EXCLUSIVE Welcome to the PIP capital of the UK where one in THREE people claim the benefit
With its bootcamp fitness classes, basketball court, football pitches and well-used running track, Victoria Park in Plymouth is an unlikely home to Britain's highest level of disability benefits claimants.
But shocking new analysis has found one in three of the area's working-age residents receives Personal Independence Payments, designed to support those with long term health conditions or disabilities.
MailOnline has scrutinised data from the Department of Work and Pensions that shows almost 33 per cent (1,336) of its 3,940 residents in this bracket are on the handout.
The park itself is a popular area for young families with well-maintained and recently refurbished Victorian terraced homes, neighbourhood watch signs and thriving independent cafes and restaurants nearby.
But just a few streets away MailOnline found addicts and alcoholics - and residents who say they are sick of seeing their taxes abused.
The council 'ward' known as St. Peter and the Waterfront is the most deprived area of the Devon coastal city and is ranked in the top 1% of most disadvantaged districts in England.
According to the city's Labour-run council, residents have a life expectancy of 77 years, roughly 7.5 years less than the city's least deprived area.
It also has high rates of smoking, childhood obesity and emergency hospital admissions.
Local resident Mary Leigh, 56, who started receiving PIP earlier this year after a heart attack stopped her working as a taxi driver said she sees high levels of benefits abuse in the area.
She said: 'It doesn't surprise me at all that this is the highest area in the country for claimants - I am sure a lot of people around here are claiming but don't need it.
'There are a lot of drug and alcohol problems in this area and you see all the users sitting about all day spending their benefits.
'They are proud of not having to work - like the rest of us are suckers.
'Unfortunately some of the people that really need benefits are going to suffer.
'I have just started receiving PIP myself having paid taxes all my life, after my heart attack I used all my savings in a year trying to get back to health and I'm hoping to one day go back to work.
'I think particularly young people need to be given more incentive to work, there's enough jobs that need doing, look at the state of the parks or the street. I'd like to see them get out and pick litter to earn their doll money.'
Antique dealer Simon Platt, 37, who has run a shop near Victoria Park for four years, said: 'I hate to say it but I think a lot of the problem is wokeism.
'Older people might've had a lot of mental health issues but they just got on with it.
'People are very quick to sign on and it seems to be quite easy. I used to be pro-Labour but they're not for the working people any more.
'Instead of giving people money they should bring in some form of support to help people into work. I'd like to see the money spent from the cuts on more apprenticeships and more jobs.'
Cafe worker Ollie Mason, 30, said: 'You walk around the streets in the morning and people are walking like zombies because they are on something.
'There are a lot of drugs in the area and a lot of businesses around here are getting robbed constantly.
'There are always people getting mugged in the park.'
As well as Plymouth being the capital for PIP payments, neighbourhoods within Newcastle-upon-Tyne and Stockton-on-Tees have similarly high rates.
Critics of Labour 's ballooning £143billion welfare bill said the figures should act as a 'wake up call' for the Government.
The analysis comes after Keir Starmer completed a humiliating backtrack on his flagship welfare reforms package at the eleventh hour, following sustained pressure from over 120 MPs.
The initial package of reforms was mooted to save around £5billion by the end of the Parliament and included a restriction on the eligibility for PIP.
Existing claimants were to be given a 13-week phase-out period of financial support in an earlier move that was seen as a bid to head off opposition by aiming to soften the impact of the changes.
It's understood now that around 370,000 existing PIP claimants will be able to keep their payments.
But the change on PIP is estimated to wipe up to £2billion off the £5billion savings by the end of the Parliament, and Universal Credit tweaks another £1billion.
Chancellor Rachel Reeves is odds-on to hike taxes to pay for the financial shortfall, experts have said.
If the legislation clears its first hurdle on Tuesday, it will then face a few hours' examination by all MPs the following week – rather than days or weeks in front of a committee tasked with looking at the Bill.
PIP can be paid even to people who are working, have savings or are getting most other benefits.
It is not means tested, tax-free and currently doled out to around 3.6million people across England, Wales and Northern Ireland.
The Labour Government is working on a plan to tighten eligibility for the payments.
Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall confirmed earlier this month that the government will overhaul the points system so a claimant must score 4 points in a single activity such as washing or dressing rather than eight points in total.
People with less severe conditions will also need to be re-assessed more often.
The proposals could see 800,000 people losing access to PIP.
But there is strong resistance from MPs are trying to block the bill as well as mayor of London, Sadiq Khan, who claims it would 'destroy the financial safety net' for millions of people.
Local resident James Walker, 52, told MailOnline he hasn't been able to work since he was 18 and currently receives £733 per month higher rate PIP due to his epilepsy, depression, anxiety, agoraphobia and COPD in addition to his £366 universal credit.
He said: 'I think the cuts are outrageous, that would really affect me in a lot of ways.
'I struggle to get by even on the higher rate of PIP so my quality of life would take a massive fall if they took that away.
'It's not enough money to live on once I have paid my £63 rent, electric, gas, council tax and water
'Labour is supposed to look after vulnerable people but Starmer is just a Conservative in a red tie.
'I know there are a lot of people exploiting PIP and I would like them to make it tougher for those people but not people who genuinely need it.'
Unemployed former florist Julie Glanville, 52, said she doesn't claim PIP but believes there are numerous fraudulent claims made.
He said: 'They need to weed out the ones taking advantage who don't want to work.
'It makes it harder for the people who genuinely need help.
'There are a lot of people in this area struggling and that need help but don't get it and a lot that don't need it.
'The whole system seems back to front sometimes.'
According to Plymouth City Council figures over 57,000 residents in the city meet the Equality Act definition of having a disability.
With about 12% of residents having their day-to-day activities limited a little, and 9% have them limited a lot.
According to the ONS the total number of benefit claimants rose to 5,985 in March 2024, up from 5,500 in March 2023.
Minicab driver Chris Kawka said: 'It's definitely not the best area to live in and there are always a lot of people hanging out in the park during the day.
'I don't know whether they really deserve that money or need it.
'People speak about this in my taxi all the time that you can get given more for not working than for working.
'I would like to see the government spend that money on programmes to get people back on their feet and back into work.'
Meanwhile Byker East in Newcastle-upon-Tyne, a universal credit hotspot, has the second highest rate of PIP claimants - 1,453 out of 4,278, almost 32 per cent.
The Central Stockton & Portrack region of Stockton-on-Tees came in third at 30.5 per cent, or 1,323 out of 4,340.
These are the only three areas where the PIP rate among working-aged people is over 30 per cent.
However in 58 areas across England, the rate is more than one in five.
Fifty four of these are across the North East, West and Yorkshire and the Humber, and four - Weston Bournville in Somerset, Augusta Park in Test Valley, Hartcliffe in Bristol and number one-ranked Victoria Park - spread across the South.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
42 minutes ago
- Times
Martha's Rule saving lives as families use right to second opinion
The NHS has said that Martha's Rule is 'undoubtedly saving lives' in England — and doctors and bereaved parents have called for it to be expanded to Wales. The scheme was launched last year in 143 hospitals, allowing concerned family members of hospital patients to contact a critical care outreach team and request an urgent second opinion. Data shows that, from September to February, 129 patients in England received lifesaving medical interventions following the Martha's Rule review, including 57 being moved to a high dependency or intensive care unit. In total there were 2,389 calls made under Martha's Rule in the first six months of the scheme. One in five of these — 465 cases in total — led to a change of care such as different medication or life-saving urgent intervention.
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Paramedic's brain tumour missed five times by doctors
A paramedic has said her brain tumour was missed five times by doctors. Hannah Lemanski, 24, thought she was experiencing symptoms of stress from shift work when she complained to medics about vomiting, headaches, and double vision. She first visited her GP in February 2023 after experiencing headaches and vision problems for two months, but was sent home with no answer and told her symptoms would be passed on to another doctor. On her fourth visit to the GP she was told she had a lazy eye. After a fifth visit to the eye assessment clinic, an MRI scan diagnosed her with central neurocytoma – a rare brain tumour which grows in the ventricles of the brain. She had 80 per cent of the tumour removed in surgery but two years on it is returning. Doctors recommended gamma-knife radiosurgery to shrink the mass but this is not funded by NHS England for her specific tumour type. The treatment is recognised by the NHS and used to treat various health conditions, including brain tumours, both benign and cancerous. She is now fundraising to get the treatment privately. Ms Lemanski, from Middlesborough, said she thought she was going to die when she was first told of her diagnosis. Her wedding to her now-husband, Przemek Lemanski, 34, who was delivering invitations at the time of the diagnosis, had to be delayed. She underwent surgery to remove 80 per cent of the tumour James Cook hospital in May 2023 and returned to work as a paramedic. During a routine scan in March 2025, she was told her tumour is returning. The NHS offers conventional radiotherapy, a destructive treatment which can lead to more cancer developing, but doctors told Hannah the most effective treatment is gamma-knife surgery – a non-invasive and highly targeted form of radiotherapy. But Ms Lemanski was told by The National Centre for Stereotactic Radiosurgery in Sheffield's Royal Hallamshire Hospital that they don't offer this treatment for her condition – and said NHS England does not commission funds for this treatment and her specific tumour type. She applied for individual funding, but this was rejected. She said: 'It's quite upsetting. You pay your taxes every month and you expect to be looked after when you need it. How can you not look after one of your own? 'Maybe if I wasn't someone who worked for the NHS, I might have just accepted the conventional radiotherapy route, which I think for anyone of a young age without cancer puts them at so much higher risk, especially when there's more effective treatments out there. 'I think it's quite discriminatory really, because I don't understand why someone's brain tumour is better than mine.' Her friend Becky Calpin, 32, has raised over £12,000 to help Ms Lemanski get private treatment, but it could cost up to £20,000. Becky said: 'Hannah is more than a paramedic – she's a bright, healthy, active young woman, married to her best friend and dreaming of starting a family. 'She's the kind of person who lights up every room – always smiling, always giving, always ready to help.' An NHS England spokesperson said: 'We understand the importance of making decisions quickly to avoid unnecessary distress and, where treatment isn't routinely funded, clinicians can submit an individual funding request if there are exceptional clinical reasons. 'The NHS funds specialist stereotactic radiosurgery and radiotherapy for some cancers where there is evidence of a clinical benefit over standard treatments, as part of the personalised care provided for patients.'
Times
2 hours ago
- Times
Third delay to ME care plan prompts backlash from patients
Health ministers have delayed a plan for the future treatment of the debilitating condition myalgic encephalomyelitis (ME) for the third time in nine months. Work on the ME Delivery Plan — which the government claims will boost research, advance medical education and improve patients' lives — began more than three years ago under the Conservative health secretary, Sajid Javid. Labour ministers have repeatedly pledged to publish the plan and have yet to explain why it has been delayed. Last October the public health minister at the time, Andrew Gwynne, said the government planned to publish 'in the winter of 2024/25'. In December, responding to the inquest into the death of the ME patient, Maeve Boothby O'Neill, 27, the minister told a coroner 'we aim to publish by the end of March'. On June 5, Gwynne's successor, Ashley Dalton, said it was 'a priority for the department to publish the final ME delivery plan by the end of June 2025'. On Saturday, however, a health department spokesperson would only say the plan would be published 'shortly'. ME, also known as chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) affects at least 400,000 people in England and Wales. Many people with long Covid experience similar symptoms. The illness is characterised by extreme fatigue, disturbed sleep that does not bring rest and a flare-up of symptoms after even mild exertion (known as post exertional malaise). It is usually triggered by a viral infection and there is no proven cure or treatment. About 25 per cent of sufferers become severely ill with many housebound or bedbound. In a small number of cases patients die. The Times understands the ME initiative has been put on the back burner because the health secretary, Wes Streeting, is determined that nothing should distract from the promotion of his ten-year plan for the NHS. In a further blow to the hopes of ME patients, Streeting has also ruled out any new money for the delivery plan and rejected appeals for a ring-fenced fund to advance ME research. The plea for a specific funding resource was made in a letter signed by all 72 Liberal Democrat MPs. But the health secretary has written back saying ring fencing ME funding 'goes against our commitment to open competition to ensure transparency and scientific excellence'. His statement appears to contradict previous government awards such as the £50 million five-year commitment made in 2021 to finance research into Motor Neurone Disease while last year the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) called for proposals to address 'evidence gaps in liver disease research'. The NIHR is also running an 'open call' for a five-year research consortium to prevent cardiovascular disease. ME campaigners had lobbied for a similar scheme to build a research network and are surprised by Streeting's response. Helen Morgan, the Liberal Democrat health spokesperson, said people with ME and their carers had been left behind for decades. 'They have faced inadequate care, scant research funding, no treatments and little hope of a better future,' she said. 'Further delay to the Delivery Plan for ME is inexcusable. People with ME are right to feel that improving this situation is not a priority for this government. The government must think again, publish the plan without delay and allocate it the resources it needs to make a real difference.' • Severely ill patient with ME begs for home feeding Sonya Chowdhury, of the charity Action for ME, said she was 'deeply dismayed' by another delay to the delivery plan: 'Just weeks ago, the minister gave a public commitment that the plan would be published by the end of June. This is now the third delay in nine months, and the government's language around publication has become increasingly vague. 'The ME community is once again left in the dark — with no clear timeline, no explanation, and growing doubt over whether the plan will appear at all. What message does this send to a group already fighting for basic recognition, where the most severely affected are so often the most neglected?' A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said: 'Our thoughts are with all those whose lives have been touched by myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome. We are committed to improving the care and support for all those affected and will publish a final delivery plan shortly.'
