other German states as well. SWR reported 1.5 million objections in North Rhine-Westphalia, 1.3 million in Bavaria and 440,000 in Rhineland-Palatinate. How you can contest the property tax Generally, to challenge your property tax obligations in Germany you need to contest the property tax assessment, which is sent in the mail by your local tax office. This needs to be done, in writing or with a visit to the tax office, and usually within one month from receipt of the assessment. After you've filed the objection, you have two months to submit a detailed justification, including any evidence you have to support your claim. If the objection is rejected, you can then file a lawsuit with the Fiscal Court within one month of receiving the rejection notice. Regarding the new property tax rules, the homeowners' association Haus & Grund has taken up the issue and is bringing a number of legal challenges against the new property tax. READ ALSO: What Germany's tax authorities need to know if you rent out your home In a post on the association's website it lists several reference numbers for ongoing cases, and suggests that owners can refer to the ongoing lawsuits and file their own objections. The cases, which were filed with courts in Berlin-Brandenburg, Rhineland-Palatinate, Cologne and Düsseldorf, argue that the new property tax rules violate the principle of equality of the Basic Law. Advertisement The cases will force German courts to clarify whether the new property tax rules are compatible with the law. They are expected to go all the way to the Federal Constitutional Court. It will likely be several years before the cases are decided, but if you want to seek compensation for paying excessive property tax from now on, you should file an objection now. If you do intend to bring a lawsuit forward, you'd be advised to seek legal counsel from a homeowners' association like Haus & Grund or similar or a lawyer. Note that this article is written for informational purposes only and should not be interpreted as legal advice.
DW
6 hours ago
- DW
German drone industry takes off – DW – 05/30/2025
Carmakers shift to drone production Germany, long known for its automotive prowess, is witnessing a quiet but significant transformation. As traditional car production slows, a new industry is taking flight—literally. Across southern Germany, start-ups and engineers are pivoting from cars to combat drones. One such innovation is the 'Falke,' a drone designed for both civilian and military use, capable of high speeds and long-range missions. Its creators emphasize affordability and mass production, leveraging materials and techniques from the automotive sector. This shift is not isolated. Near Munich, drone developers are collaborating with car part suppliers, repurposing their expertise and infrastructure to meet the growing demand for military-grade drones. Ukraine war has changed German mindset The war in Ukraine has accelerated this trend. Companies like High Cat are already supplying drones to the front lines, designed to resist jamming and deliver real-time reconnaissance. These aren't just tech experiments—they're the result of serious engineering, often funded by private investors who once shied away from defense ventures. Even packaging companies are adapting, creating climate-controlled transport cases for drones. The transformation is industrial and cultural: Engineers and entrepreneurs are learning to think like soldiers, designing for battlefield conditions. Automotive suppliers, facing declining orders, are finding new life in defense manufacturing, applying their precision and scale to drone production. Tapping into the €500 billion fund Germany's defense sector is poised for further growth, thanks to a €500 billion special fund aimed at strengthening national security. This fund opens doors for manufacturers across the country, especially those with existing capabilities in high-precision production. Companies that once hesitated to enter the arms industry are now reconsidering, driven by both financial incentives and a growing sense of responsibility to defend democratic values. With the right support and strategic partnerships, Germany's factories could become key players in Europe's defense landscape—transforming economic uncertainty into industrial opportunity. This video summary was created by AI from the original DW script. It was edited by a journalist before publication.
