Meta asks judge to rule that FTC failed to prove its monopoly case
FACEBOOK parent company Meta Platforms asked a federal judge on Thursday to throw out the US Federal Trade Commission's case accusing it of an illegal social media monopoly, saying the agency failed to prove its case at a high-stakes antitrust trial.
At the trial, which began on April 14 in Washington, the FTC has sought to show that Meta, then known as Facebook, illegally dominated the market for social media platforms used to share updates with friends and family through its acquisitions of Instagram and WhatsApp.
The FTC is seeking to unwind those deals, which occurred more than a decade ago.
If granted, Meta's request for a ruling on the evidence so far would bring a quicker end to the case, though US District Judge James Boasberg could decline to take it up. Meta is now presenting its own evidence at the trial, which may run into June.
A spokesperson for the FTC did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Thursday.
The FTC is seeking to show that Meta, then known as Facebook, bought Instagram and WhatsApp to take out upstart rivals, pointing to emails where CEO Mark Zuckerberg worried about the apps' growth.
BT in your inbox
Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox.
Sign Up
Sign Up
But evidence at trial showed that WhatsApp had no plan to expand to become a social network rival to Facebook, and that Zuckerberg knew that before the deal was finalised, Meta said on Thursday. And testimony showed Instagram grew after the acquisition, the company said.
Meta also argued FTC failed to show a meaningful difference between supposed friends-and-family sharing apps - such as SnapChat, Instagram and Facebook - and TikTok, which Meta said it has been forced to imitate to survive.
Platforms where users broadcast content to strangers based on shared interests, such as X, TikTok, YouTube and Reddit are not interchangeable, the FTC has said.
'The through line connecting all of these social apps is that each vies to show the most compelling user-generated content so that it can take as much user time and attention as possible from the other apps, including Meta's apps,' the company said.
If Boasberg does not grant Meta's request, the FTC and Meta are expected to file final briefs and deliver closing arguments after the company is finished presenting evidence.
If the judge then finds that Meta holds an illegal monopoly, the case would go to a second trial over the appropriate measures to address it. REUTERS
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
35 minutes ago
- CNA
Tech giants' indirect emissions rose 150% in three years as AI expands, UN agency says
GENEVA :Indirect carbon emissions from the operations of four of the leading AI-focused tech companies, Amazon, Microsoft, Alphabet and Meta, rose on average by 150 per cent from 2020-2023, as they had to use more power for energy-demanding data centres, a United Nations report said on Thursday. The use of artificial intelligence is driving up global indirect emissions because of the vast amounts of energy required to power data centres, the report by the International Telecommunication Union (ITU), the U.N. agency for digital technologies, said. Indirect emissions include those generated by purchased electricity, steam, heating and cooling consumed by a company. Amazon's operational carbon emissions grew the most at 182 per cent in 2023 compared to three years before, followed by Microsoft at 155 per cent, Meta at 145 per cent and Alphabet at 138 per cent, according to the report. The ITU tracked the greenhouse gas emissions of 200 leading digital companies between 2020 and 2023. Meta, which owns Facebook and WhatsApp, pointed Reuters to its sustainability report that said it is working to reduce emissions, energy and water used to power its data centres. The other companies did not respond immediately to requests for comment. As investment in AI increases, carbon emissions from the top-emitting AI systems are predicted to reach up to 102.6 million tons of carbon dioxide equivalent (tCO2) per year, the report stated. The data centres that are needed for AI development could also put pressure on existing energy infrastructure. "The rapid growth of artificial intelligence is driving a sharp rise in global electricity demand, with electricity use by data centres increasing four times faster than the overall rise in electricity consumption," the report found. It also highlighted that although a growing number of digital companies had set emissions targets, those ambitions had not yet fully translated into actual reductions of emissions.
AsiaOne
8 hours ago
- AsiaOne
Malaysian woman apologises to 11-year-old daughter for 'only' spending $300k on her birthday, Malaysia News
A Malaysian influencer has apologised to her daughter for 'only' spending RM1 million (S$303,000) on her 11th birthday, drawing criticism from netizens. In a video posted to Farhana Zahra's TikTok account on Monday (June 2), she documented the elaborate celebration and also apologised for the amount she'd spent for the special day. "This is all mum can afford. Mum only spent 1 million for this birthday," she wrote in the clip. At the start of the video, Farhana, who has over 1.8 million followers on the social media platform, is seen walking down the stairs holding two of her daughters as photographers snap photos and guests cheer. Midway through, she presents her daughter with gifts, which included a brand-new Apple desktop computer and a Rolex watch. Behind the family stands a large banner adorned with pink balloons. But the surprises didn't end there. Toward the end of the video, her daughter, Yaya, is gifted with a black Toyota multi-purpose vehicle, prompting a heartfelt hug between mother and daughter. @farhanazahra91 Selamat ulang tahun Yaya yang ke 11 tahun, besar da anak mama, semoga cita-cita untuk menjadi business women berjaya menjadi kenyataan 🥺 #farhanazahra91 #farhanazahra #cikna ♬ original sound - Farhana Zahra Former driver gifted a brand-new Mercedes In a separate video, Farhana, who's reportedly a beauty and lifestyle brand founder, surprised a special guest — her daughter's former driver — with a brand-new luxury car as part of the birthday celebrations. The red Mercedes-Benz was unveiled after being delivered to the car porch by a trailer truck, drawing the attention of party guests. Farhana then expressed her gratitude to the driver, who had worked for the family for two years, and gifted him the car. She also wished him success in his career as a technician and expressed hope that the gift would support his future journey. In the comments section of the post, several netizens have criticised the lavish spending, with some questioning the mother's parenting style. One commenter wrote, "Even 10 ringgit, if given sincerely from a mother's heart, is more meaningful than spending 1 million just to show off for content." Another said the gesture felt emotionally conflicting, adding: "I don't know if I should be happy or sad, but either way, this doesn't seem like the right way to raise a child." One commenter also chided: "I know you're a successful founder, but don't say 'only one million.' It might be a small amount to you, but to others, it's a lot." Both videos have since garnered over three million views and more than 196,000 likes combined. [[nid:687329]]
Straits Times
14 hours ago
- Straits Times
Bukchon emerges as a new shopping hot spot in South Korea for global tourists
The House of Sulwhasoo, located in the heart of Bukchon. PHOTO: THE HOUSE OF SULWHASOO BUKCHON/FACEBOOK Bukchon emerges as a new shopping hot spot in South Korea for global tourists SEOUL – Nestled between the historical grandeur of the main palace Gyeongbokgung and the winding alleys of traditional hanok, Bukchon is being transformed from a heritage enclave into one of Seoul's most dynamic shopping destinations, particularly for international travellers. Once known primarily for its well-preserved architecture and cultural significance, it is now a growing hub for fashion, beauty and fragrance brands. With an influx of flagship stores, limited-edition product launches and experiential spaces, the neighbourhood is drawing attention fro m domestic trendsetters and foreign visitors. The transformation began around fiv e y ears ago, with small, independent perfumers popping up around Bukchon. 'That became a unique characteristic of the area, which then attracted an increasing number of fragrance brands. Now, you can find many domestic scent-related brands here. And with Tamburins – the most popular among foreign visitors – opening a store here too, it really proves Bukchon's growing status,' said a staff member of a local perfumery. That growth is backed by hard data. According to Seoul's real-time statistics, monthly credit card spending in Bukchon Hanok Village rose from 1.9 billion won (S$1.78 million) in January to more than 2.57 billion won in April. Projections suggest spending may exceed three billion won by the end of May. Recognising its potential , global and local brands are establishing a presence in the neighbourhood. Tamburins, a K-beauty fragrance label known for its minimalist design and immersive retail experience, opened its Bukchon flagship store in 2023. Tourist Giselle Roberts from Britain said: 'I'm a huge fan of South Korean actor Jung Hae-in, and after watching K-drama Love Next Door (2024), I really wanted to visit this area. It feels so authentic with all the traditional Korean architecture. Since Tamburins is one of the must-have items in South Korea, visiting the store was a top priority for me.' Luxury skincare brand Sulwhasoo also launched its House of Sulwhasoo Bukchon in a renovated hanok-yangok hybrid space that blends traditional Korean and Western architectural styles in 2021. A look into the interior of The House of Sulwhasoo. PHOTO: THE HOUSE OF SULWHASOO BUKCHON/FACEBOOK 'Bukchon is a symbolic area where the past and present coexist beautifully,' a Sulwhasoo representative said. 'The concept of 'house' is both private and expressive of one's tastes, which allows for a deeper connection to the brand.' House of Sulwhasoo Bukchon offers guided tours in Korean, English and Chinese, with foreign visitors making up about 60 to 70 per cent of attendees. 'I'm an exchange student from Mexico, and my Korean friend arranged this guided tour for me,' said Dominique Rodriguez. 'I really enjoyed experiencing the products while learning about the brand's history. It felt more like being in an exhibition than a typical store.' Fashion has followed suit. In August 2024, Adidas opened the Adidas Bukchon Heritage Store – its first sneaker-focused location in Korea. The shop features hanok-inspired architecture, traditional motifs and exclusive product drops. Adidas Bukchon Heritage Store. PHOTO: ADIDAS KOREA 'The Adidas Bukchon Heritage Store is a special place where customers can experience the history and culture of South Korea, which is gaining worldwide attention, while enjoying shopping,' said Mr Peter Kwak, general manager of Adidas Korea. The store's standout release, the Samba Tal, reinterprets the Samba sneaker with design elements from traditional Korean mask dance. Adidas Korea reports that more than half of the customers at its Bukchon Heritage Store are international visitors, highlighting the location's growing global appeal. Other notable openings include K-beauty store Yless, artisan fragrance atelier Granhand and lifestyle brand Nonfiction. Global brands, such as fragrance house Le Labo, are preparing to enter the scene sometime in 2025. Industry insiders say Bukchon's unique blend of heritage and innovation gives it a distinct edge. Yless' flagship store in Bukchon. PHOTO: YLESS 'Unlike areas like Seongsu-dong or Hannam-dong, Bukchon leverages the appeal of 'Korean tradition', making it the perfect place for experiential space marketing,' said fashion editor Lee Han-gyu. 'From hanok-inspired interiors to cultural storytelling, these brands give tourists a reason to visit and come back.' THE KOREA HERALD/ASIA NEWS NETWORK Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
