Consumer panel orders power company to pay ₹10 lakh to Nagpur farmer for crop damage
A consumer commission in Maharashtra's Nagpur has directed four employees of a state-run power company to pay ₹10 lakh to a farmer whose bamboo crop was damaged in a fire caused by a fault in power lines passing through his field.
Additional District Consumer Grievance Redressal Commission, Nagpur, in a recent order, directed three top-ranked engineers of the Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Company Limited (MSEDCL) and its regional director in the area to pay the compensation.
The commission held that the officials "failed to maintain the power lines properly and were negligent, which constitutes a deficiency in service".
The complainant, a 68-year-old farmer, stated that he had planted 5,000 bamboo trees on his farm, which were in a semi-dry state for sale.
He alleged that on March 22, 2018, the trees caught fire due to friction and sparking between two wires of the MSEDCL's high-tension transmission line passing over his field and were completely burnt.
The farmer brought the matter to the notice of the tehsildar and the local police station and informed the electricity company.
A panchnama (spot inspection report) was conducted, and the power company repaired the line. The forest department assessed the damage at ₹10.27 lakh, and the assessment was given to the MSEDCL's executive engineer.
However, the farmer was only paid ₹4.2 lakh as compensation, following which he moved the consumer commission.
The complainant asserted that the damage was due to the negligence of the opposite parties and improper maintenance of the power lines and demanded compensation as assessed by the forest department.
He also sought ₹2 lakh for physical and mental distress and ₹50,000 for complaint expenses.
The MSEDCL officials, in their written statement, denied the complainant's entire claim and sought dismissal of the complaint, stating that if the complainant was not satisfied with the compensation, he should have sought redressal under the Electricity Act.
The commission held that MSEDCL was negligent in maintaining the power lines, which constituted a deficiency in service.
It accepted the forest department's detailed and factual report of ₹10.27 lakh as the true extent of the damage and directed the opposing parties to pay the amount as compensation with 9% annual interest from the date the report was filed (May 23, 2018) until the actual payment.
The MSEDCL staffers have also been asked to pay ₹40,000 for mental and physical distress and ₹10,000 for the expenses incurred by the farmer.
The commission has directed that the payment be made within 45 days from the order date (May 15).
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
MSEDCL issues two notices to PMC regarding unauthorised electricity usage and unpaid bill
Pune: MSEDCL has sent PMC two separate notices for Rs 4.14 lakh for unauthorized electricity usage at two establishments. The civic body operates a gymnasium within the premises of Lokmanya Nagar Garden and Chandrakant Botre gymnasium and Madhukar Budhkar study centre within the premises of Dharmaveer Sambhaji Maharaj Primary School, the power company stated in the notice issued to the executive engineer of PMC. The school is located on Lal Bahadur Shastri (LBS) Road and the garden is situated in the Lokmanya Nagar society in Navi Peth. These two gymnasiums and the study centre are currently operational. The garden has unpaid dues of Rs 1.81 lakh and the school has not paid an electricity bill of up to Rs 2.33 lakh. MSEDCL has issued two separate notices to PMC under section 126 of the Electricity Act, 2003. "The two establishments used an existing connection for pole light to power appliances within the premises. So this constitutes unauthorised use. It was not adhering to the purpose for which the connection was given and does not qualify as theft, which is why notices were issued under section 126 and not under section 135, which constitutes theft," an MSEDCL spokesperson said. MSEDCL has provided a regular timeframe to the corporation to repay the dues as per the norms and PMC has intimated its intent to pay the bill, he added. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Giao dịch vàng CFDs với sàn môi giới tin cậy IC Markets Tìm hiểu thêm Undo Typically, consumers can pay their bills in 21 working days after the due date, following which there is a 15-day notice period given to the consumers. The electricity bills of the two entities have left unpaid for almost a year since June 2024, an MSEDCL spokesperson said. The gymnasium and the study centre located in the school premises consumed 5,701 kilowatt-hours (kWh) of electricity, while the gymnasium in the garden consumed 6,368 kWh of electricity. The gymnasium in the garden had installed two bulbs, 16 tube lights, seven ceiling fans and one exhaust fan, while the gymnasium and study centre in the school installed 43 tube lights, 16 fans, one television screen, four CCTV cameras and one treadmill, as per the notice. "MSEDCL sought an explanation from the PMC representatives running the garden and the school regarding the duration for which the gymnasiums and the study centre are operational. Since the power company did not receive any clear timeframe at the time of issuing the notice, it has sought payment of dues along with a penalty," stated the notice issued to the executive engineer of PMC. Akshay Jain, president of the media department of Maharashtra Pradesh Youth Congress, raised the issue with MSEDCL to take action against PMC. "Even if PMC repays the dues, public money is wasted through improper management leading to penalties," he said.
Hindustan Times
3 days ago
- Hindustan Times
Nine killed in electrocution incidents in Pune over past year
Over the last year, according to data shared by the power department of Pune Municipal Corporation (PMC), nine people died in electrocution incidents in the city, triggering widespread concern and public outrage. In the latest incident which occurred near Inamdar Chowk on June 2, an eight-year-old girl reportedly came in contact with a hoarding illegally connected to a PMC-maintained streetlight pole. The hoarding was allegedly linked to a political party and had an unauthorised electricity connection, according to civic officials. Manisha Shekatkar, chief, electrical department, said inspections would be completed within two days, and strict action, including disconnection and penalties, would follow in cases of violations. 'The number of illegal connections and unapproved hoardings drawing power from streetlight poles is alarming. We will not tolerate such threats to public safety,' said Shekatkar. She said they have started checking earthing, overhead wires, illegal connections, and underground cables in the city. 'PMC has laid underground cables for most streetlight poles, but some areas, especially newly merged villages and suburbs, still have overhead wires. We are regularly working to remove such overhead cables. Now, we have also started a fresh drive to act against illegal connections on streetlight poles, loose wiring, open circuits, and underground service lines,' she said. Civic activists and residents have consistently raised concerns about exposed wiring, broken electrical boxes, and poor maintenance by both PMC and Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Company Ltd (MSEDCL). 'Overhead wires should be underground. They're prone to illegal tapping and pose serious risks. The city must release a detailed audit of all-electric poles and conduct pre-monsoon maintenance,' said Sudhir Kulkarni, civic activist. MSEDCL officials claim regular inspections are conducted, but no official data has been released on the number of poles or overhead lines in Pune. The recurring electrocution incidents have exposed critical gaps in coordination between civic and electricity authorities. Citizens are now demanding urgent reforms, strict accountability, and permanent solutions to prevent such avoidable tragedies. Dinesh Nale, a resident of Rasta Peth said, 'We are scared to even let our children play outside during rains. How many more lives will it take before the authorities wake up and fix these dangerous poles?' One of the senior officials of MSEDCL Pune circle said, 'We conduct routine checks, especially before the monsoon. However, in some cases, the issues arise from infrastructure maintained by the civic body. We are working on improving coordination to prevent future accidents.' Past incidents June 2025: An eight-year-old girl died in Rasta Peth after touching a streetlight pole. May 2025: A ten-year-old boy died in Warje after touching a live electric pole during heavy rain. September 2024: Two men electrocuted while on a music vehicle during a procession in Wadgaonsheri. August 2024: A schoolboy in Hadapsar and a woman near Bremen Chowk in Aundh died after stepping into electrically charged water. July 2024: Three youths died while trying to retrieve a food cart from floodwater in the Samarth police station area. June 2024: A housekeeping worker died after stepping on a live wire near Amar Tech Park, Balewadi.
NDTV
25-05-2025
- NDTV
Consumer Body Orders Power Company Staffers To Pay Rs 10 Lakh To Maharashtra Farmer
Mumbai: A consumer commission in Maharashtra's Nagpur has directed four employees of a state-run power company to pay Rs 10 lakh to a farmer whose bamboo crop was damaged in a fire caused by a fault in power lines passing through his field. Additional District Consumer Grievance Redressal Commission, Nagpur, in a recent order, directed three top-ranked engineers of the Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Company Limited (MSEDCL) and its regional director in the area to pay the compensation. The commission held that the officials "failed to maintain the power lines properly and were negligent, which constitutes a deficiency in service". The complainant, a 68-year-old farmer, stated that he had planted 5,000 bamboo trees on his farm, which were in a semi-dry state for sale. He alleged that on March 22, 2018, the trees caught fire due to friction and sparking between two wires of the MSEDCL's high-tension transmission line passing over his field and were completely burnt. The farmer brought the matter to the notice of the tehsildar and the local police station and informed the electricity company. A panchnama (spot inspection report) was conducted, and the power company repaired the line. The forest department assessed the damage at Rs 10.27 lakh, and the assessment was given to the MSEDCL's executive engineer. However, the farmer was only paid Rs 4.2 lakh as compensation, following which he moved the consumer commission. The complainant asserted that the damage was due to the negligence of the opposite parties and improper maintenance of the power lines and demanded compensation as assessed by the forest department. He also sought Rs 2 lakh for physical and mental distress and Rs 50,000 for complaint expenses. The MSEDCL officials, in their written statement, denied the complainant's entire claim and sought dismissal of the complaint, stating that if the complainant was not satisfied with the compensation, he should have sought redressal under the Electricity Act. The commission held that MSEDCL was negligent in maintaining the power lines, which constituted a deficiency in service. It accepted the forest department's detailed and factual report of Rs 10.27 lakh as the true extent of the damage and directed the opposing parties to pay the amount as compensation with 9 per cent annual interest from the date the report was filed (May 23, 2018) until the actual payment. The MSEDCL staffers have also been asked to pay Rs 40,000 for mental and physical distress and Rs 10,000 for the expenses incurred by the farmer. The commission has directed that the payment be made within 45 days from the order date (May 15).
