'No Other Land' directors fume as Israeli military blocks media trip to view settler violence
'The next time your politicians call this country the only democracy in the Middle East, film this so that they can see how democratic it really is. Film the reality and truth of what they're doing to us,' Oscar-winning Palestinian filmmaker Basel Adra told dozens of international journalists at the entrance to his village in the occupied West Bank, which had unexpectedly turned into a heavily manned Israeli military checkpoint.
'The only democracy in the Middle East is preventing international media from filming villages after settlers attacked them.'
Exactly three months ago to the day, Adra, along with No Other Land co-directors Yuval Abraham and Hamdan Ballal, was on stage at the 97th Academy Awards to receive the award for Best Documentary. It was the first time a Palestinian film had won an Oscar.
On Monday, those behind this remarkable achievement were reduced to arguing without success with masked Israeli forces to let their group through to the villages that have captured the world's attention.
No Other Land documented the struggles of the residents of Masafer Yatta, a cluster of hamlets and villages, to stop the Israeli military from demolishing their communities. In the 1980s, the army designated it as a military training area, ordering residents to leave, a fate that has befallen many Palestinians in the occupied West Bank, particularly agricultural communities. Despite this, about 1,000 people have stayed in the area, including Adra and his family.
The community has faced regular attacks from Israeli settlers. The violence intensified after the October 7, 2023 Hamas -led attack on Israel that triggered the war in Gaza. With international attention focused on the war, Israeli ministers in the far-right government, many themselves prominent settlers themselves, urged the seizure of Palestinian land.
'I think the film made a huge difference in the opinions of people all over the world … but sadly it did not make a difference for the people who have power. Israel is an ally of your countries. Here it is blocking journalists from these allied countries from visiting and seeing these crimes being committed,' said Abraham, an Israeli Jew, who made the trip from Jerusalem to help Adra's tour.
On Sunday evening, the Israeli army declared the village of Khirbet Khallet Al Dabaa, where the tour was set to take place, a closed military zone, according to Palestinian news agency Wafa. The day before, Israeli forces arrested two foreign activists working to support the communities in Masafer Yatta.
Attacks on these communities rose to critical levels in the months after No Other Land was released, a situation that the filmmakers tried to show the world's media on Monday. Ballal was brutally attacked by a mob of Israeli settlers in March.
'There is destruction of water wells, pipes and solar panels. Settlers have come into the village and set up in the area under military protection. They have attacked children and pregnant women,' Adra said.
Addressing the Israeli troops, whose numbers soon swelled to include more soldiers, as well as civilian and border police, he said: 'I have so many videos of settlers here to attack us and shoot us and you do nothing. Right now when journalists are here to see this and interview people you come to prevent them.'
A softly spoken soldier, face covered with a balaclava, only reiterated that his forces were there to 'keep the public order'.
'Last week had a lot of disturbance to the order,' he added. 'In this crossroads, no journalists, no guests, to keep the order in the area. Right here you are a public disturbance.'
These mild exchanges were the extent of the confrontations on Monday. Even the arrival of a senior Palestinian Authority official to observe the situation caused little commotion.
But hours after the media left, the reports of violence and intimidation against Palestinians in the occupied West Bank resumed, including the military reportedly shooting a minor and settlers using drones to intimidate Palestinian shepherds and their sheep near Bethlehem.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Middle East Eye
24 minutes ago
- Middle East Eye
US-backed Gaza aid group suspends distribution to starving Palestinians for a day
The US and Israel-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), which has been plagued by scandal, has said it will not give out any aid on Wednesday to starving Palestinians. The decision comes the day after Israeli forces killed at least 27 Palestinians as they were attempting to reach a GHF distribution site in Rafah. Crowds had gathered early in the al-Alam area, west of Rafah, seeking basic food supplies, amid worsening, famine-like conditions in the Gaza Strip. Israeli artillery and warplanes then targeted civilians, according to eyewitnesses. The GHF said on Wednesday that it had paused distribution for a day, and asked the Israeli military to "guide foot traffic in a way that minimises confusion or escalation risks" near military perimeters, develop clearer guidance for civilians and improve training to support civilian safety. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters "Our top priority remains ensuring the safety and dignity of civilians receiving aid," a GHF spokesperson said. Meanwhile, an Israeli military spokesperson labelled areas leading to GHF sites 'combat zones', issuing a warning against civilians moving in those areas. The spokesperson did not elaborate on how an aid distribution site was a combat zone, or how civilians were supposed to receive aid without moving in the area. 'Recipe for disaster' The UN and aid organisations have accused the GHF, which uses private American security and logistics workers, of militarising humanitarian aid. The killings on Tuesday marked the latest in a string of Israeli attacks on Palestinians seeking aid at newly established GHF-run distribution points. At least 102 Palestinians have been killed and over 490 wounded in similar attacks over the past eight days since the initiative's launch, according to the Gaza-based Government Media Office. Gaza Humanitarian Foundation appoints US evangelical leader who denied mass killings as chief Read More » "The so-called 'aid' distribution centres, situated in exposed and perilous red zones controlled by the occupying forces, have become bloodbaths. Starving civilians are lured there due to the crippling famine and tight siege," the office said in a statement. "They are then deliberately and coldly shot, a scene that exposes the true malice of the operation and its real objectives." The office described these actions as genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity, calling for immediate global action and an investigation into the latest Israeli assaults. "The continuation of these crimes, amid shameful international silence, is a stain on humanity and proves that the occupation continues to perpetrate the most heinous forms of genocide under the world's gaze, without deterrence or accountability," the statement concluded. The UN Security Council is due on Wednesday to vote on a demand for a ceasefire in Gaza and humanitarian access into the enclave. It is not yet clear whether Washington will veto the proposal. Malnutrition has become widespread as aid has only trickled into the enclave since Israel partially lifted an 11-week blockade in late May. "It is unacceptable. Civilians are risking - and in several instances losing - their lives just trying to get food," UN spokesperson Stephane Dujarric said. He added that the GHF's aid distribution model was "a recipe for disaster, which is exactly what is going on." The GHF this week named evangelical leader Johnnie Moore, a former adviser to US President Donald Trump, as its new chief. Moore, a former member of the US Commission on International Religious Freedom, has dismissed reports of mass killings at the GHF aid sites as 'fictional massacres'. He was appointed after the initiative's former head, Jake Wood, resigned. Moore has emerged as a vocal advocate for the scandal-plagued initiative, claiming that reports of the killings were 'lies…spread by terrorists,' contradicting eyewitness accounts, footage, and reports by hospital directors and medical staff.
Middle East Eye
24 minutes ago
- Middle East Eye
Exclusive: UK believes Trump may sanction Amal Clooney over ICC Palestine role
The British government believes the US could sanction prominent human rights lawyer Amal Clooney over her role advising the ICC chief prosecutor on arrest warrants for Israeli leaders, Middle East Eye can reveal. In April it emerged that the British Foreign Office had warned senior British lawyers involved in the ICC's war crimes case against two senior Israeli leaders that they are at risk of US sanctions. This came after the Trump administration imposed financial and visa sanctions on Karim Khan, the court's British chief prosecutor, in February. Last November the ICC issued arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defence Minister Yoav Gallant on charges of war crimes and crimes against humanity. Trump's executive order, a response to the arrest warrants, warned further measures could follow 'on those responsible for those transgressions'. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters Multiple sources within the British government told MEE that last week the Foreign Office's legal directorate listed Amal Clooney and Lord Justice Adrian Fulford as being potentially at risk of US sanctions. Clooney, a prominent British barrister of Lebanese and Palestinian descent, is the wife of Hollywood actor George Clooney. But she is not an American citizen and could be barred from entering the US if she is sanctioned. 'I believe in the rule of law' Both lawyers served early last year on an independent panel of legal advisors convened by the ICC prosecutor. The panel expressed their support for Khan's decision to seek arrest warrants for senior Israeli and Hamas leaders for war crimes and crimes against humanity, and ICC judges granted his application in November. In a statement published on the Clooney Foundation for Justice (CFJ) website last May, Clooney said she served on the panel 'because I believe in the rule of law and the need to protect civilian lives". Amal Clooney critics humbled as role in Israel-Hamas ICC arrest warrant bid revealed Read More » 'As a human rights lawyer, I will never accept that one child's life has less value than another's,' she added. Adam Keith, a director at Human Rights First, told MEE: "The Trump administration's sanctions programme targeting the ICC is so sweeping that just providing legal advice or input regarding the court's Palestine investigation appears to be sanctionable. "This means it could get any non-American placed on the Treasury Department's financial blacklist and barred from entering the United States." Keith described the programme as "an outrageous misuse of sanctions, and a direct attack on an accountability body that survivors and advocates around the world rely on for justice". The British Foreign Office did not respond to multiple requests for comment. The CFJ was co-founded by the Clooneys in 2016. In 2024 Amal won the Legal 500 Award for international lawyer of the year. And just last week she was photographed backstage at her husband's Broadway play Good Night, and Good Luck with senior Democrats Hillary Clinton and Nancy Pelosi. Trump's order gave the US Treasury and State Department a 60-day deadline to provide recommendations on who else besides Khan should be sanctioned. No further sanctions have been announced, although they may not have been made public. Fulford, named alongside by Clooney by the British Foreign Office's legal directorate, is a former judge of the ICC and former vice-president of the Court of Appeal. In December 2024 he said it was 'vital' that ICC member states should act on the warrant for Netanyahu's arrest. MEE contacted Fulford and the Clooney Foundation for Justice for comment but did not receive a response by the time of publication.
The National
29 minutes ago
- The National
Israeli Ultra-Orthodox party reportedly planning to quit Netanyahu coalition
Ultra-Orthodox leaders in Israel have reportedly ordered politicians in the United Torah Judaism party, which sits in Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu 's far-right coalition, to withdraw from government over lack of progress on passing legislation to exempt young men from the community from military service. Reports of the UTJ's imminent withdrawal have sparked opposition plans to put forward a bill to dissolve parliament, giving Mr Netanyahu about a week to find a solution to save his coalition. If he fails, it opens up the possibility that Israel has to hold early elections. The issue of whether Ultra-Orthodox youths should perform military service, which is mandatory for all other Jewish Israelis, has proven to be one of the most insurmountable in Israeli politics in recent years. The Ultra-Orthodox community have grown increasingly frustrated in recent weeks over delays in passing an exemption law. The wider dispute intensified during the Gaza War. Israel's military says it is facing a manpower shortage and many Israelis feel their children take on an unfair burden while the Ultra-Orthodox stay away from military service to dedicate themselves to religious study. The community also receives significant subsidies to continue their secluded way of life, which many Israelis also criticise as an unfair financial burden that encourages the community not to integrate. The UTJ's reported plans to withdraw come after a meeting to find a solution between the party's senior officials and Yuli Edelstein, chairman of the Knesset's Foreign Affairs and Defence Committee, ended in failure. Mr Edelstein, a member of Mr Netanyahu's Likud party, previously vowed to find a solution that 'significantly increases [the military's] conscription base,' echoing frustration by many in the ultranationalist, hawkish coalition at the Ultra-Orthodox's refusal to serve. The UTJ party holds seven of the ruling coalition's 68 seats, meaning that their departure would not end the government's majority in the 120-seat Knesset. However, a second Ultra-Orthodox party, Shas, is also demanding the passage of a bill to exempt their young men from service. Shas, which has 11 seats, have not yet commented on their stance towards the current impasse, but it is considered likely to follow UTJ's suit, which would deprive Mr Netanyahu of his majority.
