'PAS Youth leader Sukri forgets Singapore's meritocracy offers equal chances, not ethnic-based'
IT IS understandable for Selangor PAS Youth Chief Mohamed Sukri Omar to be concerned about the status of Malay Muslims in Singapore.
Sukri has claimed that he was not interfering in Singapore's domestic politics but merely expressing moral concern over the alleged marginalisation and political under-representation of the Malay Muslim community.
However, his remarks came at a sensitive time – coinciding with Facebook (FB) postings from Australia urging Malays in Singapore to vote along ethnic and religious lines.
This led to the Singaporean authorities having requested the FB administrator to remove or block such postings as they border on interference in the country's internal affairs, especially with general elections slared for May 3.
While Sukri's concerns might stem from the ethnic and religious dynamics of Malaysian politics, it is neither appropriate nor wise to subtly recommend Malaysia's model of ethnic and religious governance to Singapore.
In Singapore, it is not just the Malays but also the Indians who are sometimes considered marginalised communities.
However, Singapore's emphasis on meritocracy, performance and hard work offers opportunities to all Singaporeans even if the pace of progress may be slow for some groups.
Singapore excels in meritocracy
By contrast, in Malaysia, meritocracy is constrained by ethnic-based privileges accorded to the majority community. While Malaysia has tremendous potential, it remains hampered by ethnic structures that inhibit full and equal participation across races and religions.
I can understand Sukri's sentiment, but he must realise that imposing Malaysia's ethnic governance framework onto Singapore is unwise.
We may have legitimate criticisms of Singapore's governance, particularly concerning minority communities but we must also acknowledge that the Singaporean system – however imperfect – allows for evolution, progress and reform.
Meanwhile, Malaysia continues to grapple with systemic issues that prevent it from fully realising its diverse potential.
While Sukri is entitled to his views and may feel a moral duty toward Malay Muslims in Singapore, he must exercise greater caution when making statements that may be construed as interference in another country's internal affairs.
Given the challenges within their own system, Malaysian politicians should be humble and cautious in judging or commenting on Singapore's governance. – April 27, 2025
Former DAP stalwart and Penang chief minister II Prof Ramasamy Palanisamy is chairman of the United Rights of Malaysian Party (Urimai) interim council.
The views expressed are solely of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Focus Malaysia.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
2 hours ago
- The Star
Gerik bus crash: Apad issues show-cause letter to bus operator
PETALING JAYA: Anthony Loke says that the Land Public Transport Agency (Apad) has issued a show-cause letter to the bus operator involved in the tragic bus crash in Gerik. "The Road Transport Department (JPJ) is undertaking safety inspections and audits on the bus and the company, in compliance with the Road Transport Act and the Land Public Transport Act. "Firm action will be taken once the investigation is completed," said the Transport Minister. He also extended his condolences to the families of the 15 Universiti Pendidikan Sultan Idris (UPSI) students who tragically lost their lives in a bus crash in Gerik. He also vowed to implement changes to strengthen road safety policies in Malaysia. "I am deeply saddened and affected by this tragic accident. Each life lost is a significant loss not only to the families, but to the future of our country. "My thoughts and prayers are with the victims and their families during this difficult time," he said in a Facebook post on Monday (June 9). He also emphasised the government's commitment to enhancing road safety measures, particularly to address threats posed by irresponsible drivers and heavy vehicles not meeting safety standards. "We are committed to protecting road users. Among the policies being drafted is the mandatory implementation of speed limiters for heavy vehicles," he said, adding that the policy is currently under comprehensive review to prevent any manipulation upon enforcement. Loke also acknowledged the swift actions of the Higher Education Ministry and UPSI management in providing support to the bereaved families. "This incident serves as a stark reminder to all parties – the government, operators and society – that there can be no compromise on the safety of lives," he said. Earlier on Monday, 15 UPSI students were killed in the accident along the East-West Highway in Banun, Gerik, and 27 other students, the bus driver and his assistant, as well as three passengers of another multi-purpose vehicle, were injured. The bus, which was carrying 42 students, overturned while the MPV, carrying four people, veered into a ditch. Preliminary investigations showed that the bus, driven by a substitute driver from another bus company, collided with the MPV before overturning. The bus is also believed to have been speeding, based on victims' accounts.
Focus Malaysia
2 hours ago
- Focus Malaysia
Will intra-racial or ethnic unity illuminate or darken Malaysia?
THE call by two-time premier Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad for an umbrella of greater unity among Malays brings an eerie feeling to all mature, educated, and level-headed Malaysians. Greater Malay unity contradicts the very fabric of 'unity in diversity' envisioned at the formation of Malaya and later Malaysia by our founding fathers. The question now is whether intra-racial unity will illuminate Malaysia—or darken and dim it. Tipping the balance against the very spirit of our formation and subsequent nation-building will bring negative repercussions both nationally and internationally, affecting our nation economically and politically. In the colorful tapestry of Malaysia, the national identity is sewn together by a rich blend of cultures—primarily Malays, Chinese, Indians, and various indigenous peoples. Now, among this delightful variety, a question lingers: Is it enough for people of the same race to stand closely together, or do we need to stretch our hands across the ethnic lines to build a truly united nation? This little piece argues that while unity within a single group may give a sense of belonging, it is that intermingling of communities—both in politics and daily life that truly nurtures a lasting bond among all Malaysians. A thoughtful person named J.S. Furnivall once described a plural society as one where different racial groups live side by side, much like guests at a grand wedding reception, each enjoying their own food without much mingling. Malaysia fits this bill perfectly; ethnic groups have their own schools, political parties, and even places of worship. In such a setting, for national harmony, it's not just about being cosy within your own circle but also about making connections with the others. Though intra-ethnic unity is necessary to some extend, it has its own limitations and it is insufficient. The desire for ethnic-based unity has been a familiar feature in Malaysian life and politics. The Malays often gather around UMNO, the Chinese rally with the MCA or DAP, and the Indians find a voice through MIC and current multiple Indian parties or other community groups. This cosy internal bonding certainly helps the communities to voice their particular needs and desires. However, as wise voices had previously pointed out, there lies the risk of becoming too self-contained, like a beehive that doesn't allow other pollinators. A constant emphasis on intra-group solidarity can create walls instead of bridges, making it hard to build trust and encouraging narratives that view relations between groups as a competition rather than a collaboration. Since independence the nation was build based on inter-racial/ethnic competition among races which cannot continue to be the trajectory for future nation building as the world has moved towards the 'earth is but one country and mankind its citizens' tenet. As we venture into the present political landscape of Malaysia, the significance of inter-ethnic unity shines through. Since the time of the 2018 general election, there have been notable shifts in political coalitions that highlight both the prospects and challenges of different ethnicities coming together, which leads to inter-ethnic unity. The current Pakatan Harapan (PH) unity government champions reforms, good governance, and inclusivity. Though it has faced some criticisms about ethnic imbalances, it remains one of the most ethnically diverse alliances in Malaysia's journey. Following the 2022 elections, the advent of unity governments, which brought together several coalitions, mark a pragmatic embrace of multi-coalitional governance. Despite their differing ideologies, these partnerships underline the necessity for cooperation across ethnic and geographical lines to uphold national steadiness. The real unity is not merely a matter of politics; it seeps into the daily grind of life. Inter-ethnic solidarity should be nurtured through, social economic and institutionalised integration. There must be education reforms that promote multicultural understanding and national harmony. A fair economic policies that shift from race-based views to need-based frameworks, striving toward a shared prosperity vision should be the hallmark. Initiating civic engagement and youth activism where the younger generations forge a Malaysian identity that transcends race must be framework towards every government machinery. While unity among a single ethnic group can surely bolster community strength, it is the cooperation across different ethnic lines—politically, economically, and socially—that lays the groundwork for Malaysia's brighter future. The evolution of the country's political frameworks reflects a delicate, yet sincere, effort towards multi-ethnic governance. As Malaysia strides forward, embracing this spirit of inter-ethnic solidarity will be the secret recipe for national resilience, unity, and inclusive growth. We cannot continue to operate on intra-ethnic, which we did since independence, as the world has moved forward for inclusivity and integration in all dimensions. ‒ June 9, 2025 Maran ( KT Maran) Seremban, Negri Sembilan The views expressed are solely of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Focus Malaysia. Main image: The Borneo Post
The Sun
2 hours ago
- The Sun
Malaysia, UAE enhance cooperation in talent mobility, workforce upskilling and AI readiness
PUTRAJAYA: Malaysia and the United Arab Emirates (UAE) have agreed to enhance bilateral cooperation in areas of talent mobility, workforce upskilling, and artificial intelligence (AI) readiness in response to the rapid evolution of global technology and labour markets. The Ministry of Human Resources (KESUMA) said the agreement was reached during an official meeting between Malaysia's Minister of Human Resources Steven Sim Chee Keong and UAE Minister of Human Resources and Emiratisation, Dr Abdulrahman Abdulmannan Al Awar, in Dubai. 'This meeting marks a pivotal step in strengthening future-oriented strategies and partnerships focused on digital labour policies, labour migration, and education transformation,' the ministry said in a statement today. It said the UAE, currently ranked third in the world for AI talent readiness, also shared insights on its successful integration of AI across key sectors such as finance, biotechnology, and public services. 'The UAE minister also emphasised the need for agile education systems and adaptable workforces to address the impact of AI on both manual labour and professional sectors,' it said. KESUMA said Malaysia acknowledged the UAE's leadership in this area and reaffirmed its commitment to preparing its workforce for the AI era. The ministry also highlighted the 2024 TalentCorp study on the Impact of AI, Digitalisation, and the Green Economy on Employment, which identified 10 high-risk sectors likely to face job displacement or transformation. 'This study now serves as the foundation for Malaysia's national strategy on workforce reskilling and upskilling to ensure readiness for a rapidly evolving job landscape,' the ministry said. As a gesture of international collaboration, the UAE has invited Sim to attend the Abu Dhabi Dialogue in February 2026, which will focus on ethical migration, workers' rights, and cross-border policy alignment. Malaysia and the UAE have enjoyed diplomatic relations since 1983, built on shared values and strong economic cooperation. The UAE is Malaysia's second-largest trading partner in the Middle East and hosts a significant Malaysian expatriate community, 13 per cent of whom hold the UAE Golden Visa.
