Zondo calls for criminal investigation into Mantashe as he disputes State Capture Report
Gwede Mantashe has consistently denied any wrongdoing, asserting that he did not solicit or accept bribes.
Tensions have escalated between Former Chief Justice Raymond Zondo and ANC heavyweight Gwede Mantashe over the findings of the State Capture Inquiry, with Zondo defending his call for a criminal investigation into Mantashe, while the minister disputes the report's conclusions.
In March 2022, the Zondo Commission released its third report, which implicated Mantashe in alleged corrupt dealings with the controversial state contractor Bosasa.
The report stated that Bosasa installed security upgrades at Mantashe's properties while he served as ANC secretary-general. Zondo concluded that there was a "reasonable prospect" of uncovering a prima facie case against Mantashe for corruption and referred the matter for further investigation.
Mantashe has consistently denied any wrongdoing, asserting that he did not solicit or accept bribes. He has also indicated his intention to challenge the findings through a judicial review.
In response to Zondo's referral, Mantashe criticised the Chief Justice, stating that Zondo "thinks he owns and manages the state capture report."
He further remarked that Zondo should allow the relevant authorities to handle the matter instead of making it about himself.
Chief Justice Zondo has defended his actions, emphasising that the referral was based on the evidence presented during the commission's proceedings. He maintains that the referral was made under the commission's mandate to investigate and report on instances of state capture. Zondo has reiterated that the findings were not personal but were grounded in the commission's objective analysis.
The National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) has stated that it will review the findings of the State Capture Inquiry and determine whether criminal investigations are warranted. NPA spokesperson Mthunzi Mhanga noted that the commission did not conduct criminal investigations and that the NPA would assess the information provided to decide on the appropriate course of action.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
an hour ago
- Daily Maverick
ANC canters to victory in two Mpumalanga wards, MK beats faltering EFF to second place
The ANC cruised to victory in the two Thembisile Hani by-elections in Mpumalanga in the latest round of by-elections. It was well up on its 2021 showing. The uMkhonto Wesizwe party beat the EFF to second place as the latter fell sharply in both wards. Thembisile Hani, Nkangala, Mpumalanga Both by-elections took place in the Thembisile Hani municipality, which borders Gauteng and Limpopo. It borders more of Gauteng and Limpopo than it does other municipalities in Mpumalanga, and sits in the northwestern corner of the province in the former KwaNdebele homeland. The municipality is linked to the nation's capital via the R573, the Moloto Road. Southern Ndebele is the most widely spoken language in the municipality. The seat of power is Ekukhanyeni, formerly Kwaggafontein. Bafana Bafana player Mandla Masango hails from Ekukhanyeni. National First Division soccer team Casric Stars ply their trade in this municipality. Thembisile Hani forms part of the Nkangala District. Other key towns in the district are Emalahleni, Middelburg and Siyabuswa. Ward 18 (Vezubuhle Thokozani) Thembisile Hani: ANC 73% (65% PR*) MK 15% EFF 9% (17% PR) Ingubo 1% (7% PR) Labour 1% The setting: Vezubuhle and Thokozani lie above the R573 Moloto Road. The ward is between the KwaMhlanga Crossroads Shopping Centre and Ekukhanyeni. The 2021 local government elections: The ANC won every voting district by a comfortable margin. The EFF finished second in every district. A local party, Ingubo Yeskethu (Ingubo), finished third, slightly ahead of the DA which obtained 5% on the proportional representation (PR) ballot. The ANC won 61% on the ward ballot, followed by the EFF on 15%. An independent candidate came third with 7%. Ingubo was just in front of the DA, with both parties taking 5%. The ANC won 40 out of the 62 seats in the council, winning 30 of the 32 wards. The only wards not won by the party were taken by two independents. The EFF was second with 12. The 2024 provincial elections: The ANC won 58% of the vote in the voting districts in this ward. The EFF was second with 17% – it came second in all voting districts. The DA was third with 8%, beating the uMkhonto Wesizwe (MK) party in all districts bar one. MK was fourth with 6% as it took votes from the ANC. The by-election: The ward councillor died. The ANC won close to three-quarters of the vote, winning more than 80% in half of the districts and more than 90% in one district. The ANC was only pushed in one of the six districts, in the most vote-rich part of the ward, Somsuswa Secondary School in Thokozani. Here its vote share declined from 69% to 57%. MK bagged 30% of the vote in this district. This is also where the EFF did best, obtaining 12%, slightly down from 14% in 2021. MK finished second in half of the voting districts, while the EFF was second in the other half. The key difference was the Somususwa Secondary School where the MK beat the EFF by 120 votes. In the final tally, MK beat the EFF by 122 votes. Ingubo's support totally collapsed in the by-election. Poll: 33% (37%) Ward 31 (Ekukhanyeni South) Thembisile Hani: ANC 70% (59%) MK 16% EFF 11% (30%) AIPO 2% (4%) Labour 1% Ingubo 1% The setting: Ekukhanyeni is the seat of power in Thembisile Hani. Ward 31 is at the southern tip of Ekukhanyeni, in the areas known as Kwaggafontein D and Kwaggafontein E. The 2021 local government election: The ANC came close to beating the EFF by two votes to one. The EFF performed better in Ward 31 than Ward 18. It won more than 40% of the vote at the vote-rich Thuthukani Primary School in Kwaggafontein E. A regional party, the African Independent People's Organization (AIPO), came third with 4%. The 2024 provincial elections: The ANC won 58% of the vote in the voting districts in this ward as well. The EFF came second with 24%. The EFF was second in all voting districts. The DA edged MK for third place, with both parties getting 4%. AIPO garnered only 1% support in the ward. The by-election: The poll was held after the ward councillor died. The ANC cantered home, exhibiting impressive growth. It won more than 85% of the vote in two of the four voting districts. It beat MK by 1,186 votes. MK beat the EFF for second place by 111 votes. As per Ward 18, both parties finished runners-up in two districts each. MK did best at Sinetjhudu Primary School in Kwaggafontein D with a 29% vote haul. This is the most-populous district in the ward. Here the difference between MK and the EFF was 139 votes. AIPO lost half of its percentage support in the ward compared with the 2021 local government election. Joseph Mathunjwa's Labour Party continues to find it tough beyond the electoral mining belt map. After a poor showing in a recent Free State by-election, the party received only 1% support each in the two Thembisile Hani by-elections. The next by-election will take place on 18 June when the ANC will defend another seat in Mpumalanga, in a township in Sabie in the Thaba Chweu municipality on the Panorama Route. After this strong showing by the ANC, the party will make the 250km-plus journey from Ekukhanyeni to Sabie with renewed vigor and confidence. DM
eNCA
an hour ago
- eNCA
SCA to rule in Nulane Investments case
BLOEMFONTEIN - The Supreme Court of Appeal is set to rule on the NPA's bid to overturn the acquittal of Nulane Investments fraud accused. The suspects were arrested for fraud and money laundering amounting to R25-million. The State is pushing for a retrial of Gupta associates and senior Free State officials. The first State Capture trial ended in the accused walking free. At the heart of the matter are government payments to Nulane for a feasibility study.
The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
‘Bring all to dialogue': Experts insist national dialogue must be people-driven
Political analysts stress the need for land restitution and broad participation to ensure a meaningful and effective national dialogue. Experts say the envisaged national dialogue must not be a top-down process, but people-driven and discuss contentious issues like land and racial polarisation. But more importantly, said one expert, the dialogue required full commitment from various actors to find a collective solution to the country's myriad problems. Political analyst and scholar Dominic Maphaka from North-West University said the dialogue was necessary to unite the diverse and divided country. National dialogue necessary to unite country He said, as outlined by President Cyril Ramaphosa, stakeholders, including business, labour, civil society, communities, youth and people with disabilities, should form part of the dialogue to chart the way forward. 'But the dialogue will require a commitment from various actors to form part of a collective solution to the myriad problems faced by the country,' Maphaka said. ALSO READ: Thandiswa Mazwai says she would've accepted invite to national dialogue had Ramaphosa sent it He alluded to the fact that, due to the vibrant civil society, nonstate actors were often at loggerheads with government and opposing its development policies. 'Despite having divergent ideologies, it is not far-fetched that South Africans share common problems in many areas. I therefore think that ideologies should not take precedence in the dialogue; instead, stakeholders should deliberate and find common policy solutions to address common policy problems,' Maphaka said. Ramaphosa yesterday said he would call a National Convention on 15 August, which would set the agenda for the National Dialogue. National Convention to set agenda A follow-up convention would be held early next year. He said the convention would be a representative gathering, bringing together government, political parties, civil society, business, labour, traditional leaders, religious leaders, cultural workers, sports organisations, women, youth and community voices. Some experts believed people and civil society, not government and political parties, should lead the planned dialogue process, including the convention. ALSO READ: Ramaphosa urges caution as floods claims lives in Eastern Cape Political analyst Lesiba Teffo said the national dialogue was not supposed to be driven by the state because that was where the seeds of its failure lay. 'It was contested from inception and some of the initiators are now in the periphery. A reasonable modality would be to start in the provinces whose reports would feed into the national convention. Otherwise, you are likely to end up with another voluminous, glossy and expensive National Development Plan 0.2 Vision 2040,' Teffo said. The need for an all-inclusive national dialogue was first proposed by former president Thabo Mbeki. Mbeki, assisted by Jacob Zuma, was the ANC's first chief negotiator at the pre-1994 Convention for a Democratic South Africa (Codesa) talks before they were replaced by Ramaphosa and Mohammed Valli Moosa. Need for national dialogue first proposed by Mbeki There seemed to be a common view that dialogue should involve various roleplayers – from civil society, to state, business, trade unions and political parties. It is understood that the struggle stalwarts' foundations were involved in consultations to kick off the process, while Nedlac was identified to play a role as one of the facilitators due to its composite nature with business, trade unions, community and government. ALSO READ: 'A meaningless publicity stunt by a limping president': EFF slams Ramaphosa's national dialogue call Political and heritage analyst George Tsibani, who supports the idea of a national dialogue, said such a gathering should address the question of land in its proper perspective. He said democratic South Africa was a result of a negotiated settlement that was underpinned by Sunset Clauses that were a compromise and did not address the land question. 'If we pretend that there was no compromise, it would take the focus away from the land issue. The land redistribution and restitution must form the cornerstone of national dialogue,' Tsibani said. Previous Codesa process failed The previous Codesa process failed to address many issues due to the Sunset Clause that allowed for the continuation of white control of the state. 'So Codesa 2 must address the land issue in its totality, meaning there must be a deliberate restitution of land for the people who lost their land during the colonial and slavery periods,' Tsibani said. NOW READ: Ramaphosa, Chief Justice mourn passing of Judge Temba Sangoni
