Hold the lies: Judge says Burger King must face false-advertising lawsuit over the size of its Whopper
A federal judge in Florida this week denied Burger King's request to dismiss a lawsuit against the company for false advertising related to its famous burger. It is the latest case of false advertising targeting fast-food chains.
The lawsuit represents 19 people from 13 different states who say they purchased Burger King's signature Whopper based on "false and misleading advertising concerning the size and/or the amount of ingredients."
In a statement to Business Insider, Burger King denied the claims.
"The plaintiffs' claims are false," a spokesperson for the company told BI. "The flame-grilled beef patties portrayed in our advertising are the same patties used in the millions of burgers we serve to guests across the US."
Burger King filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit in May 2022, two months after it was first filed. It argued that since every burger is hand-made at the restaurant, the "look" of each sandwich "necessarily will differ."
US Southern Florida District Judge Roy Altman, however, said in his ruling on Monday that he would allow the plaintiff's claims of negligent misrepresentation to move forward.
In some states, the law requires that a customer have a "special relationship" with a company to sue it for misrepresentation in ads. The law defines a special relationship as requiring a "position of confidence or trust," like with a lawyer or engineer.A food service business would not typically fall into this category.But Florida law does not have this requirement, Altman wrote.
Altman said Burger King's lawyers were "resisting the common-sense reading of Florida law" by suggesting that Burger King could not be liable based on the absence of a special relationship.
The Russo Firm, a class action law firm representing the plaintiffs, wrote in a blog post that Altman's ruling was "significant."
"The court's decision underscores the importance of truthful advertising and may set a precedent for how fast-food chains represent their products," the post says. "The outcome of this case could have broader implications for marketing standards within the industry."
The Whopper lawsuit is the latest example of false-advertising claims targeting fast-food chains. In 2023, for example, a federal judge in Brooklyn dismissed a similar false advertising lawsuit against Wendy's and McDonald's that accused the restaurants of marketing their burgers as larger than reality.
US District Judge Hector Gonzalez said in his ruling for that case that the plaintiff did not prove that a reasonable consumer would have been misled by the ads.
Also in 2023, a man filed a class action lawsuit against Buffalo Wild Wings, accusing the company of misrepresenting its boneless chicken wings, which are actually made with chicken breast meat.
Bill Marler, an attorney specializing in food safety cases, previously told BI that these kinds of class action lawsuits are often legally unproductive and walk the "thin line between consumer advocacy and just being annoying."
"It raises the issue about what's the real purpose here? Is it that they're being a consumer advocate and then extracting fees and costs out of the company to discourage them from doing it again? Or is it just a tool to extract fees and costs out of a company?" Marler said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
36 minutes ago
- Yahoo
LinkedIn's founder says Gen Z graduates are 'enormously attractive' to employers for one reason
The rise of AI has sparked fears that it will cause jobs to disappear. But Reid Hoffman says young people should embrace AI in their job hunt. The LinkedIn founder said knowing how to use AI will make them "enormously attractive" to employers. Reid Hoffman, venture capitalist and the founder of LinkedIn, says young people should use their familiarity with AI as a selling point to potential employers. "You are generation AI. You are AI native. So bringing the fact that you have AI in your tool set is one of the things that makes you enormously attractive," Hoffman said in a video he published on his YouTube channel on Thursday. Hoffman was addressing questions sent in by college students on how they should best navigate the job hunt. Several students had asked Hoffman about AI's impact on their employment prospects. Hoffman said in his video that AI's impact on jobs is a "legitimate worry," but he added that students could try to use it to their advantage. "Look, on this side, it's transforming the workspace, entry-level work, employers' confusion. But on this side, it's making you able to show your unique capabilities. That, you know, in an environment with a bunch of older people, you might be able to help them out," he said. A representative for Hoffman did not respond to a request for comment from Business Insider. The rise of AI has sparked fears that companies could end up hiring fewer staff in the years to come. Last month, the CEO of Anthropic, Dario Amodei, said in an interview with Axios that AI may wipe out half of all entry-level office jobs. In the interview, Amodei said he expects unemployment to rise by 10% to 20% over the next one to five years. "Most of them are unaware that this is about to happen," he said. "It sounds crazy, and people just don't believe it." But not all business leaders agree with Amodei's dire prediction. Jensen Huang, the CEO of chip giant Nvidia, told reporters on the sidelines of VivaTech 2025 in Paris this week that Amodei was wrong. "I pretty much disagree with almost everything he says," Huang said of Amodei. "He thinks AI is so scary, but only they should do it." Huang said that while some jobs would disappear, AI could also create new job opportunities. "Do I think AI will change jobs? It will change everyone's — it's changed mine," Huang said. Mark Cuban had a similar response to Amodei's comments as Huang. The "Shark Tank" star wrote in a BlueSky post last month that AI will create, and not destroy, jobs. "Someone needs to remind the CEO that at one point there were more than 2m secretaries. There were also separate employees to do in office dictation. They were the original white collar displacements," Cuban wrote. "New companies with new jobs will come from AI and increase TOTAL employment," he added. Read the original article on Business Insider
Business Insider
2 hours ago
- Business Insider
LinkedIn's founder says Gen Z graduates are 'enormously attractive' to employers for one reason
Reid Hoffman, venture capitalist and the founder of LinkedIn, says young people should use their familiarity with AI as a selling point to potential employers. "You are generation AI. You are AI native. So bringing the fact that you have AI in your tool set is one of the things that makes you enormously attractive," Hoffman said in a video he published on his YouTube channel on Thursday. Hoffman was addressing questions sent in by college students on how they should best navigate the job hunt. Several students had asked Hoffman about AI's impact on their employment prospects. Hoffman said in his video that AI's impact on jobs is a "legitimate worry," but he added that students could try to use it to their advantage. "Look, on this side, it's transforming the workspace, entry-level work, employers' confusion. But on this side, it's making you able to show your unique capabilities. That, you know, in an environment with a bunch of older people, you might be able to help them out," he said. A representative for Hoffman did not respond to a request for comment from Business Insider. The rise of AI has sparked fears that companies could end up hiring fewer staff in the years to come. Last month, the CEO of Anthropic, Dario Amodei, said in an interview with Axios that AI may wipe out half of all entry-level office jobs. In the interview, Amodei said he expects unemployment to rise by 10% to 20% over the next one to five years. "Most of them are unaware that this is about to happen," he said. "It sounds crazy, and people just don't believe it." But not all business leaders agree with Amodei's dire prediction. Jensen Huang, the CEO of chip giant Nvidia, told reporters on the sidelines of VivaTech 2025 in Paris this week that Amodei was wrong. "I pretty much disagree with almost everything he says," Huang said of Amodei. "He thinks AI is so scary, but only they should do it." Huang said that while some jobs would disappear, AI could also create new job opportunities. "Do I think AI will change jobs? It will change everyone's — it's changed mine," Huang said. Mark Cuban had a similar response to Amodei's comments as Huang. The "Shark Tank" star wrote in a BlueSky post last month that AI will create, and not destroy, jobs. "Someone needs to remind the CEO that at one point there were more than 2m secretaries. There were also separate employees to do in office dictation. They were the original white collar displacements," Cuban wrote. "New companies with new jobs will come from AI and increase TOTAL employment," he added.
Business Insider
3 hours ago
- Business Insider
Instagram is throwing shy and indecisive users a lifeline with a new update
Instagram said it is rolling out a slate of new features catering to shy, low-key users who want to post without announcing everything to their entire followers' list. Adam Mosseri, the head of the Meta-run social media platform, said in a Thursday news release that users will soon be able to make posts without informing their followers, and rearrange existing posts on their grid. "We know creative expression can feel intimidating, especially when posting something to feed. To address this directly, we're exploring a way to let you quietly post to your profile without broadcasting it to everyone's feeds," Mosseri said in the release. "We'll also make it possible to re-order the posts on your grid. We hope this added flexibility over how and where your content shows up helps you create and share without added pressure," he added. The changes will allow users to "overcome self-doubt and just make it, share it, do it anyway," Mosseri said. It is not clear when the updates will be rolled out. Representatives for Meta did not respond to a query from Business Insider on the matter. Another new update, trial reels, has already been rolled out. This feature allows users to share a reel with non-followers before sharing it with followers. "We've heard from creators that this takes the guesswork out of how content will perform, and our hope is that trial reels will give everyone greater freedom to explore their creativity in a low-pressure way," Mosseri said in the release. The new updates come in an era when Instagram users are becoming more private — posting less on their feeds, sharing more on their stories, and moving to private messaging. "The amount of content people post publicly in feeds is going down across the entire industry because people are moving more and more sharing to stories — which you could argue is a different kind of feed — but even more into messaging, group chats, one-on-one chats," Mosseri told BI's Peter Kafka in May.
