New report a ‘wake-up call' for ministers over struggles faced by BME carers
The Scottish Government has been told 'the time for excuses is over' as a new study showed black and minority ethnic (BME) unpaid carers still face the same kind of difficulties they did almost two decades ago.
A new report said evidence gathered by the Minority Ethnic Carers of People Project (MECOPP) and others highlighted how BME carers 'continue to face disproportionate barriers to accessing support'.
Meanwhile, a survey included in the report revealed that two-thirds (67%) of unpaid BME carers said their caring role caused them financial difficulties, causing 52% to cut back spending on food and household utility bills.
The report said that Carer's Allowance and other benefits 'are often insufficient or difficult to access, adding stress'.
Meanwhile, 70% of 173 unpaid BME carers surveyed said they felt lonely 'sometimes or always' – with the report adding that 'cultural stigma or lack of understanding about caregiving and disability in some communities can prevent carers from seeking support or even discussing their struggles'.
Almost three quarters of those surveyed (74%) said they did not have time to look after themselves properly, with 50% reporting physical health issues such as fatigue or pain, and 40% saying they suffered from mental health issues such as stress or depression.
The research comes almost two decades on from a 2006 Scottish Government report on unpaid care, which 'explicitly acknowledged the barriers faced by black and minority ethnic carers in accessing and using care services'.
But the Where Are We Now? study, published by MECOPP and Heriot-Watt University with the support of Oxfam Scotland, said little had changed.
The report, published ahead of Carers Week next week, said: 'It has now been nearly two decades since that report, yet many of the challenges it identified remain largely unaddressed, highlighting a persistent gap in policy attention and structural change for BME carers in Scotland.'
It added that BME carers 'face unique difficulties in accessing support', adding that a cultural heritage where 'caregiving is viewed as a natural family duty' can cause people to delay seeking help from outside sources.
This is part of the 'disproportionate barriers to accessing support' BME carers can face, with these also including language issues, a stigma around accessing formal care, and low levels of awareness about rights and entitlements.
Speaking as the research was published, MECOPP chief executive Margaret Chiwanza said: 'This report is a wake-up call that can't be ignored.
'For far too long, BME unpaid carers have been overlooked – unseen, unheard, and unsupported.
'We heard from people battling poverty, burnout and breakdowns, worn out and worn down by a system that keeps failing them.'
She continued: 'The Scottish Government has known about these problems for nearly 20 years ago but little has changed.
'The same barriers are still there – services that don't understand different cultures, information people can't access and policies that haven't delivered.
'It's not enough. BME carers deserve to be seen, heard and properly supported, and not face more decades of delay. This is about fairness, and the time for excuses is over.'
A 39-year-old Pakistani carer spoke out about her experiences, saying: 'I have never had any respite. Caring is 365 days a year, 24 hours a day.
'The only respite I get is when my son goes to bed. Then I start on the laundry and preparing his care needs for the next day.'
Jamie Livingstone, the head of Oxfam Scotland, said: 'Unpaid carers are caring day in, day out, behind closed doors and often without the support they desperately need and these challenges are particularly acute for those from black and minority ethnic communities.
'Many already face deep-rooted poverty and inequality, and unpaid caring is simply pushing them beyond breaking point.
'They're exhausted, isolated and being failed by a system that should be there to help. Politicians must stop paying lip service to inclusion and start delivering the real change BME unpaid carers in Scotland have already waited far too long for.'
Social Justice Secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville said: 'We work closely with the charity MECOPP and are already acting to address issues raised in their report.
'We are also working with them alongside other carers groups as we look to legislate for a right to breaks from caring, for carers from all backgrounds.
'In the meantime, we have increased our voluntary sector Short Breaks Fund to £13m, which includes funding for several short breaks projects which aim to support BME carers.'
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
30 minutes ago
- Scotsman
SNP ministers accused of secrecy over £2m Grangemouth carbon capture study
Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... SNP ministers have been accused of secrecy after refusing to publish a £2 million study into whether a pipeline that will connect Grangemouth with a key carbon capture project will fall flat. The 'alarming' move comes as Chancellor Rachel Reeves is poised to confirm at her spending review this week whether the Acorn carbon capture project for St Fergus, near Peterhead, will finally receive the funding it needs to get off the ground. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Carbon capture technology is seen as being essential to Scotland and the UK reaching net zero | POOL/AFP via Getty Images The previous Conservative UK government only granted the Acorn project reserve status and ploughed funding into carbon capture and storage projects south of the Border instead. This comes as finance secretary Shona Robison asked Chancellor Rachel Reeves to award funding for the Acorn carbon capture project and to ensure Scotland receives a share of GB Energy funding that matches its contribution to UK clean energy goals, ahead of the UK spending review. She also called on the Chancellor to 'prioritise growth' and to fully fund the employer national insurance increase for Scotland's public services. Ms Robison urged the UK Government to abandon some of its 'damaging policies' such as cuts to welfare support for disabled people, to scrap the two-child benefit cap and to reinstate a universal winter fuel payment, ahead of the review on 11 June. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad She said the Scottish Government had not yet been provided with 'clarity' on spending priorities. The delays to the project has been partly blamed for SNP ministers rolling back climate targets, with the Acorn plans initially hoped to be up and running before 2030. But now, the Scottish Government has refused to release the results of a feasibility study into the pipeline, despite confirming the document was completed in March. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad SNP ministers handed over £2m to National Gas last year to assess whether it was possible to turn an old 174-mile gas pipeline that runs from Grangemouth in the Central Belt to St Fergus, Aberdeenshire into 'Europe's largest carbon capture pipeline'. Officials have refused to release details of what the study shows, despite campaigners requesting it under Freedom of Information law. Acting Energy Secretary Gillian Martin during a visit to drone manufacturer Flowcopter in Loanhead, to mark the publication of the Scottish Government's Green Industrial Strategy | Andrew Milligan/PA Wire Concerns have been raised about carbon capture technology, which campaigners warn simply allows oil and gas companies to continue burning fossil fuels. Under the technology, harmful carbon emissions are prevented from being released into the atmosphere and instead trapped and injected into the seabed. Fears have been raised about leakage, with the technology not yet tested at commercial scale. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad During a trip to St Fergus in 2023, then prime minister Rishi Sunak also raised concerns about the technology, warning that it would be a boost 'if we can get it to work'. Now, campaigners have warned that any further public funds for the Acorn project would benefit major oil companies, including Shell, which have made £90 billion profits in recent years and Harbour Energy who recently laid off 250 staff despite paying out almost £1bn to shareholders in the past three years. The UK government has already pledged £22bn to the carbon capture industry, a move which the Public Accounts Committee branded a 'high risk gamble' that could push up household energy bills. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad First Minister John Swinney has vowed to increase the public handout from the Scottish Government for the Acorn project beyond £80m. But that is contingent on the UK government first backing the project - amid doubts the funding could be axed in the spending review amid a perilous economic backdrop. Friends of the Earth Scotland's climate campaigner Alex Lee said: 'The public are again being forced to pay for the oil industry's greenwashing carbon capture plans, and it is deeply alarming that we don't even get to see what our money has unearthed. 'Plans to run a 280km high pressure carbon pipeline through towns and villages are fraught with danger and uncertainty because this has never been done before in Scotland. Have the people who live along the route of this pipeline proposal been informed of the risks and consulted on these proposals? Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'It is a farce that ministers have been talking up carbon capture for 20 years and only now are they checking whether it would even be feasible to do this. 'When working climate solutions are crying out for funding, there should be no public investment in dodgy scams like carbon capture.' Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves and Energy Security and Net Zero Secretary Ed Miliband during a meeting of the National Wealth Fund Taskforce in 11 Downing Street. PIC: Justin Tallis/PA Wire Scottish Greens co-leader Patrick Harvie said: 'The Greens have always been sceptical about putting too much reliance on untested carbon capture technology, and we are firmly opposed to using it as an excuse for more fossil fuel extraction or burning. 'Even its advocates don't think it will make any impact on our emissions in the near future, so the priority has to be the action we know how to take right now - cutting road and air traffic levels, insulating homes and shifting to clean heating, and supporting communities to change land use. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'Climate action isn't rocket science and we don't need to wait for new technologies to get off the drawing board - we just need to do what we know works.' A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'The Scottish Government provided National Gas with a £2m grant to support a study to explore the technical feasibility and viability of repurposing an existing gas pipeline for the transportation of carbon dioxide. 'The conclusions of the study were requested under environmental information regulations. However, for reasons of commercial confidentiality these can't be released. 'The Scottish Government fully supports the deployment of carbon capture and storage (CCS), and we have been advised by the Climate Change Committee that they 'cannot see a route to net zero that does not include CCS'.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad A UK government spokesperson said: 'We are delivering first of a kind carbon capture projects in the UK, supporting thousands of jobs across the country, reigniting industrial heartlands and tackling the climate crisis.
Glasgow Times
an hour ago
- Glasgow Times
Plan revealed for land trageted by flytippers in Glasgow's Milton
Over £650,000 of funding to develop vacant and derelict land in Scotland is set to be used on a 'woodland enhancement' project on land next to Birsay Road. Almost £2m has also been allocated to a scheme which will see 42 flats developed on the former Tureen Street school in Calton — and plans have already been sent to Glasgow City Council. Cash for the two projects is coming from the Scottish Government. Glasgow councillors will be asked to accept the money on Thursday. Glasgow has the highest concentration of urban vacant land in Scotland, although it has been decreasing. The most recent figures show there were 781 hectares across 574 sites in 2024, down from 834 hectares over 599 sites in 2023. Green Action Trust, an environmental regeneration charity, is set to deliver the 'Milton Discovery Wood' scheme on behalf of the council. The land, which has a history of shallow coal mining, has been empty for at least 45 years. A council report states it is 'prone to flytipping and anti-social behaviour' and the funding will help to provide a 'parkland environment for community benefit'. Waste will be removed from the site and entrance ways improved to make it safer. Outdoor classroom spaces are planned to give 'nature play and education opportunities' to nearby schools. Construction is expected to start in February next year and be completed by June. The trust has said the wood will become a 'safe and accessible community resource' in an area which 'currently has little usable, attractive greenspace'. Planting, including trees, hedging and wildflower, is proposed as well as active travel routes. Community consultation is planned over the summer. In Calton, Thenue Housing Association is set to redevelop the former Tureen Street school, which has been derelict for at least 18 years and is on Historic Environment Scotland's building at risk register. Plans include partial demolition, stabilisation and façade retention of the B-listed former school buildings. The council report adds the site has become 'known for anti-social behaviour in the Calton area'. The housing association has already requested planning permission from the council and, if approved, work could start in December. A council report states vacant and derelict land 'constrains the economic potential of the city in addition to blighting local communities'. In Glasgow, development is hindered by 'a combination of poor ground condition, fragmented ownership and inadequate infrastructure'. This year is the final year of vacant and derelict land investment programme funding from the Scottish Government. In future, applications for support will come under its regeneration capital grant fund.
The National
3 hours ago
- The National
Scottish independence 'already begun as UK political culture diverges'
Professor Danny Dorling of the University of Oxford told the Sunday National that the divergence is particularly evident in social policies such as the Scottish Child Payment. This policy, he said, has significantly helped tackle child poverty in Scotland while remaining almost entirely ignored by English political elites, who he accused of wearing 'unbelievable blinkers'. Dorling described the mid-pandemic launch of the Scottish Child Payment by the SNP in February 2021 as both 'really interesting' and largely 'unnoticed' south of the Border. READ MORE: Labour 'could lift 700,000 children out of poverty using SNP policy' The professor said the SNP had 'worked out the cost of living crisis could be just as deadly as the pandemic'. 'Nobody says it like that – but certainly it's important,' he went on. 'Prices went up 30% in a couple of years. That's really serious." In response, he noted, the Scottish Government introduced a modest £10 weekly payment for children under six in families claiming benefits. 'The clever thing politically is the point of principle. Once it's established, you're no longer debating it," Dorling said. He compared the move to an early New Labour policy: "In 1997, they introduced a very small fee for going to university. 'It's just about £1000 a year', right? We now have the highest fees in the world in England.' In Scotland, the pattern has repeated – the Scottish Child Payment has risen significantly to £27.15 per week, with the scope also expanded to all children under 16 in families receiving benefits. The University of Oxford's Professor Danny Dorling (Image: Newsquest) Dorling said: 'It's a lot of money. If you've got three kids, that's about £4000 a year extra untapered – you don't lose it if you get any other benefits – that money means that your children can eat and eat well, I mean healthily. 'This is quite an incredible policy and the cost is still pretty low.' The Scottish Child Payment has been cited as a key reason that child poverty rates are falling in Scotland even as they climb in all other UK nations. Figures published in March showed that 31% of children across the UK were in relative poverty, up from 30% the previous year. In Scotland, however, the rate had dropped from 26% to 22%. However, despite the policy's success – and adoption by other parties including Scottish Labour – Dorling said it was almost unknown south of the Border due to 'the unbelievable blinkers of English politicians and English poverty analysts not to look at this, to try to pretend it isn't happening'. The professor said that, in his opinion, the difference comes down to 'understanding the culture of English elitist politics'. READ MORE: Lesley Riddoch: Independence is at 54 per cent – so why won't the SNP mention it? He argued that many MPs, academics, and analysts emerge from a narrow 'dinner-party world' – studying PPE at top universities before entering policy roles – which creates intellectual isolation and resistance to external ideas. 'The fundamental argument that's always put forward when somebody says we could do this is 'it's not possible',' Dorling said. 'Now, if you've got somewhere within the boundary of the UK demonstrating it's possible, that's really annoying. That's the killer. 'Also, Scotland had the worst poverty rate in Europe when I was a child. The fact that Scotland [now] has a lower poverty rate than any region of England, it doesn't compute.' Dorling said that, as a geographer, he is typically looking abroad for policy inspiration rather than doing "what we always do in Britain, which is go 'we'll invent one out of our own head'". Nicola Sturgeon introduced the Scottish Child Payment while first minister (Image: Colin Mearns) 'But in the last five years, when I do public talks, I try to get people to guess [where this policy is] – that's the punch line, which makes people laugh – and after they go, 'is that in Iceland? is it wherever?', it normally takes them more than 10 guesses. 'I go, 'no, that's done in Scotland'. And they don't know. I can't explain it. I do think it's bizarre.' Dorling argued that this is contributing to a 'growing divide' between politics north and south of the Border 'since 1997, but earlier, if you look at the MPs elected as independents in the 1970s, a growing cultural divide between England and Scotland'. 'Scotland used to be in some ways culturally really part of the Union. You used to produce some of the most obnoxious government ministers. You go to Edinburgh University and learn how to be nasty and go into finance. You shouldn't underestimate how English Scotland was, even in my lifetime.' However, he said that, especially among young people, the divide between English and Scottish politics was widening. READ MORE: John Curtice issues verdict on Hamilton by-election after 'surprise' result 'You know, we no longer get any Scottish students,' the University of Oxford professor said. 'I haven't met in 12 years a student from Scotland. Why would you travel down to England and pay fees? 'So there is a way in which a form of independence has begun already. It's cultural, especially with the young people.' Dorling further argued that the Scottish Child Payment had been a 'tricky political decision because you are deciding not to spend money on other things, principally the old'. However, he said this had come from politicians like Nicola Sturgeon. 'These typically tend to be women in their 40s or 50s, quite strong, quite determined. In most European countries, this is a growing demographic of politicians,' Dorling said. However, he said that growing leadership demographic was not being reflected in England, another aspect of the increasing political divide north and south of the Border.
