March for Welsh independence warned they face 'uphill battle'
March for Welsh independence warned they face 'uphill battle'
Thousands of people took to the streets of Barry on Saturday for the March for Independence
(Image: Mark Lewis )
Over the weekend, more than 6,000 people took to the streets of Barry in a march for Welsh independence, sparking conversation among Wales Online readers. Supporters from all over Wales, some accompanied by their children, participated in the March for Independence, an event organised by YesCymru and AUOBCymru.
Since 2019, thousands have joined independence marches in various locations across Wales – including Caernarfon, Merthyr, Wrexham, Bangor, Swansea, Carmarthen and Cardiff. This time, it was Barry's turn to host the march.
The organisers highlighted the town's significant role in the Cymru Fydd movement for Welsh self-government in the 1890s.
Following the march, a rally was held in King Square, featuring speeches from supporters such as former Plaid Cymru leader Leanne Wood, Catalan campaigner Anna Arqué i Solsona, political activist Kiera Marshall, Wales Green Party spokesperson Tessa Marshall and singer-songwriter Eädyth Crawford.
The rally, hosted by Vale of Glamorgan Plaid Cymru councillor Mark Hooper, also featured live music from Emma Winter, known from Y Llais, the Welsh version of The Voice.
In a first for the March for Independence, all speakers and performers – with the exception of the MC – were women.
Article continues below
However, people commenting on WalesOnline were sceptical that independence was viable. Tannerbanc said: " I am as proud as anyone to be Welsh but compared to the past most industry has been lost in Wales, do we generate enough wealth here (GDP) to pay for the public services that are demanded ? especially by those who do not contribute towards it. Unfortunately we are far too much a a public sector and benefits country, who do these people think pays for that ? They should travel across the PoW bridge now and then and see there are far more areas of prosperity there and they are subsidizing Wales. Then there is the issue of government, has the Senedd really benefited Wales ? I think most people would say no, the Senedd could hold a referendum to ask that question to know for sure?"
Andypandy60 adds: "Whilst being a great country to live in and especially living in the Vale of Glamorgan, it is not a place that can support itself. We are half the size of Scotland and we depend on financial support from Westminster, without that we would be a third world country. The Senedd has not done us any favours. As for 25 years Labour has had the monopoly. Next year in the elections, it will be interesting to see how well Reform and Plaid Cymru perform.
Barbarap states: "The clue is in the title United Kingdom which is what we need to be. Hopefully, to regain our place on the world stage. The money that has been spent on the Welsh assembly could fund face to face GP appointments and therefore relieve the amount of times A&E is being used."
Boyo1958 says: "I am strongly for the language but not PC on the whole. Where is the money coming from to resolve the issues that the Senedd has created over the past years? With only 3 million people, it is not enough to run the country. By all means, protect and encourage more Welsh language uptake but otherwise forget Independence."
Violentrevoltnow writes: "The Yes Cymru movement faces an uphill battle against a system that thrives on dependency, manipulation, and deception. Independence may sound empowering, but the reality is that the very industries sustaining the UK, those tied to crime, addiction, and poverty, are deeply entrenched and reliant on systemic dysfunction. Breaking away doesn't eliminate these issues; it risks amplifying them within a smaller, less resilient framework.
Article continues below
"Devolved governments have already demonstrated the flaws in this path, struggling to manage the balance between autonomy and dependency. The public, driven by surface-level narratives, demands change without realizing they're feeding the cycle that undermines true progress. Independence under these conditions isn't liberation, it's stepping deeper into a system designed to perpetuate control and dependency."
Do you think that Wales would prosper if they gained independence? Join in the conversation HERE or in the comments below.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Powys County Times
8 hours ago
- Powys County Times
Farage to call for Port Talbot blast furnaces to reopen
Nigel Farage will call for Port Talbot's blast furnaces to reopen after they were shut down last year as Reform UK sets its sights on the Welsh elections in 2026. On a visit to the South Wales town, the party leader is expected to say that the resumption of traditional steelmaking should be a long-term ambition, a spokesman said. Mr Farage believes his party has a chance of ending Labour's long-standing dominance in Wales during the Senedd elections next year amid opinion poll momentum and gains made at the local polls last month. The Government has backed plans for a new £1.25 billion electric arc furnace at the Tata steelworks, with the switch-on due in 2027 as part of the push towards greener production. The plant's last blast furnace was shut down in September 2024. Some MPs have said workers in South Wales have been let down in comparison with those retaining jobs in Scunthorpe, where ministers took control of the steelworks to prevent the closure of its blast furnaces. The Government has said the two steelworks were in different situations. Mr Farage's speech comes as Reform seeks to draw a line under internal clashes after chairman Zia Yusuf quit the party on Thursday only to return 48 hours later, saying the resignation had been 'born out of exhaustion'. It followed a row in which he described a question to the Prime Minister concerning a ban on burkas from his party's newest MP, Sarah Pochin, as 'dumb'. Mr Yusuf will now have four jobs, including leading the party's plans to cut public spending via the so-called 'UK Doge', based on the US Department of Government Efficiency which was led by tech billionaire Elon Musk. Mr Farage's spokesman said: 'He will focus part of the speech on Keir Starmer's year of failure in the UK as a whole but especially Wales. Of course for years Welsh Labour blamed all issues on the Tories in Westminster, now their excuse is gone and the game is up for them.' Reform had also been hoping to cause an upset last week in Scotland, where it was fighting a Holyrood by-election in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse, but Labour secured a shock victory. Scotland's First Minister John Swinney had claimed the contest would be a 'two-horse race' between the SNP and Reform but Mr Farage's party came third with 7,088 votes to Labour's 8,559 and the SNP's 7,957.
Wales Online
10 hours ago
- Wales Online
Nigel Farage reveals his vision and promises to Wales
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info The 1851 census recorded that more people in Wales were employed in industry than in agriculture, a first for any country, meaning it has the claim to be the first industrial nation. And for a time, Wales was undeniably an industrial powerhouse. Wales once produced almost 60 million tons of coal per year and South Wales alone was the biggest coal exporter in the world. The Cardiff Coal Exchange set the global price for steam coal and Swansea smelted most of the world's copper. Merthyr Tydfil was the world's largest producer of iron and the Port Talbot Steelworks were once the largest steel plant in Europe. Much of that is now gone. Wales's economy lags the UK in jobs, wages & growth and the deindustrialisation of Wales means that GDP per capita is £10,000 less than the UK. For many years Welsh Labour blamed the Conservatives in Westminster for this and, in fact, for all other ills. However, the truth is that Labour are just as much as responsible, if not more so than the Tories. Since the first elections to the then Welsh Assembly in 1999, Labour has been in power in Cardiff Bay for 26 years, the longest term in government of any party in Europe. With Labour now holding office in Westminster, Welsh Labour have no one left to blame. Next May voters in Wales will get the opportunity to vote in the Senedd elections and have the opportunity to not only to pass judgment on Labour's track record but also decide on the future direction of the nation. They can choose from more of the same mismanaged decline from Labour, or they can vote for a party, Reform, that unashamedly wants to see Wales reindustrialise to prosper and grow. Labour closed Wales' only primary steel making furnaces, we want to open them in the long run. We have said and say again that we think it's better to use British coal for British steel than imported coal. Which is why we would allow coal, if suitable, to be mined in Wales as part of Reform's long-term ambition to reopen the Port Talbot Steelworks but we know this will not be quick or easy. A Reform-run Senedd would also use Welsh Development Grants to support real industry. We'll redirect economic funding from consultants and NGOs to actual factory floors, machinery, and industrial jobs in places like Llanelli, Shotton, and Ebbw Vale. We'll also set up regional technical colleges teaching welding, plumbing, robotics, electrical trades, and industrial automation. Every young person who wants to work should have a path into a proper trade. More than that, we will change the way Wales is run. We will put the interests of the Welsh people first and make sure that local people go to the front of the social housing queue. We'd stop the use of any building for asylum seeker accommodation. We would end funding to the Wales Refugee Council and scrap the 'Nation of Sanctuary' for asylum seekers and any funding that goes with it. For WalesOnline's free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation, sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here A Reform UK Senedd will also save hundreds of millions each year by cutting bureaucracy, waste and bad management. The establishment of Welsh DOGE will help us uncover where there is woke and wasteful spending and we will make sure those funds are redirected to frontline services. People might say these are lofty ambitions for a party that currently has no representation in the Senedd, but its clear that the people of Wales want Reform. Our growth in Wales has been extraordinary. We now have almost 11,000 members and tens of thousands of supporters. We are winning Council by-elections in Wales with almost 50 per cent of the vote. The result in Scotland last week confirmed to us that we if we can do that well in Scotland, then we can win here in Wales. It also made clear that a vote for the Conservatives is a vote for Labour, it's more obvious than ever before that the Tories can't win in Wales. The only party that can end Labour's 26 years of failure in Wales and put the nation on a better path is Reform and I am confident we can do it.
Wales Online
17 hours ago
- Wales Online
Nigel Farage issues stark message to Wales ahead of visit
Nigel Farage issues stark message to Wales ahead of visit The Reform UK leader is due to make a speech in Port Talbot on Monday Nigel Farage (Image: PA Wire/PA Images ) Nigel Farage has issued a stark message to Wales ahead of visiting to make a speech. The Reform UK leader will visit Port Talbot on Monday June 9 to give a speech to garner support for his party ahead of the Welsh assembly elections next year. A recent YouGov poll placed Reform in second place behind Plaid Cymru. Labour, which has topped every assembly election since devolution more than a quarter of a century ago, languishes in third in the poll. Farage is now jockeying to position Reform as the main challenger party in Wales. He told the Sunday Times: 'We've done what we've done in England; we're going to have a very credible message after what happened in Scotland. Article continues below "Monday is above all a statement of intent: Welsh politics, we're coming to get you." Sign up for our free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here. Mr Farage was speaking with Zia Yusuf, the donor and businessman who is coming back to Reform UK just 48 hours after his shock resignation as the party's chairman. Mr Yusuf will now take up a new role. In an interview with The Sunday Times the 38-year-old businessman said his resignation was a 'mistake' and the result of 'exhaustion' and working for 11 months 'without a day off'. Article continues below He resigned on Friday after saying it was 'dumb' of the party's newest MP to ask Prime Minister Keir Starmer if he would ban the burqa when that is not even a Reform UK policy. Mr Yusuf said at the time that working to get Reform UK elected was not a good use of his time but has now changed his mind and will return to lead Reform's Elon Musk-style Doge unit, to scrutinise and cut council spending.
