logo
The Price of Wartime Ambivalence

The Price of Wartime Ambivalence

The Atlantic5 days ago

A relatively young Ukrainian state, having freed itself from Moscow's grasp, is trying to find its place as an independent nation in a changing world order. Moscow, however, decides to reclaim what it lost and sends an army to take Kyiv. An outnumbered Ukrainian force intercepts the Russian soldiers just north of the city. Ukraine's fate hangs in the balance.
This is a description not of February 2022 but of January 1918, when the Bolsheviks advanced on Kyiv to crush the Ukrainian People's Republic. The country was only months old, and fell quickly. In the ensuing two years, Kyiv changed hands multiple times among competing Tsarist, Ukrainian, Bolshevik, and German armies, but in the end, Moscow prevailed.
It is during these turbulent years that the Ukrainian author Andrey Kurkov has set his Kyiv mysteries, an ongoing series of crime novels that follows the policeman Samson Kolechko as he negotiates bandits, speculators, and roaming soldiers of various stripes in his quest to keep order amid the chaos caused by war. Kurkov's mysteries contain enough of the typical tropes of crime fiction to keep fans of the genre satisfied. There is the melancholic police officer with a traumatic origin story (Samson's father was murdered by Cossacks during the revolution); there is the long-suffering love interest (level-headed Nadezhda is the perfect foil to anxious Samson); there are eccentric villains (an ailing Belgian thief steals silver in order to make himself a new skeleton); there are chases, shootouts, and puzzles aplenty.
Kurkov's crime capers are deceptive, however. They lure you into seemingly safe generic territory only to subtly undermine your expectations. In the first novel, The Silver Bone, Samson doesn't even join the police force until about a third of the way in, leaving the reader suspended in the tense atmosphere of occupied Kyiv waiting for the story to begin. In the series' second book, The Stolen Heart, which has recently been published in Boris Dralyuk's English translation, the central crime—the illegal sale of pig meat—seems trivial, except that the Bolshevik secret police, or cheka, consider such 'sabotage' punishable by death. These novels are more than detective thrillers: They are studies in the surprising ambivalence that people living under occupation may feel, even when those in power go to extraordinary lengths to cement their rule through violence, manipulation, and terror. And they are important today not just for their insight into the past but also as a guide for surviving the present.
Samson despises the lawlessness that accompanies the breakdown of states, and he yearns for the restoration of order; less important to him is the ideology of the party in power. In a job interview with his soon-to-be commanding officer, he is asked whom he supports: the Tsarists, the Ukrainian nationalists, the German-backed government, or the 'workers' regime'? He answers, 'I sympathize with you.' He knows this vague answer can be interpreted as ideologically acceptable.
But the inhabitants of a police state can drift in ambivalence for only so long before they are compelled to make a moral choice. Samson realizes that arresting speculators and burglars on behalf of the Bolsheviks will not bring back the stability of his middle-class, prerevolutionary youth. Indeed, he isn't immune to the police's aggression simply because he works for them: His furniture, including his late father's beautiful writing desk, is confiscated, and two Red Army soldiers are billeted in his apartment.
There are echoes here of Kurkov's Kyivan literary predecessor, Mikhail Bulgakov, who died in 1940. Bulgakov's novel The White Guard, published in 1925 and set at the same time, is an elegy for Tsarist Kyiv that detests both Ukrainian national aspirations and Bolshevik rule. (Curiously, its theatrical adaptation was a favorite of Stalin's, a fact that kept its author employed through the terror of the 1930s.) The White Guard hinges on the contrast between the cozy bourgeois home of the Turbin family, based on Bulgakov's family home on Kyiv's most picturesque street, and the barbarism unfolding outside. In The Stolen Heart, Samson sees Red Army soldiers violently dispossessing a middle-class family on that same street. At moments like this, Samson begins to doubt his decision to serve the occupation regime: Yes, order is being established, but at what cost? And is order based on legalized violence and theft really order?
Bulgakov would have had little time for a Bolshevik lackey like Samson. His protagonists are uncompromisingly loyal to class and empire, and, in this sense, less interesting than Kurkov's more hesitant characters. As a writer born in Russia who built his career in Ukraine, Kurkov understands what it means to be caught between fiercely competing political and cultural projects (as, indeed, do several million Ukrainians living in areas now occupied by Russia). Many of Kurkov's other books examine how the instinct not to take sides often conflicts with the moral imperative to do so. The protagonist of his 1996 breakthrough novel, Death and the Penguin, for instance, naively thinks he can work for the Mafia while remaining an innocent civilian. The more recent Grey Bees, which is set in the aftermath of Russia's original assault on eastern Ukraine in 2014, revolves around the inhabitants of the no-man's-land between the Ukrainian and Russian armies and their attempts to remain neutral. In the end, keeping your head down is usually unsustainable, and Kurkov's protagonists tend, eventually, to locate their moral backbones.
In this regard, another early-20th-century influence besides Bulgakov lurks in The Stolen Heart: Mykola Khvylovy. The Ukrainian modernist died by suicide in 1933 in protest of Stalin's arrests of Ukrainian writers. His books were banned for decades, and, unlike Bulgakov's, they rarely reached the outside world in translation. His most famous story, 'I (a Romance),' is about a cheka officer who discovers his mother among a group of counterrevolutionaries and is forced by his superiors to execute her. Khvylovy never did such a thing, but he did fight for the Bolsheviks during the Ukrainian wars of independence that followed the 1917 revolution, and in the end he despaired at what the Russians did to his country and his culture. The story ends with the bewildered officer trudging across the war-torn steppe into the uncertain future, haunted by the moral vacuum within.
Near the end of The Stolen Heart, Samson is ordered by a cheka officer to sign an execution warrant for the pork speculator, whom he has finally apprehended. When he refuses to do so, the officer takes Samson's hand, dips his thumb in red ink, and guides it toward the order, leaving a fingerprint in place of a signature: 'The firm red thumbprint looked strange in this rectangle, like that of a criminal,' Samson reflects. That night, he awakens, weeping, from a dream in which he sits beside the coffin of a man with a seeping bullet wound. Looking at his hands, he notices that 'his fingers were smeared with red ink, as if with blood. He knew it wasn't blood. The ink had a chemical scent. The red lines of the verdict issued earlier that day kept rising up in his memory, and a whisper from the darkness kept on repeating, repeating, 'Samson, repent.'' The price of being part of the occupation bureaucracy has become clear.
In his translator's note for The Silver Bone, Dralyuk (who handles Kurkov's wry tone and the novels' historical fabric with characteristic dexterity) writes of contemporary Ukrainians that 'the Samsons of today have a far clearer sense of who they are and where they stand.' This is perhaps why Kyiv did not fall in 2022 as it did in 1918: Ukrainians understood that the 'order' imposed by an occupation would come at the price of their freedom. They chose freedom, even if it brought instability, even at the cost of their safety and, for some, their life. That lesson is relevant far beyond Ukraine, wherever ordinary people face the threat of becoming cogs in the machinery of malevolent administrations.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Neo-Nazi group ‘actively seeking to grow in US' with planned paramilitary training event
Neo-Nazi group ‘actively seeking to grow in US' with planned paramilitary training event

Yahoo

time18 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Neo-Nazi group ‘actively seeking to grow in US' with planned paramilitary training event

An international neo-Nazi terrorist organization is boldly continuing to build in the US and planning a new paramilitary training event without fear of local authorities or the FBI, which once dismantled it in a nationwide effort. The Base, founded in 2018 by a former Pentagon contractor living in Russia and now suspected of Kremlin-sponsored espionage, once boasted close to 50 stateside members before the bureau made more than a dozen arrests in a years-long counter-terrorism operation. But since the presidential election campaign last year and what many then believed to be a surefire victory for Donald Trump, the Base saw an opportunity in a potential administration uninterested in policing white supremacy and went about ramping up its ranks. Related: Energized neo-Nazis feel their moment has come as Trump changes everything Now, the Base has a presence in Ukraine, performing sabotage operations inside the country against the embattled government, and new and dangerous cells emerging across Europe, and it appears to be growing in the US, where the FBI under the Maga acolyte Kash Patel has signalled it isn't prioritizing investigations of far-right extremism. In its early history, part of what first piqued the interest of authorities was the Base's courting of military veterans who could help drill its foot soldiers in a series of training camps across the US. Eventually implicated in an assassination plot, mass shootings and other actions in Europe, the Base went so far as to have a fortified compound and cell in Michigan, led by a US army dropout. Online evidence from its various accounts, several of which live on Russian servers to avoid censorship on American sites, shows the Base has real plans for a national gathering this summer where members intend to train in paramilitary drills as in years past. 'The Base in [the] USA is preparing for an upcoming national training event,' reads one of its recent posts soliciting crypto donations. 'This one might be our most attended training event in [the] USA in a while. We could really use some financial support to help our members with travel expenses.' The post continued: 'When you donate money to the Base, you're investing in a White Defense Force that's aiming to protect white people from political persecution and physical destruction.' The Base then published a new photo of armed members claiming to be in the midwest, which follows a trend in 2025 of the group bragging about its unafraid American presence. As a sort of taunt to its enemies, on the day of Trump's inauguration the Base released a photo of four members somewhere in Appalachia, in what was the largest number of American members in one photo in over a year. Related: Alleged former members of neo-Nazi group claim its leader is Russian spy 'The upcoming national training event indicates that the group is seeking to grow and is willing to take the risk of advertising it publicly in advance,' said Joshua Fisher-Birch, an analyst of far-right terrorism who has been following the Base's movements for close to a decade. 'The Base appears to be actively seeking to grow in the US.' Fisher-Birch notes that even if the gathering involves 'fewer than 20 people', it is by no means 'low profile' and suggests the group sees momentum is on its side. 'An event entails planning, coordination, travel and face-to-face meetings between different regional groups, indicating that they operate in an environment where they view the potential amount of risk as acceptable,' he said. 'The group has previously stated multiple times that being a member or training with them is a risky endeavor; however, planning a meetup, which they will inevitably use for propaganda purposes, is a different approach than even a year ago, when the group advertised regional activities.' In response to queries about the Base's latest movements, the FBI told the Guardian that it only investigates people who have or are planning to commit a federal crime and pose 'a threat to national security'. 'Our focus is not on membership in particular groups but on criminal activity,' said a spokesperson for the FBI. 'Membership in groups is not illegal in and of itself and is protected by the first amendment.' But in Michigan and in Georgia, members of the Base were charged with their criminal associations to the group. The Trump administration's security posture on the far right is to downplay its significance. Yet experts unanimously agree: it is the top domestic terrorism threat facing the country. Instead, Patel, the FBI's director, has gone about removing agents from pursuing the far right, while one of Trump's first actions in his second term was to provide unconditional pardons, en masse, to all of the January 6 insurrectionists. Fisher-Birch also pointed out that the Base had taken itself more seriously and upped its activities in Ukraine to the tune of calling for the murder of government officials and acts of sabotage – with the clearly stated goal of forming a white ethnostate in the west of the country. Already, the Ukrainian cell has uploaded geolocated videos of some of these attacks, one showing the burning of a military vehicle and what looks like a government electrical box. In a video released on a Russian video-sharing site in mid-May, Rinaldo Nazzaro, the founder and leader of the Base, who is living in St Petersburg, released a video describing the importance of new training videos proving to potential recruits that his group is not just online, but in the real world. 'It's propaganda through actions, not just words,' he said. It isn't clear where the paramilitary training will take place, but Nazzaro is known to have purchased land in the Pacific north-west that he intended to use as a headquarters for the Base and its activities.

Russia bombards Kyiv after Putin vows revenge for Operation Spiderweb
Russia bombards Kyiv after Putin vows revenge for Operation Spiderweb

Yahoo

time31 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Russia bombards Kyiv after Putin vows revenge for Operation Spiderweb

Russia launched an intense missile and drone barrage at Kyiv overnight after Vladimir Putin vowed to respond to Ukraine's Operation Spiderweb attack on some of the Kremlin's nuclear-capable bombers. Volodymyr Zelenskyy said Russia had launched more than 400 drones and more than 40 missiles at Ukraine, as he urged allies to build pressure on the Kremlin to end its war. Four people were killed, including three emergency workers in Kyiv. The Ukrainian president wrote in a social media post: 'If someone does not put pressure and gives the war more time to take lives, they are complicit and responsible. We need to act decisively.' Missiles and drones hammered the Ukrainian capital leading fires to rage through residential buildings and forcing the local metro system to close after a train was hit. It was part of a nationwide assault that ranks among the largest coordinated attacks in the three years of full-scale war, with 44 ballistic and cruise missiles and 407 drones launched. About 50 people were injured across the country. Yurii Ihnat, the Ukrainian air force spokesperson, said Ukrainian forces had shot down about 30 of the cruise missiles and up to 200 of the drones. Russia's defence ministry said its forces had carried out the overnight attacks in response to what it called Ukrainian 'terrorist acts' against Russia. The Kremlin later described its three-year invasion of Ukraine as 'existential' for Russia, casting it as nothing short of a battle for the 'future' of Russia. 'For us it is an existential issue, an issue on our national interest, safety, on our future and the future of our children, of our country,' the Kremlin spokesperson, Dmitry Peskov, told reporters, responding to remarks by Trump on Thursday comparing Moscow and Kyiv to brawling children. On Friday night Trump was more critical of Ukraine, telling reporters on Air Force One that Operation Spiderweb had 'given Putin a reason to go in and bomb the hell out of them'. Despite the efforts of Ukraine's air defences, the authorities in Kyiv reported that three emergency workers had been killed and 20 people wounded, of whom 16 had been hospitalised. 'Search and rescue operations are ongoing at several locations,' Kyiv's mayor, Vitali Klitschko, said on Telegram. Related: Hegseth says Nato allies 'very close' to raising defence spending target to 5% According to the ministry of internal affairs, the three victims were firefighters from the state emergency service who died while responding to the attack. 'They were working under fire to help people,' the ministry said in a statement. Operation of the city's metro transport system was disrupted after a Russian strike damaged a train travelling between stations, the city's military administration said. The air attack also triggered fires in residential buildings in different parts of Kyiv, authorities said. A residential block in the Solomianskyi district took severe damage to the upper floors with entire windows, balcony frames, and parts of an outer wall blown away. More than 2,000 households in Kyiv's eastern bank remained without electricity on Friday morning. Russia had previously vowed to take revenge on Ukraine after Monday's audacious drone attack, known as Operation Spiderweb, on its bomber fleet. Initially, two TU-95MC and two TU-160MC bombers were deployed by Russia on Thursday night. This was a lower number than had been feared and may have been the result of the Kremlin's resources being reduced by the events of 1 June. Kalibr missiles were also fired from Russian warships stationed in the Black Sea. Putin informed the US president, Donald Trump, in a call on Wednesday that Russia would respond to the operation that Ukraine has claimed damaged or destroyed 41 aircraft. 'They went deep into Russia and [Putin] actually told me we have no choice but to attack based on that, and it's probably not going to be pretty,' Trump had told reporters. Trump said it may be better to let Ukraine and Russia 'fight for a while' rather than pursue peace immediately. Ukraine and Russia met for talks in Istanbul on Monday with no headway to a truce, but the two sides signalled progress on other issues, including the transfer of captives and bodies. The barrage on Kyiv had begun with the buzz of Russian kamikaze drones followed by Ukrainian anti-aircraft fire. Through the night the city was shaken by large explosions. Tymur Tkachenko, the head of Kyiv's military administration, said drones had struck the upper floors of a high-rise apartment building and started a fire in Darnytskyi district on the east side of the city. One unofficial Telegram channel said a shopping centre in the area was ablaze. Tkachenko said a fire had also broken out in an apartment building in a western district. Drone fragments were found in three districts. Ukraine's commissioner for human rights, Dmytro Lubinets, demanded a strong international response to Russia's latest attack. 'Russia is acting like a terrorist, systematically targeting civilian infrastructure,' he wrote on Telegram. 'The world must respond clearly and take concrete steps, including condemning the aggressor's actions.' Elsewhere in the country, 10 people were reported injured in the western city of Ternopil, including five emergency workers, said the regional governor, Viacheslav Nehoda. Three people were injured in Ukraine's central Poltava region after strikes on administrative buildings, warehouses and a cafe. Russian forces also struck the Khmelnytskyi region, damaging a private residential building, outbuildings, and several vehicles. Air defence forces shot down three Russian missiles in the western Lviv region overnight, according to the regional head, Maksym Kozytskyi.

‘He's a bulldog': the man behind the success of Ukraine's Operation Spiderweb
‘He's a bulldog': the man behind the success of Ukraine's Operation Spiderweb

Yahoo

time31 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

‘He's a bulldog': the man behind the success of Ukraine's Operation Spiderweb

It was unsurprising to those who know Vasyl Malyuk, the head of the Security Service of Ukraine (SBU), that his statement announcing the success of Operation Spiderweb had a certain physicality to it. The audacious drone attacks on distant bases hosting Russia's strategic bombers was 'a serious slap in the face to Russia's power', said Malyuk, 42, a sometime boxer and weightlifter. 'Our strikes will continue as long as Russia terrorises Ukrainians with missiles and Shahed drones.' Shaven-headed and with the physique and bearing of a stereotypical nightclub bouncer, Malyuk has led the SBU since the former holder of the office Ivan Bakanov, a childhood friend of Volodymyr Zelenskyy, was fired in 2022 for apparent incompetence. Malyuk had been his deputy. There have been high-profile successes over the last three years. One stunt – a photograph of Malyuk holding a bruised Dmitry Kozyura, the head of the SBU's counter-terrorism department, by the scruff of the neck at the time of his arrest on suspicion of being a Russian double agent – attracted the coverage for which it was designed. When Zakhar Prilepin, a Russian paramilitary leader, survived a suspected SBU sponsored assassination attempt, one of a series targeting Ukrainian foes at the time, Malyuk made headlines by commenting that Prilepin's 'pelvis and legs were severely injured, and, sorry, he lost his genitals'. 'Therefore, it is God's will that he continue to live and enjoy life', he added drily. Meanwhile, Sea Baby marine drones, the SBU's own invention, are credited with striking 11 Russian military ships and pushing the Black Sea fleet 'all the way to Novorossiysk'. Though none of this compares to the global attention drawn by the 1 June attacks that were said to have been masterminded by Malyuk. 'I am confident that the SBU operations led by Vasyl Malyuk will be the subject of books and films,' said one SBU officer on condition of anonymity. 'Because compared to what the security service is doing now, Hollywood is nervously smoking on the sidelines.' The number of Russian aircraft permanently put out of action by the attack on four bases on Sunday is disputed, with Ukraine claiming to have destroyed 41. US intelligence officials suggest that 10 combat aircraft were destroyed and up to 20 damaged. Whatever the physical cost, the footage of the 117 drones flying out from the top of lorries to strike deep into Russia, and without the aid of western weaponry, has struck a psychological blow. Ukraine's foreign affairs minister, Sergiy Kyslytsya, claimed it had 'changed the paradigm and dynamics' of the faltering peace talks with Russia in Istanbul on Tuesday. It was followed by a massive underwater blast targeting the key road and rail bridge connecting the Russian-occupied Crimean peninsula to Russia, damaging its supports. The attacks were serious enough for Vladimir Putin to inform Donald Trump in a transatlantic call that he would 'respond'. Four people in Kyiv were killed in the early hours of Friday morning after that vengeance was delivered in the form of a heavy barrage and drone attack on the capital. So who is the security chief who has got Putin's attention? 'He's a bulldog,' said one senior Ukrainian official who has worked closely with Malyuk. 'He isn't an intellectual, he doesn't reflect, or hesitate. He is purposeful.' 'But he isn't evil – that's important,' the source added. 'Often those heading these organisations are evil. Malyuk doesn't want to hurt anyone but he knows that sometimes he has to.' Malyuk was born in the city of Korostyshiv, 80 miles (130km) west of Kyiv, and it is said he was determined to join the SBU after it emerged as an independent body from the KGB following the breakup of the Soviet Union. He enrolled at 17 and attended the SBU's academy, finding friends most easily among those with a mutual appreciation of sport and exercise, and graduating with a degree in jurisprudence in 2005. 'He was very calm in his youth,' said a source who knew him then. 'He was always physically very strong. He was constantly training in the gym. He believes that when a person goes in for sports, he is disciplined and organised. He used to box, they say he injured his arm at some stage.' Unlike British or American domestic counter-intelligence, the SBU rolls up secret service operations with the sort of tasks that might fall to the police and special forces. Malyuk spent a large part of his career in anti-corruption and tackling organised crime. He rose to the position of deputy head of the SBU in his local city by 2019 which was when he first came across Zelenskyy, who was in the first months of his presidency. 'He got into a helicopter with Zelenskyy and began to show him all the violations in the Zhytomyr region,' said an SBU source. 'He showed him where amber was being illegally mined. Zelenskyy was impressed and said: 'I give Malyuk the authority to deal with these problems.'' Related: Operation Spiderweb: a visual guide to Ukraine's destruction of Russian aircraft A few months before Russia launched its full-scale war, there was a brief sojourn into the world of politics when he was made a deputy to the interior minister, Denys Monastyrsky. Sources said he had never shown any ambition to have a political career, something that has recommended him to many in intelligence circles, and he swiftly rejoined the SBU after Russia's invasion. The organisation was in a sorry state. The head of the spy agency in the Kherson region had withdrawn his agents ahead of Russia's occupation against Zelenskyy's orders. Bakanov, in what would turn out to be one of his last acts as chief, had enrolled his son in the service so ensuring he would avoid mobilisation. Russian agents were widely regarded to have penetrated the organisation. Malyuk is said to have set as a priority the task of turning out the moles. 'One of the good signs of Operation Spiderweb is that it didn't leak,' said one senior member of Ukraine's security. 'He has got rid of a lot of traitors. Not every one of them, as that's not possible. But a lot.' Malyuk also personally took an interest in the so-called Alpha unit within the SBU that carries out operations on and behind the frontline, to which he is a regular visitor. According to the service, since February the SBU has been responsible for destroying nearly 2,000 tanks, more than 3,000 armoured vehicles and host of aircraft, rocket launch systems and military facilities, including ammunition depots, as well as over 30 oil refineries. It is widely accepted that Malyuk himself would not have dreamed up Operation Spiderweb but he had the ability to see the potential and have the ear of the president. 'This idea was born deep inside the security services,' said Ivan Stupak, who was an SBU agent between 2004 and 2015. 'And this idea went directly to Mr Malyuk. He liked this idea. And there was one more obstacle, President Zelenskyy. There was high chance that Mr Zelenskyy would reject this idea but Mr Malyuk convinced Mr Zelenskyy.' Yuri Butusov, a military journalist, said Malyuk had also enabled the operation by disregarding hierarchy and pushing forward young agents and risk-takers. Unlike some at the top of government, his focus was on winning the war rather than factional disputes within the administration, he suggested. Related: The Guardian view on Ukraine's spectacular attack: 21st-century tactics still require support from allies | Editorial 'Malyuk has given the freedom of action and resources to promote very decisive, very responsible leaders, some of them very young people,' Butusov said. 'They are risk-takers. He is very different to other people in power. He sets aside political influence, economic and business interests.' Sources inside the government said they did not believe it was Malyuk's decision to publicise the operations to this extent. 'Zelenskyy is all about media attention, he eats and drinks it,' said one government source. Malyuk, in contrast, is said to keep his comments to the point when briefing ministers and expects a similar lack of verbosity from those within his service. Sources said the power and success had yet to go to Malyuk's head. 'If he sees problems in the heads of departments, he becomes tough,' said a second SBU officer. 'But in general, he is constructive. He gives his subordinates the time he thinks they need to complete their tasks. It's easier to govern when you have carte blanche. But you still need to earn carte blanche. And Malyuk earned this carte blanche.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store