logo
University of Cambridge granted High Court injunction against protesters

University of Cambridge granted High Court injunction against protesters

Yahoo21-03-2025

The University of Cambridge has been granted a High Court order blocking Israel-Palestine protests on parts of its campus until the end of July.
Last month, a judge dismissed a request by the university for a five-year injunction blocking direct action related to the conflict on several sites without the university's consent.
The university returned to the High Court on Wednesday, asking a judge for a four-month injunction preventing protesters from disrupting multiple graduation events on two sites planned up to July 26, the final graduation ceremony of the academic year.
The European Legal Support Center (ELSC) opposed the university's bid, with its lawyers telling the court the injunction is a 'disproportionate infringement' on the human rights of the protesters and would set a 'dangerous precedent' for protesting on campuses.
In a ruling on Friday, Mr Justice Soole granted the injunction, stating there is an 'imminent and real risk of a recurrence' of direct action on the campus and a 'strong probability that this will otherwise occur' if the order is not issued.
He said: 'I am satisfied that there is a compelling need for the granting of an injunction.'
He added the 'proposed terms are the minimum necessary in the circumstances'.
Lawyers for the university told the court in London that last year, pro-Palestine protesters staged demonstrations at Senate House Yard and Greenwich House, which 'forced' a graduation ceremony to be moved.
Myriam Stacey KC, for the university, told the hearing there is a 'real and imminent risk' of further action on campus, with protesters saying 'we will be back' after leaving Senate House Yard at the end of November.
She said the protesters appeared to be mostly affiliated with the group Cambridge for Palestine, whose stated aims online include for the university to 'divest from institutions and companies complicit in the ongoing ethnic cleansing of Palestine'.
She told the court: 'It is the activity we are seeking to stop, not the viewpoint. It is legally irrelevant who is doing this. It is what they are doing that we object to.'
Ms Stacey continued in written submissions that the university sought to prohibit protesters from entering, occupying or remaining on the sites for direct action without its consent, directly blocking access to the sites, or erecting or placing structures on them, such as tents or sleeping equipment.
Owen Greenhall, for ELSC, said in written submissions the university was discriminating against the 'race and/or political belief' of protesters as it was only after pro-Palestine actions that it began seeking an injunction, allowing other demonstrations such as those for Ukraine or industrial action.
He said an injunction was 'not necessary' and would have a 'chilling effect on political expression at Cambridge'.
But Mr Justice Soole said the injunction 'does provide a fair balance between the rights of all parties'.
Following the ruling, a spokesperson for the university said: 'The University of Cambridge welcomes today's decision at the High Court.
'We took this action to protect the right of students to graduate and to prevent access to buildings that contain sensitive, confidential information.
'This was never about preventing lawful protest. The injunction safeguards a very small part of the University estate from an occupation that would prevent graduations from going ahead.
'It also protects the right for our staff to work. Protests occur regularly at the university, including a rally held immediately outside Great St Mary's church during the last graduation ceremony while an injunction covering the Senate House, a few yards away, was in place.'
Cambridge for Palestine said it 'condemns' the decision, which it described as 'a violent move to criminalise and police our movement'.
Anna Ost, senior legal officer at ELSC, said: 'It is more important than ever to resist attempts to shut down protests for Palestinian liberation.
'The extent of the five-year injunction the university originally asked for demonstrated that they were seeking to restrict protests.'
She continued: 'Instead of acting urgently to review their investments, the university has stalled and sought to silence their critics with this injunction.
'We remain deeply concerned about the broader trend of universities using legal measures to target solidarity with Palestine.'
Ruth Ehrlich, head of advocacy and campaigns at Liberty, which also intervened in the case, said: 'Today's judgment sets a dangerous precedent which will severely restrict protest rights on campus.
'Students have long been at the forefront of movements for social change, whether in opposing apartheid or rising tuition fees.
'It is not right that universities are curbing students' ability to do so, and creating a hostile space for people simply trying to make their voices heard.
'We urge universities to allow students to speak up for what they believe in on campus, and to protect the right to protest.'
The University of Cambridge has been approached for comment.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Trump job approval at 38 percent in new survey
Trump job approval at 38 percent in new survey

The Hill

time24 minutes ago

  • The Hill

Trump job approval at 38 percent in new survey

President Trump's approval rating dipped to 38 percent, the lowest of his second term, according to the latest poll from Quinnipiac University. In the June poll, 38 percent of registered voters approved of the way Trump is doing his job, while 54 percent disapproved. The results mark the first time Trump's numbers dipped below 40-percent threshold since returning to office in January — when he enjoyed an all-time high job approval rating of 46 percent. In February, that number slumped to 45 percent; in March, to 42 percent; and in April, to 41 percent. Quinnipiac University did not release polling data in May. Immigration remains the president's best issue, with 43 percent approval and 54 percent disapproval ratings. But the numbers have declined slightly from April, when 45 percent approved and 50 percent disapproved of his handling of immigration. On the issue of deportations, 40 percent approved and 56 percent disapproved — a slightly downward turn from April, when 42 percent approved and 53 percent disapproved. Trump's approval is 40 percent on the economy, 38 percent on trade, 37 percent on universities, 35 percent on the Israel-Hamas conflict and 34 percent on the Russia-Ukraine war. 'As the Russia – Ukraine war grinds through its third year, Americans make it clear they have little appetite for the way the Trump administration is handling the situation,' Quinnipiac University polling analyst Tim Malloy said in a statement. Polling averages maintained by Decision Desk HQ show Trump's job approval rating at 47 percent approval and 49.9 percent disapproval. A poll this week from YouGov/The Economist has Trump's approval among registered voters at 45 percent and his disapproval at 53 percent. The latest poll was conducted June 5-9, with 1,265 self-identified registered voters. The margin of error is 2.8 percentage points.

Unpacking claims Ilhan Omar's daughter called for 'death to the colonial empire' on Instagram
Unpacking claims Ilhan Omar's daughter called for 'death to the colonial empire' on Instagram

Yahoo

time32 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Unpacking claims Ilhan Omar's daughter called for 'death to the colonial empire' on Instagram

In June 2025, rumors abounded that Isra Hirsi, daughter of U.S. Rep. Ilhan Omar, a Democrat from Minnesota, had posted "death to the colonial empire" from Los Angeles to Rafah in Gaza on an Instagram story. Instagram stories are posts that disappear after 24 hours unless the accounts that post them highlight them on their profile page. For example, X user End Wokeness shared a screen capture of the supposed Instagram story alongside a photograph of Hirsi with her mother Omar (archived): As of this writing, the End Wokeness post had gained 10,000 and 660,000 views. The screen capture appeared on other X posts, including one by far-right political activist Laura Loomer (archived), who said Hirsi, who is Black, wanted "violence in the LA riots and calling for the end of Western Civilization." Another accused Hirsi of hating her own country, the U.S., and of wanting "a race war" (archived). Further, Snopes users searched the website seeking to confirm the veracity of these claims. In addition, conservative news outlet The Daily Caller published a report making these same allegations. However, due to the nature of Instagram stories and the fact that more than 24 hours had passed since Hirsi supposedly posted it, Snopes could not confirm she had indeed done so. We contacted her via Instagram direct messages to ask whether she had and we will update the story should she respond. However, we were able to confirm that the Instagram story Hirsi allegedly reposted did exist. It was created by Instagram user @__public_library, whose bio gave a first name — Amanda — self-describing as a writer, care worker, mother and a "revert" — which is how some converts to Islam describe themselves. The term "reversion" is sometimes preferred to the term "conversion," based on the belief that babies who are born with a Muslim nature and raised in other religions and cultures will return to their innate Muslim nature. Indeed, one of her stories on June 11, 2025, indicated @__public_library had "reverted" in September 2024: (Instagram user @__public_library) Many of her posts related to the humanitarian crisis in Gaza as a result of the Israel-Hamas war. Indeed, on June 8, 2025, @__public_library posted a series of images with text and a song by Natalia Lafourcade titled "Hasta la Raíz" (archived). One of the images was the same that appeared in Hirsi's alleged Instagram story, showing children playing jump rope on a dirt road with the text: "From LA to Rafah, there is one common oppressor. Death to the colonial empire. Life for our children." The post appeared to draw a parallel between the Israel-Hamas war and the confrontations between protesters in Los Angeles and Immigration and Customs Enforcement on the weekend of June 9, 2025. Below the post, the user had written the following (emphasis ours): I am the Granddaughter of Mexican migrants.I am the daughter of an occupied land.I am the mother of resistance.I am both witness and the keeper of generational is a never-ending empires must end in occupied "America" to occupied Palestine We found no indication that Hirsi followed @__public_library, though it is not necessary to follow a public Instagram account to reshare one of their posts. Hirsi, who is Black and a Muslim, has also frequently posted in solidarity with Palestinians in Gaza, including on posts that aimed to share personal news. For example, she used the tag #FreePalestine in the post where she announced her graduation from Barnard College at Columbia University. The post also included a photo of her holding up a Palestinian flag on stage during the graduation ceremony (archived):In April 2025, Hirsi said she had been suspended from Barnard College after taking part in a pro-Palestine protest on campus (archived): As of this writing, there isn't enough evidence to determine whether Hirsi did or did not reshare @__public_library's Instagram story. We will update this article if and when Hirsi responds to our request for comment. Ibrahim, Nur. "What We Know about Trump Deploying National Guard for LA Protests." Snopes, 10 June 2025, Accessed 11 June 2025. Isra Hirsi — THE INTERNATIONAL CONGRESS OF YOUTH VOICES. "THE INTERNATIONAL CONGRESS of YOUTH VOICES." THE INTERNATIONAL CONGRESS of YOUTH VOICES, 2014, Accessed 11 June 2025. MacPhail, Kyle Abdur-Raqeeb. "Islam21c." Islam21c, 19 Nov. 2015, Accessed 11 June 2025. Nace, Aki. "Ilhan Omar's Daughter Says She Was Suspended from College after Pro-Palestinian Protest at Columbia - CBS Minnesota." 18 Apr. 2024, Accessed 11 June 2025. Sandoval, Natalie. "Ilhan Omar's 'Hyper Woke' Daughter Has Message for America." Dailycaller, The Daily Caller, 10 June 2025, Accessed 11 June 2025. 2025, Accessed 11 June 2025.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store