Egypt is illegally detaining Alaa Abd el-Fattah, UN investigation finds
British-Egyptian writer and activist Alaa Abd el-Fattah is being illegally detained in Egypt and should be released immediately, UN investigators have said.
In a ruling from the United Nations' Working Group on Arbitrary Detention (UNWGAD), a panel of independent human rights experts found that Egyptian authorities have an obligation to release Mr el-Fattah immediately under international law.
In a legal opinion shared with el-Fattah's lawyers, UNWGAD requested that the Egyptian government 'take the steps necessary to remedy the situation of Mr. Abd el-Fattah without delay'.
The panel said: 'The appropriate remedy would be to release Mr. Abd el-Fattah immediately and accord him an enforceable right to compensation and other reparations, in accordance with international law.'
Mr el-Fattah has spent most of the last decade in prison. He been detained in Egypt since September 29, 2019, and in 2021 was handed an 'unjust' five-year prison sentence for sharing a social media post, according to Amnesty International.
He was due to be released last September, but has remained in custody.
The UNWGAD panel said Mr el-Fattah's continued imprisonment was illegal on four different grounds: the lack of a warrant at the time of his arrest, and lack of reasons for his arrest; being arrested for exercising freedom of expression; the lack of a fair trial; and the fact his detention was discriminatory, due to his political views.
Mr el-Fattah's lawyer Can Yeginsu said: 'The UN Working Group has delivered a clear and unequivocal decision: Alaa Abd el-Fattah's detention is arbitrary and in breach of international law. Egypt is now obligated to release Alaa immediately."
Mr Yeginsu said the British government now must take action to free Mr el-Fattah.
"With Alaa's continued detention now confirmed as illegal under international law, we are calling on the British government to take Egypt to the International Court of Justice for breach of the Vienna Convention,' he said.
'For too long now the Egyptian regime has withheld access to a British citizen that they are holding illegally and it cannot be allowed to stand."
Last week 100 MPs urged Sir Keir Starmer to 'deploy every tool' available to help free Mr El-Fattah, who at the time had been on hunger strike for more than 80 days.
The cross-party group of parliamentarians argued in a letter that Mr el-Fattah was a 'political prisoner' who should have been released last year, and added he has been 'acutely unwell' in prison.
Mr el-Fattah's mother, Laila Soueif, has been on hunger strike since her son's sentence was meant to end.
'We are requesting an urgent update on progress, given the serious risks both to his health and that of his mother Laila Soueif, who has been on hunger strike in support of him since September 2024,' the letter said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
North Wales Chronicle
an hour ago
- North Wales Chronicle
Tina Satchwell remembered by family as ‘kind, loving and gentle soul'
Tina's cousin, Sarah Howard, said the family 'finally have justice' following the conviction of Richard Satchwell. Satchwell, a British truck driver, was found unanimously guilty of the murder of his wife at their home in Co Cork. The 58-year-old had denied the murder of Mrs Satchwell on a date between March 19 and March 20 2017. The jury in the trial returned the verdict on Friday afternoon at the Central Criminal Court in Dublin. The jury had been deliberating for a total of nine hours and 28 minutes since Tuesday afternoon. Relatives of Mrs Satchwell wept as the guilty verdict was returned. Ms Howard, who gave evidence for the prosecution in the trial, said: 'During this trial Tina was portrayed in a way that is not true to who she was. 'Tina was our precious sister, cousin, auntie and daughter. Her presence in our life meant so much to us all. 'We, as a family, can never put into words the impact that her loss has had on all of us. 'Tina was a kind, loving, gentle soul who loved her animals like they loved her and that is the way we want her remembered. 'Today, as a family, we finally have justice for Tina.' Tina's half-sister, Lorraine Howard, thanked the judge, Mr Justice Paul McDermott, and the prosecution team, including senior barrister Gerardine Small. 'Your hard work and professionalism shone through like the classy ladies you were. We will never be able to put into words how thankful we are for you. We want to sincerely thank the judge, the jury, for their dedication,' she said. 'We would like to thank all the witnesses who helped us reach this verdict today. I would like to personally thank Sarah Howard, who came up to give evidence and her support two weeks postpartum from her beautiful baby girl. You did yourself and Tina proud. 'Thank you to (Superintendent) Ann Marie Twomey and (Detective Garda) Dave Kelleher for putting the pieces together and finding Tina. 'We would like to thank John O'Connell, the victim support workers, for keeping our spirits high.'
Metro
an hour ago
- Metro
Heaven nightclub bouncer cleared of rape charge
A security guard at a popular London's nightclub has been found not guilty of raping a 19-year-old woman in his car during a shift. Morenikeji Adewole, 47, of Dartford, Kent, was previously charged with raping the woman near the club in the back seat of his Lexus while she was drunk in the early hours of November 1 last year. The woman had queued outside the club for around two hours with five friends for a Halloween-themed event but was denied entry for being too intoxicated, a trial at Southwark Crown Court was told. Adewole then walked her away from the club's entrance and picked her up in his car before driving the woman to a small road called Adelphi Terrace. A jury of eight men and four women reached a unanimous verdict on Friday after around six hours and 30 minutes of deliberations, with Adewole found not guilty of both rape and attempted rape. The defendant cried and wiped away tears with tissues in the dock as the verdicts were delivered in court. During the trial, Adewole claimed that there was sexual activity with the complainant, but he did not have penetrative intercourse with the woman. He said that the woman had earlier told him she was 25 years old, but in the car, she said she was 19, and he immediately stopped. Addressing Adewole after the verdict, Judge Martin Griffith said he should still be 'ashamed' of himself for taking advantage of the drunken woman. 'Your job was to take care of them (the club attendees). Your response to that was to go off in a car with her because your brain was driven by your groin,' the judge said. The trial heard Adewole had used a false ID to get a job at the club, having been employed at Heaven under the name Olusola Julius Alabi, and was in the UK on a five-year tourist visa that did not allow him to work in the country. He had previously pleaded guilty to two counts of possession of an identification document with improper intention relating to the offences. Judge Griffith passed concurrent six-month custodial sentences for each offence, but said the time had already been served by the defendant during his time on remand. More Trending A victim surcharge would also be drawn up in due course, he said. Heaven nightclub, which has operated in Charing Cross for more than 40 years, was temporarily closed down by Westminster City Council after the alleged incident on public safety grounds. The venue, in Charing Cross, London had its licence suspended following the suspected assault on November 1 and faced possible permanent closure. However, at a hearing in December, councillors allowed the club to reopen as long as it adhered to a list of new conditions, which include a 'last entry' of 3am, a ban on drinking alcohol in the queue and improved security. Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: British flight attendant 'in tears' in court accused of smuggling 46kg of drugs MORE: Husband's tearful appeal for 'missing' wife he had murdered and buried under the stairs MORE: Robert Jenrick has a point but he has no business making it
Sky News
2 hours ago
- Sky News
Former UN chief's labelling of Gaza war as 'genocide' marks extraordinary shift
In a stark and direct intervention, Martin Griffiths, the former UN humanitarian chief, has described the situation in Gaza as genocide. The statement, made during an interview I conducted with Griffiths on The World, marks one of the most pointed accusations yet from a figure known to be deeply embedded in the world of international politics and diplomacy. "I think now we've got to the point this is unequivocal. Of course it is genocide. Just as it is weaponising aid. "We don't need to look behind ourselves to see that's the case. That should encourage us even more because we, of course, all doubted whether it would come to that level of definition. "We all doubted whether famine is actually there. I think starvation is killing people. That's bad enough. We don't have to worry about famine, which is obviously there lurking in the shadows. "Also, genocide… of course that's what has happened. We only need to look at the statements made. Prime Minister Netanyahu has the virtue of being very clear about his objectives." 3:14 His choice of words is extraordinary - not just for its gravity, but because it's Griffiths who is saying it. A veteran diplomat with decades of experience navigating complex international crises, Griffiths is known for his calm and thoughtful demeanour - not for inflammatory language. For him to use the term "genocide" in a television interview signals a significant shift in how some within the international system are now interpreting events on the ground in Gaza - 20 months since Israel launched its war. 4:40 The timing is also noteworthy. Just weeks earlier, Tom Fletcher, another respected former British ambassador and current UN humanitarian chief, came close to using the phrase during a UN Security Council session. He said: "What more evidence do you need now? Will you act decisively to prevent genocide and to ensure respect for international humanitarian law? Or will you say instead: 'we did all we could?'" Whilst he stopped short, his tone showed a clear change in how leading international figures now view the direction of Israeli military operations in Gaza; staggering civilian deaths, and the statements made by Israeli officials prosecuting this war. 31:58 Griffiths' remarks now go a step further. It comes as the British government continues to grapple with public anger over the mounting civilian toll - and faces growing scrutiny over its continued arms exports to Israel. 6:00 This latest statement by Griffiths doesn't just reflect humanitarian concern. As a former ambassador, he knows the weight his words carry. And with the humanitarian crisis in Gaza worsening, his warning challenges Israel's allies to ask deeply uncomfortable questions. South Africa to the International Court of Justice last year - accusing its actions in Gaza of amounting to genocide - called the claims "unfounded", "absurd" and amounting to "libel".
