Abrego Garcia's lawyers ask judge to fine Trump administration for contempt
Lawyers for Kilmar Abrego Garcia have asked a federal judge in Maryland to impose fines against the Trump administration for contempt, arguing that it flagrantly ignored court ordersfor several weeks to return him to the U.S. from El Salvador.
Abrego Garcia's attorneys said the administration claimed to be powerless to retrieve him, even while it secretly built a human smuggling case against him. The U.S. brought Abrego Garcia to a federal court in Nashville, Tennessee last week to face those charges.
'The Government's defiance has not been subtle,' the attorneys said in a filing late Wednesday. 'It has been vocal and sustained and flagrant.'
The attorneys also are asking U.S. District Court Judge Paula Xinis to compel the release of documents the federal government withheld by claiming they contain protected state secrets. Or as an alternative, the lawyers suggested a special master to investigate the government's 'willful noncompliance' of court orders.
'What the Government improperly seeks to hide must be exposed for all to see,' Abrego Garcia's attorneys wrote.
Their request came a day after the Trump administration said it will ask Xinis to dismiss the case, with U.S. attorneys describing recent accusations by Abrego Garcia's attorneys as baseless, desperate and disappointing.
'But the proof is in the pudding — Defendants have returned Abrego Garcia to the United States just as they were ordered to do,' they wrote.
Legal experts said last month that the Abrego Garcia case may be headed for contempt. And the request by his attorneys adds to the ongoing friction between the White House and the courts during President Donald Trump's second term.
Courts can hold parties to civil litigation or criminal cases in contempt for disobeying their orders. The penalty can take the form of fines or other civil punishments, or even prosecution and jail time, if pursued criminally. But contempt processes are slow and deliberative, and, when the government's involved, there's usually a resolution before penalties kick in.
The U.S. mistakenly deported Abrego Garcia to an El Salvador prison in March. The expulsion violated a U.S. immigration judge's order in 2019 that shielded him from deportation to his native country because he likely faced gang persecution there.
Abrego Garcia's American wife sued, prompting Xinis to order his return on April 4. The Supreme Court ruled April 10 that the administration must work to bring him back.
Arguments ensued over the next several weeks about whether the Trump administration was following those orders or not. Trump also said publicly that he could return Abrego Garcia to the U.S. with a call to El Salvador President Nayib Bukele.
Xinis ordered U.S. attorneys to submit documents and testimony to show what the government had done to follow her orders. The Trump administration claimed that much of that information is protected under the state secrets privilege. The judge has not ruled on that matter.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Toronto Star
22 minutes ago
- Toronto Star
The Latest: Trump meets with National Security Council on Israel-Iran attacks
The new Israeli military operation against Iran is giving President Donald Trump a fresh test of his campaign promise to disentangle the U.S. from foreign conflicts. It lands as he's dealing with domestic turmoil: Opponents of his administration are set to rally in hundreds of cities on Saturday during the military parade in Washington to mark the Army's 250th anniversary, which coincides with Trump's birthday. Secretary of State Marco Rubio, doubling as Trump's national security adviser, asserted that the U.S. was 'not involved' and that protecting U.S. forces in the region is the Republican administration's central concern. Trump, however, said Friday that he knows of Israel's plans and warned Iran of 'a lot more to come.' The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday temporarily blocked a federal judge's order directing Trump to return control of National Guard troops to California after he deployed them against people protesting immigration raids in Los Angeles. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW Here's the Latest: 4 detainees escaped from a New Jersey immigration detention facility Authorities are looking for four detainees who escaped from an immigration detention facility in Newark, New Jersey, according to the Department of Homeland Security. More 'law enforcement partners' have been brought in to find the detainees missing from Delaney Hall, according to an emailed statement attributed to a senior DHS official whom the department did not identify. The statement also didn't specify which law enforcement agencies are involved. ▶Read more about what's going on at Delaney Hall. Marines to take over operations in downtown LA, commander says Maj. Gen. Scott Sherman, commander of Task Force 51 who is overseeing the 4,700 troops deployed in Los Angeles, said Friday that 200 Marines have finished training on civil disturbance. Sherman said the Marines will take over operations at noon local time in downtown Los Angeles. He says they will be protecting federal property and personnel. The Marines will join some 2,000 National Guard troops that have been on the streets of the city since last week when immigration raids set off protests. Trump is convening a National Security Council meeting on Israel's attack on Iran ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW The meeting in the Situation Room, which was scheduled to begin at 11 a.m., is the only item listed on Trump's public schedule for Friday. There are currently no plans for him to appear before reporters. Kilmar Abrego Garcia pleads not guilty to human smuggling in Tennessee Kilmar Abrego Garcia 's plea was the first chance the Maryland construction worker has had in a U.S. courtroom to answer the Trump administration's allegations against him since he was mistakenly deported in March to a notorious prison in El Salvador. The Republican administration returned Abrego Garcia to the U.S. last week to face a new indictment charging him with human smuggling for transported immigrants inside the United States. Abrego Garcia was driving a vehicle with nine passengers during a 2022 traffic stop in Tennessee. 'There's no way a jury is going to see the evidence and agree that this sheet metal worker is the leader of an international MS-13 smuggling conspiracy,' his lawyer Simon Sandoval-Moshenberg said last week. U.S. attorneys have asked U.S. Magistrate Judge Barbara Holmes to keep Abrego Garcia in jail, describing him as a danger to the community and a flight risk. Los Angeles had another relatively calm night Most of the sprawling city has been spared as protests continue downtown, near City Hall and a federal detention center where some immigrants are being held. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW On the third night of an 8 p.m. curfew, Los Angeles police arrested several demonstrators who refused to leave a downtown street, and Homeland Security officers deployed flash bangs to disperse a crowd near the jail. Those incidents were outliers. As with the previous two nights, the hourslong demonstrations remained peaceful and upbeat, drawing a few hundred attendees who were chanting, dancing and poking fun at the Trump administration's characterization of the city as a 'war zone.' The LAPD said there have been about 470 arrests since Saturday, the vast majority for failing to leave the downtown area at the request of law enforcement. A handful of more serious charges include assault against officers and possession of a Molotov cocktail and a gun. Nine officers have been hurt, mostly with minor injuries. ▶ Read more about the crackdown and protests in Los Angeles Detained Columbia protester asks judge to order his release, says government missed appeal deadline The letter lawyers for Mahmoud Khalil sent Friday to U.S. District Judge Michael Farbiarz in New Jersey says Khalil has satisfied all the court's requirements for his release, including posting a $1 bond, while lawyers for the government missed the judge's Friday's 9:30 a.m. deadline. In response, the judge gave the government until 1:30 p.m. Friday. Khalil's lawyers say the government hasn't shown any grounds to keep detaining him, other than reasons the judge already dismissed. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW 'The deadline has come and gone and Mahmoud Khalil must be released immediately,' his lawyers said in a statement provided by the American Civil Liberties Union. 'Anything further is an attempt to prolong his unconstitutional, arbitrary, and cruel detention.' Spokespeople for the Justice Department and Homeland Security didn't immediately respond to emails seeking comment. ▶ Read more about Khalil's case California governor concerned that private Medicaid data will facilitate deportations Gavin Newsom 's office expressed concern that the data will be used for immigration raids supported by the National Guard troops and Marines Trump deployed in Los Angeles. 'We deeply value the privacy of all Californians,' the statement said. 'This potential data transfer brought to our attention by the AP is extremely concerning, and if true, potentially unlawful, particularly given numerous headlines highlighting potential improper federal use of personal information and federal actions to target the personal information of Americans.' Health and Human Services spokesman Andrew Nixon said the data was shared legally, 'to ensure that Medicaid benefits are reserved for individuals who are lawfully entitled to receive them.' ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW Nixon wouldn't answer questions about how DHS would use it, and DHS officials did not respond to requests for comment. Trump administration gives personal data of immigrant Medicaid enrollees to deportation officials The data includes the immigration status of millions of Medicaid enrollees, which could facilitate locating people to deport as part of his sweeping immigration crackdown. An internal memo and emails obtained by The Associated Press show that Medicaid officials unsuccessfully sought to block the data transfer, citing legal and ethical concerns. Nevertheless, two top advisers to Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. ordered the dataset handed over to the Department of Homeland Security, the emails show. The dataset includes people living in California, Illinois, Washington state and Washington, D.C., all of which allow non-U.S. citizens to enroll in Medicaid programs that use only state taxpayer dollars. ▶ Read more about how DHS now has personal data of immigrant Medicaid enrollees ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW Republican enthusiasm for Musk cools after his feud with Trump, a new AP-NORC poll finds The tech billionaire has lost some of his luster with Republicans since his messy public falling-out with the president last week. Fewer Republicans view Trump's onetime government efficiency bulldog 'very favorably' compared with April, according to the new poll from The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research. Though most Republicans continue to hold a positive view of Musk, their diminished fervor suggests his vocal opposition to Trump's signature spending and tax cut legislation — and Musk's subsequent online political and personal taunts — may have cost him. About half of Americans have a negative opinion of Tesla — far more than other car companies. Tesla has dropped in value and amid protests in the U.S. and Europe. ▶ Read more about the AP/NORC poll on opinions about Elon Musk Trump praises appellate court for blocking judges order that his National Guard deployment is illegal ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW 'If I didn't send the Military into Los Angeles, that city would be burning to the ground right now,' Trump said on his Truth Social platform Friday. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday temporarily blocked a federal judge's order directing Trump to return control of National Guard troops to California, and set an appellate hearing for Tuesday. California Gov. Gavin Newsom had asked for an emergency intervention to stop troops from supporting immigration raids. 'Today was really about a test of democracy, and today we passed the test,' Newsom said before the appeals court decision. 'The district court has no authority to usurp the President's authority as Commander in Chief,' White House spokesperson Anna Kelly said. ▶ Read more about California's legal challenge of Trump's military deployment in Los Angeles Trump: U.S. was aware of Israeli attack ahead of time The U.S. president said Friday morning that 'we know what's going on' when asked what sort of advance warning he got from Israel about its attack on Iran. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW 'Heads-up? It wasn't a heads-up. It was, we know what's going on,' he told the Wall Street Journal. Trump again cited the Israel attack as a warning to Iran to make a nuclear deal. US shifts military resources in Mideast in response to Israel strikes on Iran The United States is shifting ships and other military resources in the Middle East in response to Israel's strikes on Iran and a possible retaliatory attack by Tehran, two U.S. officials said Friday. The Navy has directed the destroyer USS Thomas Hudner to begin sailing toward the Eastern Mediterranean and also has directed a second destroyer to begin moving forward, so it can be available if requested by the White House. The president is meeting with his National Security Council principals, including Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and Gen. Dan Caine, chairman of Joint Chiefs of Staff, on Friday morning to discuss the situation, one of the officials said. The officials spoke on the condition of anonymity to provide details not yet made public. — Tara Copp. Judge blocks Trump's election order, siding with Democrats who called it overreach ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW The Republican president's March 25 executive order sought to overhaul elections nationwide by compelling officials to require documentary proof of citizenship for everyone registering to vote for federal elections, accepting only mailed ballots received by Election Day and conditioning federal election grant funding on states adhering to the new ballot deadline. The White House has defended the order as 'standing up for free, fair and honest elections' and called proof of citizenship a 'commonsense' requirement. The judge sided with a group of Democratic state attorneys general who challenged the effort as unconstitutional. The attorneys general said the directive 'usurps the States' constitutional power and seeks to amend election law by fiat.' Israel told the Trump administration of the attacks ahead of time Israel told the Trump administration that large-scale attacks were coming and expected Iranian retaliation would be severe and that's why the United States ordered the evacuations of some nonessential embassy staffers and authorized the voluntary departure of military dependents in the region, U.S. officials said on condition of anonymity to describe private diplomatic discussions. Special envoy Steve Witkoff still plans to go to Oman this weekend for talks on Tehran's nuclear program, but it's not clear if the Iranians would participate, officials said. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW Trump warns there'll be more attacks on Iran In an interview with ABC News on Friday morning, Trump said the Israeli attack on Iran was 'excellent' and again previewed more attacks to come. 'We gave them a chance and they didn't take it,' Trump told ABC's Jon Karl. 'They got hit hard, very hard. They got hit about as hard as you're going to get hit. And there's more to come. A lot more.' Israeli strikes on Iran lead to new test of Trump's ability to deliver on 'America first' agenda Just hours before Israel launched strikes on Iran early Friday, President Donald Trump was still holding onto tattered threads of hope that a long-simmering dispute over Tehran's nuclear program could be resolved without military action. But with the Israeli military operation called 'Rising Lion' now underway — something Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says will go on for 'as many days as it takes' — Trump will be tested anew on his ability to make good on a campaign promise to disentangle the U.S. from foreign conflicts. 'I gave Iran chance after chance to make a deal,' Trump said in a Friday morning social media post. 'I told them, in the strongest of words, to 'just do it,' but no matter how hard they tried, no matter how close they got, they just couldn't get it done.' ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ▶ Read more about the new test to Trump's agenda Appeals court temporarily blocks judge's ruling to return control of National Guard to California The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday temporarily blocked a federal judge's order that directed President Donald Trump to return control of National Guard troops to California after he deployed them there following protests in Los Angeles over immigration raids. The court said it would hold a hearing on the matter on Tuesday. The ruling came only hours after a federal judge's order was to take effect at noon Friday. ▶ Read more about the court ruling Marines moving soon into Los Angeles, preparing to take over some security posts Marines are expected to begin moving into the city soon and will formally take over security from National Guard troops at some of the protest locations Friday morning. The arriving Marines will take some time to transition with the Guard soldiers leaving the posts, according to a U.S. official who spoke on condition of anonymity Thursday night to discuss troop movements. About 700 Marines have been undergoing civil disturbance training at Naval Weapons Station Seal Beach in Orange County, California. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ___ Associated Press reporter Lolita C. Baldor contributed to this report. Judge invokes King George III in deliberations over Trump's use of the National Guard U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer ruled that Trump's deployment of the National Guard in Los Angeles without approval of California's governor exceeded was illegal and violates the Tenth Amendment. The order applied only to the National Guard troops and not Marines who were also deployed to the LA protests. The judge said he would not rule on the Marines because they were not out on the streets yet. 'We're talking about the president exercising his authority, and the president is of course limited in that authority. That's the difference between a constitutional government and King George,' Breyer said during Thursday's court hearing, referring to the king of England during the American Revolution. 'This country was founded in response to a monarch, and the Constitution is a document of limitations,' Breyer said. 'I'm trying to figure out where the lines are drawn.' Judge has bigger questions in court hearing over Trump's use of National Guard in immigration raids California Gov. Gavin Newsom requested that the judge temporarily block Trump's use of the National Guard specifically for immigration raids. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW But Thursday's hearing opened with Senior U.S. District Court Judge Charles R. Breyer asking attorneys whether Trump followed the law when he called in the National Guard. Trump orders government wildland firefighting consolidated into single program Thursday's executive order is meant to centralize duties now split among five agencies and two Cabinet departments. Former federal officials have warned that such a consolidation could be costly and increase the risk of catastrophic blazes as global warming makes wildfires more severe and destructive. Officials have not disclosed how much the change could cost. In its first months, the administration sharply reduced the ranks of firefighters through layoffs and retirement offers and temporarily cut off money for wildfire prevention work. Trump tells immigrants from Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua and Venezuela to leave The Department of Homeland Security is notifying hundreds of thousands of Cubans, Haitians, Nicaraguans and Venezuelans that their temporary permission to live and work in the United States has been revoked and they should leave the country. The termination notices are being sent by email to about 532,000 people who came to the country under the humanitarian parole program created by the Biden administration. They arrived with financial sponsors and were given two-year permits to live and work in the U.S. DHS said the letters informed people that both their temporary legal status and work permit were revoked 'effective immediately.' ▶ Read more about the termination notices
Toronto Star
25 minutes ago
- Toronto Star
Our Defence Minister on threats, bigger budgets, and Canada's new relationship with the U.S.
Canada's Minister of National Defence David McGuinty joins It's Political to discuss increases to the country's defense budget and what the relationship looks like with the U.S. going forward. The conversation follows Prime Minister Mark Carney's announcement this week that Canada will greatly increase military spending to 2 per cent of GDP just as NATO allies get together later this month to discuss raising the bar to 5 per cent. We also speak to industry experts about just how integrated the Canadian and American militaries are, and what it would mean to become less reliant on the U.S.
CTV News
26 minutes ago
- CTV News
U.S. appeals court won't reconsider Trump's US$5M loss in sex assault case
NEW YORK - Donald Trump failed to persuade a federal appeals court to reconsider the US$5 million verdict won by E. Jean Carroll after a jury found that the U.S. president sexually abused and defamed the former magazine columnist in the 1990s. In an 8-2 vote, the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan on Friday left intact its Dec. 30 decision by a three-judge panel upholding the jury award. Carroll, now 81, accused Trump of attacking her around 1996 in a Bergdorf Goodman department store dressing room in Manhattan, and defaming her in an October 2022 Truth Social post by denying her claim as a hoax. In his denial, which repeated a similar denial in June 2019, Trump said the former Elle columnist was 'not my type' and made up the rape claim to promote her memoir. Jurors decided in May 2023 that Trump had sexually assaulted Carroll, and had defamed her by lying. They did not find that Trump raped Carroll, as she had claimed. The president, who turns 79 on Saturday, is separately asking the appeals court to throw out an US$83.3 million jury verdict in January 2024 for defaming Carroll and damaging her reputation when the Republican first denied her rape claim. Oral arguments are scheduled for June 24. A further appeal of the US$5 million verdict would go to the U.S. Supreme Court. A spokesman for Trump's lawyers said in a statement that Americans 'demand an immediate end to the political weaponization of our justice system and a swift dismissal of all of the Witch Hunts, including the Democrat-funded Carroll Hoax, which will continue to be appealed.' The US$5 million verdict included US$2.98 million for defamation and US$2.02 million for sexual assault. Carroll is 'very pleased' with Friday's order, her lawyer Roberta Kaplan said in a statement. 'Although President Trump continues to try every possible maneuver to challenge the findings of two separate juries, those efforts have failed.' Dissent challenges evidence rulings Circuit Judges Steven Menashi and Michael Park, both appointed by Trump, dissented from the order. Menashi wrote that evidence in the case 'makes it more likely that President Trump believed that the lawsuit had been concocted by his political opposition - and therefore that he was not speaking with actual malice.' The judge also said the panel also improperly allowed 'stale' trial testimony about Trump's alleged groping of businesswoman Jessica Leeds on a plane in the late 1970s. In seeking reconsideration, Trump maintained that the trial judge erred in letting jurors review a 2005 'Access Hollywood' video of him bragging about his sexual prowess. He also challenged a 'pile-on' of inflammatory evidence that he mistreated Leeds and former People magazine writer Natasha Stoynoff, who accused Trump of forcibly kissing her at his Mar-a-Lago estate in 2005. Trump has denied Leeds' and Stoynoff's claims. In seeking to overturn the US$83.3 million verdict, Trump argued that the Supreme Court's decision last July providing him substantial criminal immunity shields him from liability in Carroll's civil case. The verdict included US$18.3 million of damages for emotional and reputational harm, and US$65 million of punitive damages. (Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York; Editing by Howard Goller) Jonathan Stempel, Reuters
