Sentencing hearing for disgraced Cree medicine man shows 'breathtaking impact' of sexual assaults
Warning: this story discusses sexual assault.
A Saskatoon prosecutor says that Cecil Wolfe's sexual assaults over nine years had a "breathtaking impact" on his victims and community.
"He breached a significant position of trust," prosecutor Lana Morelli said Tuesday at Court of King's Bench.
"The victims' own trauma was compounded by the sexual assaults by a trusted healer."
The 63-year-old pleaded guilty before Justice John Morrall in February to a dozen sexual assaults. Wolfe returned to court this week to hear from his victims and the submissions from Morelli, co-chair Maria Shupenia and defence lawyer Harvey Neufeld.
Both the defence and Crown say Wolfe will face time in a federal penitentiary. The defence is asking for a sentence in the four to five year range. The Crown is arguing for 10 years and nine months.
Morelli said the case presents unique challenges in terms of finding comparable cases as a reference for sentencing. Medical cases typically lack a spiritual component, while religious abuses lack the medical element.
"A medicine man is a symbol of culture, tradition, spirituality — and the healing as a doctor," she said.
The defence filed seven letters of support for Wolfe, but Morelli said one of the notes had a troubling aspect. It appears that Wolfe continued to treat at least one woman since his charges, "and this appears in violation of his release conditions."
She said the Crown is agreeing that so-called Gladue factors do play into the sentencing submissions — "he had a life shaped by colonialism" — but that his culture had not been stripped away.
Further, even though he only went to Grade 3 in his education, "he has 63 years of life experience," Morelli said.
"Lack of education does not mean he should not appreciate that his actions are wrong."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
2 hours ago
Defence targets E.M.'s credibility, judge questions 'consent videos' shown at world juniors sex assault trial
Headlines Latest News Podcasts (new window) Composite image shows five former NHL players accused of sexually assaulting a woman at a London, Ont., hotel in 2018 when they were on Canada's 2018 world junior hockey team. Each is shown entering the courthouse Monday: Dillon Dubé, Cal Foote, Alex Formenton, Carter Hart and Michael McLeod, left to right. (Carlos Osorio/Reuters) Photo: (Nicole Osborne/CP, Nicole Osborne/CP, Nicole Osborne/CP, Brett Gundlock/Reuters, Nicole Osborne/CP) Defence teams have begun closing arguments at London, Ont., trial. The sexual assault trial that began in late April for five former Hockey Canada world junior players continues today in Ontario Superior Court. Each of the five defence teams and the Crown will have a chance to present their closing arguments. Defence lawyer David Humphrey is targeting the complainant E.M.'s reliability as a witness. He argued E.M. 'chose to abandon restraint' and has refused to take any personal responsibility for her own actions on the night of June 18-19, 2018. Four of the five accused men — Michael McLeod, Dillon Dubé, Alex Formenton and Cal Foote — chose not to testify in their own defence. Carter Hart testified earlier in the trial. All five men have pleaded not guilty to the alleged assaults in a London hotel room. McLeod has also pleaded not guilty to being a party to the offence. WARNING: Court proceedings include graphic details of alleged sexual assault and might affect those who have experienced sexual violence or know someone who's been affected. Lucas Powers (new window) Throughout the weeks-long trial, demonstrators have regularly appeared outside the London courthouse as the defendants, lawyers and observers arrive for proceedings. Many voice support for the complainant, carrying signs with messages like, I believe you E.M. and We believe survivors. But they've also been confronted by some people who say the lives and reputations of five men have been irrevocably damaged by allegations of sexual assault. The polarization on the courthouse steps echoes a broader debate on social media and in discussions across Canada as this high-profile trial plays out under tremendous public scrutiny. My colleague, Karen Paul, took a closer look into how the trial has become a flashpoint for both the #MeToo and #HimToo movements, and what research indicates. You can read her feature reporting here (new window) . 'Scared young men' in group chat Kate Dubinski (new window) The Crown has taken the position that the group chats between the then world junior hockey teammates, on June 16, 2018, were a sort of collusion to advance a false narrative, Humphrey reminds the court. But he argues the players told each other they need to tell the same story not because they were trying to make up lies, but because they were typing these messages as scared young men, not thinking that their every word is going to be interpreted in a court of law and may be held against them. The men are living the hockey players' dream … heading to the NHL, and were trying to figure out what was going on with the Hockey Canada investigation. The men were simply trying to figure out what was going on and wanted to tell the truth, Humphrey maintains. One proof of that is McLeod told the men in the group chat that he'd had sex with E.M. before everyone else showed up. He wants people to tell the story truthfully, Humphrey says. As of Monday, citizens of 12 countries can't enter the United States. Government to focus on reducing non-permanent residents in Montreal, Laval. Israel's Foreign Ministry called charity boat 'selfie yacht' of 'celebrities'. PM to announce purchase of more drones, armoured vehicles, aircraft and underwater sensors. Doctors urge vaccination following death of Ontario infant infected with measles in the womb.
CBC
4 hours ago
- CBC
Robert Miller, billionaire accused of sex crimes, makes 1st court appearance
Montreal billionaire Robert Miller appeared in court on Monday, making a rare public appearance as his lawyers argue that he is too sick to stand trial. Miller, 81, is facing 24 charges related to sex crimes involving 11 women, most of whom were minors at the time of the alleged crimes. He has pleaded not guilty and has denied the allegations against him. Miller has not previously appeared in court, but on Monday, he appeared via videoconference. He wore a mask and a Boston Red Sox baseball cap and he appeared frail. Miller's lawyers are arguing that he has advanced stage Parkinson's disease and is unfit to stand trial. They have submitted assessments from several doctors who have determined that Miller's health is poor and going to trial could worsen his condition or even prove fatal. On Monday, the court heard from a medical expert called by the Crown. Dr. Pierre Blanchet, a Parkinson's disease expert, testified that he met Miller for a 45-minute evaluation on May 20. He said Miller appeared frail, underweight, weak and was experiencing cognitive decline.
Global News
5 hours ago
- Global News
World junior complainant created a ‘false narrative,' McLeod's lawyer says
The female complainant in the high-profile world junior sexual assault trial 'chose to abandon restraint' the night of the alleged acts, a defence lawyer for one of the players says. David Humphrey, lawyer for Michael McLeod, told Superior Court Justice Maria Carroccia Monday the complainant, known as E.M. in court documents, created a 'false narrative' in the face of regret after meeting McLeod and his teammates in London, Ont., in June 2018. 'This is a case where the defence has an embarrassment of riches — a cornucopia of compelling credibility and reliability concerns in E.M.'s testimony,' Humphrey told Carroccia during his closing submissions inside a London courtroom. 'She's created a false narrative in which she bears no responsibility.' Closing submissions began Monday after the defence rested its case last week. The trial, which has been proceeding by judge alone after two juries were dismissed, began in late April. Story continues below advertisement 2:10 Crown cross-examines 1 of the 5 accused men at world junior hockey sexual assault trial McLeod, Carter Hart, Alex Formenton, Dillon Dube and Callan Foote have pleaded not guilty to sexual assault stemming from what the Crown alleges was non-consensual group sex with the then 20-year-old woman in McLeod's hotel room. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy McLeod has also pleaded not guilty to an additional charge of being a party to the offence of sexual assault. Defence lawyers said last week they would collaborate to avoid repetition during their submissions, and that they'd need two-to-three hours each. Crown prosecutors said they'd need a day for their closing submissions. 'Her communication of consent is overwhelming': Humphrey Court has heard that the team was in London for events marking its gold-medal performance at that year's championship, and that the complainant was out with friends when they met at a downtown bar on June 18, 2018. Story continues below advertisement After being with McLeod and his teammates at the bar, E.M. would go on to have consensual sex with McLeod in his room in the early morning hours of June 19. Court has heard that E.M., who testified she was drunk and not of clear mind, was in the washroom after she had sex with McLeod and came out to a group of men in the room allegedly invited for a '3 way' by McLeod in a group chat. It was then that the Crown alleges several sexual acts took place without E.M.'s consent. The 27-year-old woman, whose identity is protected under a standard publication ban, was subject to intense cross-examination during her nearly two weeks on the stand. 2:29 World junior trial hears 2018 police interviews with 2 accused Defence lawyers have suggested E.M. wasn't as drunk as she has testified she was, wanted a 'wild night' with the players and was 'egging' them on to have sex with her, and accused her of having a 'clear agenda' at the trial. Story continues below advertisement E.M. has pushed back against those claims and at points outright rejected them, saying she was coaxed into staying in the room, was disrespected and was taken advantage of by the group, who she said 'could see I was out of my mind.' Only Hart testified at the trial, while the other players' lawyers cited evidence and police interviews that were already played out in court as part of the reasons why they weren't calling evidence. Humphrey argued Monday E.M. 'made a choice to take that night in a different direction' and when her sobriety returned, 'regret emerges.' He argued when E.M.'s mother found her crying after she got home, she told her a 'white lie that snowballed into a criminal investigation' because she regretted drinking too much and cheating on her boyfriend with a group of men. Humphrey said her mother pressured her into going to the police, and with E.M. being a self-identifying people-pleaser, the pressure got to a point where she could no longer resist. After police in 2018 decided not to lay charges, E.M., 'armed' with that information, 'retools her narrative' to support her lawsuit against Hockey Canada. 'She is not an honest or reliable witness,' Humphrey said. 'Her communication of consent is overwhelming.'
