Maharashtra consumer commission orders builder to pay Rs 12 lakh for delay, missing amenities
Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar: The Maharashtra State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission bench at Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar found a construction company guilty of
deficiency in service
and directed it to pay over Rs 12 lakh to three complainants for delayed flat possession, missing amenities, and mental harassment.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
The bench, comprising presiding member Milind Sonawane and members Dr Nisha Chavhan and Nagesh Kumbre, delivered the order on April 24 after hearing the complaint filed jointly by Manjusha Bharadkar, Sunil Bharadkar, and Saurabh Bharadkar through their lawyer Naseem Shaikh.
Advocate Shaikh told TOI, "The trio booked flats in the builder's project, but the possession was allegedly delayed, and even the essential amenities that were promised at the time of booking the flats were not provided despite full payment."
On hearing both sides, the commission held that the builder's failure to deliver possession on time and non-fulfilment of promised facilities constituted a clear deficiency in service under the
Consumer Protection Act
.
In a key direction, the commission ordered the construction firm '
Golden Dreams Builders Pvt Ltd
' to provide the promised amenities within three months from the date of the order. The commission, in its judgement, mentioned that these amenities include water supply, electricity, parking, compound wall, main entrance gate, underground drainage, and a transformer — all of which were part of the original agreement with the buyers.
Additionally, the construction company was directed to issue the completion certificate for the flats within the same three-month period. As compensation, the commission ordered the company to pay Rs 5 lakh jointly to Manjusha and Sunil Bharadkar and Rs 5 lakh to Saurabh Bharadkar, along with 9% annual interest from the date of complaint filing — August 23, 2018 — until full realisation of the amount. Furthermore, the builder was directed to pay Rs 1.5 lakh towards compensation for mental harassment caused to the complainants and Rs 50,000 towards litigation expenses.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
In its detailed order, the commission strongly emphasised that builders must honour their commitments made to homebuyers at the time of agreement and cannot be allowed to ignore contractual obligations after collecting payment. The commission stated that the delay and non-availability of basic infrastructure led to considerable inconvenience, which warranted substantial compensation.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
20 minutes ago
- Time of India
IITMS pilot project nears completion at key traffic junctions
Nagpur: The Rs 197-crore Integrated Intelligent Traffic Management System (IITMS) pilot project neared completion at ten critical traffic intersections across the city, confirmed additional municipal commissioner Vaishnavi B. The initiative represents a significant step towards modernising urban traffic management. The project involved installing advanced CCTVs, sensors, and UPS batteries and reached its final stages. Sources indicated that installation work was completed at all 10 locations, and the focus shifted to rigorous testing and connection checks. This phase ensured that all components, including wiring and footage connectivity, functioned optimally. At Kachipura intersection, land development and cable pooling work commenced, paving the way for implementing automated traffic signals (ATS). Although integrating artificial intelligence (AI) into the system will take additional time, most junctions were anticipated to be AI-enabled within the next few days. The command and control centre (COC) expected to display all junctions shortly, although minor network issues related to the smart city infrastructure were being addressed. "The pilot project is not merely a test but a comprehensive evaluation of the system's functionality. Once all components are verified, the project will be presented to the commissioner for approval. This demonstration will ensure that the system meets the required standards before full-scale implementation, which is projected to be completed by December 2026," said Vaishnavi.
Time of India
25 minutes ago
- Time of India
MCG plans 20% hike in water tariff to bridge revenue gap, seeks uniform billing
Gurgaon: Metered water supply rates for residential plotted areas may go up by 20%, while unmetered water connections may see a 50% hike if an MCG proposal submitted to urban local bodies (ULB) department goes through. The corporation's proposal stems from the substantial difference between the amount MCG pays to GMDA for bulk water supply and the charges collected from residents for water services. MCG chief engineer Vijay Dhaka says the steep hike of rates for the unmetered connections "is to encourage people to have metered water connections" — hence the proposal to increase the water and sewerage charges by 20% for the metered connections in the residential areas and 50% for the unmetered connections". MCG suggests implementing uniform rates citywide by adopting the Haryana Urban Development Authority (HUDA) notice of Jan 12, 2018, with slight modifications to reduce the revenue-expenditure gap. MCG currently follows two different charging mechanisms: one for areas transferred from HSVP builder areas and another for old Gurgaon and villages. In HSVP sectors, certain private developers have established townships and colonies. Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Giao dịch vàng CFDs với mức chênh lệch giá thấp nhất IC Markets Đăng ký Undo These private builders were responsible for maintaining and operating water supply and sewerage services. It is mentioned in the MCG's proposal that GMDA supplied bulk water to these colonies at a rate of Rs 10 per kilolitre, in accordance with govt policy. Following this, five colonies, namely Palam Vihar, Suncity, Sushant Lok-1, South City-1 and South City-2, were transferred to MCG in 2019. Currently, MCG collects user charges for water supply and sewerage services in both HSVP sectors and these townships, based on Haryana Urban Development Authority (HUDA) notification dated Jan 12, 2018. For residential plotted colonies, water charges are Rs 2.5 per KL for initial 10 KL usage, followed by Rs 5 per KL for subsequent 10 KL as per this notification. Rural areas pay Rs 2 per kilolitre for water and sewerage services, as per PHED notification of April 3, 2017. This rate is double what MCG charges from old Gurgaon and incorporated villages, based on ULB department rates from March 9, 2011 notification. The corporation has identified rate inconsistencies between the two notifications that determine charges across different city areas under MCG jurisdiction. This variation in revenue collection could potentially cause legal issues, the civic body has noted in its proposal. The MCG's submission to ULB department indicates that it receives approximately 80 lakh kilolitres of drinking water monthly through 148 bulk connections at Rs 10 per kilolitre, distributing to old town, villages, HSVP sectors and private builder areas. The corporation pays about Rs 10 crore monthly to GMDA for bulk supply and sewerage maintenance, plus additional maintenance and leakage costs. However, monthly revenue collection remains at Rs 5 crore, creating financial strain. The corporation suggests increasing institutional metered connection charges from Rs 10 per KL to Rs 12 per KL and industrial and commercial metered connection charges from Rs 15 per KL to Rs 18 per KL. Chaitali Mandhotra, a resident of Ardee City, said, "Water and sewerage charges are a complete mess in Ardee City. There are people who have not installed metres and they are getting bills amounting to a flat rate of Rs 550 plus taxes." "Then, people are getting bills for the metered connection as per the HUDA notification. Moreover, there is a third category of people like me, who have already installed a water meter. However, I am still getting a flat bill like those with unmetered water connections. Moreover, in our colony, a majority of the houses are ground-plus-two floors. In these residential buildings, some units are getting one bill only for all three floors. However, some are getting three separate bills. So, this billing system needs to be regulated."
Time of India
25 minutes ago
- Time of India
Chandigarh administration to provide 10% job reservation and increased compensation for Agniveers and Armed forces families
1 2 Chandigarh: The UT administration is set to offer a 10% reservation in government jobs for Agniveers. Acting on a recommendation from Zila Sainik Board, the administration plans to implement this reservation in all direct recruitment for Group B and Group C posts. The move aims to recognise the Agniveers' service and dedication to national security, ensuring better employment opportunities for them after their military tenure. A meeting of Zila Sainik Board (ZSB), Chandigarh, was convened on Tuesday under the chairmanship of Nishant Kumar Yadav, deputy commissioner-cum-president, ZSB, Chandigarh. The meeting was attended by Brig BS Dhillon (retd), vice-president ZSB; Lt Col Sanjeev Sharma, representative of Station HQ Chandigarh; Lt Col RK Singh (retd); Shri KK Sharda (social worker); and Col HS Ghuman (retd), Zila Sainik Welfare Officer. The board deliberated on key issues pertaining to the welfare of ex-servicemen and their families. After thorough discussions, the board forwarded some proposals to the administration. It proposed to increase the rate of ex gratia compensation from the existing Rs 50 lakh to Rs 1 crore for the families of soldiers of the Defence Armed Forces and Paramilitary Forces who are martyred in action. The board also proposed the introduction of a new scheme to provide one-time financial assistance of Rs 1 lakh to the next of kin of defence personnel who lose their lives in harness and are declared 'physical casualty (fatal)' other than those occurring in battle. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Giao dịch vàng CFDs với mức chênh lệch giá thấp nhất IC Markets Đăng ký Undo The deputy commissioner emphasised the urgent need to renovate the Sainik Rest House in Sector 21 and instructed the officials of the ZSB to coordinate with the chief engineer to expedite the process of floating the tender and initiate the renovation work as per the approved plan.
