Letters to the Editor: Can Israel and Palestinians ever work together to solve decades-long conflict?
To the editor: I am an American Jew, and I appreciate your printing of this article ('My family's archive shows why Palestinians are owed reparations,' May 13). We all know that terrible mistakes were made back in May 1948 by the British and the U.N., and that many Palestinians were unfairly treated. We, as Jews, having suffered atrocities in Europe, should know better.
I am not at all happy with the current administration in Israel and cringe with shame as to what they are doing in Gaza. On the other hand, the Israelis have suffered untold losses as well at the hands of Palestinians. The lesson here, I believe, is that both sides have to acknowledge wrongdoing, and both sides need to come together and fix it. I realize this may be a pipe dream, but is there any other way out of this morass?
Barbara Busch, Santa Barbara
..
To the editor: Guest contributor Adel Bseiso's familial story is touching and sad. However, it is also incomplete. The Palestinian narration of the Nakba says primarily that the sovereign state of Israel abruptly swept in and displaced hundreds of thousands of Palestinians, a planned act of aggression not unlike the Six-Day War in 1967.
What was supposed to occur in 1948 was a United Nations-mandated partition of both Palestinian and Jewish nations. However, a coalition of Arab nations rejected that plan, and would come to lose that gambit and the war.
The possibility of the Palestinians and Arab nations accepting the U.N. partition is a 'what if' of Middle Eastern history that for some reason is rarely discussed. In the spirit of widening this discussion, I would be curious whether Bseiso or scholars could return to his family archives — and determine what proportion of land his family would have retained had the partition plan been accepted.
Ron Shinkman, Northridge
..
To the editor: Bseiso's piece about his Palestinian family was anguishing to read. The situation in Gaza is appalling. This should not stand.
Jeri Marston, Los Angeles
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Associated Press
19 minutes ago
- Associated Press
Ameen Khalifa survived gunfire on a first trip to get food at Gaza's new aid hub, but not the second
Shootings have erupted multiple times in the last week in the vicinity of new aid hubs where desperate Palestinians are being directed to collect food, including on June 1 and June 3. Witnesses have told the Associated Press that it is nearby Israeli troops that have opened fire, and more than 80 people have been killed according to Gaza hospital officials. Israel has said soldiers fired warning shots or, in some cases, have shot towards 'suspects' approaching the troops in the areas nearby the aid centers. (AP video by Mohammad Jahjouh, Mariam Dagga and Wafaa Shurafa)
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Israeli military recovers body of elusive Hamas leader Mohammed Sinwar
The Israeli military recovered the body of de facto Hamas leader Mohammed Sinwar in a tunnel underneath the European Hospital in southern Gaza, the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) said Sunday. The IDF said it made the announcement after the body went through an identification process. Sinwar is the younger brother of former Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar, who was killed by the Israeli military in southern Gaza in October. His death marks the latest in a string of assassinations that have dealt a serious blow to the group's top brass but are yet to break its grip on power in the besieged enclave. The elusive Sinwar was targeted in a massive airstrike on the hospital in Khan Younis on May 13, a day after Hamas released Israeli-American soldier Edan Alexander. At the time, the IDF said it had struck 'Hamas terrorists in a command-and-control center' in underground infrastructure at the hospital. But it took more than two weeks for Israel to say that it had definitively killed Sinwar in the strike. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu made the announcement on the 600th day of the war two weeks ago. 'We changed the face of the Middle East, we pushed the terrorists from our territories, we entered the Gaza Strip with force, we eliminated tens of thousands of terrorists, we eliminated (Mohammad) Deif, (Ismail) Haniyeh, Yahya Sinwar and Mohammed Sinwar,' Netanyahu said in a speech at the Knesset, Israel's parliament. The attack killed 28 Palestinians and wounded more than 50 others, the Palestinian Ministry of Health said after the strike. This is a developing story and will be updated.
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Israel vows to stop aid boat with Greta Thunberg and other activists on board from reaching Gaza
Israel vowed on Sunday to stop an aid boat carrying Greta Thunberg and other activists on board from reaching Gaza. As of Sunday evening, the UK-flagged civilian vessel was north of Egypt in the Mediterranean Sea, slowly approaching the coast of Gaza. The 'Madleen' is part of the Freedom Flotilla Coalition, an organization that has campaigned against Israel's blockade of Gaza and tried to break the siege by boat. 'We know that it's a very risky mission and we know that previous experiences with flotillas like this have resulted in attacks, violence and even cases of death,' Thunberg told CNN on Saturday. 'But of course none of those risks are even remotely as high as the risk that Palestinians are facing everyday just by trying to survive.' Defense Minister Israel Katz reiterated that the Madleen, operated by the Freedom Flotilla Coalition, would not make it to the besieged enclave. 'I have instructed the IDF to ensure that the 'Madleen' flotilla does not reach Gaza,' said Katz in a statement, referring to the name of the ship. Katz warned the ship that 'you'd better turn back – because you will not reach Gaza.' Thunberg and the Madleen expect to reach Gaza within the next day, organizer Yasemin Acar told CNN on Saturday. 'We are still on our way to Gaza. There's no turning back, and we're hoping to make it into Gaza within two days,' Acar said. The coalition campaigns to end Israel's blockade of Gaza and has tried to reach the enclave several times in the past After an 11-week blockade that prevented any humanitarian aid from entering Gaza, Israel has begun allowing a trickle of aid in once again. But it is only a fraction of the aid that entered the enclave before the war, with humanitarian organizations warning of a worsening humanitarian crisis and the growing risk of widespread famine. Francesca Albanese, the United Nations Special Rapporteur for the occupied Palestinian territories, said on social media that the flotilla carries more than food. 'It is not only the aid, it is the HUMANITY THEY CARRY. For all of us,' she said. The crew, which has publicized the location of the ship with an online tracker, began preparing for the possibility of interception by the Israeli military. Among those joining the crew are Rima Hassan, a French member of the European Parliament, and 'Game of Thrones' actor Liam Cunningham. 'From both a legal and moral standpoint, Israel has no right to intercept this vessel,' the group said in a statement. 'The people of Gaza, under siege, starving, and facing the threat of annihilation, have the legal right to decide who enters their territories.' Last month, another vessel from the Freedom Flotilla Coalition came under what its organizers said was an Israeli drone attack off the coast of Malta in international waters. The group did not provide evidence that the drone was Israeli, while the Israeli military has declined to comment on the alleged attack. The ship, the 'Conscience,' was heading to Malta, where a large contingent of activists were due to board before it departed for Gaza, more than 1,000 miles away, but had not made it into port, the group said. The coalition told CNN that Thunberg was among those who were expected to board the vessel in Malta.
