Five women from one family on trial over alleged knife attack in Rathkeale
in the dock |
Each of the five accused have pleaded not guilty before a jury of eight men and four women in front of Judge Fiona O'Sullivan, Limerick Circuit Criminal Court.
The complainant, Christina McCarthy née Harty, sustained disfiguring knife wounds to her face, as well as to her left hand as she was trying to defend herself, Limerick Circuit Criminal Court heard.
The aggravated burglary and knife attack allegedly occurred at Ms McCarthy's home at Ballingrane, Rathkeale, Co Limerick, on December 10th, 2019.
Mary Ellen Daly neé Harty. Picture: Brendan Gleeson
News in 90 Seconds - May 16th
Sergeant Rob Sheehy, Henry Street Garda Station, Limerick, showed photographs in court of 'horizontal and vertical' knife wounds to Ms. McCarthy's face as well as 'two gashes or wounds' on her left hand.
Sergeant Sheehy agreed with prosecuting barrister, Lily Buckley, that the knife wounds to Ms McCarthy's face 'ran along her jaws up to her ears'.
Christina Casey. Picture: Brendan Gleeson
Ms Buckley told the court that Ms McCarthy was 'resting' in her bedroom when all five accused women arrived together in cars, at her home, on the date in question.
Inspector Barry Manton confirmed in court that photographs shown to the jury that were taken by gardai at the scene, included images of bloodied hair, as well as 'blood spattering' and 'blood staining' found on flooring, walls and bedsheets inside the complainant's house.
Mother and daughter, Nora 'Josie' Harty, (57), and Mary Ellen Daly neé Harty, (34), both with an address at Lisheen Park, Patrickswell, Co Limerick, are accused of one count of committing aggravated burglary while in possession of knives at Ms McCarthy's home, during which they assaulted her causing her serious harm.
Nora Harty, a first cousin of the complainant, is also charged with causing criminal damage to a window at the complainant's home.
Rita Johnson. Picture: Brendan Gleeson
Ciara Johnson, (30), St Ita's Street, St Mary's Park, Limerick, and Christina Casey, (48), St Aidan's Close, Brookfield, Tallaght, Dublin, are charged that, while in possessing of a knife and a baseball bat respectively, they committed aggravated burglary at Ms McCarthy's home, during which they intended to assault her, causing her harm. The court heard that Ciara Johnson is a daughter-in-law to Nora Harty, and Ms Casey is Nora Harty's sister.
The fifth accused, Rita Johnson, (51), St Ita's Street, St Mary's Park, mother to Ciara Johnson, is charged with committing burglary at Ms McCarthy's house, during which she intended to assault and cause harm to Ms McCarthy.
Ms Buckley told the jury that the alleged knife attack and burglary occurred 24 hours after an alleged verbal and physical interaction involving the complainant, her daughter Amanda Sheridan née McCarthy, and two of the five accused, Mary Ellen Daly and Ciara Johnson. Read more
Each of the five accused have pleaded not guilty before a jury of eight men and four women in front of Judge Fiona O'Sullivan, Limerick Circuit Criminal Court.
Ms Buckley, instructed by Brendan Gill, state solicitor for County Limerick, told the jury: 'The accused are presumed innocent and retain that presumption of innocence until you may decide otherwise.'
'The burden of proof is on the prosecution and the standard of proof is beyond a reasonable doubt - not beyond all doubt,' the prosecution barrister added.
Nora Josie Harty is represented by barrister Liam Carroll; Mary Ellen Daly is represented by barrister Grace Hogan; Ciara Johnson is being represented by barrister Karla Ray; Christina Casey is represented by barrister Joseph McMahon; and Rita Johnson is represented by barrister Johanna O'Connor.
The trial resumes Monday when the court is expected to hear evidence from the complainant.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
4 hours ago
- Sunday World
Thug who left man with ‘life-changing injuries' after being invited to his home jailed
Tristian McAteer told Stephen Doherty that he was taking his television and then attacked him with the knife and slashed him in the face and head A Donegal man who attacked another man after he had been invited back to his home for drinks and food leaving him with 'life-changing injuries' has been sentenced to six years in prison. Tristian McAteer attacked his victim with a knife, slashing his face after he was invited back to Stephen Doherty's house in Ballybofey on October 16th, 2024. The 26-year-old accused appeared at Letterkenny Circuit Court where he pleaded guilty to two charges including robbery and the production of an article, namely a knife. Details of the incident were outlined to the court by Detective Garda John O'Sullivan and state barrister, Ms Fiona Crawford, BL. The accused and Mr Doherty, along with a woman, had been out drinking at the Shamrock Bar in Ballybofey, earlier in the day. When back at Mr Doherty's house at Navenny Street, the victim asked McAteer and the woman if they would like something to eat. When he came back into the room with food, McAteer told Mr Doherty that he was taking his television and then attacked him with the knife, slashed him in the face and head. Mr Doherty tried to defend himself and managed to get on top of McAteer and put his knees on top of his arms as he tried to hold him down. Tristan McAteer News in 90 Seconds - 7th June However, the woman then attacked Mr Doherty by stabbing him with a screwdriver in the head and then striking him in the back with slats of wood from a child's bed which she had found in the house. Mr Doherty managed to flee from his house to a nearby bar to raise the alarm while bleeding heavily. He asked to look at their live CCTV and as he did so he witnessed McAteer and the woman leaving his home and getting into a taxi with two of his televisions, a PlayStation 4 console and controller and a portable speaker Mr Doherty was then taken to hospital where he was treated for his multiple injuries. They included lacerations to his cheek and forehead and damage to his nose. The scene was secured by Gardai and later that evening, McAteer was located and arrested at Glenfin Street at approximately 9.50pm. His clothing was covered in blood, he had been fighting with other people and he was pepper-sprayed by Gardai before being arrested. He has been in custody at Castlerea Prison since October 21st, 2024 and has entered a plea to both charges. Tristan McAteer The woman who attacked Mr Doherty during the incident is also due to come before the Circuit Court and Judge John Aylmer remarked that this was very much a "joint enterprise." A victim impact statement was read out in court on behalf of the victim Mr Doherty. The statement on behalf of Mr Doherty, who was not in court, told how the incident had resulted in his home being turned upside down and his life destroyed. He said he thought his life was at risk at one stage when McAteer had the blade to his throat and that he was seriously injured as a result of the attack. The court heard how McAteer has 30 previous convictions for a range of offences including robbery, possession of knives, assault, road traffic, criminal damage and breach of a safety order. Barrister for the accused, Mr Peter Nolan, BL, said his client was actually a very quiet man when sober but is often under the influence of some kind of intoxicant. He had a troubled background, never knew his father and his relationship with his mother is strained although she has always supported him. His brother died tragically earlier this year and this had had a particularly bad impact on McAteer and he realises now that he is at a crossroads in his life and that his life is bleak, said Mr Nolan. McAteer has now broken all contact with the co-accused and other people he was involved with. Mr Nolan added that this was a "classic situation" of a man with no qualifications, no work history and not ability to be gainfully employed so he slips into the easy way of drinking but now realises that's not the way. He said McAteer had put his hands up and gone forward on a signed plea and was anxious to deal with the case. He added that it was a story that Judge Aylmer has heard numerous times but he was anxious that something be done for McAteer stressing that he agreed with the Judge that this was very much a "joint enterprise" and that BOTH of them were responsible for it. Passing sentence, Judge Aylmer said the aggravating features of the case was that McAteer had previous convictions for robbery and assault and the fact that he produced a weapon and used it on the homeowner. He added that all this occurred all occurred in the sanctity of Mr Doherty's home where McAteer had been invited as a guest before walking away with his television. His victim had been left in a state of anxiety and depression and had to get counselling to help him for guidance moving forward. Before considering mitigation, Judge Aylmer said he placed the robbery at the upper end of the scale meriting a sentence of 11 years in prison and the production of a knife at the utmost end of the scale meriting a full maximum sentence of five years in prison. He added the accused had come before the court on a signed plea which was "very wise" where he said almost nothing else could be said for him. He accepted McAteer was remorseful, that Gardai said he was quiet when sober and that his entire criminal record was related to his chronic drug and alcohol addictions, adding he will have plenty of time to address these issues in prison. Due to the signed plea, he was reducing the sentence of robbery to one of seven years and the production of a knife to one of three years with both sentences to run concurrently. He added that he wanted to encourage McAteer to engage in his rehabilitation and said he was suspending the last 12 months of the sentence meaning the accused will serve six years in prison. When the sentence was handed down McAteer spoke up to Judge Aylmer and called the sentence "disgusting" before being led away by prison officers.
Sunday World
4 hours ago
- Sunday World
Woman (38) caught with over €4k worth of drugs including an ‘exotic substance'
Defence barrister, Mr Garnet Orange, SC said at the time of the offence, Candice Faulkner Faulkner was an advocate for the cannabis use. A Donegal woman has appeared in court after being caught with over €4,000 worth of drugs, including an 'exotic substance.' Candice Faulkner (38) of Marion Park, Buncrana appeared at Letterkenny Circuit Court before Judge John Aylmer charged with drugs offences. She is charged with possession of a controlled drug, namely cannabis, for unlawful sale or supply at Marion Park on December 28, 2020. Additionally, she is also charged with possessing cannabis resin for the purpose of unlawful sale or supply to another on the same date and location. Faulkner is also charged with possessing N,N-Dimethyltryptamine for the purpose of unlawful sale or supply to another on the same date and location. Garda Declan O'Brien and State Prosecutor Fiona Crawford BL outlined the details of the case and said a search warrant was obtained to search Faulkner's property in December 2020. Faulkner was not present at the time of the search on December 28, 2020 but she returned to the house while the gardaí were there. Candice Faulkner. Photo: Northwest News Pix News in 90 Seconds - 7th June The court heard that cannabis, cannabis resin and N,N-Dimethyltryptamine (N N DMT) were found at the property. Faulkner made full admissions to owning the cannabis while scales, jars and various other items were also found in the property. The court heard Faulkner had previous convictions but they related to traffic matters. Defence barrister, Mr Garnet Orange, SC said at the time of the offence, Faulkner was an advocate for the cannabis use. The cannabis found was 87.7 grams valued at €1,754 while the 289grams of cannabis resin was valued at €1,735.80. However, the court heard it was difficult to put a value on the other plant material but it was valued at €620. In relation to the N,N-Dimethyltryptamine (N N DMT), the court heard a 'strange' red bark material and is a hallucinogenic. Mr Orange referred to the substance as 'eye catching' and an 'exotic substance'. He added there was a difficulty in identifying what it was and placing an evaluation on the substance. Mr Orange said when Faulkner was asked about the substance, she 'didn't have a clue about it' and he said it was found on top of the wardrobe and was covered in dust. The court heard there was a process to distil the hallucinogenic and there was no evidence to suggest that this process was carried out. Mr Orange said Faulkner is a long time cannabis user who uses it in the context of ADHD and she is not out selling drugs on the street. He said the emphasis should be on supply rather than sale. Judge John Aylmer questioned about the other items found at the house and Mr Orange said Faulkner would measure out her own consumption before use and the drugs were for personal use while she also denies that a tick list had anything to do with her. The court heard Faulkner is keen to stop using and is no longer an advocate for cannabis use. Mr Orange asked Judge John Aylmer to deal with the case by a suspended sentence and asked for a probation report to be completed on his client. Judge John Aylmer approved the request for a probation report and ordered it to include an assessment for suitability for community service. The case was adjourned to the October session of the Letterkenny Circuit Court.
Sunday World
4 hours ago
- Sunday World
Former H block boss suspects collusion in jail slaying of loyalist thug
'There are still too many coincidences and unanswered questions hanging over Billy Wright's killing in the Maze' PACEMAKER BFST 11-06-02: Mark Fulton pictured (left)in 1996 who was found dead today in his prison cell. He is pictured with his close friend and associate of Former LVF leader Billy Wright. Christopher McWilliams (foreground), one of the killers of Loyalist leader Billy Wright, walks free from Magilligan Prison in Co Londonderry Friday October 20, 2000. McWilliams, who shot the notorious Loyalist Volunteer Force leader on December 27, 1997, today denied any British Government collusion in the murder. See PA story ULSTER Wright. PA Photo/Belfast Telegraph: Ian Trevithick. William McKee says he was thrown to the wolves as British security services allowed the murder of loyalist killer Billy Wright on his watch. McKee was at his desk as governor of the Maze Prison on December 27, 1997, the day the INLA claimed their biggest scalp of the Troubles. It was the final weeks and months of negotiations that would lead to the signing of the Good Friday Agreement and Wright was seen as one of the remaining obstacles to a settlement. Vehemently opposed to the peace process, he stayed at the head of his LVF sectarian killing machine despite being behind bars, orchestrating and ordering attacks with the help of his trusted second in command, Mark 'Swinger' Fulton. William McKee News in 90 Seconds - 7th June So when Christopher 'Crip' McWilliams, John Kenneway and John 'Sonny' Glennon intercepted Wright as he made his way from his cell in the Maze to a visit from his girlfriend, they removed one of the biggest obstacles to peace. Armed with a pistol smuggled into what was supposed to be the most secure prison in Europe, the trio climbed over the prison roof and shot him inside the prison transport van. In October 1998 they were convicted of murder and possession of a firearm and ammunition with intent to endanger life. They were sentenced to life imprisonment for the murder and 20 years on the firearms offence. Within two years they were free men, under the terms of the peace accord. It was a day that was to leave a permanent scar on the mind and soul of McKee. As the man in charge, he found himself thrust into the spotlight. He was to discover he may have been an unwitting pawn in a bigger game, played out by MI5 in collusion with the INLA. Collusion Inside The Maze is the title of McKee's newly published book, a novel that teases out the conspiracy theories that still surround the death of one of the most notorious and dangerous killers in the history of the conflict. 'It's a 'what if' book,' McKee told the Sunday World. 'I have to be careful, I'm still covered by the Official Secrets Act — as far as the facts are concerned, I can only stick to what is in the public domain, but what happened has never sat well with me. There are too many coincidences and unanswered questions.' Billy Wright He said his decision to address those questions in the form of a novel is an attempt to highlight certain issues, including the role of the security services and why he as governor was never informed of intelligence that pointed to a planned attack on Wright. 'What is fact is that during a bugged INLA meeting on the Antrim Road, a plan to assassinate 'King Rat' Wright was discussed. That meeting was 12 days before Wright was killed. 'When Wright was transferred from Maghaberry, so were Glennon and McWilliams. I was never told that there was clear intelligence Wright was going to be killed. Did they just let it happen? 'It has festered with me for a long time. Wright was a very bad man — he had been linked to 20 sectarian murders — but even given that, he should have been moved out of the Maze.' Republicans were threatening to take retaliatory action against Wright's LVF, which would have put the entire peace process at the risk of collapse. McKee said he was in his office when he got the call that there had been a shooting in H Block 6. 'You just know what to do, it's not a question of 'oh my God what next?' Your training takes over — you know what to do. 'People always asked me to tell the true story, but I don't know what the true story is, so I decided to write a thriller that was loosely based on the murder, giving possibilities that may account for state collusion,' he said. The coffin of Billy Wright. Photo: CRISPIN RODWELL Much of what is in the book is drawn from his imagination but unmistakably grounded in real events. 'I used Billy Wright's name but, under the Official Secrets Act, I couldn't use anything that was not in the public domain. 'The killing of Wright is a significant part of the book, but there are other incidents as well, including ones connected to the IRA's Nutting Squad, Stakeknife and the Disappeared.' He said he has shared the book with a number of former combatants who have given it their seal of approval on what was a decisive moment in our history. 'One combatant told me, 'Mate, that's not a novel, that's a true story'. I hope it goes some way to shedding some light on what may or may not have happened.' Billy McKee joined the Prison Service as a 22-year-old never intending it to be his career, but he quickly rose through the ranks, eventually finding himself governor at Maghaberry and the Maze. At the height of the Troubles the job was fraught with risk. He had to move house three times at short notice because of death threats. 'I'd get a call in the middle of the night from the security services telling me, 'Get out of the house now, they're on their way to kill you'. The police couldn't come in case it compromised an informant or agent. The government would move us to another house until it happened again.' The pressure was too much for his marriage, which collapsed. His mental health suffered. He recalls leaving Maghaberry in the back of an ambulance believing he had suffered a heart attack. It wasn't but it was a panic attack brought on by the pressures of dealing with a failing marriage, death threats and being head of one of the most notorious prisons in Europe. After a near 30-year career in the Prison Service, he retired on medical grounds but to this day struggles with PTSD. 'I've had 66 counselling sessions learning to live with what I call my 'black cloud' — some days it's there some days it's not. When I was in the Prison Service I was known as Billy, since I left I introduce myself as William, I'm trying to leave that person behind. 'Revisiting the Wright murder has been cathartic because as I've said the circumstances have festered with me for years.' These days William spends much of his time talking to youth groups and often to former combatants. 'It helps me, but I also think it helps young people and even those who went through it all in this country to listen to someone who stared it in the face.'
