Should McInnes be in charge of Kilmarnock against Hearts?
It is not a situation many - if any - football managers will have ever been in.On Sunday, Derek McInnes will manage Kilmarnock for, seemingly, the final time ahead of his protracted move to Heart of Midlothian.The team he will be managing against? Hearts. His current employers against his future ones.The 53-year-old is currently negotiating personal terms with the Tynecastle club and, all going smoothly, will take over once the season finishes.Awkward? Certainly. Unprofessional? Up for debate.
McInnes nowhere to be seen post-match
Although McInnes met the media before Wednesday's 3-0 loss to Motherwell, it was assistant manager Paul Sheerin who faced the music post-match."The manager made his point in the press in the lead up, so we know his stance on the situation," Sheerin said. "That's the only reason I'm stood here."There's walks of life where you work your notice and nothing is really said about it. It's part and parcel of people's contracts."I understand their frustrations and there is an awkwardness about it. We can't get away from that, but I'm sure the manager will do his best for the club."It was a united front from the Kilmarnock coaching staff - and, given Sheerin could be in line to join McInnes in Gorgie, that is perhaps as expected - but it did not impress everyone."That's feeble," BBC Scotland chief sports writer Tom English said on Sportsound. "Front up. He's excusing himself of his managerial duties, of which post-match media is one."His team were poor tonight. Derek McInnes is the manager of Kilmarnock until the end of the season and he's put Paul Sheerin in that position to explain that."He was happy to talk pre-match and eulogise his team's recent record, a lot of wins. Now he's had a sore defeat and he's nowhere to be found."Why not front up? What's he afraid of?"
Where's Derek? In the dugout? In the stand? At home?
The most obvious answer is McInnes might not have decided what he wants to do on Sunday.Sit in the dugout or in the stand? Or nowhere at all? Damned if he does, damned if he doesn't. It's an unenviable position."You've got to come out and do the interview after the game, especially after a disappointing performance," former Kilmarnock goalkeeper Cammy Bell agreed."He needs to come out and have that conversation. I'd be very surprised to see him in the dugout on Sunday. I think he'll be in the stand."Supporters are equally unimpressed. When canvassed for their opinion pre-match, plenty of credit was given to the work McInnes has done at Rugby Park, but concerns about Sunday's game were mentioned."I'm quite disappointed with the way it's been handled," said one disgruntled fan. "He has taken Killie to Europe and we've stayed safe this year. I just wish both clubs had waited until Monday and shown the fans more respect."Some said Chris Burke, the under-18 manager, should take charge for the next games, or have someone sitting there until we have a new manager in place."Former Kilmarnock assistant Gerry McCabe disagreed. "Derek has done very well at Kilmarnock, he can leave with his head held high," he said."He's still Kilmarnock manager. Football will throw up things like that and people might say the timing is wrong, but Derek says he's focused on getting Killie safe and that's what he's done."Fans will be disappointed he's leaving, but I think Derek can handle that."
What do you think?
Now the dust has settled post Motherwell match, what do you think Kilmarnock fans?Is there an option other than dugout or stand? Is it possible for McInnes to do a professional job in this position?Let us know your thoughts here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Scottish Premiership club reveal exit of FIFTEEN players as club captain and league title winner among released stars
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) IT'S a summer of change ahead at Kilmarnock following Stuart Kettlewell's arrival as manager. And it looks like the new Rugby Park boss is going to have a VERY different group of players working with him next season. 3 Stuart Kettlewell has taken over as Kilmarnock manager Credit: KILMARNOCK FC 3 Captain Kyle Vassell is leaving the club Credit: Callan Media- Commissioned by The Sun Glasgow 3 Gary Mackay-Steven is also out of contract Credit: Kenny Ramsay Derek McInnes quit Kilmarnock at the end of the season to become the new Hearts manager. The 53-year old's departure brought to an end a successful three-and-a-half year stint in charge that saw Killie enjoy the highs of promotion and a venture into European football. But now, it's Stuart Kettlewell who's tasked with taking things forward at the club. The former Motherwell boss was confirmed the new Killie gaffer last week on a two-year contract. But it certainly won't only be big changes in the dugout, with the club revealing plenty of change on the park as well. Kilmarnock have released their squad update following the conclusion of the 2024/25 season and it reveals that FIFTEEN players are leaving the club. Among them are a whole host of big names and first team regulars. Club captain Kyle Vassell is departing after two-and-a-half years with Killie. Regular starters Danny Armstrong, Liam Donnelly and Joe Wright are also moving on. Bobby Wales departs having already agreed a move to Swansea, while there are also exits for goalkeeper Kieran O'Hara, Innes Cameron, Kyle Magennis and Fraser Murray. Derek McInnes spotted leaving Rugby Park for last time as Kilmarnock fans thank ex-manager Former Scotland international Gary Mackay-Steven is also a free agent. The winger, 34, won three league titles during his time with Celtic between 2017 and 2019. In addition to those 12 names above, three players are leaving Kilmarnock after their loan deals expired. Scotland caps Calvin Ramsay and Stuart Findlay have gone back to Liverpool and Oxford respectively, while Tom Wilson-Brown's temporary spell from Leicester is over. The club say they are in conversations with a number of players and with the transfer window opening, fans should expect updates to follow in due course. Keep up to date with ALL the latest news and transfers at the Scottish Sun football page
BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
Vassell and Armstrong among 12 Killie exits
Captain Kyle Vassell and winger Danny Armstrong are among 12 players leaving Kilmarnock at the end of their had already been announced that Vassell's fellow striker's, Bobby Wales and Innes Cameron, have signed for Swansea City and Barrow the Scottish Premiership club have announced that defender Joe Wright, midfielders Liam Donnelly, Fraser Murray, Kyle Magennis and Aaron Brown, winger Gary Mackay-Steven and goalkeepers Kieran O'Hara and Aidan Glavin are also now out of Kilmarnock "thank each of the departing squad members for the role they have played", they add that "conversations are ongoing with a number of players" and do not say whether any of the out-of-contract players are included in also point out that Liverpool right-back Calvin Ramsay, Oxford United centre-half Stuart Findlay and Leicester City defender Tom Wilson-Brown have returned to their parent clubs following their loan spells at Rugby Kilmarnock add that, following the appointment of Stuart Kettlewell as manager to succeed Heart of Midlothian-bound Derek McInnes, fans should expect updates with the transfer window due to open on 12 Junee.
Glasgow Times
2 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
Celtic and Rangers in talks with clubs over SFA's new system
Architects of the initiative believe it will tackle the shortage of young players featuring in first-team football. The Scottish FA has given clubs the go-ahead to implement these changes from June 16. Talks of partnerships are already underway, with clubs such as Celtic in discussions with Queen's Park, Rangers with Raith Rovers, and Dundee United with Montrose. Recent data from the CIES Observatory shows that St Mirren offered only 0.8 per cent of their first-team minutes to players aged 21 or under. Dundee topped the SPFL Premiership with 24.8 per cent. Concerned by this trend, the governing body, in consultation with clubs, has decided to allow more flexibility for Scottish youngsters aged 16-21 to switch between their parent club and a lower league partner. SFA chief football officer Andy Gould and head of men's elite strategy Chris Docherty, who studied similar systems in Austria, Belgium, Croatia, Hungary, and Serbia, convinced clubs of the need for change. Read more: Who could make up Russell Martin's Rangers backroom team if appointment is made Former Celtic misfit linked with move to Hearts Mr Gould told Herald Sport: "This can definitely make a difference to Scotland teams of the future. "It's an opportunity for clubs to use a system that enhances their chances of getting players into their first team. "At the top end of the game, it gives them a greater opportunity of selling those players and, down the line, there is an opportunity for the national team to get the benefit of that." The new system permits SPFL Premiership or Championship clubs to sign agreements with clubs in League One, League Two, or the Highland and Lowland Leagues. This allows for a maximum of three players eligible for Scotland's national team to be placed on a 'co-operation list.' Unlike loans, these players can freely switch between the parent club and the lower league partner during the league season. The parent clubs will pay the player's full salary, maintain the player's registration, and have the right to recall the player at any time and send another one in their place. The existing loan system remains in place, allowing clubs to use a combination of the two systems to increase the maximum number of players they can take from the same parent outfit from three to five. Scotland face Iceland at Hampden on Friday night with Motherwell captain Lennon Miller, Kieran Bowie of Hibs, and James Wilson of Hearts in the squad, with Docherty citing the trio as a positive development. He said: "Not all of those players will start every World Cup qualifier. "But Steve (Clarke) has called up players like Lennon Miller and James Wilson, now the youngest ever Scotland player, and he has shown clubs in the SPFL that if you put a young player in the first team at a young age and start to develop them, they have a real chance of making it into a Scotland squad. "So I think the national coach, in this case, is sending a signal to clubs that if you develop young players, that will develop the national team and help them as well." The architects of the new system hope that it will provide a competitive edge over others, although the benefits may not be immediately visible.
