logo
Judge denies defence's request to drop charges in Joshlin Smith trial

Judge denies defence's request to drop charges in Joshlin Smith trial

IOL News23-04-2025

Jacquen Appollis, Steveno van Rhyn and Kelly Smith face charges of human trafficking and kidnapping.
Image: Robin-Lee Francke/IOL
As the State closed its case in the Joshlin Smith matter on Wednesday morning, it is now time for the defence to bring forth its case.
Earlier, the State called Colonel Riaan Morris from the provincial Commercial Crimes Unit, who played six videos for the court.
The videos include Kelly Smith being filmed on Sunday, March 3, 2024, at an open prayer service being held for Joshlin.
The other videos also show Kelly having a meeting at the Spur with now Minister Gayton McKenzie.
Judge Nathan Erasmus dismissed the applications.
Image: Ayanda Ndamane/Independent Newspapers
A few videos of the meeting with McKenzie are shown.
He was also provided with two links, which led to two videos of McKenzie, seated in the back of a vehicle, where he questions Steveno van Rhyn about his whereabouts and what happened to Joshlin.
As the State closed its case in the matter, Judge Nathan Erasmus was told that the defence counsel would bring forth Section 174 applications.
A Section 174 application, under South Africa's Criminal Procedure Act, allows an accused person to be discharged if the court believes there is no evidence to support a conviction at the close of the State's case.
Fanie Harmse, the legal representative for Jacquen 'Boeta' Appollis, chose not to bring forth an application.
Van Rhyn's lawyer, Nobuhle Mkabayi, brought forth an application.
'The defence will argue accused two has no case to answer. All state witnesses who testified didn't bring any evidence that this court can come to the conclusion that accused two has committed an offence. It will be unfair if the accused is only brought into the dock to supplement the State's case,' she submitted.
When Judge Erasmus mentions that State witness Laurentia Lombaard implicated van Rhyn, Mkabayi shot back, stating she was 'not credible'.
'Your client made a statement which I found admissible, that he admitted to being with when Joshlin was taken away, and he had gone back to find out what he's cut was,' Judge Erasmus said.
'I strongly submit there is no evidence,' Mkabayi submitted.
Kelly's lawyer, Rinesh Sivnarain, also brought forth an application to have charges discharged against his client.
'My submission case has not brought enough prima facie evidence against my client. In regards to human trafficking, only one witness, Laurentia Lombaard, and I submit that her evidence was of such poor quality that it should be rejected in its entirety,' he submitted.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Warrant issued for suspect in murder of whistleblower engineer Armand Swart
Warrant issued for suspect in murder of whistleblower engineer Armand Swart

IOL News

time2 hours ago

  • IOL News

Warrant issued for suspect in murder of whistleblower engineer Armand Swart

IOL Police have issued a warrant for Lucky Boitumelo Molefe in the murder of engineer Armard Swart, who was shot dead after exposing Transnet tender fraud. Picture: SAPS A warrant for the arrest of Lucky Boitumelo Molefe has been issued in connection with the murder of 30-year-old engineer, Armard Swart. Swart, an employee at Q Tech Engineering Company based in Vereeniging, was shot and killed while seated in his vehicle outside his workplace by two suspects who were driving a white Hyundai i20 on 17 April 2024. Police said he sustained multiple gunshot wounds and was declared deceased on the scene.

Justice seems elusive as the accused in the Sindiso Magaqa murder pleads guilty
Justice seems elusive as the accused in the Sindiso Magaqa murder pleads guilty

The Star

time16 hours ago

  • The Star

Justice seems elusive as the accused in the Sindiso Magaqa murder pleads guilty

Nearly eight years after the assassination of former ANC Youth League secretary-general Sindiso Magaqa, a key breakthrough in the long-running murder case has finally arrived. One of the four men charged with his killing, Sibusiso Ncengwa, has pleaded guilty in the Pietermaritzburg High Court, admitting to pulling the trigger in the 2017 shooting. National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) spokesperson Natasha Ramkisson-Kara confirmed that Ncengwa, who was charged alongside Sbonelo Myeza, Mlungisi Ncalane and Mbulelo Mpofana, admitted to the murder of Magaqa and several related crimes during court proceedings on 6 June 2025. His confession marks a pivotal moment in a case that has drawn national attention and exposed deep political tensions in KwaZulu-Natal. According to the NPA, Ncengwa submitted formal admissions in terms of Section 220 of the Criminal Procedure Act. These included admitting to the murder of Magaqa on 13 July 2017 in uMzimkhulu, the attempted murder of Jabulile Msiya, Nonsikelelo Mafa and Nceba Mazongolo, malicious damage to property involving the victims' vehicles, and unlawful possession of a firearm. The court found Ncengwa guilty based on his admissions. His sentencing is scheduled for 30 June 2025. Meanwhile, his co-accused, Myeza and Mpofana, will appear in court on 19 June 2025 for a new indictment following the separation of their trial from Ncengwa's. The fourth accused, Mlungisi Ncalane, has been declared unfit to stand trial and is currently admitted to a psychiatric facility. Ncengwa's detailed confession outlined the planning, coordination, and execution of the attack, implicating all the accused in a plot that has long been suspected to be politically motivated.

Ten Dead in Austrian School Shooting
Ten Dead in Austrian School Shooting

IOL News

time18 hours ago

  • IOL News

Ten Dead in Austrian School Shooting

IOL Ten people are dead following a suspected school shooting in the southeastern Austrian city of Graz on Tuesday. Ten people are dead following a suspected school shooting in the southeastern Austrian city of Graz on Tuesday, in what officials are calling one of the deadliest mass shootings in the country's recent history. Among the deceased are several students, at least one adult, and the suspected shooter, according to Graz Mayor Elke Kahr, who confirmed the fatalities to the Austrian Press Agency (APA). The shooting unfolded earlier in the day at a local school, prompting a massive police operation. Law enforcement authorities said on the social media platform X (formerly Twitter) that gunshots had been reported inside the building, triggering an emergency response. 'Currently, a police operation is underway... The reason for the deployment was that gunshots were heard in the building,' police posted. The building has since been secured, though details surrounding the motive and exact sequence of events remain unclear. "The situation is very unclear at the moment," police sources told APA. Austrian police and interior ministry officials have not issued a detailed statement as of Tuesday evening, and they were not immediately reachable for comment by AFP. The suspected shooter is believed to be among the ten fatalities, although authorities have not yet released any identities or indicated whether the shooter was a student, staff member, or outsider. The tragedy has sent shockwaves through Austria and beyond. European Union foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas expressed her condolences, calling the incident 'deeply shocking.' 'Every child should feel safe at school and be able to learn free from fear and violence,' Kallas wrote on X.. 'My thoughts are with the victims, their families and the Austrian people in this dark moment.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store