LNP's youth crime legislation condemned by UN as ‘incompatible with basic child rights'
The United Nations special rapporteur on torture has urged Queensland's parliament to vote down the government's headline youth crime legislation, calling it 'incompatible with basic child rights'.
The Liberal National government ran on a slogan of 'adult crime, adult time' at last October's election. It passed legislation to sentence children convicted of 13 offences the same as adults in December.
Parliament will consider a second round of legislation, adding an additional 20 offences, this week.
In an open letter to Australian authorities, Alice Jill Edwards, the special rapporteur on torture and Albert K Barume, special rapporteur on the rights of Indigenous peoples, said Australia's criminal legal systems 'appear to be in crisis nationwide'.
They warned that the system 'is creating a future under-class of Australians'.
'Children are suffering undue harm to their safety and wellbeing, as well as to their educational and life prospects as a result of shortsighted approaches to youth criminality and detention.'
Edwards and Barume specifically singled out the Making Queensland Safer (Adult Crime, Adult Time) Amendment Bill in the open letter.
'[The bill] would have an especially negative impact on the lives of Indigenous children, who are already disproportionately represented in the criminal legal system. We urge members of the Queensland parliament to vote against the bill,' they said.
Edwards, a human rights lawyer, is the first Australian in the role.
In April, Queensland's premier, David Crisafulli, criticised the UN for interfering in local politics, saying 'this place will govern its laws'.
'This place will determine how we keep Queenslanders safe, and this place will be accountable to Queenslanders, not United Nations boffins,' he said.
However, the government has conceded that both rounds of legislation are contrary to state and international human rights law, with the youth justice minister, Laura Gerber, acknowledging the legislation would limit 'the right to protection from cruel, inhumane or degrading treatment and the right to humane treatment when deprived of liberty' by requiring the increased use of police watch houses to hold children.
Some of the offences included in this week's legislation will apply to few or even no youth criminals.
According to statistics shared with the parliamentary committee by the Department of Youth Justice and Victim Support, several have not been committed by a child in the last five years, such as accessory after the fact to murder or kidnapping for ransom.
Others are extraordinarily rare; just one child has been proven to be guilty of kidnapping in that time.
In total there were just 467 counts of the new offences committed in 2024.
About 624,414 offences were committed in 2024, according to police statistics. Youth crime represents about 13% of all crime, according to the Queensland Audit Office.
The opposition leader, Steven Miles, announced on Monday afternoon that his party would support expanding the laws. Labor also voted for the first tranche.
'We won't be opposing the LNP's attempts to fix their mistakes,' Miles said. 'Of course, we couldn't stand in the way anyway. The LNP has a big majority and so these laws will pass either way.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
36 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Erin Patterson makes new claims about fatal beef Wellington lunch - as she accuses the lone survivor of lying
Accused killer Erin Patterson has refuted claims she told her lunch guests at an ill-fated lunch that she had been diagnosed with cancer. Entering the witness box for a second day on Thursday, Patterson further claimed she had never asked her guests over on the pretext of discussing with them a medical issue. The 50-year-old has pleaded not guilty to the murders of Don and Gail Patterson, and Gail's sister, Heather Wilkinson. They died after consuming death cap mushrooms served in beef Wellingtons during lunch at her Leongatha home on July 29, 2023. In opening the trial in the Supreme Court of Victoria, sitting in the Latrobe Valley Magistrates' Court in Victoria's east, Patterson's barrister Colin Mandy, SC told the jury on day one there was no dispute with the prosecution about how and why the guests came be at the lunch. 'It is not in dispute that Erin Patterson invited the guests over for lunch to her house in Leongatha. It is not in dispute that she invited her husband, Simon, over as well because she said she wanted to discuss a health issue that she was concerned about,' he said then. 'That is not in issue. The fact that she's never been diagnosed with cancer is not in issue.' But on Thursday, Patterson told the court she had never mentioned anything to her in-laws about a medical issue to entice them to accept her lunch invite. The jury heard previously evidence from child protection worker Katrina Cripps who claimed on August 1, 2023 at the Monash Medical Centre Patterson told her she had invited her guests over to discuss a medical issue. 'I wouldn't have put it like that because that wasn't the reason I invited people,' Patterson told prosecutor Dr Nanette Rogers under cross examination. 'Ms Cripps is wrong, is she?' Dr Rogers asked. 'Yes,' Patterson responded. 'You deny that?' Dr Rogers continued. 'I didn't say that to her. I told her I had invited Don and Gail and Ian and Heather to lunch and I did confirm we had discussed some medical issues, but I did not tell her that was the reason for the lunch or the reason for the invitation, because it was not,' Patterson said. The jury had heard evidence in the opening days of the trial from Pastor Ian Wilkinson, who was the only person to survive the deadly lunch. Mr Wilkinson claimed Patterson told lunch guests she had undertaken a diagnostic test that showed a spot on the scan that was a tumour. 'I remember him saying that in his evidence, but I don't believe I said that,' Patterson said. 'Might you have said it?' Dr Rogers asked. 'I don't think so, no,' Patterson said. Slowly dying at Korumburra Hospital after the lunch, the court heard Don Patterson also claimed Patterson mentioned she had been diagnosed with ovarian cancer. The court heard Don had told Simon: 'Mum doesn't want me to tell you this. It's about what Erin talked to us about at the lunch.' 'Donald asked if Simon thought he should tell him and Simon said 'yes'. Donald then said, 'Erin told us that she had tests for a medical term relating to something on her elbow 'and that they'd found ovarian cancer. She will probably need chemo and some surgery and she wasn't sure how to tell the kids',' Dr Rogers said at the trial's opening. Patterson told the jury she denied telling her lunch guests she had been diagnosed with cancer. 'I don't think I put it that precisely, no,' she said. 'Well, how did you put it?' Dr Rogers asked. 'I don't remember saying I'd had a diagnosis,' she responded. In what became nothing short of a heated exchange, Dr Rogers bombarded Patterson with questions suggesting she told repeated lies about the deadly lunch. 'You told this lie, I suggest, as part of your efforts to get the lunch guests, and Simon, to attend your lunch; correct or incorrect?' Dr Rogers asked. 'Incorrect,' came the response. 'I suggest that you never thought you would have to account for this lie about having cancer because you thought that the lunch guests would die?' Dr Rogers said. 'That's not true.' 'And your lie would never be found out; correct or incorrect?' 'That's not true,' Patterson insisted. The trial before Justice Christoper Beale continues. . I
Sky News
an hour ago
- Sky News
Erin Patterson: Woman accused of killing three people with poisonous mushrooms denies measuring 'fatal dose'
Why you can trust Sky News A woman accused of murdering three of her estranged husband's relatives with poisonous death cap mushrooms inside a beef wellington has denied she measured a "fatal dose" on her kitchen scales. Erin Patterson is charged with murdering her mother-in-law Gail Patterson, father-in-law Donald Patterson, and Gail's sister, Heather Wilkinson. She is also charged with the attempted murder of Ian Wilkinson, Heather's husband. Her estranged husband, Simon Patterson, was also invited to lunch but didn't attend. Prosecutors say Patterson knowingly served the guests lethal death cap mushrooms in a beef wellington at her home in Leongatha, Victoria, Australia, on 29 July, 2023. The 50-year-old denies all the charges, claiming the deaths were a "terrible accident". Under cross-examination on Thursday by the prosecution in court, Patterson was asked whether a series of photos of mushrooms placed on weighing scales in her kitchen was evidence she had been measuring a "fatal dose" to serve to her lunch guests. "I suggest that you were weighing these death cap mushrooms so that you could calculate the weight required for the administration of a fatal dose for one person. Agree or disagree?" barrister Nanette Rogers said. "Disagree," Patterson replied. Patterson accepted she had lied to police and medical professionals after the lunch when she was asked whether she had ever foraged for mushrooms or owned a food dehydrator - which was later found in a waste disposal plant containing traces of death caps. Giving evidence earlier in the day while being questioned by her own barrister, Colin Mandy, Patterson told the trial in Morwell, Victoria, she did not intentionally pick death cap mushrooms, or knowingly serve them to her lunch guests. She also denied that she pretended to be sick after the lunch to avoid becoming a suspect in the case.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Kate Ritchie's footy star ex-husband is charged with refusing breath test following string of drink driving offences
Kate Ritchie 's ex-husband and former NRL player Stuart Webb has been charged with refusing a breath test. The 44-year-old former Sydney Roosters hooker was pulled over in Sydney by Eastern Suburbs Police Area Command at 11.10pm on May 5. Webb was charged with refusing to submit a breath analysis and driving an unregistered vehicle. He was listed to appear at Waverley Local Court on Wednesday and the hearing was adjourned to be heard again at Downing Local Court on July 9. Mr Webb has previously been caught drink driving by police on five occasions. He was most recently charged with drink driving in 2019, with court documents stating that it was his 'fifth PCA (prescribed contention of alcohol) offence since 1999.' Two of those incidents are understood to have taken place in 2012 and 2017, while he was married to Ms Ritchie. He was handed a six-month driving ban in 2019 and an interlock device was fitted to his car for 24 months. A magistrate had told Mr Webb he was 'lucky he hasn't been sent to jail' noting that his driving record was 'appalling'. The former Sydney Roosters star was placed on a conditional release order for two years. In 2003, Mr Webb was signed by the Sydney Roosters and made his debut for the club later that year. After two seasons at Moore Park, he'd hop over to rivals, South Sydney. A year later, he'd move again, joining up with St George, where he would make 19 appearances across the 2008-2009 season, before stepping away from NRL football. After hanging up his footy boots Mr Webb would pursued a career as a chef. At the end of that season, Mr Webb proposed to radio personality Ritchie during a European getaway. The pair are understood to have begun dating in 2008. They subsequently tied the knot at a countryside outdoor ceremony at Quamby Estate in Tasmania in 2010, but after nearly 10 years of marriage, they chose to part ways in 2020. They would also have a baby girl, Mae, in 2014. Rumours had swirled that their marriage was on the rocks in 2019, with Mr Webb subsequently being hit with an apprehended violence order (AVO) in 2019. The order was made for the Home and Away star's protection. It came as a NSW Police spokesperson confirmed officers were 'investigating an incident at a home in Randwick' where it was understood the couple had lived, but no charges were laid. Conditions of the AVO state that Mr Webb was 'not to approach or be in the company of Katherine Leigh Ritchie for at least 12 hours after drinking alcohol or taking illicit drugs.' He was also required not to threaten, stalk or harass the TV star. Despite that, Ms Ritchie and her ex-husband have reunited on several occasions, most notably to attend their daughter Mae's football matches. Ms Ritchie, who had gone public with new boyfriend Will Skelton, and Mr Webb cut friendly figures as they shared a happy chat on the field. They had also reunited to celebrate their daughter's 10th birthday last year.
