Hong Kong man blames mental illness for stabbing elderly father to death
A 35-year-old Hong Kong clerk who cut and stabbed his father more than 80 times in the family home following an argument has maintained that he was not at fault for killing him because he was mentally unstable.
Lee Man-lok pleaded guilty at the High Court on Thursday to manslaughter on the basis of diminished responsibility for fatally assaulting Lee Hok-choi, 78, on October 11, 2021.
Prosecutors agreed to reduce the original murder charge after three psychiatrists concluded the defendant's ability to form rational judgment and exercise self-control was substantially impaired by schizophrenia.
Asked whether he agreed with the prosecution's summary of the case, the defendant confirmed that he did but said: 'Because this is due to my mental illness [prompting me to] kill my father, I think this is not my fault.'
Mr Justice Anthony Kwok Kai-on said he considered the remark a plea for mitigation and urged the defendant to leave any submission in court to his lawyers.
The court heard that at the time of the offence, the accused was staying at a rehabilitation hostel in Nam Cheong following his release from a psychiatric hospital, while his family had lived in Kwai Chung's Yin Lai Court for around 30 years.
The father's neighbour alerted police after hearing screams for help from his flat at around 4.40pm that day.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
41 minutes ago
- South China Morning Post
Malaysia's Najib discharged over US$6.3 million money laundering case
A judge on Friday discharged disgraced former Malaysian prime minister Najib Razak from a US$6.3 million money laundering case after ruling that the prosecution had failed to provide relevant documents to the defence. The ruling marks the second time a case involving Najib has been dismissed due to prosecutorial inaction, raising fresh questions about the conduct and priorities of the Attorney General's Chambers (AGC). Najib, who led the country for nine years until his defeat in the 2018 general election, is currently serving a 12-year prison sentence following his 2020 conviction in the first of several 1MDB-related cases . For this case, he has maintained that he was granted the right to home detention under the directive of Malaysia 's previous king. On Friday, High Court judge K. Muniandy granted Najib's application for a discharge not amounting to an acquittal (DNAA) after defence lawyer Shafee Abdullah argued that it was unjust to keep the former prime minister in legal limbo for more than six years without a confirmed trial date. '[Najib] is very happy simply because there are not too many cases overhanging his head [now],' the lawyer told reporters after the verdict. A DNAA does not absolve the accused of an alleged offence and allows the prosecution to refile charges at a later date. Najib, now 72, was initially charged in February 2019 with three counts of receiving 27 million ringgit (US$6.3 million) in proceeds from unlawful activities through three personal bank accounts on July 8, 2014.
South China Morning Post
6 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Staff at second-hand luxury stores in Hong Kong fear for safety after robbery
Employees at second-hand luxury goods stores in Hong Kong have voiced fears over their safety after a Tsim Sha Tsui shop was robbed of HK$3 million (US$382,170) in Hermes and Van Cleef & Arpels products, with a saleswoman rendered unconscious during the crime. Security and insurance experts highlighted the importance of insuring luxury goods, installing comprehensive antitheft measures and carrying out staff training to minimise the risk of becoming a target for criminals. Zoe Chan, an employee at MM Station, a second-hand luxury goods store in the same neighbourhood as the business that was robbed on Wednesday, said she was worried the shop's security system was not enough to protect staff. 'There is nothing else we can do [in case of a robbery],' she told the Post. The store on Granville Road is equipped with surveillance cameras, gates at the door that beep if someone leaves with a tagged item and an alarm system that automatically calls police if someone tries to break in. There is also an access control system at the doors. Mia Chan Wai-shin, co-owner of JM Vintage, a second-hand luxury goods store on Hart Avenue, said staff felt vulnerable despite having comprehensive security measures in place, such as surveillance cameras.
South China Morning Post
20 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Hongkongers wonder what Wang Junxia can bring to city, 29 years after Olympic gold
Hongkongers are questioning how former Olympic gold medallist Wang Junxia qualified for residency under the Quality Migrant Admission Scheme, 29 years after the end of her controversial athletics career. Advertisement Wang and her 15-year-old daughter, Wang Danting, had their residency confirmed on Wednesday, sparking debate online as to how the former Chinese athlete, who still holds the 3,000 metre world record, could contribute to her new home. A large number of comments focused on the 52-year-old's history as part of a group of athletes known as the 'Ma Family Army'. Coached by the notorious Ma Junren, they dominated athletics in the early 1990s, only to later admit they had been forced to take 'large doses of illegal drugs over the years'. 'She was part of the Ma Family Army, is she coming to Hong Kong to teach doping?' one commentator said. Another comment questioned 'how much investment is she bringing to the city', before adding, 'don't tell me, she got nothing but was still approved'. Wang Junxia at the Standard Chartered Hong Kong Marathon Expo at Victoria Park in February, 2007. Photo: David Wong 'She's way beyond her prime now … any interschool runner could beat her now. How is she still? I suggested the Audit Commission or the ICAC and other departments investigate to check for any illegal behaviour,' another commentator said.
