DWP 'safeguards' demanded after tragic deaths of vulnerable benefit claimants
DWP 'safeguards' demanded after tragic deaths of vulnerable benefit claimants
A two-year inquiry by the Commons Work and Pensions Committee found some vulnerable claimants had 'paid the ultimate price' after being forced to deal with the Department for Work and Pensions
MPs heard that some vulnerable claimants had died as a result of DWP failures
(Image: Andrew Aitchison, In Pictures via Getty Images )
The parliamentary committee's extensive research into the calamitous impact of persistent cost-reductions at the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has culminated in a significant report, advocating for fresh safeguarding protocols to avert "tragic deaths."
Following a two-year inquiry, the cross-party Work and Pensions committee has published the Safeguarding Vulnerable Claimants report, which was handed repeated evidence that some benefit claimants have suffered 'the ultimate price' in their interactions with the DWP, after having their payments cut.
The committee listened to testimonies suggesting that continuous budgetary cuts and efforts to push people into employment had created a sentiment among many that work had become more important than genuine assistance for those at risk.
The DWP's approach left numerous claimants "fearful" to engage, with one individual summarising the sentiment as "a system that is meant to wrap its arms around us is strangling us."
DWP to confirm exactly when PIP claimants will be cut off from payments
READ MORE:
A major cultural change is needed at the DWP, the report said
(Image: Jerome Ellerby )
To counteract these outcomes, the report implores that new statutory responsibilities be instated on the department to protect claimants, urging officials to proactively direct individuals to additional support avenues. Beyond these measures, the report calls for a far-reaching cultural shift within the DWP, essential for forestalling future fatalities linked to lack of monetary support.
Article continues below
The absence of a coordinated approach to safeguarding those interacting with the benefits body was highlighted by MPs as an area needing improvement. The committee found no public webpage outlining the actual safeguarding policy, prompting calls for change.
The report also recommended mandatory health impact assessments from the DWP Chief Medical Advisor's team for any policy alterations.
Financial sanctions, one of the most contentious measures used to encourage benefit claimants into work, were identified as a "risk" in terms of safeguarding. In recent times, work coaches have been given more responsibility to use their judgement to prevent harm, leading to inevitable inconsistencies in safeguarding practices.
The committee expressed concern in its report about vulnerable claimants having to navigate through an "MP filter" during the arduous process of appealing benefits decisions. This requires them to get their local MP to refer their case in order to involve the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman.
Many benefit claimants feel 'fearful' of contacting the DWP
The report also pointed out failures in adequately directing Brits to the full financial support they are entitled to when making a benefit claim. It further noted the absence of a specific category to guide victims of domestic abuse towards additional help when applying for Universal Credit.
A key recommendation from the committee was for coroners to more thoroughly investigate and document any links between changes in benefit entitlement and an individual's death.
Debbie Abrahams, Committee Chair and MP for Oldham, highlighted evidence suggesting that some claimants had 'paid the ultimate price' due to cost-cutting measures at the DWP. She stated: "That people continue to face harm after dealing with the DWP is a self-evident failure of safeguarding in the system.
"Until recently, getting people back into work to cut costs had been prioritised over providing support and care for vulnerable people.
"We heard evidence that the process itself of engaging with the DWP itself too often led to mental distress. Where this led to not being able to get financial support, many had paid the ultimate price."
Debbie Abrahams MP for Oldham East and Saddleworth and Chair of the Works and Pensions Committee
(Image: Philip Coburn/Daily Mirror )
Abrahams further commented: "We've heard that whilst some have been lifted by the system when it works well, this can depend on claimants' confidence that the system will help them. Too often, we heard their trust has been smashed by continual cost-cutting drives and an unhelpful media narrative.
"Many fear coming forward and expressing that they need additional support due to their circumstances and they fall deeper into vulnerability and despair as a result.
"This has to change. And the Committee was heartened by the evidence the Secretary of State gave to the Committee on this last November.
"Is this a system that is going to help people find their way back into sustainable work? Is this a system that will humanely support those who never can? Both need to happen.
Article continues below
"Deep-rooted cultural change of the DWP is desperately needed to rebuild trust and put safeguarding at the heart of policy development.
"Introducing a statutory duty to safeguard vulnerable claimants for the Department is a fundamental part of this. It will help to focus minds from the top-down, ensuring that safeguarding is everyone's business; improving accountability, and ensure proactive identification of vulnerability and the consistent application of the best protective practices."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
DWP and Government to issue £524 one-off payment to pensioners
The DWP and Scottish Government are set to issue a series of one-off payments and energy bill help to people over State Pension age in the coming months, with the first payment due imminently People over the State Pension age could be eligible for a series of additional payments and assistance with energy bills in the coming months, courtesy of the Scottish Government and the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP). There are four cash payments and one that is paid directly to energy suppliers, all amounting to up to £524.75 in extra support. It's crucial to note that most of these payments won't be disbursed until later this year, but they could be considered now when planning household budgets closer to Christmas - particularly as energy bills typically surge during the colder months due to increased usage. The Pension Age Winter Fuel Payment has now superseded the Winter Fuel Payment for all Scottish pensioners. This winter, everyone aged 66 and above will receive at least £100 from the Scottish Government, while those on Pension Credit will be entitled to a higher payment of either £203.40 or £305.10, depending on their age. New applications for Pension Credit submitted before September 22, which subsequently prove successful, will qualify for the higher rates of Pension Age Winter Fuel Payment. This date is significant as it ensures an automatic payment during the designated payment window; any applications made after this date until mid-December would be paid in arrears, reports the Daily Record. Winter Fuel Payment U-turn Last week, Chancellor Rachel Reeves declared that over 9 million pensioners in England and Wales will automatically receive this year's Winter Fuel Payment, following a reversal by the UK Government on its decision to limit the annual heating allowance to pensioners receiving means-tested benefits such as Pension Credit. Pensioners born before 22 September 1959 will automatically receive payments of £200 if they are aged between 66 and 79, or £300 if they are 80 and over, later this year. However, pensioners with an annual income exceeding £35,000 will not be eligible for the Winter Fuel Payment. Those above this threshold will need to repay the money either through PAYE or a Self Assessment tax return. An option to opt-out of the payment has also been announced, although no further details have been confirmed yet. The impact of this policy reversal on the 1.1 million pensioners in Scotland, where the Pension Age Winter Heating Payment has replaced Winter Fuel Payments, remains uncertain. Pension Credit Regarding Pension Credit, nearly 1.4 million older people across Great Britain, including over 125,000 residing in Scotland, are currently receiving this benefit, which could provide an average of £4,300 in additional support during the 2025/26 financial year. Some older individuals believe that having savings or owning their home makes them ineligible for this means-tested benefit. However, even an award of just £1 per week can unlock other forms of support. To determine if you're eligible for a Pension Credit claim, you can utilise the Pension Credit calculator on You'll need to provide details of your: earnings, benefits and pensions savings and investments Alternatively, pensioners can contact the Pension Credit helpline directly to make a claim on 0800 99 1234 - lines are open 8am to 6pm, Monday to Friday. Full details on here. Financial help for pensioner households in 2025 Financial help on the way during 2025/26 includes: Winter Heating Payment (£59.75) - cash payment issued by the Scottish Government Pension Age Winter Heating Payment (£100 - £305) - cash payment issued by the Scottish Government Winter Fuel Payment (£100 - £300) - cash payments issued by DWP to pensioners in England and Wales only Warm Home Discount (£150) - paid directly from DWP to energy providers and usually added as credit to customer's electricity account DWP Christmas Bonus (£10) - issued by DWP Someone aged between 66 and 79, living in Scotland in receipt of Pension Credit, will receive £273.15 from the three cash payments before the end of March 2026. However, most of these will be issued before the end of this year. This is made up of: £203.40 from the Pension Age Winter Heating Payment, due to be issued on November 30 £59.75 from the Winter Heating Payment £10 DWP Christmas Bonus Someone over 80, living in Scotland in receipt of Pension Credit, will receive £374.86 from the three cash payments before the end of March 2026. This is made up of: £305.10 from the Pension Age Winter Heating Payment £59.75 from the Winter Heating Payment £10 DWP Christmas Bonus Winter Heating Payment (£59.75) - Scotland only Payments were issued in December last year and expected to be around the same time in 2025. You may qualify for Winter Heating Payment automatically if you get one of these benefits: Pension Credit Universal Credit - full guide on eligibility here Income Support or Income based Jobseeker's Allowance - full guide on eligibility here Income Related Employment Support Allowance - full guide on eligibility here Support for Mortgage Interest - full guide on eligibility here The qualifying week for this year's payment will be in early November, typically the first full week - we will update this article once more details have been released. Find out more on the dedicated pages on here. Pension Age Winter Heating Payment - between£100 - £305.10 Every person over State Pension age living in Scotland will automatically receive a one-off heating payment of at least £100 by St Andrew's Day on November 30 - even if they are not in receipt of a means-tested benefit such as Pension Credit. Those aged between 66 and 79 in receipt of Pension Credit will be paid £203.40 Those aged 80 and over in receipt of Pension Credit will be paid £305.10 To be eligible for the 2025 payment, you must have been born before September 22, 1959. During the qualifying week - September 15-21 - you must also: live in Scotland, or an eligible country abroad get at least one other, specific benefit on at least one day of the qualifying week Those benefits are: Pension Credit Universal Credit income-related Employment and Support Allowance (ESA) income-based Jobseeker's Allowance (JSA) Income Support Payment rates Those aged between 66 and 79 in receipt of Pension Credit will be paid £203.40 Those aged 80 and over in receipt of Pension Credit will be paid £305.10 Winter Fuel Payments - between £200 and £300 (not Scotland) The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has confirmed that the 2025/26 Winter Fuel Payment will be issued to everyone born before September 22, 1959. Payments of £200 will be issued automatically to those aged between 66 and 79, while those aged 80 or over will receive £300. Nobody needs to claim the payment. Pensioners also need to have an annual income of under £35,000 to qualify for the payment this winter. Details of an option to opt out of the payments will be announced in due course. Full details on how much people will receive from DWP - depending on their household age and living arrangements - will be published by the DWP on here shortly. Warm Home Discount - £150 paid to energy provider The Warm Home Discount Scheme for winter 2025 to 2026 usually opens in October and will give people on certain benefits £150 off their electricity bill. The money is paid directly by the DWP to energy suppliers between October and March. Eligible households may also be able to get the discount off their gas bill instead - if their supplier provides them with both gas and electricity, just contact them once the scheme opens to find out. If you're a credit customer the £150 will be added to your electricity account and if you're on Pay As You Go or Prepayment, you'll be sent a voucher that you can use to top-up your meter. Eligibility rules are changing this year to provide the support to more households - you can read about this here. We will update this article with details for this winter as soon as they are published. You can read more about the changes to eligibility on here. DWP Christmas Bonus - £10 The bonus is a one-off, tax-free £10 payment made to people in receipt of State Pension or those claiming certain other benefits during the qualifying week - usually the first full week of December. Nobody needs to apply for the extra £10 as it should automatically go into the account where you usually receive your State Pension or benefit payment. It is made as a separate payment, independent of your scheduled State Pension or benefit payment, so it may arrive on a different day. Eligible benefits Adult Disability Payment Armed Forces Independence Payment Attendance Allowance Carer's Allowance Carer Support Payment Child Disability Payment Constant Attendance Allowance (paid under Industrial Injuries or War Pensions schemes) Contribution-based Employment and Support Allowance (once the main phase of the benefit is entered after the first 13 weeks of claim) Disability Living Allowance Incapacity Benefit at the long-term rate Industrial Death Benefit (for widows or widowers) Mobility Supplement Pension Credit - the guarantee element Pension Age Disability Payment Personal Independence Payment (PIP) State Pension (including Graduated Retirement Benefit) Severe Disablement Allowance (transitionally protected) Unemployability Supplement or Allowance (paid under Industrial Injuries or War Pensions schemes) War Disablement Pension at State Pension age War Widow's Pension Widowed Mother's Allowance Widowed Parent's Allowance Widow's Pension
The National
2 hours ago
- The National
Cuts to PIP will plunge families further into poverty, research says
The UK Labour Government proposed changes to Personal Independence Payments (PIP) earlier this year which will mean only those who score a minimum of four points in at least one daily living activity will be eligible for the benefit. It is estimated up to 1.3 million people across England and Wales could lose at least some support under the changes. In Scotland, PIP is devolved, but Finance Secretary Shona Robison has warned people will also be affected because the money comes from block grant funding, meaning a cut in UK spending on the benefit will reduce Holyrood's Budget for it. READ MORE: Scottish Government names date for ditching two-child cap New research carried out by Professor Morag Treanor of Glasgow University on behalf of several charities has recommended that the UK Government must not implement any changes to Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payments if they were to result in vulnerable and disadvantaged families being pushed into even deeper poverty. Aberlour chief executive SallyAnn Kelly said the research has shown that is "exactly what could happen". "We are clear that reforms should always protect the most vulnerable and should be implemented in a manner that does not push more people into further and more entrenched poverty," she said. "This research suggests that this is exactly what could happen. We are urging the Government to think again and prevent this very harmful outcome by making changes that safeguard the most vulnerable families. "Our research and work into public debt has outlined the struggles facing families and how the cost of living crisis is leading to millions of people lacking the means to pay for their basic needs and seeing them spiralling into debt, often to public bodies, as a consequence. "If these reforms are introduced in their current shape this research strongly suggests that many of our most disadvantaged families will be pushed even deeper into debt." The report considered the levels of debt owed to public bodies, including the levels of debt experienced by disabled people and lone parent families. It found 53% of people with a disability had public debt or arrears, while 58% of lone parents with one or more disabled children did. A total of 55% of children with a disability are in a lone parent family. READ MORE: Stirling Labour councillors face no-confidence vote Those lone parent families with a disability are most likely to depend on food banks and are at a high risk of having fuel and energy debts/arrears, the report said. While 8% of lone parent families made at least one food bank request from 2022 to 2025, that rose to 17% for a lone parent with one or more disabled child and 18% for couples with one or more disabled child. The report said there is evidence that disability benefits provide a level of support and a protective blanket to disabled couple parents or lone parent families who might otherwise fall deeper and further into debt. Experts say this strongly indicates that disabled benefits are helping mitigate, to some extent, financial hardship and help prevent disabled families from plunging even further into debt. Cara Hilton, senior policy manager for Scotland at Trussell, said: "The UK Government's plans to slash support for disabled people who most need our collective protection from hunger is cruel and irresponsible. "This research clearly shows that the right support can help prevent disabled families from falling into hardship. Cutting it is ill-considered and will leave more disabled people at risk of needing a food bank. 'One of the key findings of this research is that people in disabled households are twice as likely to be referred to a food bank than people in households without a disability. If the government chooses to go ahead with cuts, these figures will only get worse." Satwat Rehman, chief executive of One Parent Families Scotland, added: "Many single parents, the majority of whom are mothers, are raising children alone and often without respite. "When disability is also part of the equation, whether a child's or their own, the pressures multiply. This report clearly shows that these families are at significantly higher risk of accruing public debts, including council tax, benefits overpayments and energy arrears. 'With the UK Government poised to introduce cuts to disability benefits, this report is a timely reminder that welfare reform must work to support, not penalise, families."
Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
13-week PIP transition period due to be confirmed
Details about how recipients will be transitioned to the new criteria for PIP is slowly being revealed An MP has shed light on the government's Green Paper proposals for Welfare Reform, with the Department for Work and Pensions poised to unveil further details about the Welfare Reform Bill, including a "transitional period". This interim phase is designed to for people set to lose their Personal Independence Payments due to the reforms. Dr Simon Opher, a GP and the MP for Stroud, disclosed on BBC Radio 4's Today programme, as reported by Daily Record, that a transitional phase will be introduced, allowing recipients to continue receiving payments for 13 weeks before their benefit is terminated. This means that those affected by the benefit cuts will still receive their entitlements for 13 weeks beyond the initial cut-off date, offering them time to prepare and budget for the end of their benefits. Carers, who are at risk of losing their Carer's Allowance when the person they care for loses PIP, will also continue to receive their allowance throughout the 13-week transition, until the PIP award ends. Dr Opher expressed his intention "to rebel" against these proposals in an imminent vote, marking the first occasion he plans to oppose the Government. He indicated that several of his colleagues are contemplating similar actions. He acknowledged that the proposed transitional period has been extended from an initial four weeks. But he remains critical of the planned changes, describing it as nothing more than "a slight delay in the disability cuts". Explaining further, he added "It doesn't change the basic fact that they're planning to cut disability payments to quite a lot of people really. So not terribly impressed, but it's something at least." Since Liz Kendall confirmed the reform in March, there's been widespread outcry from MPs, disability charities, and PIP recipients against the upcoming changes set for November 2026. The Green Paper has launched a consultation period, urging the public to contribute their opinions on the undecided aspects of these reforms, pivotal among them being how benefits will be transitionally protected for those affected. In a bid to reduce costs while maintaining support through PIP for future claimants, the Government aims to save £5 billion each year by the end of this decade. Government impact assessments have indicated that approximately 250,000 people, 50,000 of whom are children throughout England, Scotland, and Wales, are at risk of slipping into relative poverty after housing expenses as a result of these policy shifts. This reformation will influence new applicants and current recipients undergoing reassessment for the daily living component of PIP. Under the new rules, claimants need to accumulate four points in any one of the categories to qualify during the assessment process. The assessments comprise ten categories with scoring based on the type of help, supervision, or equipment individuals necessitate to perform activities promptly, effectively, and safely. For instance, being able to prepare and cook a simple meal unaided is worth no points. But if you cannot prepare or cook food at all you could score up to eight points in that category. The reform proposes several other changes including:. Ending reassessments for disabled individuals who will never be able to work Abolishing the Work Capability Assessment Offering improved employment support to eliminate the barriers preventing disabled people from working Introducing legislation to protect those on health and disability benefits from reassessment or losing their payments if they take a chance on work
