Malachy Clerkin: Calling the football championship wide open is a polite way of saying every team is flawed
And so we get down to business. A
football championship
that has already provided more watchable games in a couple of months than in the previous two years combined will now shift gear.
For all the good vibes around football in 2025, winning and losing were kind of abstract concepts up to this point, consequences a sort of far-off threat/promise. Not any more.
From here on out, you either do the thing or you spend the next seven months annoyed that you did not do the thing. Of the 16 teams lining out this weekend, only
Armagh
have nothing immediate to play for. Win, lose or draw, they will top Group 4 and are guaranteed an All-Ireland quarter-final place. But even at that, knocking
Galway
out would be a delicious way to round off the group stage.
Regular as clockwork, the moaning has begun. You know it, you hear it, you can feel it in the air. 'Why?' trill the voices. Why are we ditching this format to bring in yet another one next year? Typical GAA, getting rid of something just when it starts to get good.
READ MORE
To which the only sane response is, Jesus effing wept! Are people's memories really this short? Have they genuinely forgotten the reasons this stuff is changing? We surely can't be that easily distracted. Can we?
Maybe we can. Maybe this is the ultimate tribute to the
Football Review Committee
. Jim Gavin is big on KPIs – or, Key Performance Indicators for the people whose lives are mercifully free of LinkedIn's assault on the language. But even he couldn't have imagined that one of the markers of the effect of the new football rules would be to make people forget the flaws in the format of the championship.
It's worth restating, just for clarity. This is still 24 games to get rid of just four teams. It's still the case that some counties who have lost three matches aren't yet gone from the championship. It's still the case that some of them might not even need to win this weekend to progress.
Since the championship began at the start of April, the collective record of
Derry
,
Clare
,
Roscommon
and
Cork
reads: Played 15, Won 3, Drew 2, Lost 10. All three wins came against Division Four opposition. Yet they're all still nominally in with a shout.
[
All-Ireland Series permutations: All to play for as group stage comes to close
Opens in new window
]
The Rossies have posted one victory since the start of the championship, a 19-point win over London, who went on to be one of only two teams not to win a game in the Tailteann Cup. Yet as long as they get at least a draw against Cork in Portlaoise, Davy Burke's side will go through to the last 12.
Derry sit alongside London and Waterford as the only teams in the country not to win a game in the 2025 championship so far. Yet they can feasibly still go through even if they lose to Dublin in Newry. It's unlikely, yes. But it's far from impossible. If the Dubs beat them by one and Armagh beat Galway by five, Paddy Tally's side sails on. Three defeats and one draw from four games and they would be just as alive in the championship as Armagh are.
Armagh's Rian O'Neill celebrates a two point score with Óisín Conaty against Dublin in Round 2 of the championship earlier this month. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho
So when someone asks you why the silly, meddling GAA had to go messing around with the format again, this is why. It's football sponsored by Hotel California – teams are checking out all over the country but still finding it very hard to leave. That won't happen next year. As soon as you lose two games in the 2026 Sam Maguire, your season is done.
As for why it feels like it has worked better this year than before, the reasons are pretty simple. The first, plainly, is the new rules. It was bad enough that the championship structure was full of holes under the old rules – actually sitting through the games made it so much worse.
Whatever you like or don't like about the new rules, everyone can see that the sport is more engaging now. The lulls and longueurs in which to contemplate the pointlessness of the format just aren't there any more.
But there's a deeper and far more obvious reason too – and one that Gavin is blue in the face telling people that no changes to the playing rules or format will ever be able to affect. The field is flatter now than it's been in ages, maybe even in generations.
Dublin
are sixth in the betting. The next three after them are Monaghan, Mayo and Derry. So, essentially, you have nine teams that can either win the All-Ireland or be the spoke in the wheel for one of the others.
When was that ever the case before? You probably have to go back to something like 1999. Galway were defending All-Ireland champions that year but got beaten by Mayo in the Connacht final, who then lost the All-Ireland semi-final to Cork. Cork were league champions but hadn't beaten Kerry in Munster in four years.
Armagh won Ulster despite starting out fifth in the betting behind Donegal, Derry, Down and Tyrone. Kildare were defending Leinster champions but couldn't beat Offaly, who couldn't beat Meath. Dublin couldn't either. It all washed out as a Meath v Cork All-Ireland final, with anything up to half a dozen counties watching on, full sure they were a match for either of them.
This year has precisely that kind of feel. When people say the championship is wide open, they're being polite. What they really mean is that every team is flawed and looks beatable. Kerry are favourites but haven't been tested. Armagh are probably the best around, but nobody's scared of them. Everyone else has lost at least once already.
When the landscape looks like that, the format doesn't matter a damn. Just throw the ball up and get on with it.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Kildare hurlers: The long and winding road to make it back to the Liam MacCarthy
The Kildare hurlers were so close they could feel it. It was 49 years ago yesterday when the Lilywhites got ahead of Wexford in the Leinster SHC semi-final, only to fall by four points thanks to the Model County's late surge. Wexford went on to lift the Liam MacCarthy Cup. Pat Dunney was at the heart of it for Kildare in Athy that day. "I remember with 10 minutes to go we were very close to winning," said the Raheens great. "Then they got a couple of scores and just held on and won - probably because you weren't in that position before, I suppose. "They were used to playing at a different level. The effort that we put in to be that close, we just couldn't sustain it for the full length of the game. "As he was for the county in the previous decade and has been since his playing days ended thanks to the work he has done in administrative roles to foster the sport in the county." No wonder then that last Saturday at Croke Park was a day to celebrate for Dunney, and that he is so looking forward to today's SHC preliminary quarter-final against Dublin. We'll get to that. His former team-mate, Noel Burke, recalled the atmosphere in Athy. "There was a real interest in Kildare hurling at that time," said the Ardclough man who was originally from Galway. "We were there or thereabouts but were good one year and bad the next. It just depended on getting a consistent amount of good lads on the team. "It was three or four clubs that were always just hanging in at the time. But it's a different story now and it's going well. You need that to have a fair chance at senior level." Dunney, a successful dual player for the Lilywhites, won an All-Ireland junior hurling title with the Lilywhites in 1962 and again four years later. All-Ireland intermediate and Division 2 success followed in 1969. "We were quite competitive then in the leagues," recalled the Prosperous man. "We were playing the Waterfords, Clares and Galways." Kildare played in the senior championship for most of the 1970s - taking a break to win the inaugural All-Ireland B competition in '74. They made it to that 1976 provincial semi-final, beating Dublin along the way in Aughrim, and made it back to the semis against Wexford the following summer. But they lost to Offaly in 1979 and returned to the B championship, which they won in 1980 - only to be heavily beaten by Galway in the All-Ireland quarter-finals. The next generation hadn't come through to consolidate the progression made. "All the team had gotten old together," Dunney said. "It ran out of numbers. It can happen, of course. Kildare remained competitive at their own level after that without winning things but then dropped back around the early 2000s. "That's why what is happening now is important. It's like a school team - you have a period where you have a brilliant team for a few years, then a period when you're not as good. "That's what happened in the 70s and the success Kildare are having now, hopefully that continues to grow the game and ensures we have the players - and the coaches - coming through. It's all about the numbers. You need the numbers involved." Kildare returned to the extended Leinster championship from 2001 for four years, but only beat Wicklow in that period. Dunney - who went on to be a selector during Mick O'Dwyer's time with the Lilywhites - was the chairman of Croke Park's hurling development committee when, in 2004, the Christy Ring and Rackard Cups were announced. Kildare have been slowly building blocks since then. Naas' move into the competitive underage ranks in Kilkenny was massive, as has been the club's progress in the Leinster club championship - and the appointment of David Herity as the Lilywhitsenior manager, and more recently Brian Dowley. Colm Nolan, the current county hurling chairman, came on board in 2014. Four years later he headed up an action plan to drive participation in non-traditional hurling areas - over 50 'action agents' were appointed to go to work. "We knew if they could get behind it that their passion, their determination locally would drive others on," said Nolan. The Lilywhites have won the Christy Ring six times, including last year, but the Joe McDonagh Cup became the next level competition to win from 2018 and Kildare's victory over Laois in last Saturday's Croker final has propelled them into the promised land of this All-Ireland SHC preliminary quarter-final and then Division 1B in 2026. The average age of the Kildare hurlers is just over 23. "This is the culmination of what we put in place 15 or 20 years ago at underage level," said Dunney. "I remember those young lads from when they were 12 or 14 playing, so it's terrific. "It's a people-driven thing. It's not about a thing you can put up on a blackboard and say, 'this is what we do'. It's about getting people down to the pitches to help out and getting kids onto the pitch, it's about having people there for every age group to help them be the best they can be. After that, then, you pray for success." Kildare's hurling community may be dizzy with success but, for Colm Nolan, what matters now is building a sustainable future at the top level. "We have to move to make sure that we can achieve the next level," he said. "That's what it's all about. "Our development is all built on the back of making sure we've got good structures, making sure we've got good quality people across the board. "We're very, very fortunate to have a very energetic, passionate hurling family. They look out for each other and share ideas - and that's really going to be even more important now that we grow that family. There's a greater participation level across the whole county and that's going to be absolutely crucial for the next 10 years."
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Shamrock Rovers versus Shelbourne transpires to be something more – what we learned from Friday's League of Ireland fixtures
The highs and lows of Josh Honohan All sorts of narratives loomed over this Dublin derby; a pairing of champions versus league leaders, Damien Duff versus Stephen Bradley and, as it transpired, Josh Honohan versus himself . Contrary to League of Ireland norms , both of these sides love having possession of the football. Shelbourne have controlled games, albeit without threatening enough, plenty of times this season, but they were reduced to sloppy passes and hopeful crosses for much of Friday night. Duff reckoned this was the first time in four years that he was afforded the luxury of a fully fit squad. Paddy Barrett back healthy and Mark Coyle back in midfield were causes for optimism, but very little quality from the home side transpired. Shelbourne's goal, a header from Honohan steered into the corner of his own net, looked to be a catalyst but ultimately marked a temporary moment of reprieve. For Shamrock Rovers , every game is another reason to talk up their title aspirations. Jack Byrne's quality from set pieces again reared its decisive head – an early free kick landing right on Daniel Cleary's head for the opener. Shels worked hard to limit Byrne from open play but failed to stifle his team-mates in the middle, with Matthew Healy looking particularly commanding. READ MORE Honohan, after a week in which he fell short of an anticipated Ireland debut, was desperate to atone for his uncharacteristic error. With seven minutes to go, Seán Gannon failed to deal with Aaron Greene's driven cross. It broke to Rovers' star wing back, who lashed the ball high into the net. Having delivered the winner, Honohan folded his arms in satisfaction à la Kylian Mbappé , before quickly raising them in apology as he was mobbed by team-mates. Twelve points now separate these two sides – a seemingly insurmountable gap, even at this stage. Bohemians find their identity In the early parts of the season, Bohemians looked devoid of identity. Alan Reynolds, under huge pressure, made flurries of changes every week, unsuccessful in his attempts to strengthen a weak spine and sharpen a blunt attack. That has all changed. Reynolds still rotates, but the tweaks are seamless. Whether it is Colm Whelan or James Clarke leading the line, the plan is clear and well executed. It was Clarke on Friday night, makeshift but fluid in that role – not a natural goal scorer but a classy facilitator for those around him. Archie Meekison has been utilised in a number of positions this season, and he looked right at home cutting in from the left wing. After spurning a good opportunity early on, Meekison took the opener very well – latching on to a heavy touch from last man Darragh Crowley and rounding Cork City goalkeeper Tein Troost twice before finding the corner. Dawson Devoy and Ross Tierney are two excellent footballers, and both look well at home now in Reynolds' set-up. They chimed well for the second goal – Devoy twisting and elusive in midfield; Tierney enthusiastic to affect play further forward. The ball eventually fell to the impressive Dayle Rooney to tap-in and all but end the contest. Cork are second from bottom and winless in eight, so in isolation this win shouldn't have Bohs fans getting carried away. Their form since early April though, validates any dreamers. Dizzy now in second place, the Gypsies have a game in hand on Shamrock Rovers that could take them within striking distance of the leaders. Derry lose ground as Galway United steady the ship Galway manager John Caulfield after the game against Derry. Photograph: Lorcan Doherty/Inpho John Caulfield spent the midseason break plotting Galway United's move to a back four but following a more open half of football than many would have expected, the Tribesmen reverted to type. After four damaging defeats on the spin, Galway are now unbeaten in three. Two points from trips to Tallaght and the Brandywell are signs of a returning stoicism, and with that five-man defence in the second half, the away side looked comfortable. Those more hectic opening stages did produce a Galway goal. As was the case in this fixture earlier in the year, Derry failed to cope with a long throw-in. This time, Moses Dyer was hauled to the ground with the ball flicked high towards him by Patrick Hickey. David Hurley, employing the hop, skip and jump technique popularised by Jorginho and Bruno Fernandes, converted the resulting penalty. Derry fought back, equalising through Kevin Holt's midriff – the unfortunate destination of a hooked attempt at a clearance from Greg Cunningham. There were big chances for Michael Duffy and Sam Todd too, perhaps influencing Galway's withdrawal. A draw does little good for Derry. Tiernan Lynch's side are now 11 points adrift of Shamrock Rovers, though they do have a game in hand. Another 0-0 for St Pat's and Drogheda Three times St Patrick's Athletic and Drogheda United have met this season, and three times the sides have failed to produce a goal. This particular scoreless draw came close – Luke Dennison denied Mason Melia from the penalty spot after 20 minutes in what was the game's defining moment. The Saints were the better side overall, without doing much to worry Dennison again. Drogheda can be happy with a point after a difficult week for the club, who have been denied access to the Uefa Conference League under the governing body's ownership rules. Though they have taken the case to the Court of Arbitration for Sport , the outlook is not good for last season's FAI Cup winners. If they are looking for positives, this season still has plenty to offer for Drogheda. They remain in third place, unbeaten in five games and sitting narrowly ahead of their Friday night opponents.
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Jake Morris praises Tipp's All-Ireland winning young guns as U-20 star Paddy McCormack gets call-up to seniors
Jake Morris has praised Tipperary's young guns for snapping at the heels of their elder team-mates, with U20 star Paddy McCormack getting called up to the panel ahead of tomorrow's All-Ireland preliminary quarter final against Laois.
