Libel lawyer seeks to have defence in his defamation action against publisher struck out
Libel lawyer Paul Tweed has asked the
High Court
to strike out a defence of truth being pleaded in a defamation case he is taking against a US publisher.
Mr Tweed claims part of an academic book entitled Subversion: The Strategic Weaponization of Narratives is defamatory because it
falsely portrays him as a 'subversive, covert agent' of the United Arab Emirates
(UAE).
The book was published by the Georgetown University Press in 2023 and written by Andreas Krieg, who teaches in King's College, London.
The court heard that Mr Tweed claims, among other things, the book falsely claims he improperly writes warning letters and/or institutes legal proceedings for the purposes of silencing voices in the West who are critical of the UAE.
READ MORE
It also falsely claims he is portrayed as a solicitor who uses his legal practice improperly to protect or advance the UAE political regime, he says.
The book also contains an argument about how certain countries use 'decentralised networks of a variety of actors, paid agents, wilful pawns and sometimes useful idiots' in order to mobilise information networks with the ultimate goal of undermining social, political consensus.
Mr Tweed claims damages and seeks an injunction requiring the removal of the book from sale or the correcting of the allegedly defamatory paragraphs.
The claims are denied and Georgetown Press pleads the defence of truth.
On Thursday, Mr Justice Micheál O'Higgins began hearing arguments on a motion filed on behalf of Mr Tweed as to why the defence of truth should be struck out or alternatively the defendant should be required to amend its defence. The defence will deliver its reply on Friday.
Mr Tweed specialises in defamation law and is representing former Sinn Féin leader Gerry Adams, whose action against the BBC is at hearing in the High Court. He also represents businessman Declan Ganley in a case against the US news broadcaster CNN which has yet to be heard.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
US and China agree to framework deal to restore trade war truce
The US and China have agreed to a framework that restores a truce in their trade war after two days of marathon negotiations in London. The breakthrough late on Tuesday followed an agreement in Geneva last month aimed at easing trade tensions between the world's two economic superpowers, which had faltered over differences regarding Chinese rare earth exports and US export controls. The US team, which included commerce secretary Howard Lutnick and US trade representative Jamieson Greer, will return to Washington to present the deal to US President Donald Trump , Mr Lutnick said. He did not provide any details about the framework. Li Chenggang, China's vice-minister of commerce, described the talks as 'rational, in-depth and candid', and said the sides had agreed to implement the consensus reached in Geneva and in a phone call between Trump and Chinese president Xi Jinping last week, according to state news agency Xinhua. READ MORE He expressed hope that the progress made in London 'will be conducive to strengthening trust between China and the United States'. China's CSI 300 index of Shanghai- and Shenzhen-listed stocks rose 0.8 per cent on Wednesday, while Hong Kong's Hang Seng benchmark was up about 1 per cent. [ How a man described as 'dumber than a sack of bricks' came to dominate global trade policy Opens in new window ] Both countries agreed in Geneva last month to slash their respective tariffs by 115 percentage points and provided a 90-day window to resolve the trade war. But the ceasefire came under pressure after Washington accused Beijing of reneging on an agreement to speed up the export of rare earths, while China criticised new US export controls. The US team, which also included treasury secretary Scott Bessent, had held two days of talks with the Chinese delegation, led by He Lifeng, a vice-premier responsible for the economy. Earlier on Tuesday, Lutnick said the talks could stretch into a third day. How to manage your pension in these volatile times Listen | 37:00 Mr Bessent left London before the talks ended to return to Washington ahead of a previously scheduled plan to testify before Congress on Wednesday. The talks were held in the historic Lancaster House mansion in central London, a short walk from Buckingham Palace, which was provided by the British government as a neutral ground for the talks. The negotiations were launched to ensure Chinese exports of rare earths to the US and American technology export controls on China did not derail broader talks between the sides. Ahead of the first round of talks in Geneva, Mr Bessent had warned that the high level of mutual tariffs had amounted to an effective embargo on bilateral trade. [ US tariffs will result in shock to global growth but not recession, World Bank says Opens in new window ] Chinese exports to the US fell more steeply in May on a year earlier than at any point since the pandemic in 2020. The US had said China was not honouring its pledge in Geneva to ease restrictions on rare earths exports, which are critical to the defence, car and tech industries, and was dragging its feet over approving licences for shipments, affecting manufacturing supply chains in the US and Europe. Beijing has accused the US of 'seriously violating' the Geneva agreement after it announced new restrictions on sales of chip design software to Chinese companies. It has also objected to the US issuing new warnings on global use of Huawei chips, and cancelling visas for Chinese students. On Monday, a senior White House official indicated that Trump could ease restrictions on selling chips to China if Beijing agreed to speed up the export of rare earths. That would amount to a significant policy shift from former president Joe Biden's administration, which implemented what it called a 'small yard, high fence' approach to restrict Beijing's ability to obtain US technology that could be used to help its military. Separately, a US federal appeals court on Tuesday allowed some of Trump's broadest tariffs to remain in place while it reviews a lower-court ruling that had blocked his 'liberation day' levies on US trading partners. The ruling extended an earlier, temporary reprieve, and will allow Trump to enact the measures as well as separate levies targeting Mexico, Canada and China. The president has however already paused the wider 'reciprocal' tariffs for 90 days. – Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2025
Irish Times
2 days ago
- Irish Times
US says trade talks with China ‘going well' as sides reconvene
The US said talks with China were 'going well' as the two sides resumed efforts in London to end a trade war between the world's largest economies. The delegations arrived at Lancaster House, a UK government building in the centre of the city, just after 10.30am, on Tuesday with US commerce secretary Howard Lutnick saying that the discussions would go deep into the day. 'We've been [talking] all day yesterday and we expect to go all day today. The talks are going well, we're spending lots of time together,' he told reporters. The talks between Chinese vice-premier He Lifeng and US officials, including Treasury secretary Scott Bessent , followed a call last week between US President Donald Trump and China's president Xi Jinping . READ MORE The meeting marked the first face-to-face talks between Mr He and Mr Bessent since a 90-day truce brokered on May 12th in Geneva, when they agreed to slash their nations' respective tariffs on the other by 115 percentage points. Since then, the truce has been tested by Chinese foot-dragging over approvals of rare-earth shipments that are critical to the defence, car and tech industries, in a move that has affected manufacturing supply chains in both the US and Europe. [ How a man described as 'dumber than a sack of bricks' came to dominate global trade policy Opens in new window ] Beijing has in turn accused Washington of 'seriously violating' the Geneva agreement by issuing new warnings on using Huawei chips globally, halting sales of chip design software to Chinese companies and cancelling visas for Chinese students. Ahead of this week's talks, senior White House officials indicated Trump could ease restrictions on selling chips to China if Beijing agreed to speed up the export of rare earths. – Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2025
Irish Examiner
3 days ago
- Irish Examiner
"A country can't fight on empty stomachs": the importance of a mobile bakery in Ukraine
When Russia invaded Ukraine in February 2022, Felicity Spector, a London-based TV news journalist and food influencer, wanted to help, not least because her paternal grandparents left Dnipro for London in the early 1900s, forced into exile by the wave of pogroms sweeping the Russian Empire. Not wanting to just be 'sitting at home, thinking, 'This is awful',' she got practical. Having been in touch with a Kyiv-based bakery for a potential news item, Spector subsequently found out 'that their warehouse had been bombed and they'd lost all their equipment and spare ingredients: Everything'. Her passion for food blogging meant she knew many London bakery owners, who, she felt, might have old or unused equipment they'd be willing to donate. Her hunch was bang on. 'Anna, who ran the bakery in Kyiv, gave me a list, and within 48 hours I'd found all of it.' A friend put Spector in touch with charity Sunflower Aid, 'and they said, 'OK, let's fill up the vans with all this stuff and drive to Ukraine'.' Spector provided 'the in-car entertainment' as they drove from London to Kyiv with the equipment and supplies, which the bakery then used to make free bread for people in need. While in Ukraine, she heard about Bake for Ukraine, a non-profit run by volunteers. 'It was working with very small bakeries, making free bread for communities that needed it. I thought, 'Wow'. I really wanted to do what I could for them, so that's how that relationship started.' Bake for Ukraine was co-founded by Odesa-born food writer and chef Maria Kalenska, who is, Spector says, 'Very passionate about spreading knowledge about Ukrainian bread culture.' Ukraine has long been known as the 'bread basket of Europe', with its blue-and-yellow flag symbolising the country's endless golden wheatfields under a vivid blue sky. 'They've always had amazing quality wheat, rye, and sunflower seeds, so, obviously, you make bread,' Spector says. 'Ukraine has a history of bread-making and many traditions and holidays are marked by specific breads.' When Spector met Kalenska, the Ukrainian was searching for a mobile bakery. The power cuts of the winter of 2022 had highlighted the need for flexibility in getting bread to people enduring prolonged blackouts and Kalenska had a specific vehicle in mind: A Swiss military mobile bakery built during the Cold War, 100 of which had been donated by a charity to Ukraine 20 years ago. Most had since been stripped for parts, but Kalenska located one in good condition near to her home city of Odesa. Spector set up a JustGiving page, which, in a matter of days, had reached £15,000 (she later discovered that British food critic Jay Rayner had posted the link on his Sunday food column, 'one of the many acts of incredible kindness we've witnessed on our bakery journey'). Spector travelled to Izmil with the Bake for Ukraine team to purchase the truck. They brought everything needed to bake test loaves of bread, including a precious sourdough starter of Kalenska's. Eleven hours after they arrived — sourdough takes time — they were tucking in to buttery, warm slices of bread, with the rest of the day's loaves packed up, ready to be donated to a local national guard unit. It would still need to be transported and serviced, but the mobile bakery was ready. A SYMBOL OF UKRAINIAN IDENTITY Spector has since travelled to Ukraine many times, using up all her holidays and taking unpaid leave to volunteer with Bake for Ukraine. She has documented many of her encounters in her book, Bread & War, 'a collection of stories about people who work or volunteer in food and how they've kept the country going during the full-scale war'. Bake for Ukraine's refurbished mobile bakery is based in Mykolaiv — a war-torn city that's still subject to kamikaze drone attacks — where it supplies bread to villagers close to the front line. The mobile bakers make sourdough palyanytsya, a bread that's become 'a kind of symbol of Ukrainian identity', says Spector, explaining that due to phonetic differences between the Ukrainian and Russian languages, Russians cannot pronounce the word for the traditional Ukrainian round loaf. At the beginning of the invasion, 'palyanytsya' became a shibboleth, a way of identifying enemy agents. If you couldn't say it, you were under suspicion; if you could, you were likely trustworthy. Kalenska told Spector she chose 'palyanytsya' for the mobile bakeries because of its heritage. 'She said 'We know this is our part of our soul. This is who we are. We are honouring the wheat and we're making something which is really beautiful'.' It's also practical: The bread, a rich recipe of flour, milk, water, butter, sugar, and salt, keeps for more than a week and receiving it is emotional for people living in devastated regions. Bread and War by Felicity Spector In Bread & War, Spector writes, 'On one trip to a badly damaged village, a woman was so delighted to see some proper Ukrainian palyanytsya that she held it to her face for several minutes, smelling and kissing the loaf over and over again.' The legacy of the Holodomor, the Stalin-induced famine of the 1930s, means in Ukraine that bread is never wasted, Spector says. 'Nobody would throw away even a crust of bread, because their grandparents said 'No, you can't, we had to eat grass. We would never waste anything. You can't throw away bread. It's valuable'.' The mobile bakery was producing 200 loaves of nutritious sourdough daily, but thanks to a recent volunteer from the Netherlands bringing a new, more efficient mixer, the output of loaves has doubled. A US grant means the volunteers can be paid, Spector says, and two more refurbished mobile bakeries are just about ready to go, thanks to fund-raising efforts by Stateside bakeries. Ukrainians aren't 'sitting around' waiting for Westerners to come and help, though. 'They're getting on with it,' Spector says. 'There's this really strong community spirit. Obviously, there's this terrible thing that's happening, but it has brought people together, and even though they are living through horrific times, lots of people somehow find the energy to do something for someone who's even worse off.' FORGET ABOUT WAR FOR A MINUTE Felicity Spector, author of Bread and War: 'I feel really invested in continuing to be there and to be helping as much as I can. I love seeing my friends and the sense of being connected with them.' One such person is Natalia, whom Spector met at the end of 2022 while travelling on a charity mission with Dmytro, a drummer with pop group Antytila. (The group, who gave up their musical careers to enlist, collaborated with Ed Sheeran on a remix of his hit, 2Step, to raise money for the charity they set up in 2014, when Crimea was illegally annexed by Russia.) Natalia, who'd run a small shop and café before the war, had begun making simple food for the Ukrainian troops who'd stopped for coffee at the remote outpost in the Dnipropetrovsk region on their way to the front line. Her volunteer-run kitchen now feeds 2,000 to 3,000 people daily, and also provides washing machines, so muddy, weary soldiers can launder their clothes. Natalia, whose son is serving in the army, told Spector, 'I want them to be able to sit next to each other and talk to each other over some food. They can forget about war for a minute and just have something nourishing that's been made by hand.' Bread & War is replete with such stories of resilience and hope, struggle and sustenance, innovation, and tradition. Spector is bringing copies with her when she returns to Ukraine in a few weeks' time. 'I want to give a book to everybody who has helped me out,' she says. 'I feel really invested in continuing to be there and to be helping as much as I can. I love seeing my friends and the sense of being connected with them.' There are many more Ukrainian stories for her to tell. Bread & War by Felicity Spector, published by Duckworth, is out now Read More Louise O'Neill among writers pushing the boundaries of theatre at Cork Midsummer Festival
