US appeals court rules for watchdog Media Matters in fight over Texas subpoena
May 30 (Reuters) - A U.S. appeals court on Friday rejected Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton's demand for internal records from liberal watchdog group Media Matters, calling the state's probe a retaliatory campaign against the nonprofit.
In its ruling, opens new tab, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit upheld a lower judge's order that blocked a Texas subpoena for financial records and other information from Media Matters.
'Tellingly, Paxton has not offered any argument to dispute that the investigation was retaliatory,' Circuit Judge Harry Edwards wrote. Edwards called the Paxton probe 'an arguably bad-faith investigation.'
Texas launched its investigation of Media Matters in late 2023, immediately after Elon Musk's social media platform X sued the organization in federal court.
In that ongoing lawsuit, X alleges that Media Matters defamed it in a report that said major advertisers' brands had appeared next to right-wing extremist content. Media Matters has defended its reporting.
The Texas attorney general's office did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Friday's ruling.
In a statement, Media Matters president and chief executive Angelo Carusone called the court's decision a victory for free speech.
A lawyer for Media Matters, Aria Branch, said the D.C. Circuit's decision should warn state attorneys general that "any attempt to intimidate and harass through baseless investigations will be met with decisive rejection from the courts."
Texas sought financial records in its request to Media Matters, in addition to communications with major corporate advertisers and X employees.
The U.S. Federal Trade Commission recently indicated it is also investigating Media Matters, according to a document seen by Reuters.
The FTC, in a civil investigative demand, asked Media Matters to hand over any communications it had with other groups that evaluate misinformation and hate speech in news and social media.
Carusone blasted the FTC probe in a prior statement and said the Trump administration has abused 'the power of the federal government to bully political opponents and silence critics." A spokesperson for the FTC declined to comment on the Reuters report.
The case is Media Matters for America et al v. Texas Attorney General Warren Kenneth Paxton Jr, U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, No. 24-7059.
For Media Matters: Aria Branch of Elias Law Group
For Paxton: Lanora Pettit of the Texas attorney general's office
Read more:
FTC probes Media Matters over Musk's X boycott claims, document shows
Media Matters accuses Musk's X of 'abusive' tactics in new lawsuit
Musk's X likely to lose records appeal in Media Matters case, court says
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
37 minutes ago
- The Independent
New Mexico police officer dies following traffic stop shooting
A police officer from northwestern New Mexico has died, several days after being critically injured when a man opened fire during a traffic stop. Law enforcement agencies gathered Sunday to escort the body of Bloomfield Police Officer Timothy Ontiveros from an Albuquerque hospital, where he had undergone multiple surgeries over recent days, to the office of the state medical investigator. A procession back to Bloomfield will be held Tuesday. Ontiveros had pulled over a man for a traffic violation on Memorial Day. Authorities said the man refused to roll down his window or provide identification. After negotiations failed, officers opted to arrest him and broke a window to take him into custody. The man subsequently began shooting, hitting Ontiveros and narrowly missing a second officer at the scene. That officer returned fire, striking and killing the suspect. Authorities said the man had a record that included previous arrests for assault, trespassing, resisting an officer and threatening hospital staff. Ontiveros, 33, previously worked for the Farmington Police Department and was a volunteer firefighter for the neighboring community of Aztec. A GoFundMe page was set up to help his family. 'In his short time with the agency, he demonstrated kindness, professionalism, and dedication to the safety of the community he served,' Bloomfield Police Chief Phillip Francisco said Sunday in a social media post. Ontiveros had joined Bloomfield police in December. Francisco asked for the community's support as the department navigated what he called a tremendous loss. Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham also mourned the loss of the officer. 'His death is a heartbreaking reminder of the dangers our law enforcement officers face every single day,' she said in a statement Sunday.
The Guardian
37 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Trump news at a glance: US-China trade relations falter amid fragile trade truce
President Donald Trump had this May hailed a 'total reset' of US-China relations, but trade relations between the world's two-largest economies have faltered since, highlighting the fragility of the truce. The US is now complaining that China not delivered on its promises to roll back restrictions on the export of key critical minerals, with Trump saying on Friday that China had 'totally violated' the agreement. China has also hit back, with its commerce ministry saying this week that China 'is determined to safeguard its rights and interests'. It also denied the accusation it had undermined the 12 May agreement. Here are the key stories at a glance: China has accused the US of 'seriously violating' the fragile US-China detente that has been in place for less than a month since the two countries agreed to pause the trade war that risked upending the global economy. Read the full story A pro-Donald Trump journalist says she was fired from her job after criticizing the president's secretary of defense, Pete Hegseth, over his attempts to restrict media access at the Pentagon. Read the full story At least 20 Planned Parenthood clinics across seven states have shuttered since the start of 2025 or have announced plans to close soon – closures that come amid immense financial and political turbulence for the reproductive health giant as the United States continues to grapple with the fallout from the end of Roe v Wade. Read the full story Millions of acres of Alaska wilderness will lose federal protections and be exposed to drilling and mining in the Trump administration's latest move to prioritize energy production over the shielding of the US's open spaces. Read the full story Political leaders across the US have condemned what they describe as a horrific, antisemitic attack in Boulder, Colorado, after a man allegedly used a makeshift flamethrower and incendiary devices to target people at a rally calling for the release of the hostages held by Hamas. Read the full story Donald Trump has pardoned two south Florida shark divers convicted of theft for freeing 19 sharks and a giant grouper from a fisherman's longline several miles from shore. Pardons for Tanner Mansell and John Moore Jr were signed on Wednesday. They had been convicted in 2022 of theft of property within special maritime jurisdiction. Read the full story Trump administration officials sparked a huge protest in a Boston suburb after immigration agents detained a high school student while they were seeking his father. US senator Joni Ernst triggered fierce criticism after making light of voters' fears that Republican Medicaid cuts could prove fatal. Massachusetts Institute of Technology barred its 2025 class president from attending her graduation ceremony after she delivered a speech condemning the war in Gaza and criticizing the university's ties to Israel. Catching up? Here's what happened on 1 June 2025.
Daily Mail
39 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Taylor Swift fans are convinced her ex Joe Alwyn silently supported her amid battle to buy back her masters
Taylor Swift fans think her ex-boyfriend Joe Alwyn subtly showed support for her while she was in the midst of buying back her music empire. On Friday the 35-year-old Eras Tour artist announced that she bought her master recordings from Shamrock Capital. And by Sunday, a fan with the TikTok handle @manumelm created a 17-second clip connecting the 34-year-old actor's last Instagram post — shared more than two months ago — to his pop star ex. Sandwiched into Joe's carousel post, uploaded on March 12, was a photo of a heart-shaped white bowl with a four-leaf clover painted at the center. Some Swifties have taken it as a symbol related to the aforementioned Los Angeles-based investment firm Shamrock. It was noted in the brief social media snippet that the photos Taylor used for her Instagram announcement last week were taken on March 27, fueling the theory that Joe knew about the deal before it was finalized in late May. While some of Swift's diehard fan base latched onto the idea, others were skeptical that Alwyn was secretly supporting the singer. 'Let's be real. He did it for St. Patrick's Day,' one person wrote, collecting over 3,000 likes. Another added to the comments thread, 'This is a bit of a stretch, I think.' A social media user named Susie Sunshine agreed, 'I kinda think we're reaching, seeing something that's not there.' There was also a fan who offered, 'He got so good at the art of secret, coded message, because he learned it from her.' And someone else wrote in all capital letters, 'It's so suspicious!' The TikTok, soundtracked by Taylor's song Right Where You Left Me, has so far racked up 30,000 likes. Taylor and Joe reportedly met when they crossed paths at the 2016 Met Gala. They were first pictured together in Nashville, Tennessee in 2017. They were an item, keeping their relationship under tight wraps, until April 2023. Following their split, Taylor began dating Kansas City Chiefs star Travis Kelce later that summer, and the two are going strong. Billboard reported that Swift spent nearly $360 million to buy back her music catalog from Shamrock Capital after 'bully' Scooter Braun sold her masters to the private equity firm in 2020, a year after buying them from Big Machine. 'I almost stopped thinking it could ever happen, after 20 years of having the carrot dangled and then yanked away,' Taylor wrote on her website on Friday. She continued, 'But that's all in the past now. I've been bursting into tears of joy at random intervals ever since I found that this is really happening. I really get to say those words. All of the music I've ever made… now belongs… to me.' Her Instagram post teasing the full statement about the masters read, 'You belong with me. Letter on my site :).' It was accompanied by several pictures of her in a simple pale blue sweater and light wash jeans while posing and smiling with six of her records.
