Vancouver abortion clinic to close after 35 years, raising concerns over access
After more than 30 years of providing abortion and reproductive health services, Vancouver's Elizabeth Bagshaw Clinic has announced it will close.
In a statement Friday, the clinic's board said the decision follows growing uncertainty linked to changes in the provincial health-care system, including Vancouver Coastal Health's plan to consolidate reproductive services into a new model.
It's unclear what specific impact those changes had on the clinic's operations. CBC News requested an interview with the clinic but did not receive a response.
Vancouver Coastal Health says it's exploring a "single provider, single site" model for delivering reproductive care in the region.
In a statement to CBC News, the health authority confirmed it's considering consolidating the three clinics it currently funds — Elizabeth Bagshaw, Everywoman's Health Centre and Willow Reproductive Health Services — under one provider at one location.
These are the only abortion clinics in Vancouver, besides a program through the B.C. Women's Hospital, according to Options for Sexual Health. The organization said abortions through other providers may require a doctor's referral.
The move, Vancouver Coastal says, is aimed at increasing service capacity, ensuring financial sustainability and better meeting current demand.
Elizabeth Bagshaw Clinic's board also pointed to an upcoming lease expiry, only one year of confirmed funding and shifting priorities within the health authority as additional challenges.
"Given the structural challenges, it became unavoidable," the clinic's board said, adding that relocating to a new site didn't make financial sense with limited funding. "This was not a choice the Board wanted to make."
Dr. Renee Hall, a physician at Elizabeth Bagshaw Clinic and medical director of the Willow Clinic, said the announcement has devastated staff. (Ben Nelms/CBC)
Founded in 1989, the clinic has treated thousands of patients from across B.C. each year, with more than half coming from outside the Vancouver Coastal Health region. Its closure, staff say, will put added strain on an already overburdened system.
"We're just absolutely devastated by the loss," said Dr. Renee Hall, a physician at the clinic and medical director at the nearby Willow Reproductive Health Centre. "Some people have been working there for 35 years."
Hall said efforts are underway to ensure services like abortions, intrauterine device (IUD) insertion and vasectomies continue elsewhere, but gaps may emerge during the transition.
"We are doing everything that we can to make sure that everything will be covered in time for the Elizabeth Bagshaw closure," she said.
Vancouver Coastal also said it is working with the clinic and other community partners to ensure continuity of care.
The Ministry of Health said the province remains committed to abortion access.
"Protecting access to abortion services is a key priority," Health Minister Josie Osborne said during an unrelated news conference Friday. "There will be no stop or ending of that access."
Health Minister Josie Osborne says protecting access to abortion services is a key priority. (Mike McArthur/CBC)
Still, some worry about the broader implications of losing one of only three abortion clinics in the city.
"It's going to be a big loss for patients," said Eleanor Fast, director of Everywoman's Health Centre. "We want to move in the direction of more access, more options, and this is obviously going in the opposite direction."
Fast said many of her clinic's patients come from places like Surrey, Abbotsford and even farther away in B.C.
"There are massive sort of deserts of care across the province and across Canada, more generally. And that's obviously a massive problem."
Both Fast and Hall say longer-term investment in reproductive health is urgently needed.
Hall says she would like to see a "centre of excellence" that not only delivers services but also trains new providers.
"That provides abortion, vasectomy and contraception to this region and also is able to train health-care providers who can go out rurally and, therefore, we can have access all over the province to serve rural areas," she said.
"British Columbians deserve to know that they can feel secure and be able to get these services when they need them."
The Elizabeth Bagshaw Clinic says it will remain open until June 30.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
B.C. mom picks up her son's ADHD medication, is given an opioid instead
A mother on Vancouver Island is warning people to double check their prescriptions after she was accidentally dispensed the powerful opioid hydromorphone instead of her son's regular ADHD medication. Comox, B.C., resident Sarah Paquin, 31, says she still shudders to think about what could have happened to her nine-year-old son had her husband not noticed the medication looked different before he gave it to him. "It was terrifying," Paquin said, standing in her front yard and playing with one of her three boys. "One simple little mistake like that could have ended horribly." WATCH | 9-year-old dispensed opioid in pharmacy mix-up: Paquin says she didn't think too much of it when she went to pick up her son Declan's medication last week and the staff member at her local Shoppers Drug Mart pharmacy didn't check her ID or take out the prescription from the bag. The next day, her husband was about to give Declan his medication when he saw the pills were a different colour and shape than normal. Her husband looked at the bottle and noticed the prescription was for someone else, and that it was for hydromorphone. Right away he returned the pills to the pharmacy. "Immediately your mind goes to the worst case scenario," Paquin said. "The results could have been catastrophic and it just makes my heart sink to think about what could have happened." Hydromorphone is a powerful opioid that is two to eight times stronger than morphine and is often used to treat acute pain or chronic cancer pain. According to the Mayo Clinic, it can cause serious unwanted effects or fatal overdose in children. Human error CBC News reached out to Loblaws, the company that owns Shoppers Drug Mart. In a written statement, the company said the incident was a case of "human error" that never should have happened. "We have controls in place to minimize risks like this — where the patient was handed the wrong prescription bag — and the associate will review these with employees to avoid a similar situation in the future," the company said. Paquin says she has since heard from the pharmacist, who was very apologetic. She says he acknowledged that steps were missed and standards were dropped, and told her the employee who dispensed the medication has been suspended pending an internal investigation. Asking for accountability Despite his reassurances, Paquin has filed a complaint with the College of Pharmacists of B.C. "The pharmacy needs to take responsibility, be held accountable for what happened," she said. In an email, the college told CBC News it takes these types of errors very seriously. "We have legal requirements in the Health Professions Act bylaws in place to prevent these occurrences, including mandatory standards for prescription preparation to ensure accuracy of the prescription product and consultations for all prescriptions, to make sure clients understand their medication, how to take it properly, and address any questions," the college said. As part of pharmacists' consultation with clients, they are required to confirm the person's identity, name and the strength and purpose of the drug, it added. In 2023-24, the college says it received a total of 990 concerns through its intake process. Of those, 54 became formal complaints and investigations, 16 of which were medication related. Paquin decided to share her ordeal on social media, to warn others to check their prescription before taking it. "It's scary that it happened to us, but I'm also in a way kind of thankful that it happened to us and we caught it because it could have been given to somebody who didn't notice and got hurt," she said.
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
England is launching a gonorrhea vaccine. Is Canada next?
England will soon begin administering a vaccine to high-risk individuals that may reduce their chances of contracting gonorrhea, but a similar program is not yet in the cards for Canada. According to studies cited by England's National Health Service, the 4CMenB vaccine, which is presently used in Canada for immunization against meningitis B, has an effectiveness of 32.7 to 42 per cent against gonorrhea. To combat rising infection rates, the health service said last month it will begin administering the vaccine free of charge in August for those deemed to be at high risk of contracting gonorrhea, including gay and bisexual men who have a history of sexually transmitted infection or multiple sex partners. But the vaccine has not been authorized for this use in Canada, even as cases of gonorrhea continue to rise across the country. According to the most recent national statistics, rates of the sexually transmitted infection more than tripled in Canada from 2010 to 2022, going from 11,381 in 2010 to 35,956 in 2022. Gonorrhea, often referred to as "the clap," is passed on through oral, anal or genital sex. People who've been infected, especially women, often show no symptoms at all. If left untreated, it can have serious health risks. In an interview with CBC News on Monday, Calgary physician Caley Shukalek, the chief medical officer for Freddie, an online service that focuses on 2SLGBTQ+ health care, said it's still too soon to know how effective the 4CMenB vaccine will be at preventing new gonorrhea infections. Early research hasn't been conclusive either, Shukalek said, citing another study conducted by researchers in France that suggested the vaccine may not have any statistical effect on gonorrhea rates. "I think in the medical community, there's still a bit of skepticism," he said, noting that more research needs to be done before the true impact is known. The potential upside is promising enough, however, that Shukalek said he has begun prescribing the vaccine to some people who are willing to pay for it out of pocket or through private health insurance. "Its safety is very well established, so for those at high risk of STIs, I think this is a very worthwhile thing and something that could be considered," he said. "But because it's kind of what we call off-label, it absolutely is something that needs to be a discussion between a prescriber and a patient to make sure that it's the right decision based on their individual risk." The vaccine is typically administered in two phases, he said, with the second dose coming at least four weeks after the first. Chris Aucoin is the executive director of the Health Equity Alliance of Nova Scotia, a group that advocates for those living with HIV and members of the 2SLGBTQ+ community. He's aware of the latest research on the use of the 4CMenB vaccine to help prevent the spread of gonorrhea, but notes that even if it's approved, it would only be one part of a potential prevention strategy. Aucoin said the best thing people can do now and in the future to prevent the spread of gonorrhea is to get tested regularly. "If people are concerned about gonorrhea rates, which are too high … the biggest factor in that for me is the fact that people don't test regularly enough." He said the recent launch of Nova Scotia's STI Care Now program, which mails out free at-home testing kits for chlamydia, gonorrhea and HIV to anyone interested across the province, is a positive step toward making this easier. "We now have a tool that's accessible to them in a way that's never been the case in Nova Scotia," he said. In a statement, the Public Health Agency of Canada said the National Advisory Committee on Immunization is monitoring the latest research on the 4CMenB vaccine. In a 2023 report, the advisory committee noted that although the vaccine is not currently authorized for this purpose, it may "offer some level of cross-protection against gonococcal infection." The agency said it expects the committee to further assess this possibility as more evidence becomes available. Nova Scotia's Department of Health and Wellness echoed this statement, noting that it takes its cues on immunization from the committee Those looking to pay out of pocket for the vaccine in the private market would be looking at around $200 per dose, the department said. In 2024, there were 368 new cases of gonorrhea reported in Nova Scotia. MORE TOP STORIES
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
A new harm reduction group is creating a safe space to do drugs in St. John's
In response to an increasing number of overdose deaths in Newfoundland and Labrador, a new group of harm reduction advocates are opening what they say is St. John's first overdose prevention site. Overdose Awareness and Response St. John's (OARS) provides safe use supplies and naloxone, and its founder says both volunteers and nurses trained in overdose intervention are on hand. "Whether that's folks that are street-entrenched or just folks downtown partying, we provide a space where people can do drugs in safety," said Luca Schaefer. Schaefer describes the operation as similar to a supervised consumption site, which are controversial in Canada. The Health Canada website describes such sites as "a safe, clean space for people to bring their own drugs to use, in the presence of trained staff. This prevents accidental overdoses and reduces the spread of infectious diseases, such as HIV." Individuals or organizations who want to open a supervised consumption site can ask the federal government for an exemption from the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act, but OARS has not yet made an application. In contrast, overdose prevention sites — which Health Canada also calls urgent public-health needs sites — "are established on a temporary basis to respond to urgent needs in a specific region or community." Ottawa can authorize the provincial health minister to set up one of these sites, but in an emailed statement to CBC News, spokesperson Khadija Rehma said OARS has not yet contacted the Health Department. "We appreciate the valuable work of community organizations and volunteers to ensure safe substance use supports and services," the statement said. Newfoundland and Labrador Health Services spokesperson Mikaela Etchegary said the provincial health authority supports harm reduction efforts, but hasn't established an official partnership with OARS. Rigel Penman, a volunteer with OARS, told CBC News the group hasn't yet applied for legal exemption because it's still in talks with various levels of government. Penman said OARS is trying to set up as "quickly as possible," especially with summer around the corner, and says the group decided not to wait for what could be a lengthy application process. WATCH | Harm reduction advocates create pop-up overdose prevention site in St. John's: The site won't supply or provide substances, Schaefer said. "If using in the space is what they need at the moment, then we're able to provide that support. And if not, they're free to take what they need," she said. For now, the site will be a pop-up tent in downtown St. John's — a setup that's "able to move and be wherever is needed or necessary," said Schaefer. OARS has run the site twice so far, on the evenings of May 23 and May 30. Schaefer says public response has been mixed, with some people approaching to get supplies, and others expressing curiosity or negativity. "This group is addressing and providing support to a marginalized and at-risk population," she said. "We should be looking to our most vulnerable people and asking ourselves what we're able to do to step up." Overdose prevention and supervised consumption sites were a talking point during the latest federal election, with Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre calling them "drug dens" and a "bizarre social experiment" and vowing to restrict them. According to Health Canada, supervised consumption sites operate in Alberta, Saskatchewan, Ontario, Quebec and British Columbia. The first site opened in Vancouver in 2003, and the model spread throughout the country in the ensuing decades. In 2016, as overdose deaths skyrocketed, several unsanctioned overdose prevention tents sprung up in the city's Downtown Eastside — ground zero for Canada's opioid crisis. Activists at the time told CBC the pop-up sites were an effort to save lives without waiting for sluggish bureaucratic approval. Last year, however, Ontario implemented a new law banning drug consumption sites near schools and child-care centres. That law forced the closure of nine sites in Ontario, despite a court injunction allowing them to remain open while a judge to examines the law's constitutionality. Schaefer says she's ready to respond to concerns from the community. In April, the RCMP warned of rising drug toxicity deaths in the province, and said cocaine is now the leading drug responsible for overdose people died from consuming drugs in Newfoundland and Labrador last year. Last month, police seized a record amount of fentanyl from a St. John's trailer — enough to kill nearly half the province. Schaefer says OARS is responding to those statistics. "There's a lot of reasons why people use drugs," she said. "They shouldn't have to worry about whether or not the drugs that they're gonna take are going to kill them." OARS outreach advocate Loo Vatcher says Newfoundland and Labrador is in desperate need of better overdose prevention. "This world is hard enough for all of us, and whether we like it or not, people are going to use substances," they said. "It's really important that we meet people where they're at." OARS will run a site once a week for now, but Vatcher says its long-term goal is to set up an indoor location to host safe use and harm reduction services. For that to happen, OARS will be fundraising more money, applying for government grants and continuing its advocacy. Vatcher said volunteers want to "put a bit of pressure on the government to do what's right, to help us create the safe space for people who deserve it." Download our free CBC News app to sign up for push alerts for CBC Newfoundland and Labrador. Sign up for our daily headlines newsletter here. Click here to visit our landing page.
